You are right- it is probably best to just prohibit discussion of any issues involving society least the discussion upset some crazy person, leading them to do something horrible. In which case all the people who identified the potential problem in society can legitimately be blamed for the crazy person's horrible crime...
Certainly there are fevered, irrational, provocative, violence-invoking viewpoints that make it into the social media and popular news and that further inflame rather than calm situations. One might almost call them... hate speech. In my experience, this type of over-the-top, rabid speech arises from the most extreme groups on both sides of the political fence. I think that the USA does a pretty good job of seeking to limit only the most immediately dangerous forms of these. It is essential in a democratic society for people to be able to argue that, in their view, the police are racists. Or that Obama is a unconstitutional dictator. But, as the courts have agreed, I feel that making the leap to saying, shoot a cop, or shoot the President, crosses the line and does (and should) become a crime.
If you think HANDS UP, DON'T SHOOT is close to being an inciting of a crime, then I am concerned that your threshold of unacceptable speech is not very compatible with what I see as a democracy. And I would be curious as to what reciprocal limits you might think appropriate for the other side of the political divide. How about calling doctors who perform abortions murderers? It would be easy to argue that this kind of speech inspired people such as Scott Roeder into killing his victim in much the same way as you suggest some of the more virulent speech against the police led to police deaths.
I don't like extremists on either side. Nor do I like the extremists and crazies being used to as strawmen to discredit and hush up much more legitimate freedom of expression. I should be able to share my views about proper policing without being accused of contributing to the murder of police by crazy people.
But my apologies- this has become a gun control thread and I wouldn't want to distract it from its normal course. Please continue.