Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

Depends. Last time I checked he was still the "alleged shooter".

Obviously 95% guilty but you tend to try to bring them in. Not blow them up.

Unless your Judge Dredd
 
Any number if they are unsure

You seem to think I dont agree lethal force may have been necessary bringing him in.

I just don't agree sitting round out side while sending in a bomb to just blow him up was really called for.

Unless the hundreds of swat dudes lost it
 
Any number if they are unsure

You seem to think I dont agree lethal force may have been necessary bringing him in.

I just don't agree sitting round out side while sending in a bomb to just blow him up was really called for.

Unless the hundreds of swat dudes lost it

I can only hope, you never experience this type of carnage.
 
I can only hope, you never experience this type of carnage.
So can I

But this irrelevent to the fact the police's job is to try to bring in law breakers (alive if possible. Probably not in this casr) to face the full force of the law.

Not be judges and just go to death penalty
 
So can I

But this irrelevent to the fact the police's job is to try to bring in law breakers (alive if possible. Probably not in this casr) to face the full force of the law.

Not be judges and just go to death penalty

Never mind...
 
Never mind...
You disagree that is their job?

I missed where there was the bit where it says "unless #######" happens and you can just blow them up.

I totally understand it was horrible, but their job is their job

The fact the victims were cops should be irrelevant
 
Good morning. At first I had no idea why people where upset that the police used a robot to end this standoff. I think I understand the argument now. I imagine each scenario will be unique. In this case, from what has been reported, they had the admitted perp pinned down and were in communication with him for some time. It's been reported that he claimed there were IEDs planted and that there will be more injured or killed. Communications stopped and he continued to fire on police. They had no idea if he could remotely detonate them.We also don't know if there were injured in harm's way that needed to be helped but could not be gotten to because of the perp. Keeping in mind that this is happening in real time, not days later on a forum, the police made the decision to stop the perp in a way that would put no more of their own in harm's way. Did they have to blow him up? Probably not but it seems they felt the need to incapacitate him quickly to end the threat. I don't know if they have the ability to use some kind of non lethal way to do so using a robot. Gas, tazer, super glue, I'm guessing they are not readily equipped like that. Would I have liked to see the guy taken alive? Sure. Do I understand why that didn't happen? I think so but I will understand better as more information comes out. Perhaps people have a fear that this will lead to more and more use of robots to be judge, jury and executioner instead of negotiations and waiting things out. Until Asimov's Laws are embedded in all technology forbidding devices to harm people, even when ordered to, I suspect this will happen again. From all I have heard now on this situation, the Police seemed to have handled this wildly chaotic situation very well situation. So did the people who were openly carrying weapons. I've seen the one man who turned over his rifle to the police,after being named a suspect, has been making the rounds on the news upset at being questioned by the police at the time. I'm glad he wasn't shot and is able to complain about the way he was treated. He may see things a bit differently after some time settles in.
 
Last edited:
You disagree that is their job?

I missed where there was the bit where it says "unless #######" happens and you can just blow them up.

I totally understand it was horrible, but their job is their job

The fact the victims were cops should be irrelevant


nuetralizing an ongoing threat is their job
 
You disagree that is their job?

I missed where there was the bit where it says "unless #######" happens and you can just blow them up.

I totally understand it was horrible, but their job is their job

The fact the victims were cops should be irrelevant

The only thing that can stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun...if that doesn't work, use a robot bomber.
 
So can I

But this irrelevent to the fact the police's job is to try to bring in law breakers (alive if possible. Probably not in this casr) to face the full force of the law.

Not be judges and just go to death penalty

Yeah, I think this is the bit that troubles me. There's a sort of deliberative, considered element to driving a bomb in and detonating it. I too think the job is primarily to effect an arrest. That's not to discount the whole, "stopping an immediate threat" bit.
 
I have heard or read that Dallas cops were running towards the shots and many were shielding the innocent protesters. Bravery beyond words.

I find the use of the robot bomb very disturbing. If the shooter was contained, other means should have been used. I understand the shooter was still dangerous, but a freaking bomb?!
I really don't like this precedent.
 
I have heard or read that Dallas cops were running towards the shots and many were shielding the innocent protesters. Bravery beyond words.

I find the use of the robot bomb very disturbing. If the shooter was contained, other means should have been used. I understand the shooter was still dangerous, but a freaking bomb?!
I really don't like this precedent.

I believe he was threatening to detonate hidden IED's, so that probably played a role in the decision.
 
I have heard or read that Dallas cops were running towards the shots and many were shielding the innocent protesters. Bravery beyond words.

I find the use of the robot bomb very disturbing. If the shooter was contained, other means should have been used. I understand the shooter was still dangerous, but a freaking bomb?!
I really don't like this precedent.

That is a theme with the US police. One moment great, the next WTF?
 
Yes, you can have an AR-15 custom made to meet the requirements. But why the hell do you bother?

The real appeal of this rifle is how effective they are for killing humans.

And yet it's still exceeding rarely used for that purpose, despite its popularity (to say nothing of the other non-AR-15 military style semi-autos). How do you square that with your statement?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom