More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

yes, possibly any polar molecule will do. i recall something about a Korean study where this was the case.

46. 2001 Geckeler, Kurt and Samal, Shashadhar at the Kwangju Institute of Science and Technology in South Korea discovered fullerenes, football-shaped buckyball molecules, formed aggregates in solution, and when diluted,

Someone did some further investigation into that one and found no evidence of the effect. See

Lack of evidence of dilution history-dependence upon solute aggregation in water. A nuclear magnetic resonance determination of self-diffusion coefficients

Fernando Hallwass, M. Engelsberg and A. M. Simas

Chem. Commun., 2002, 2530 - 2531
 
not at all, rustum roy's experiment is going to blow the doors down once it catches on with other scientists.


you'll just have to admit you were wrong.

When are we going to be able to peruse the results of this experiment? I'm tickled about the idea of an experiment "catching on" with scientists.
 
When are we going to be able to peruse the results of this experiment?


2007:

Manju Lata Rao, Rustum Roy, Iris R. Bell and Richard Hoover: "The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy ", Homeopathy Volume 96, Issue 3, July 2007, Pages 175-182

See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=88831

Here you can see the text of a letter about it written by four forum members, which was published at Homeopathy Volume 97, Issue 1, pages 44-45.

There's plenty of further comment on the paper, the letter and Rao's "response" in the thread.
 
It looks as if Dana may be winding up to drop another "bomb":

DanaUllman said:
I have also previously posed a question that no one has yet to respond: What would you think if one or two or more homeopathic medicines in post-Avogadro’s number dose were found to have an influence on genetic expression? Would THAT be of interest? Come on…go on record…


He's dropped it:

Dana Ullman reports that a new study done at the Amala Cancer Research Centre in India and published in the Oxford University Press journal called e-CAM shows that homeopathy has a dramatic impact on gene expression...

Here it is: http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/6/2/257

Sunila ES, Kuttan R, Preethi KC, Kuttan G: Dynamized preparations in cell culture. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2009 Jun;6(2):257-63. Epub 2007 Oct 3.

I don't know why Dana was so coy about naming it over on Science Based Medicine - it was published over 18 months ago.
 
Fine. Show that you can distiguish a homoeopathic preparation from the stock carrier material in this way, and I'm listening. If it's "dramatic", that should be easy.

Rolfe.
 
He's dropped it:



Here it is: http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/6/2/257

Sunila ES, Kuttan R, Preethi KC, Kuttan G: Dynamized preparations in cell culture. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2009 Jun;6(2):257-63. Epub 2007 Oct 3.

I don't know why Dana was so coy about naming it over on Science Based Medicine - it was published over 18 months ago.


While not wishing to spoil anyone's fun, can someone just tell me what gross error has been committed in this trial, since it has all the typical hallmarks- fragile and over-complicated experimental model with plenty of room for error. Presumably there was no blinding for one thing.
 
If we would grant the woo-woo physics of water...

To me, it does not say one single thing on how this then would translate in the body being triggered into healing.

And, I never got an answer to a question I once asked in a homeopathy store:

If it works, then why can I not put some diluted drops of most of the remedies into the ocean and have all people on the planet heal by just taking a dip in the ocean?


Follow what I call Randi's Rule: Before trying to explain a phenomenon, first demonstrate it exists.

IIRC, there have been no repeatable tests that show anything other than a placebo effect. So one need not jump into explanations, much less one that throws known physics on its head.
 
Ullman will probably try that debating technique but the arbitrators on that case had nothing to do with the editing of the homeopathy articles.

After being warned, tutored and restricted, he attacked other editors for bias and lack of assumption of good faith. Banning him for one year just gives wiki an all too brief rest from him.
1 year bans have a habit of being extended.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents#DanaUllman
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipe...thy#Log_of_blocks.2C_bans.2C_and_restrictions
 
He even managed to offend his friends along the way. Hilarious.

Methinks, Enric, you doth protest too loudly. In complete and due respect, I wrote that I wish to assume good faith but was confused by your proposal. Instead of providing any clarity, you chose to attack the question. Methinks that you should answer the question, and I urge you to assume good faith on my part and to avoid providing warnings which you yourself have just ignored by not showing good faith. When you reply to my initial concern, please also cite your reason to either include or exclude the "news and notes" article on Oscillococcinum published in the Lancet. They assert that the result from this treatment is clinically relevant. DanaUllmanTalk 20:36, 27 July 2009 (UTC)
Dana, when you say that Enric is "not showing good faith" you are accusing him of bad faith. Please be careful. Best just not to mention good faith. WP:AAGF —Whig (talk) 05:28, 28 July 2009 (UTC)
Whig, you have misquoted me. I never said that! I simply said "I wish to assume good faith". Please do not put quotes on things that I did not say. As I noted above, I was simply confused by what Enric had written. DanaUllmanTalk 03:03, 29 July 2009 (UTC)
I most certainly did not misquote you. You stated just above, "I urge you to assume good faith on my part and to avoid providing warnings which you yourself have just ignored by not showing good faith." The last four words are what I excerpted last time. My advice remains: AAGF. —Whig (talk) 03:47, 29 July 2009 (UTC)


As usual the funniest thing is when his own contradictions are placed in such close proximity.
 
He's dropped it:

Here it is: http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/6/2/257

Sunila ES, Kuttan R, Preethi KC, Kuttan G: Dynamized preparations in cell culture. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2009 Jun;6(2):257-63. Epub 2007 Oct 3.

I don't know why Dana was so coy about naming it over on Science Based Medicine - it was published over 18 months ago.
While not wishing to spoil anyone's fun, can someone just tell me what gross error has been committed in this trial, since it has all the typical hallmarks- fragile and over-complicated experimental model with plenty of room for error. Presumably there was no blinding for one thing.


I've just spotted a discussion of it over at White Coat Underground:

http://scienceblogs.com/whitecoatunderground/2009/06/oprahs_website_of_woo.php

Dana cites it in post #13.
 
Dana's managed to get his Darwin stuff published again: The Curious Case of Charles Darwin and Homeopathy. He's puffing it in the Huffpo, where he of course plugs his big celebrity book of homoeopathy as well.

Mostly the same stuff that's already been repeatedly demolished here and elsewhere, but there's a new bit: apparently Darwin admired a German homoeopath. The reference Dana cites to support this "admiration" is from Francis Darwin's Life and Letters of Charles Darwin. The introduction to the 1862 letters says:
1862.

[Owing to the illness from scarlet fever of one of his boys, he took a house at Bournemouth in the autumn. He wrote to Dr. Gray from Southampton (August 21, 1862):--

"We are a wretched family, and ought to be exterminated. We slept here to rest our poor boy on his journey to Bournemouth, and my poor dear wife sickened with scarlet fever, and has had it pretty sharply, but is recovering well. There is no end of trouble in this weary world. I shall not feel safe till we are all at home together, and when that will be I know not. But it is foolish complaining."

Dr. Gray used to send postage stamps to the scarlet fever patient; with regard to this good-natured deed my father wrote--

"I must just recur to stamps; my little man has calculated that he will now have 6 stamps which no other boy in the school has. Here is a triumph. Your last letter was plaistered with many coloured stamps, and he long surveyed the envelope in bed with much quiet satisfaction."

The greater number of the letters of 1862 deal with the Orchid work, but the wave of conversion to Evolution was still spreading, and reviews and letters bearing on the subject still came in numbers. As an example of the odd letters he received may be mentioned one which arrived in January of this year "from a German homoeopathic doctor, an ardent admirer of the 'Origin.' Had himself published nearly the same sort of book, but goes much deeper. Explains the origin of plants and animals on the principles of homoeopathy or by the law of spirality. Book fell dead in Germany. Therefore would I translate it and publish it in England."]


Dana quotes the last paragraph, noting that the first section "was probably written by Francis Darwin", and describes it as "an August 20, 1862, letter to Asa Gray". I can't find any sign of this letter in the Darwin Correspondence project. It looks to me like a note of a letter Darwin received, rather than one he wrote.

Dana writes:
What is intriguing about Darwin's statement is that he asserted that this writing by a homeopathic doctor is similar to his own but ‘goes much deeper’.


I don't see any evidence that Darwin had actually read this German homoeopath's book, or even that the homoeopath had sent him a copy. It looks more as if Darwin is merely reporting the homeopath's opinion of his own work as expressed in his letter to Darwin.

It is hard to see how this support's Dana's assertion of "Darwin's Admiration of Another Homeopath".
 
Come on guys...do your homework. The information about the German homeopath was NOT new, though your remarks do verify my previous contention: you did NOT read the chapter on Darwin in my book ir read my book at all.

Ironically, your arm chair philosophizing is cute...but heck, you pull things out of the air by suggesting that Charles Darwin really did not write his own letters. Good one.

Spin on! You remind me of Fox News.

My new article does have some new stuff in it, but perhaps THIS is what you mean by double-blind...you close both of your eyes when reading.
 
Come on guys...do your homework. The information about the German homeopath was NOT new, though your remarks do verify my previous contention: you did NOT read the chapter on Darwin in my book ir read my book at all.

Why the hell would we want to read your book, Dana? Not making enough money scamming the homeopaths that you need sceptics to buy your book as well?
 
Come on guys...do your homework. The information about the German homeopath was NOT new, though your remarks do verify my previous contention: you did NOT read the chapter on Darwin in my book ir read my book at all.

Ironically, your arm chair philosophizing is cute...but heck, you pull things out of the air by suggesting that Charles Darwin really did not write his own letters. Good one.

Spin on! You remind me of Fox News.

My new article does have some new stuff in it, but perhaps THIS is what you mean by double-blind...you close both of your eyes when reading.

Ah yes. Homeopathy - an idea so stagnant that 147 year old offhand remarks are considered au courant.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom