Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

A small, largely homogenous nation with a lot of wealth and historically low crime rates compared to a large, ethnically diverse nation with significant wealth disparities and ethnic tensions. South East Asia manages a Zero Tolerance Policy when it comes to crime, yet they have lower first-time and reoffending rates.
And this supports the supposed effectiveness of harsher punishments how?
 
And this supports the supposed effectiveness of harsher punishments how?

To explain harsher punishments efficacy, China managed to break mass opium addiction due to Lin Zexu imposing harsh penalties on distributors and forcing addicts into rehab in Canton. Then there's Singapore having one of the lowest murder and crime rates in the world. They can work, you just have to pay a high price for it.
 
... They can work, you just have to pay a high price for it.
Including finding that the system is judge and jury.

Authoritarian states have the added advantage that they have reporting and statistics under control. Plus, much of the shenanigans in such regimes involves official corruption, which is often easier to hide than street crime. Especially if the perp has mad connects with power.
 
Sure do. All the Suicides, the Stupid Gun-Brandishing Arrests and the people who stupidly shoot at a neighbor or relative...usually while Drunk!

I've seen the so-called "Gun Culture"...and it sucks.

When the press talks about gun culture, they almost alway talk about hunting. In fact the modern gun culture has almost nothing to do with traditional hunting or shooting sports.
 
Canada also allows widespread private gun ownership,(though it is a privilege rather then a right) but you just don't see the level of violence you see in the US.
And the level of gun shootings are on the rise. Maybe discussing those topics would be more productive then demanding a ban on all guns.
Anyway, such a ban in the US would never work. It would be prohibition all over again.
 
Alrighty then.

You do realize you live in a large experiment called the USA, no? It can be compared to other places, you know, those 'furrin' and funny places, some of which don't even know how to speak English. And guess what? Among those peoples who are supposedly enlightened and modern, you live scraping the very bottom of the nasty barrel. In fact, dead last. Sorry, but you did ask.

If you have any other questions, best to ask them soon, as you have vastly more chances of being gunned down than I do.

You will wait a very long time for an answer to this post. It is of course all that needs saying on the gun question, and therefore needs to be ignored, not addressed, by those who want to keep their guns.
 
Canada also allows widespread private gun ownership,(though it is a privilege rather then a right) but you just don't see the level of violence you see in the US.
And the level of gun shootings are on the rise. Maybe discussing those topics would be more productive then demanding a ban on all guns.
Anyway, such a ban in the US would never work. It would be prohibition all over again.

There's no difference between a "Privilege" and a "Right". For example, the US "Bill of Rights" is really just a "Bunch of Privileges" that the Rulers let the subjects have until....it becomes too inconvenient.
 
Y'all need to know that Americans are not going to be giving up their guns -- not now, not ever. This especially while Democrats are turning Chicago into '70s Colombia with the drug gangs running the city, and murder rates around the country skyrocketing while the Democrat-controlled national government encourages anti-police protests and the inevitable riots.
 
There's no difference between a "Privilege" and a "Right". For example, the US "Bill of Rights" is really just a "Bunch of Privileges" that the Rulers let the subjects have until....it becomes too inconvenient.

This is incorrect, even if only in a philosophical way. The BoR in spirit is not the government granting such privileges as it sees fit, but rather that the rights exist in and of themselves and the government cannot infringe upon them without overwhelmingly good reason (which the people must agree on).
 
You will wait a very long time for an answer to this post. It is of course all that needs saying on the gun question, and therefore needs to be ignored, not addressed, by those who want to keep their guns.

What you may think is Anti is somewhat so, but behind it is a defense from what is coming. This will sound off topic; it is not.

The tipping point has already been passed. The return on any given innovation is now highest in Asia. The heavy duty hard science baton is far from passing yet, as the interest of leaders has been on early stages of growth. But for China to retain world leadership not just in dollar terms, but across the board, it will start to invest in basic science as well. The effects of this ongoing shift are hard to see, but best served by example. The CCDs in some commercial goods surpass the best US spy satellites could come up with. That's surmountable as a logistics problem, but stated as a strategic one, it means the US is losing, and has lost, the ability to make what sustains it militarily. It will progressively lose the critical mass in R&D to retain leadership in many fields. This seems wildly out of tune with the current state of affairs, but the smart money looks at trends, not out the window. The US is a debtor nation with a shrinking free cash flow problem, and may soon simply not have the cash to compete, as what happened to the USSR. It is a question of when.

The remedy is to of course be on top of one's game. In this post-industrial world, that means tops in science and engineering. That means having the critical mass not just in brains, but in process experience on the ground. The US, though with points of brilliance, is losing ground fast. You do not get there by encouraging mythology, emotional attachment to anachronistic approaches to any domain or endeavor, and severely divisive policies that weaken you as a player.

In short, as the world is smarting up, the US is dumbing down. All part of a package called a worldview, a militaristic mindset that extends to civilian life, and an oversimplification of critical issues to allow private interest to trump the public trust. As everyone navel gazes, thinking a barrel in some house is a defense of the country - go freaking figure that one - your lunch will be eaten, and without a shot being fired. This is bad for the commons, as currently the other options for lead world policeman are truly gruesome.
 
Y'all need to know that Americans are not going to be giving up their guns -- not now, not ever. This especially while Democrats are turning Chicago into '70s Colombia with the drug gangs running the city, and murder rates around the country skyrocketing while the Democrat-controlled national government encourages anti-police protests and the inevitable riots.

Guns are the answer, Baby.
 
This is incorrect, even if only in a philosophical way. The BoR in spirit is not the government granting such privileges as it sees fit, but rather that the rights exist in and of themselves and the government cannot infringe upon them without overwhelmingly good reason (which the people must agree on).

"Rights exist in an of themselves"? What kind of magical thinking is this? It's childish!

Tell me....what right did Black Slaves in the Southern US have to the pursuit of Life, Liberty and Happiness? What right did Indians have to be "secure in their Possessions"? the Japanese-Americans during WW2....nope...no rights for them!

The Patriot Act and the Extrajudicial killing of Americans.

There's your Freakin' Rights!
 
That was my point.

They don't know but blow him up

You are missing my point, perhaps.

I think they thought he could set the bombs off remotely, and might start doing so if he were not neutralized. For that matter, if he had already shot 12 people, what on earth would make someone think he would give up and let every know where the bombs were?

If they bombs had been real (which the police believed at the time) he could have either set them off remotely, or they might have been on timers. He had stopped negotiating and was shooting again. Why wait for him to maybe stop shooting? Was there any indication he would stop?
 
I'd like to thank the my fellow Dallas and D-FW peeps for weighing in. I was at a work location in Lewisville when the news broke and by the time I got back to our main campus in Plano it was about 10:30pm. Went home, drank beer and watched the news until 4am.
:(
 
"Rights exist in an of themselves"? What kind of magical thinking is this? It's childish!

Tell me....what right did Black Slaves in the Southern US have to the pursuit of Life, Liberty and Happiness? What right did Indians have to be "secure in their Possessions"? the Japanese-Americans during WW2....nope...no rights for them!

The Patriot Act and the Extrajudicial killing of Americans.

There's your Freakin' Rights!

I suppose it serves me right for feeding the troll.
 
You are missing my point, perhaps.

I think they thought he could set the bombs off remotely, and might start doing so if he were not neutralized. For that matter, if he had already shot 12 people, what on earth would make someone think he would give up and let every know where the bombs were?

If they bombs had been real (which the police believed at the time) he could have either set them off remotely, or they might have been on timers. He had stopped negotiating and was shooting again. Why wait for him to maybe stop shooting? Was there any indication he would stop?

Finite ammo comes to mind.

Your tale of justification goes step-wise with each link in the chain having some reasoning behind it. But the cops turned out to be wrong. This indicates there was poor reasoning somewhere.

Do you think police agencies should add bomb-laden robots to their inventories in case similar circumstances arise? Remember, for this to happen at all, the cops had to have a bomb around in storage, ready to transport to the scene and be deployed.

I'm curious to know if the robot-bomb was an existing plan or spur of the moment expediency.
 
F But the cops turned out to be wrong. This indicates there was poor reasoning somewhere.

This tells me the cops were acting on the information they had on-hand at the time. That information was incorrect, but that does not indicate poor reasoning. The scene of large emergencies is always chaotic and it is always difficult to separate accurate from inaccurate information during such an emergency. Fog of War, even if it is not actually a war.

Do you think police agencies should add bomb-laden robots to their inventories in case similar circumstances arise?

No

Remember, for this to happen at all, the cops had to have a bomb around in storage, ready to transport to the scene and be deployed.

I am guessing you are wrong about that. If you are, would that indicate poor reasoning?

Police departments have explosives used to detonate suspicious packages or to train bomb squads (the Miami police, for example, used explosives to breach the wall of the nightclub during the recent mass shooting there). Maybe little prepackaged devices, or maybe just some explosives and blasting caps that can be measured out to suit the occasion. Take some of that, add some shrapnel (open up a couple of shotgun shells and use the shot), and you've got an improvised grenade - I am guessing an ordnance tech could do it in a minute or two. The robot may already been equipped to hold and detonate explosive charges, because blowing up suspicious packages is part of what bomb disposal robots are designed to do.

I'm curious to know if the robot-bomb was an existing plan or spur of the moment expediency.

I am guessing that it was a spur of the moment plan. We don't know that yet, of course.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom