More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Come on meow, even you must realise how ridiculous you look with claims like these. Your claims are ignorant and foolish, and you must know that on a shallow level, never mind deep down.


It's only trolling. "She only does it to annoy, because she knows it teases."

Rolfe.
 
your letter is trivial nitpicking and deep down you know it.


Uh, there were so many trivial nits we could have picked in that paper, it took a conscious effort of will not to do that, and just stick to the glaring, fatal flaws.

Have you realised yet that Rao accepted our criticisms as being justified?

Rolfe.
 
Uh, there were so many trivial nits we could have picked in that paper, it took a conscious effort of will not to do that, and just stick to the glaring, fatal flaws.

Have you realised yet that Rao accepted our criticisms as being justified?

Rolfe.


i'd like to see the response.
 
Last edited:
Well, it's making me sneeze.

Meow, meow. Sounds like you are allergic to cats.

Since sneezing is also caused by pepper, take one grain of finally ground pepper and put it in a full-sized Olympic swimming pool full of twice distilled water and mix thoroughly. Drink a tea-spoonful of the results and you will be cured! :boggled:
 
Meow

i had a year of Stat and Quant Analysis. i know what it is.

and if i didn't i could google it and fake it. so why do u bother even asking.

rustum roy, ennis and rey are digging your grave.

Then you should be ashamed of yourself. :o
I know you could google it, and I expect you have, but still you have not answered the question.
That's why I bother asking ;)

Come on, I'm only a tiny little mouse, this should be easy, even for a little pussy-cat like you.
(I have a big pencil though, so watch out! :eye-poppi)

BillyJoe
 
P.W. Bridgman, PhD, former professor of physics at Harvard for a couple of decades, and he is a Nobel Laureate. He wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE. He found that whenever one takes water to certain altitudes and freeze it, it freezes in a different pattern based on the high pressure of altitude. However, he found that once water is frozen at one altitude, it "remembers" the structure of the water and refreezes in a similar pattern at a different altitude. Water does seem to have a memory, and you can seem to "write" on it.


I've been trying to track down references to these findings of Bridgman's, but haven't found much. The comments I've so far found (including the one I've quoted above) do all have something in common, though.

Here's another one (see the section entitled "An Overview of Recent Research"). In this case Dana mentions Roy, Tiller, Bell and Hoover referring to Bridgman's work in their 2005 Materials Research Innovations paper (I recognise a passage from the abstract also quoted here):
The authors also refer to the work of PW Bridgman, a Nobel Prize-winning physicist (1946) and professor at Harvard. He wrote several books, including the THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDES. He researched the effects of freezing water at various altitudes and found that freezing water at higher altitudes created different ice crystallization patterns than at lower altitudes. And yet, when he melted the ice that was frozen at a high altitude and then refroze it at a low altitude, the ice maintained the crystallization pattern of the higher altitude.
These experiments provide additional evidence for how pressure can influence the STRUCTURE of water without influencing the material content of the water.


I had hoped to find a proper reference for the Bridgman work on water frozen at altitude, but on checking the Roy et al paper I found that the work of Bridgman's they referred to was actually on SiO2 glass rather than water. There doesn't appear to be any mention of any observations by Bridgman on water frozen at high altitude.
 
Come on, Mojo, you know you're not actually supposed to follow up on references and read the source material. That's just nitpicking.
 
meow...

How many more days do you need to decipher that Wikipedia article ;) on p value.

:D

BJ
 
Well, several of us agree on something important: modern physicians are NOT scientists. This is an important point, and I'm glad that we have common ground here.

If you think about it, how many conventional drugs have stood the test of time?

about the only thing i am in disagreement with.

drugs are critically important. only a fool homeopath thinks they should be done away with.
 
Hey Delusions de Grandeur...
That's very interesting. I'm sure that water is not the only memory storage device in nature.
As for Bridgman's book...I mis-named it. It is THE PHYSICS OF HIGH PRESSURE.
The good news about our dialogue here is that several of you have publically stated that you will consider homeopathy as valid if there is some technology that can differentiate one homeopathic medicine from another, even at post-Avogadro number doses. Cool...because THIS is the subject of Rustum Roy's forthcoming article. I previously gave a link to a webcast discussion of this new research. Did anyone out there get a chance to hear/see it?


yes, possibly any polar molecule will do. i recall something about a Korean study where this was the case.

46. 2001 Geckeler, Kurt and Samal, Shashadhar at the Kwangju Institute of Science and Technology in South Korea discovered fullerenes, football-shaped buckyball molecules, formed aggregates in solution, and when diluted, the size of the fullerene particles increased. Cyclodextrin molecules behaved the same way. So did the organic molecule sodium guanosine monophosphate, DNA and sodium chloride. Dilution made molecules cluster five to 10 times bigger than those in the original solutions. Growth was not linear, and depended on the original concentration. Geckeler and Samal found that the more dilute the solution inthebeginning, the larger the aggregates become, and only worked in polar solvents like water, in which one end of the molecule has a pronounced positive charge while the other end is negative. Chemical Communications, 2001, page 2224; there is no volume number NewScientist.com http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn1532

47. 2003 Bell I., Lewis D., Brooks A., Lewis S., Schwartz G. Gas Discharge Visualization Evaluation of Ultramolecular Doses of Homeopathic Medicines Under Blinded, Controlled Conditions. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, Volume 9, Number 1, 2003, pp. 25-38.

48. 2004 Belon, P., J. Cumps, M. Ennis, P.F. Mannaioni, M. Roberfroid, J. Sainte-Laudy, & F.A. Wiegant (2004) “Histamine dilutions modulate basophil activation”, Inflammation Research, 53(5):181-8.
 
2001 Geckeler, Kurt and Samal, Shashadhar at the Kwangju Institute of Science and Technology in South Korea discovered fullerenes, football-shaped buckyball molecules, formed aggregates in solution, and when diluted, the size of the fullerene particles increased.
How dare they blacken Buckminster Fuller's name! :mad:

But seriously...

How does this help homoeopathy. It doesn't matter how big these molecules get, they're still going to be diluted out. Also the effect is lost at the usual dilutions used in homoeopathic preparations.

But please don't answer this criticism, just post yet another quote instead.
(Well, after you get through with that wiki article)

BJ
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom