I started replying to this thread on the evening when the rebuttals to what I'd said were put forward; but a horrible feeling of tiredness came over me so I had to abandon the attempt. Perhaps Satan was impeding me ... No, surely a cactus couldn't do that; besides, it's in the other room! ... Do you think Satan's a good name for a cactus?
... OK, this is getting off-track. Back to the issues!
TimCallahan said:
It's hardly surprising that the websites of the fundamentalist Tekton ministry would support the idea of harmonization of the disparate accounts in the
gospels. However, their reasoning is a bit circular. For example, the claim that the resurrected Jesus filled the desciples in on what happened at the
trials and in the garden of Gethsemane means that we have to believe in the historical reality of the Resurrecction in order to accept the gospel accounts
of the Passion and Resurrection stories. Yet those stories are supposed to be taken as evidence of the Resurrection.
The idea that Jesus filled the disciples in about what happened at the trial after his resurrection is a suggestion, rather than a claim - they're saying it's one possible explanation for how the gospel writers knew so much about the trial. They also suggest several others. They don't, as far as I'm aware, say the trial story is evidence of the resurrection. I'd be surprised if they did, since whatever you think of their religious leanings, the arguments they put forward do seem to be of a scholarly nature rather than a simplistic one.
I'm sure the article writer did have a biased foregone conclusion in mind when he wrote the article - that the gospel accounts of Jesus' trial are authentic; but nevertheless, it's quite an in-depth analysis of the trial and what might have happened.
TimCallahan said:
Also, it is simply impossible to harmonize Luke's report that Pilate sent Jesus to Herod Antipas, and that his soldiers, rather than Pilate's, were the
ones who mocked Jesus, with the accounts in the other gospels that it was Pilate's soldiers who mocked Jesus. How is it, in fact, that of all the gospels
only Luke knows of this episode? Or how can one harmonize Matthew, were the disciples are told to go to Galilee, where they meet Jesus, with Luke, where
they are specifically told to stay in Jerusalem, where they meet Jesus? It is also impossible to harmonize Mark's account of the Resurrection, where there
is only an empty tomb as evidence and no post Resurrection appearances by Jesus, with the post Resurrection appearances of Jesus in the other gospels.
I always thought the idea was that both sets of soldiers mocked Jesus.
I don't think it's necessary to conclude that only Luke supposedly knew of the visit to Herod, since there might have been other reasons the others didn't mention it, such as not thinking it to be of sufficient importance to cram into the possibly limited space they had. Luke is the one most concerned with historical detail; the others focus on various aspects of Jesus' ministry rather than historical documentation.
The
article about the trial I linked to addresses a few critical takes on the Herod visit.
It also says:
But the question remains: Is it truly realistic and reasonable to expect the kind of certitude that Carmichael implicitly demands from the Gospel writers?
Quite frankly, no. As part of our answer, it will be necessary to briefly recap some of the material we have used in
this article relative to Gospel authorship - for understanding WHO wrote the trial accounts is a key to understanding WHY they were written as they were.
We presume, based on data presented in the just-linked article, that the following represents the authorship and purpose of each Gospel, other than as ancient biographies (bioi):
Matthew - by the Apostle and tax collector; formulated as a teaching gospel
Mark - by the secretary of Peter; based on Peter's preaching
Luke - by the companion of Paul; intended as a historical document
John - by the Apostle; a kerygmatic and missionary presentation
Now with these things in mind, it should be asked: Which of these accounts would be expect to be done best, according to the standards of historical reportage?
Obviously, the answer is Luke: As he has been reckoned worthy as a historian, we expect the most accurate representation of chronology from him.
I don't see the instructions to go to Galilee and the instruction to stay in Jerusalem as contradictory - they were given at different times, the one about Galilee before the forty day post-resurrection period and the one about Jerusalem at the end of it. Was it not possible to travel to Galilee and then to come back to Jerusalem within a period of a few weeks? In fact Luke himself has both instructions - the one to go to Galilee in his gospel, and then the one in Acts, where he says Jesus' final instructions just before he departed for good were for them to stay in Jerusalem. Can Luke really have been sloppy enough to so glaringly contradict himself? Since both his gospel and Acts were written to the same person, is it not likely such a big discrepancy would have been picked up early and corrected?
... I've just had a look in Google to try to find the distance between Jerusalem and Galilee and how long it would take to walk. One source said it's 68 miles.
Then I found this rather amusing article. ... Well, amusing unless you're Dan Barker.
Post-resurrection appearances of Jesus are mentioned at the end of Mark, but they are in the bit where the authorship's disputed. However, if Mark didn't mention any, it wouldn't prove a contradiction.
See Tektonics' article speculating on whether the end of Mark's authentic and why, if it ended at verse 8 rather than verse 20, it might have been deliberate design.
TimCallahan said:
For that matter, how does one harmonize the account in 1 Corinthians with that of the Gospel of John?:
1 Corinthians 15:5 - 8:
1. Jesus first appeared to Peter.
2. Jesus appeared to the 12 (including Judas?).
3. Jesus appeared to more than 500 people at one time (a fact somehow missed by the gospel writers).
4. After that he appeared to James.
5. Then to all the apostles - whatever that means.
6. Last, he appeared to Paul.
Gospel of John,chapters 20 and 21:
1. Jesus first appeared to Mary Magdalene.
2. Jesus next appeared to the disciples in Jerusalem, though Thomas wasn't present.
3. Eight days later He appeared to them again, this time with Thomas present.
4. In chapter 21 Jesus again appears to the disciples, who, for some strange reason, have returned to the Sea of Tiberius (Galilee) and have resumed their
occupation as fishermen.
Why would you think it strange that they went to the sea of Galilee after Jesus specifically told them to?
According to Tektonics' article harmonising the resurrection accounts:
2. 1 Cor. 15, despite Barker's challenge, is not to be included, though it could be. 1 Cor. 15 is a creedal statement meant to emphasize that the leading people of the church saw the resurrected Jesus. It is therefore stylized for a purpose and need not be force-fitted into the narrative accounts.
I don't understand what he means by that, but
he seems to know what he's talking about.

I tried to find more detail on his website, but gave up after a brief look; I didn't find anything, possibly because I was distracted by
another amusing related article here. - well, amusing except if you're Richard Carrier, whoever he is.
Perhaps I ought to say that it's Barker and Carrier's arguments that are being discussed amusingly - the articles aren't personal attacks.
Basically, I don't think a case can be made that easily at all that Tektonics' articles on the trial and the harmonisation of the resurrection accounts of Jesus are specious.
Well, discussing this has convinced me of the old addage ... "The devil's in the detail". Didn't I say at the beginning of this post that I suspected Satan was around somewhere!
