More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

I can't be bothered to comment at Huffington Post in response to Dana's misconceived article, but he does seem to have a little band of acolytes posting in support of himwith the usual naive and credulous puffery.

Here for example;

" My personal experience is that homeopathy has been a literal life saver for me in my treatment of serious, chronic illnesses such as neuropathy."

Of course, the only thing we can know for sure is that if it was cured by sugar pills it was neither serious nor life-threatening. The problem with hom patients is that every sniff and cough or pins and needles has either to be plague or a brain tumour. They are just lucky that DUllman is always available to feed their delusion.
 
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.

And people here should probably not want to learn about Darwin because he wanted to learn...and you don't.

And you don't have to buy a book to read it because there is a new invention called libraries...you really should try one...

If any of you do get around to reading my eCAM article, you may actually learn something (don't worry...it won't hurt).
 
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.
Oooo I've learned enough things Mr. Gully like how the physics and chemistry renders homeopathy moot.
 
Last edited:
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.

And people here should probably not want to learn about Darwin because he wanted to learn...and you don't.

And you don't have to buy a book to read it because there is a new invention called libraries...you really should try one...

If any of you do get around to reading my eCAM article, you may actually learn something (don't worry...it won't hurt).

Oh Dana. We are not your audience. Obviously what you really mean is, "people who will read my ******** and accept it without question" when you say "learn something." Because we have been down this road before.

Your problem isn't that we haven't read this information. Your problem is that we have.

Linda
 
Your problem isn't that we haven't read this information. Your problem is that we have.

Linda
Let me get this straight. Gully is Dana Ullman. Great. Hehehehe..... I have some good questions for him. Like why is it that no chemist or physicist has never observed or have developed a chemical model that would legitimize homeopathy outside of people who study homeopathy.
i


rustum roy can distinguish a remedy from placebo using UV spect
Say what? Why use UV spectra when water itself is IR active. If anything you should be able to detect the changes in the structure of water in the IR region.
EDIT:
Also, as someone who is running the spectra of materials hydrated with water its a pain in the ass to do it correctly. If you let the material set outside it will hydrate with the humid air. If you run the material incorrectly in the spectrometer you might force the water out.
 
Last edited:
Come on guys...do your homework. The information about the German homeopath was NOT new, though your remarks do verify my previous contention: you did NOT read the chapter on Darwin in my book ir read my book at all.


Do you have any evidence for Darwin's "admiration" of the German homoeopath beyond what you referenced in your eCAM article? If you do, why didn't you reference it there, given that the note you referenced clearly fails to support your contention?
 
I stay out of homoeopathy debates because there are folks here with vastly better knowledge than my own. But I had to comment on this:

He's puffing it in the Huffpo, where he of course plugs his big celebrity book of homoeopathy as well.

From that link:

It is impossible to know if Charles Darwin would have survived long enough to have written his seminal book in 1859, published 10 years after Dr. Gully’s treatment. We may all have to thank the water cure and homeopathic treatment provided by Dr. Gully for Darwin’s survival.

What a bunch of weasel words meant for a credulous audience. "It is impossible to know ..." and "We may ..." are all designed to avoid responsibility for a clear cut statement that there is no evidence that homeopathy had anything whatsoever to do with Darwin's survival.

That article is a sickening piece of garbage.
 
I stay out of homoeopathy debates because there are folks here with vastly better knowledge than my own. But I had to comment on this:



From that link:



What a bunch of weasel words meant for a credulous audience. "It is impossible to know ..." and "We may ..." are all designed to avoid responsibility for a clear cut statement that there is no evidence that homeopathy had anything whatsoever to do with Darwin's survival.

That article is a sickening piece of garbage.

Some of the comments to the article are hilarious! :D

Whitely2009 said:
Homeopathy is a strange and marvelous "material" chemistry science versus organic and inorganic chemistry. It is really involved with quantum physics.

I have been making and effectively using my own homeopathic medicines for many years. Many of my veterinarian friends use homeopathy very effectively on horses, dogs, cats, and other animals. One can easily prove the power of homeopathy by making mineral versions and using them on plants as super fertilizer. The plants and animals do not speak English so there is no placebo effect....
 
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.

And people here should probably not want to learn about Darwin because he wanted to learn...and you don't.

No, no, Dana, I have learnt a lot since I started to study homeopathy 6 or 7 years ago. I've learnt a lot about critically appraising evidence- more than I was ever taught during my training, which itself has been an important insight. I have learnt a lot about the mindset of True Bleevers in alt.med. I have learnt an enormous amount about the lies, half-truths and weasel-words that are necessary to sustain faith in alt.med. You have been responsible for some important parts of that learning and I both thank and pity you. It is indeed a pity that you seem unable to learn these things for yourself. It is a sad waste of a life to insist that false things are true and lead others down that same path.
 
If any of you do get around to reading my eCAM article, you may actually learn something (don't worry...it won't hurt).
You have already been shown to use misquotes and quoting out of context in order to further your favourite superstition. Why should we believe that you have suddenly stopped this practice?

And why is interesting if Darwin believed in supernatural healing (which he did not according to the sources we have seen until now)? Homoeopathy will not suddenly be able to work, simply because Darwin - or anybody else - believes it.

You should rather spend your energy on furthering good quality clinical tests that showed the worth of homoeopathy. But, as you well know, they have already been performed, and homoeopathy came out as a dud.
 
Amazing that these plants and animals are able to report that their condition has improved, isn't it?


And in all the time since Darwin no one has ever successfully generated successful results in animals or plants when adequate blinding and controls stop the experimenters cheating or kidding themselves. The mere fact that DUllman cites badly reported experiments from over century ago should teach himself something rather important. I certainly don't see any evidence of him wanting to learn from that.

It's the same with various of the studies that he continues to puff around the interweb, the COPD paper for instance, where their deficiencies have been pointed out to him so often and so clearly that it must take a very special kind of stubbornness to resist learning from the lessons have been given. That shiny, shiny dome seems to be a near-perfect reflector of accurate information.
 
Mojo, could you please link or re-post that interesting calculation you recently did that shows the erosion of "positive" results for homeopathy according to the SoH's, or was it Fac Hom's, list of papers supportive of homeopathy.

I think that has been one of the most useful contributions to the meta-analysis of the homeopathic literature. It quite clearly shows that, even when the work is reported by believers, greater concordance with the need for good controls is leading asymptotically to demonstrating zero-effect from homeopathy.
 
And in all the time since Darwin no one has ever successfully generated successful results in animals or plants when adequate blinding and controls stop the experimenters cheating or kidding themselves. The mere fact that DUllman cites badly reported experiments from over century ago should teach himself something rather important. I certainly don't see any evidence of him wanting to learn from that.


Even Darwin's experiments only showed that Drosera is sensitive to very low concentrations of ammonium. As reported in chapter 7 (pages 136-173) of Insectivorous Plants (1875) there is no mention of serial dilution. There is certainly no mention of succussion, which Dana has repeatedly assured us is essential in the preparation of homoeopathic remedies (remember the sort of fuss he makes whenever anyone discusses the ludicrous dilutions without mentioning the magic shaking?).

Darwin established an orthodox dose-response, with more dilute solutions having lesser effect. See also the conditions he says are necessary for solutions of various strengths: "It is to be especially observed that the experiments with the weaker solutions ought to be tried after several days of very warm weather. Those with the weakest solutions should be made on plants which have been kept for a considerable time in a warm greenhouse, or cool hothouse; but this is by no means necessary for trials with solutions of moderate strength."

While Darwin was at first surprised that Drosera reacted to concentrations that were at the time undetectable, he notes in a footnote on page 170 that the development of spectroscopy since his first observations meant that chemists could detect substances at lower concentrations than those that Drosera reacts to: "the spectroscope has altogether beaten Drosera".

Incidentally, note Dana's use of ellipsis in the passage he quotes from Insectivorous Plants. One of the sections he omits, from immediately before "...in fact, every time that we perceive an odor, we have evidence that infinitely smaller particles act on our nerves" (Dana capitalises the first letter of that passage so it looks like the start of a sentence) says "Astonishing as is this result, there is no sound reason why we should reject it as incredible. Prof. Donders, of Utrecht, informs me that from experiments formerly made by him and Dr. De Ruyter, he inferred that less than the one-millionth of a grain of sulphate of atropine, in an extremely diluted state, if applied directly to the iris of a dog, paralyses the muscles of this organ. But, ..."

Oh, and of course there's no connection whatsoever with "like cures like".

Darwin's experiments on Drosera are nothing to do with homoeopathy, no matter how the homoeopaths try to spin them.
 
Last edited:
Mojo, could you please link or re-post that interesting calculation you recently did that shows the erosion of "positive" results for homeopathy according to the SoH's, or was it Fac Hom's, list of papers supportive of homeopathy.

I think that has been one of the most useful contributions to the meta-analysis of the homeopathic literature. It quite clearly shows that, even when the work is reported by believers, greater concordance with the need for good controls is leading asymptotically to demonstrating zero-effect from homeopathy.


It was the BHA/FoH (which seem to be aspects of the same organisation).

First, a study published in Homeopathy (Mathie RT: The research evidence base for homeopathy: a fresh assessment of the literature. Homeopathy (2003) 92, 84–91) counted the trials between 1975 and the end of 2002 and found 50 positive, 41 inconclusive and 2 negative.

Mathie is "Research Development Adviser, British Homeopathic Association & Faculty of Homeopathy".

Second, a document giving its source as the British Homeopathic Association says that they found 119 trials up to the end of 2005. The percentages they give there are 49% positive, 48% inconclusive, and 3% negative; these work out to 58 positive, 57 inconclusive and 4 negative (Peter Fisher, the editor of Homeopathy, the Faculty's journal, has cited these same figures, although without saying where they came from).

Third, a document produced by the Faculty of Homeopathy and published on the BHA's website, which says "Up to the end of 2008, 138 RCTs had been published: 60 positive; 10 negative; 68 not statistically conclusive."

None of these appears to have taken any notice of study quality or size, indeed the 2003 Mathie paper explicitly states that it ignored study quality.

Assuming that all these figures have been arrived at on the same basis:

Up to 2002: 93 trials, 53.8% positive;
2003-2005: 26 trials, 30.8% positive;
2006-2008: 19 trials, 10.5% positive.

At least they appear to be getting better at conducting trials.
 
Last edited:
Some of the comments to the article are hilarious! :D
Hilarious. It makes me want to scream. The way Dana Ullman or any other homeopath is backwards from every single field of science on the face of the earth. They are trying to prove efficacy without having any clue as to how the mechanism actually works.
 
They are trying to prove efficacy without having any clue as to how the mechanism actually works.


Actually, that's no real problem. There isn't much point in worrying about a mechanism for nonexistent effects.

Their problem is that they have resorted to trying to prove efficacy by reference to vaguely reported anomalies, and by arguments to antiquity, popularity, authority, and other irrelevancies.

And, of course, by misusing meta-analyses:
Our 1997 meta-analysis has unfortunately been misused by homoeopaths as evidence that their therapy is proven.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom