Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

...

The remedy is to of course be on top of one's game. In this post-industrial world, that means tops in science and engineering. That means having the critical mass not just in brains, but in process experience on the ground. The US, though with points of brilliance, is losing ground fast. You do not get there by encouraging mythology, emotional attachment to anachronistic approaches to any domain or endeavor, and severely divisive policies that weaken you as a player.

In short, as the world is smarting up, the US is dumbing down. All part of a package called a worldview, a militaristic mindset that extends to civilian life, and an oversimplification of critical issues to allow private interest to trump the public trust. As everyone navel gazes, thinking a barrel in some house is a defense of the country - go freaking figure that one - your lunch will be eaten, and without a shot being fired.


Sounds like you've been spending time in the government library...

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/10/u...=WhatsNext&contentID=WhatsNext&pgtype=article
 
This tells me the cops were acting on the information they had on-hand at the time. That information was incorrect, but that does not indicate poor reasoning. The scene of large emergencies is always chaotic and it is always difficult to separate accurate from inaccurate information during such an emergency. Fog of War, even if it is not actually a war.

Reasonable reasoning would take into account the fog, wouldn't it? You seem to be saying that they acted on bad information in a situation likely to generate bad information, but that's reasonable to do.

Let me suggest something else. A risk-reward calculation that leans toward "worst case" preferentially. This may be a bias we want to encourage, but we should recognize that acting in this fashion isn't without concomitant cost.

I think we both recognize that lack of information limits our analysis of this event, but even after we get the details, we'd still be wrong to extend the unique elements of what happened here to be a reflection of an overall policing policy.

What I can point out is that aggressive policing in the name and service of officer safety is the trend generating some of the outrage, the same outrage which inspired the protest. Abuse of power and misuse of authority, especially the authority to take a life, is seen as a broad problem in US policing.
 
Last edited:
Police departments have explosives used to detonate suspicious packages or to train bomb squads (the Miami police, for example, used explosives to breach the wall of the nightclub during the recent mass shooting there). Maybe little prepackaged devices, or maybe just some explosives and blasting caps that can be measured out to suit the occasion. Take some of that, add some shrapnel (open up a couple of shotgun shells and use the shot), and you've got an improvised grenade - I am guessing an ordnance tech could do it in a minute or two. The robot may already been equipped to hold and detonate explosive charges, because blowing up suspicious packages is part of what bomb disposal robots are designed to do.

Of course we don't know, but that's what I figured too. Any police department now could think that was a good idea and if they could blow up suspicious packages, do the same thing.

I don't see it as uniquely bad or good. If they'd have a sniper kill a person, this is the same, only more effective in some situations. And it would be their responsibility to avoid collateral damage same as if they fired at a suspect in a crowd or chased a car down a highway.

Still, I'll never think of Wall-E the same again.
 
Of course we don't know, but that's what I figured too. Any police department now could think that was a good idea and if they could blow up suspicious packages, do the same thing.

I don't see it as uniquely bad or good. If they'd have a sniper kill a person, this is the same, only more effective in some situations. And it would be their responsibility to avoid collateral damage same as if they fired at a suspect in a crowd or chased a car down a highway.

Still, I'll never think of Wall-E the same again.

SWAT teams used to be only used for times when time was absolutely critical. Now, they're being used to serve warrants and because they don't want suspected drug dealers of simply flushing their entire supply down the toilet.

Military equipment was sold to police in order to protect against well-armed terrorists, and that was great when police in Watertown were pursuing the Boston Marathon bombers. Then Ferguson happened, and we saw them deployed against mourners and people walking down their own street.

Not sure I like this whole "police use remote-control bombs to kill people" thing...
 
SWAT teams used to be only used for times when time was absolutely critical. Now, they're being used to serve warrants and because they don't want suspected drug dealers of simply flushing their entire supply down the toilet.

Military equipment was sold to police in order to protect against well-armed terrorists, and that was great when police in Watertown were pursuing the Boston Marathon bombers. Then Ferguson happened, and we saw them deployed against mourners and people walking down their own street.

Not sure I like this whole "police use remote-control bombs to kill people" thing...

I agree with you there (I'm generally anti-cop), but I think the solution needs to come from a mindset change. If a SWAT team is used to serve a warrant, why not a robot with a warrant in one claw and a bomb in the other? The technology can't be made to go away.

Police need to be outraged at a military mindset when it's not necessary. Then the SWAT teams, tanks, drones and robots will shrink back to being used in only desperate circumstances where they can save lives, rather than being cool tools a police department just can't wait try out.
 
There was something else which stood out for me, besides the bomb robot. It's the fact that none of the Dallas cops killed any of the innocent open-carry folks. That certainly could have happened but didn't. Good on them.
 
There was something else which stood out for me, besides the bomb robot. It's the fact that none of the Dallas cops killed any of the innocent open-carry folks. That certainly could have happened but didn't. Good on them.

Jeez...Congratulating people for doing the moral thing is pretty-low expectations, isn't it?
 
There was something else which stood out for me, besides the bomb robot. It's the fact that none of the Dallas cops killed any of the innocent open-carry folks. That certainly could have happened but didn't. Good on them.
Why did none of these innocent folks engage the suspect and bump him off before he managed to shoot the police officers? Isn't that what gun ownership is all about?

By the way, are ordinary US citizens allowed to possess mobile robot bombs? If not, why not?
 
There was something else which stood out for me, besides the bomb robot. It's the fact that none of the Dallas cops killed any of the innocent open-carry folks. That certainly could have happened but didn't. Good on them.

The presence of the open carry advocates might have been what led to the perception that there were multiple gunmen. That may have affected the overall response, and possibly delayed getting some of the wounded to treatment.
 
While using the bomb robot to take out the suspect was novel, to me it smacks of the police acting as judge, jury, and executioner. They had the suspect contained. He was certainly dangerous, but in my opinion as long as he was contained they should have concentrated on taking him alive and let the justice system deal with him from there.
 
My state does not allow hunting big game with a rifle that holds more than six rounds total. A big game rifle is also required to have a caliber of at least 6mm.

The AR-15 fails both of these requirements.
I've talked about the AR-15 a lot on this forum. I'm fairly certain that I've mentioned that fact that they can be had in many calibers from 17 to 51 caliber with magazine capacities from 1 to 250 rounds. As long as it's limitations are taken into consideration, the AR-15 passes most any requirement for hunting in the USA.

Ranb
 
That's not really logical. What most people mean is "the more efficient people killing tools", popular venacular a "powerful" rifle, also "machine gun".
Why do you think most people mean machine gun when referring to an AR-15?
 
Originally Posted by AJM8125 View Post
Here we have people that want to convince me that I don't need an AR, even though they can't quite identify one.
That's not really logical. What most people mean is "the more efficient people killing tools", popular venacular a "powerful" rifle, also "machine gun".

And you have just underlined AJM8125's point.
 
I've talked about the AR-15 a lot on this forum. I'm fairly certain that I've mentioned that fact that they can be had in many calibers from 17 to 51 caliber with magazine capacities from 1 to 250 rounds. As long as it's limitations are taken into consideration, the AR-15 passes most any requirement for hunting in the USA.

Ranb

Yes, you can have an AR-15 custom made to meet the requirements. But why the hell do you bother?

The real appeal of this rifle is how effective they are for killing humans.
 
Last edited:
While using the bomb robot to take out the suspect was novel, to me it smacks of the police acting as judge, jury, and executioner. They had the suspect contained. He was certainly dangerous, but in my opinion as long as he was contained they should have concentrated on taking him alive and let the justice system deal with him from there.

The police action was entirely correct. I only wish the pos could have been sniped earlier.
 
Jeez...Congratulating people for doing the moral thing is pretty-low expectations, isn't it?

What does morality have to do with managing to avoid hitting the wrong people during a wild shootout, during which innocent people who were responding to a call for help are getting cut down left and right in an ambush? The cops deserve high praise for being able to do so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom