More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)


I've meaning to explicitly point out one of Ullman's most annoying habits and this is a good opportunity to do it.

As usual in that video piece he willfully cherry-picks papers that are variously discredited, useless or superseded, but he does something else.

Even if the results of his favourite papers were entirely correct the effects that they find are utterly trivial.

He makes the schoolboy error of muddling statistical significance with biological/clinical significance, but he compounds this with a neat rhetorical trick: a careful elision, where he concentrates on how important the disease is but swiftly by-passes how small is the effect he can claim for homeopathy even at the most generous possible interpretation of the data. He is most guilty of this when describing that useless Frass paper from Chest. He is very keen to tell us how important a disease is COPD, which is true and no reasonable sceptical rational doctor could disagree, but he allows his assertion of the disease's importance to imply an importance for the effect allegedly found for homeopathy, which is so disproportionate as to be close to deceptive.

The effect of this is to claim that any positive result, however minor, legitimises a naively binary interpretation: works vs doesn't work. So, a trivial positive test on any single parameter of a poor trial is declared to show that homeopathy "WORKS!". Once he has cherry-picked a result sitting on the right side of that binary alternative it can now be promoted publicly without any connection to the underlying truth.

It's quite cunning and perfectly tuned to misleading the credulous and ignorant.
 
Last edited:
And going on from there, we find the main problem with countering that. Explaining just exactly how he is wrong to the fence-sitters or the poorly informed (even the high-flying medical poorly informed) exposes the sceptic to instant accusations of rudeness.

Dana (and those like him) have the positive message. Contradicting this message, especially with arguments that sound a bit like "he's lying", isn't the done thing. It's obsessive, pernickety, negative and impolite.

So there.

Rolfe.
 
It didn't last long, he is back into homeopathy, this time pushing homeopathy for children.

One paragraph took my attention
In fact, homeopathic medicine, for many reasons, has achieved such popularity in Europe that it is no longer considered an "alternative medicine." First, England's Royal Family has been under homeopathic care since the 1830s. Second, organized medicine in Europe has not been as antagonistic to homeopathy as American medical organizations have been. And third, convincing research has been published in numerous European medical and scientific journals.

Apart from the fact that no convincing research has been produced, why is he stressing the European link? Is that a marketing feature in the US?
 
Might just be that people in the US don't have the personal experience that would give the lie to the statements, and he's banking on sufficient numbers of them not checking up. Argumentum ad populum is easier to do if the population you're invoking isn't too easy to sample directly.

I like the way he implies that the Royal Family have homoeopathic primary care, and possibly nothing but homoeopathic care, all the time! Any time the Queen is actually seriously sick, you can be sure Peter Fisher won't get within a mile of her.

Rolfe.
 
Might just be that people in the US don't have the personal experience that would give the lie to the statements, and he's banking on sufficient numbers of them not checking up. Argumentum ad populum is easier to do if the population you're invoking isn't too easy to sample directly.

I like the way he implies that the Royal Family have homoeopathic primary care, and possibly nothing but homoeopathic care, all the time! Any time the Queen is actually seriously sick, you can be sure Peter Fisher won't get within a mile of her.

Rolfe.
:)

And at her age, I'm sure that Fisher doesn't want her to expire while in his care. Or am I too cynical.:rolleyes:
 
Here's Ullman, claiming that the Shang meta-analysis has been "blown of the water". Much like Orac's critique of the famed COPD study, I suppose. Blogged here.
 
JD Power rates homeopaths now?

Apparently they look quite fancy, but if you lift the bonnet ("hood", my American friends) you find that the engine is missing so it will only run downhill and they're no good at all over rough terrain.

The DU model has been test-driven quite frequently, but the wheels keep falling off.
 
Here's Ullman, claiming that the Shang meta-analysis has been "blown of the water". Much like Orac's critique of the famed COPD study, I suppose. Blogged here.


The "companion paper" Dana referred to, by Rutten and Stolper (not "Stopler" as Dana spells it), has now been published (Homeopathy Volume 97, Issue 4, October 2008, Pages 169-177). I don't have access to the full text.
 
The "companion paper" Dana referred to, by Rutten and Stolper (not "Stopler" as Dana spells it), has now been published (Homeopathy Volume 97, Issue 4, October 2008, Pages 169-177). I don't have access to the full text.

Neither do I, but after reading this
Important data were not mentioned in Shang et al's paper, but only provided subsequently.
in a supposedly scientific paper I won't be paying for the rest of it.

:o What am I talking about, Homeopathy scientific?
 
The "companion paper" Dana referred to, by Rutten and Stolper (not "Stopler" as Dana spells it), has now been published (Homeopathy Volume 97, Issue 4, October 2008, Pages 169-177). I don't have access to the full text.

I have access to the full text, if anyone is interested enough PM me with an e-mail address. I had a quick look, and picked out the most obvious brain-dead error in the paper here.
 
Heh, just noticed I spelled Stolper's name incorrectly myself. Must be Dana's attention to detail rubbing off on me.
 
Last edited:
I have access to the full text, if anyone is interested enough PM me with an e-mail address. I had a quick look, and picked out the most obvious brain-dead error in the paper here.

After looking at your analysis there is no need to see the full paper, any other criticism would just be nit-picking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom