Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

Restraint, good judgement and doing your job error-free are not on the moral spectrum. They are, however, worth noting.


Why? Are these attributes so uncommon in policing that they need to be pointed out and encouraged?

That's concerning.
 
Good morning. At first I had no idea why people where upset that the police used a robot to end this standoff. I think I understand the argument now. I imagine each scenario will be unique. In this case, from what has been reported, they had the admitted perp pinned down and were in communication with him for some time. It's been reported that he claimed there were IEDs planted and that there will be more injured or killed. Communications stopped and he continued to fire on police. They had no idea if he could remotely detonate them.We also don't know if there were injured in harm's way that needed to be helped but could not be gotten to because of the perp. Keeping in mind that this is happening in real time, not days later on a forum, the police made the decision to stop the perp in a way that would put no more of their own in harm's way. Did they have to blow him up? Probably not but it seems they felt the need to incapacitate him quickly to end the threat. I don't know if they have the ability to use some kind of non lethal way to do so using a robot. Gas, tazer, super glue, I'm guessing they are not readily equipped like that. Would I have liked to see the guy taken alive? Sure. Do I understand why that didn't happen? I think so but I will understand better as more information comes out. Perhaps people have a fear that this will lead to more and more use of robots to be judge, jury and executioner instead of negotiations and waiting things out. Until Asimov's Laws are embedded in all technology forbidding devices to harm people, even when ordered to, I suspect this will happen again. <remainder respectfully snipped>

Good points. Yes, the shooter was "contained", but how much freedom of movement he had I don't know. Was he in a building? If so, how do you enter the building with a sniper in it without risking more deaths?

Do you lob in tear gas? Now you have a crazy guy desperately wanting to leave the area, and he has a gun.

Do you send in a gas designed to make him unconscious? I don't know if such a thing is readily available. And how do you set the dose? Too little and and the guy's still conscious when you go in for him. Too much and you'll kill him.

Do you wait him out? He's human--he's gotta asleep some time. But some people can wake up very easily ... and he has a gun.

I've listed some options that might have been available instead of the robot bomb, along with reasons why they might not work. Anyone care to add to the list?
 
Yes, you can have an AR-15 custom made to meet the requirements. But why the hell do you bother?

The real appeal of this rifle is how effective they are for killing humans.
Speak for yourself and the relatively few other who use them that way. The appeal for me is the modular design and the versatility. I bother because there are more interesting cartridges out there to shoot than the 5.56.

An AR-15 custom made is as simple as swapping out parts, not something most people need a gunsmith for. If you can operate a screwdriver and a punch, then you can make your own "custom made" AR-15.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
Good points. Yes, the shooter was "contained",

I guess a big part of my question is this: Was he really contained?

He was still shooting. He had broken off communication with police. He was threatening to trigger IEDs. There were thought to be other shooters in the area.

He had already shot 12 cops and bystander. The cops are trained to seek cover, to provide cover for each other, to communicate. Some of them were combat veterans.

And he shot 12 of them anyway.

I would would never assume the guy was contained, just because he had not moved in a while. He had demonstrated a clear ability to outshoot police officers.

As for the "Judge, Jury, and executioner" concept: how is this different than a sniper in the same context? A sniper pulls a trigger, and EOD tech flips a switch. Either way, it is a person taking action to kill a person at distance. You don't know there is a sniper targeting you anymore than you know that Wall-E is no longer your friend. They don't exactly advertise that snipers are aiming at you.
 
Last edited:
Why anymore discussion of ARs? For two day now they have been saying he used an SKS. Larger slower bullet, and ten round fixed magazine. Full sized wooden stock. Not on even California's list of assault rifles.
 
Why anymore discussion of ARs? For two day now they have been saying he used an SKS. Larger slower bullet, and ten round fixed magazine. Full sized wooden stock. Not on even California's list of assault rifles.

Because a discussion of how the promotion of blood libel on social media sites fuels violence against police would be uncomfortable?

Hands up; don't shoot!
 
Because a discussion of how the promotion of blood libel on social media sites fuels violence against police would be uncomfortable?

Hands up; don't shoot!

You are right- it is probably best to just prohibit discussion of any issues involving society least the discussion upset some crazy person, leading them to do something horrible. In which case all the people who identified the potential problem in society can legitimately be blamed for the crazy person's horrible crime...

Certainly there are fevered, irrational, provocative, violence-invoking viewpoints that make it into the social media and popular news and that further inflame rather than calm situations. One might almost call them... hate speech. In my experience, this type of over-the-top, rabid speech arises from the most extreme groups on both sides of the political fence. I think that the USA does a pretty good job of seeking to limit only the most immediately dangerous forms of these. It is essential in a democratic society for people to be able to argue that, in their view, the police are racists. Or that Obama is a unconstitutional dictator. But, as the courts have agreed, I feel that making the leap to saying, shoot a cop, or shoot the President, crosses the line and does (and should) become a crime.

If you think HANDS UP, DON'T SHOOT is close to being an inciting of a crime, then I am concerned that your threshold of unacceptable speech is not very compatible with what I see as a democracy. And I would be curious as to what reciprocal limits you might think appropriate for the other side of the political divide. How about calling doctors who perform abortions murderers? It would be easy to argue that this kind of speech inspired people such as Scott Roeder into killing his victim in much the same way as you suggest some of the more virulent speech against the police led to police deaths.

I don't like extremists on either side. Nor do I like the extremists and crazies being used to as strawmen to discredit and hush up much more legitimate freedom of expression. I should be able to share my views about proper policing without being accused of contributing to the murder of police by crazy people.

But my apologies- this has become a gun control thread and I wouldn't want to distract it from its normal course. Please continue.
 
Last edited:
Because a discussion of how the promotion of blood libel on social media sites fuels violence against police would be uncomfortable?

Hands up; don't shoot!

Awww... disappointed that blacks will no longer tolerate the "guilty before proven innocent" attitude that some (actual, quite a few) conservatives continue to spew out.

TOO BAD!!!:mad::mad::mad:
 
Why anymore discussion of ARs? For two day now they have been saying he used an SKS. Larger slower bullet, and ten round fixed magazine. Full sized wooden stock. Not on even California's list of assault rifles.

I actually have an SKS 56, and I was thinking of taking it to the range today until I heard that bit of news. Maybe I'll take one of my other guns. Eeeek.
 
I have heard or read that Dallas cops were running towards the shots and many were shielding the innocent protesters. Bravery beyond words.

I find the use of the robot bomb very disturbing. If the shooter was contained, other means should have been used. I understand the shooter was still dangerous, but a freaking bomb?!
I really don't like this precedent.

they should have used less effective methods, possibly leading to more deaths to protect the feelings of you and those like you?

Dead is dead, I don't care what method they used unless it involved Torture or civilian casualties.
 
Well, if the cops can now use bombs we might as well give them Warthogs or maybe daisy cutters for those really bad areas.
 
You are right- it is probably best to just prohibit discussion of any issues involving society least the discussion upset some crazy person, leading them to do something horrible. In which case all the people who identified the potential problem in society can legitimately be blamed for the crazy person's horrible crime...

Certainly there are fevered, irrational, provocative, violence-invoking viewpoints that make it into the social media and popular news and that further inflame rather than calm situations. One might almost call them... hate speech. In my experience, this type of over-the-top, rabid speech arises from the most extreme groups on both sides of the political fence. I think that the USA does a pretty good job of seeking to limit only the most immediately dangerous forms of these. It is essential in a democratic society for people to be able to argue that, in their view, the police are racists. Or that Obama is a unconstitutional dictator. But, as the courts have agreed, I feel that making the leap to saying, shoot a cop, or shoot the President, crosses the line and does (and should) become a crime.

If you think HANDS UP, DON'T SHOOT is close to being an inciting of a crime, then I am concerned that your threshold of unacceptable speech is not very compatible with what I see as a democracy. And I would be curious as to what reciprocal limits you might think appropriate for the other side of the political divide. How about calling doctors who perform abortions murderers? It would be easy to argue that this kind of speech inspired people such as Scott Roeder into killing his victim in much the same way as you suggest some of the more virulent speech against the police led to police deaths.

I don't like extremists on either side. Nor do I like the extremists and crazies being used to as strawmen to discredit and hush up much more legitimate freedom of expression. I should be able to share my views about proper policing without being accused of contributing to the murder of police by crazy people.

But my apologies- this has become a gun control thread and I wouldn't want to distract it from its normal course. Please continue.

Your whole post is just a ridiculous strawman. Cylinder implied that the participants here were avoiding an uncomfortable discussion of the irresponsible anti-cop rhetoric on social media which might have incited the Dallas massacre, as well as other recent attacks on police. I don't know if people here are consciously avoiding it, or whether such a discussion would be uncomfortable, but your post certainly had nothing to do with what he wrote.
 
Well, if the cops can now use bombs we might as well give them Warthogs or maybe daisy cutters for those really bad areas.

I don't know for sure, but I suspect the robot bomb was quite small, targeted, and always under the control of an operator with a high resolution, wide angle video (and audio) feed. If so, then it was perhaps even more discriminating than a cop with a rifle from 100 feet away. An A-10 attack plane or a daisy cutter probably wouldn't be as easy to target on a single person without causing collateral damage.

I don't really have a problem with the police using this type of technology, although I don't see why it necessarily had to be lethal. It seems like you could deliver something incapacitating almost as easily.
 
Well, if the cops can now use bombs we might as well give them Warthogs or maybe daisy cutters for those really bad areas.

Well, if the cops can now use high speed projectiles we might as well give them howitzers and rail guns for those really bad areas.
 
Last edited:
Awww... disappointed that blacks will no longer tolerate the "guilty before proven innocent" attitude that some (actual, quite a few) conservatives continue to spew out.

TOO BAD!!!:mad::mad::mad:

The problems blacks have in our society are entirely, start to finish, a reflection of how they are as a populace.

They are outrageously, embarrassingly, unacceptably, unforgivably, inexcusably criminal.

They dislike the police because the police inhibit criminality.

Narratives of innocent blacks being mistreated by police are 97% BS with only a dash of reality to it. The media encouraging this victim attitude is the height of irresponsibility.
 
The problems blacks have in our society are entirely, start to finish, a reflection of how they are as a populace.

They are outrageously, embarrassingly, unacceptably, unforgivably, inexcusably criminal.

They dislike the police because the police inhibit criminality.

Narratives of innocent blacks being mistreated by police are 97% BS with only a dash of reality to it. The media encouraging this victim attitude is the height of irresponsibility.

Well,Well, looky what the cat dragged in.........

Take it to Stormfront buddy.
 
The problems blacks have in our society are entirely, start to finish, a reflection of how they are as a populace.

They are outrageously, embarrassingly, unacceptably, unforgivably, inexcusably criminal.

They dislike the police because the police inhibit criminality.

Narratives of innocent blacks being mistreated by police are 97% BS with only a dash of reality to it. The media encouraging this victim attitude is the height of irresponsibility.

The brutal double standard inflicted upon the black population by US law enforcement throughout the history of the nation is more than well documented.
 
The problems blacks have in our society are entirely, start to finish, a reflection of how they are as a populace.

They are outrageously, embarrassingly, unacceptably, unforgivably, inexcusably criminal.

They dislike the police because the police inhibit criminality.

Narratives of innocent blacks being mistreated by police are 97% BS with only a dash of reality to it. The media encouraging this victim attitude is the height of irresponsibility.

Are you regretting bringing them over and and treating them like animals for so long?

So much easier when they just shut up or else and picked the cotton?
 
The problems blacks have in our society are entirely, start to finish, a reflection of how they are as a populace.

They are outrageously, embarrassingly, unacceptably, unforgivably, inexcusably criminal.

They dislike the police because the police inhibit criminality.

Narratives of innocent blacks being mistreated by police are 97% BS with only a dash of reality to it. The media encouraging this victim attitude is the height of irresponsibility.

Thank you so much for allowing me the opportunity to write the post I just deleted. Ignorance is an easy foil, and boy was a review of US history a refreshing reminder of... At any rate, amazing. Thanks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom