More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Geckeler, Kurt and Samal, Shashadhar at the Kwangju Institute of Science and Technology in South Korea discovered fullerenes, football-shaped buckyball molecules, formed aggregates in solution, and when diluted, the size of the fullerene particles increased. Cyclodextrin molecules behaved the same way. So did the organic molecule sodium guanosine monophosphate, DNA and sodium chloride. Dilution made molecules cluster five to 10 times bigger than those in the original solutions.


If the molecules cluster together, then they will in still be diluted out of a sequentially diluted preparation in the same way. The only difference will be that in the tiny proportion of samples that actually have any molecules from the MT present, there will be a cluster of more than one molecule present, but there will, of course, be even fewer samples with any molecules present than if the molecules were not clustered.

For example, if typically ten molecules clustered together in a 30C preparation, then rather than giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient, you could carry this on for another 36 billion years without more than one patient being likely to get a dose containing molecules of solute from the MT, but the lucky patient would receive ten molecules. If the clusters contain more molecules than this you could keep going even longer.

No help to homoeopathy whatsoever.
 
If the molecules cluster together, then they will in still be diluted out of a sequentially diluted preparation in the same way. The only difference will be that in the tiny proportion of samples that actually have any molecules from the MT present, there will be a cluster of more than one molecule present, but there will, of course, be even fewer samples with any molecules present than if the molecules were not clustered.

For example, if typically ten molecules clustered together in a 30C preparation, then rather than giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient, you could carry this on for another 36 billion years without more than one patient being likely to get a dose containing molecules of solute from the MT, but the lucky patient would receive ten molecules. If the clusters contain more molecules than this you could keep going even longer.

No help to homoeopathy whatsoever.


As is so often the case with homeopathy, it only becomes really really funny when you take the claims of its proponents at face value.

As I have said before, the whole thing is a giant exercise in reductio ad absurdum. Their claims often seem superficially attractive, especially to a non-scientist- "Ooh, 'like cures like' is quite like vaccination". But it falls apart as soon as you take any one of their claims to its logical conclusion, which is also why the whole effort of putting it through clinical trials is literally a waste of time, money and resources and is not going to yield more meaningful results than those we already have. It doesn't work (beyond placebo). End of story.
 
Last edited:
Mojo

Seeing you stole my response and altered it, I will repay you by stealing your response and altering it. :D

If typically ten molecules clustered together in a 30C preparation, then rather than giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver [one] molecule of the original material to [one] patient, you could carry this on for another 36 billion years [to deliver ten molecules to one patient].


Ah, great response, if I do say so myself. :cool:

BJ
 
P.W. Bridgman, PhD, former professor of physics at Harvard for a couple of decades, and he is a Nobel Laureate. He wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH PRESSURE. He found that whenever one takes water to certain pressures and freeze it, it freezes in a different pattern based on the high pressure. However, he found that once water is frozen at one pressure, it "remembers" the structure of the water and refreezes in a similar pattern at a different pressure. Water does seem to have a memory, and you can seem to "write" on it.


Several years ago, I debated Saul Green, PhD, a chemist and skeptic of homeopathy. He thoroughy embarrassed himself and fellow skeptics by answering this question by saying that it was "folk wisdom." Needless to say, that is not the right answer.

What do YOU think is the right answer?



what do i think is the right answer? i am quite certain that saul green thoroughly embarrassed himself.

when you get the book it will be fun to see how you manage to twist what bridgman wrote.
 
what do i think is the right answer? i am quite certain that saul green thoroughly embarrassed himself.

when you get the book it will be fun to see how you manage to twist what bridgman wrote.

The book is from 1931. You would think that this Earth shattering revolution of Physics would have had some follow up by now. Particularly, as when it was purportedly discovered by Bridgman, he had 30 years ahead of him. Do you suppose that a Nobel laureate could not get the required lab time? :boggled:
 
what do i think is the right answer? i am quite certain that saul green thoroughly embarrassed himself.
Sure you are since you were there...weren't you?
You have read the book in question...haven't you?

when you get the book it will be fun to see how you manage to twist what bridgman wrote.
Wait a minute? You have not read the book, your messiah got the name of the book wrong and now you are claiming that people who are actually out to get the book will "twist it"?

That is truly pathetic. Not only are you making a fool of yourself, you are one of the laziest people around. Why don't you actually do some work and actually go down to the damn library and get the book and prove everyone here wrong?

I'm not surprised by this level of intelligence coming from a homeopath.
 
when you get the book it will be fun to see how you manage to twist what bridgman wrote.


Can you give us a page reference?

If you don't have the book to hand, perhaps you could try the university research library you used to drop in on, unless it's already closed for the summer.
 
Last edited:
what do i think is the right answer? i am quite certain that saul green thoroughly embarrassed himself.

when you get the book it will be fun to see how you manage to twist what bridgman wrote.


I like her. Can I keeps her? She make me laff!

Rolfe.
 
That is truly pathetic. Not only are you making a fool of yourself, you are one of the laziest people around. Why don't you actually do some work and actually go down to the damn library and get the book and prove everyone here wrong?


Might have to wait a week or two, there's that wiki article on p value to dicipher first. ;)

BJ
 
Meow, meow. Sounds like you are allergic to cats.

Since sneezing is also caused by pepper, take one grain of finally ground pepper and put it in a full-sized Olympic swimming pool full of twice distilled water and mix thoroughly. Drink a tea-spoonful of the results and you will be cured! :boggled:

Well I can't sneeze at that homeopathetic remedy ..
 
An opportunist writes

Homeopathic Medicines for Traumatic Head Injury by "DanaUllman, citizen journalist".

http://www.naturalnews. com/026057.html

Natasha Richardson recently passed away as a result of a seemingly mild traumatic head injury, and the world mourns. Now, every mother and father and concerned friend will worry when anyone near and dear to them suffers from any head injury. The good news is that research has confirmed that homeopathic medicines can be used to treat people who suffer from head trauma.


His evidence for this? A ten year old trial of individualised homoeopathy in "patients with persistent MTBI (mean 2.93 years since injury, SD 3.1)" - not a trial of homoeopathy used in the immediate aftermath of head injury (although I suppose a trial of that would run into insurmountable ethical problems). It just isn't relevant to his claim that "homeopathic medicines can be used preventively to avoid complications from acute head injury".

It appears that 10 of the 60 patients involved dropped out:
A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 60 patients, with a four-month follow-up (N = 50)

Oh, and the abstract concludes:
Our findings require large-scale, independent replication.


Any signs of this in the decade since it was published?
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, I note that Dana says that Cicuta should be considered "if the head injury is severe enough to suggest mental retardation", and people "who have difficulty understanding others" may benefit from Hellaborus. Physician, heal thyself!
 
By the way, here's another comment from Dana:
Because Oscillococcinum is made from the liver & heart of a duck and because ducks are reservoirs of flu viruses, this drug make sense, biologically. It has been used in homeopathy since the 1920s and thus verifies that homeopaths have been knowledgeable of avian sources of flu virus for a long time.


:boggled:
 
It looks as if Dana may be winding up to drop another "bomb":

DanaUllman said:
I have also previously posed a question that no one has yet to respond: What would you think if one or two or more homeopathic medicines in post-Avogadro’s number dose were found to have an influence on genetic expression? Would THAT be of interest? Come on…go on record…
 
Here's this month's offering:

Doctatorship: Military thinking in medicine

http://www.odemagazine.com/doc/63/military-medicine/

To treat a patient, the doctor must provide a diagnosis that determines the existence of a “Western medical disease,” or WMD, even if this diagnosis is sometimes based on faulty medical intelligence or just selective intelligence.


I'm really impressed with his invocation of the claims of the existence of WMDs that were unsupported by actual evidence. "Selective intelligence" is a pretty much perfect description of the cherry-picking of a handful of apparently positive trials that are then continually cited. That must be a highly compartmentalised mind he has there.
 
Last edited:
How do you compartmentalise something who's dimensions are already Planck-length?

It seems Dana is revealing yet more unexplored quantum weirdness in homeopathy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom