More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

it's just one more piece of evidence that water has a memory of some sort or another.


You mean like this?
"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Paolo Bellavite, M.D. and Andrea Signorini, M.D., The Emerging Science of Homeopathy: Complexity, Biodynamics, and Nanopharmacology, 2002, pp.68-69

:dl:


BTW, I added another couple of questions:

3) Can you produce any evidence that Bridgman wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE?

4) While we're on the subject of Nobel Laureates, have you managed to track down the citation for "nobel winning prize chemist" Dr. Rey yet?

5) Any chance of answering the first two as well?
 
You mean like this?

BTW, I added another couple of questions:

3) Can you produce any evidence that Bridgman wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE?

4) While we're on the subject of Nobel Laureates, have you managed to track down the citation for "nobel winning prize chemist" Dr. Rey yet?

5) Any chance of answering the first two as well?

yes, rey did in fact win the nobel prize but it was in a parallel universe not this one.


meow meow




you are being slowly defeated by the evidence that continues to come in at a steady rate. eventually you will have to surrender and accept that polar solvents have a memory.
 
you are being slowly defeated by the evidence that continues to come in at a steady rate. eventually you will have to surrender and accept that polar solvents have a memory.

You understand that you repeatedly posting the same old links is not the same as evidence coming in at a steady rate, don't you?
 
it's just one more piece of evidence that water has a memory of some sort or another.
But it doesn't apply to homoeopathy.
Because homoeopathic preparations are not prepared at altitude or frozen.
It's as simple as that.

another thing to remind us that what we think we know about water may be very far from the truth.
​
And also a reminder that still, after all this time, there is nothing in all of this to support homoeopathy.

you people are close to being defeated. there's just too much evidence coming in from way too many leading universities from around the world.
Your world must be pretty isolated because, thanks to the efforts of many people around the world, the reverse seems to be happening.

BJ
 
But it doesn't apply to homoeopathy.


Your world must be pretty isolated because, thanks to the efforts of many people around the world, the reverse seems to be happening.

BJ


not at all, rustum roy's experiment is going to blow the doors down once it catches on with other scientists.


you'll just have to admit you were wrong.
 
Just curious,
How long does water memory last once it is imprinted?
What is the saturation point of this memory?
What happens when you mix water with different memories together?
How does this memory affect cellular mechanisms?
 
you'll just have to admit you were wrong.
dftt.gif
 
[qimg]http://www.dontfeedthetroll.de/images/dftt.gif[/qimg]

Fair point.

I suspect the responders have been hoping to tease out something more substantial to reply to (or from which to derive something of comedy value). In the meantime, it keeps our typing fingers supple.
 
Badly Shaven Monkey said that there was discussion elsewhere on this list that provided a critique of Rey's thermoluminesence work. I read a lot of study on this list about his work, but I saw no reasonable or good critique of it. Because it was published in such a high grade physics journal, the ball is in the skeptics' court to provide a specific critique. Please enlighten me.
there is no critique of rey's work unless you want to include, "it wasn't blinded....blah blah blah"
 
Wow indeed, there is all this sound scientific evidence for homeopathy yet a little over 99.9% of scientists refuse to believe in it and denounce it as bunk. I wonder what they are missing? Unless, no, surely not, perhaps, I wonder, no that's daft, it can't be. James, Why do you think proper scientists aren't convinced by the wealth of solid evidence?

Am I right in thinking that Professor Ennis’s replicated basic science trial, is the same trail that spectacularly failed to replicate when conducted properly on the Horizon programme ?

when the dozens upon dozens upon dozens of studies and experiments are presented to these scientists most would conclude that something is likely to be occurring. (especially rey, roy and the basophil studies)


the experiment on the Horizon show was 1/50th the scale of the ennis 2004 study. the budget was a pittance of the ennis study.

not to mention there was some dumb arse homeopath present and the sample size was horrible not to mention all the other flaws outlined by ullman and others.

the show was an absolute joke.





face it, your days are numbered. rustum roy and iris bell are your dream crushers.
 
Wow. If that is the best critique that you skeptics can give on the serious basic science studies that I previously posted (no one has mentioned anything about the work by Elia on the thermodynamics of homeopathics), then, there must be some quiet supporters of homeopathy here.


they have never had an answer for elia. think they are terrified of it. another nail in the coffin.




Titre du document / Document title
New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions
Auteur(s) / Author(s)
ELIA V. (1) ; NICCOLI M. (1) ;
Affiliation(s) du ou des auteurs / Author(s) Affiliation(s)
(1) Department of Chemistry, University ' Federico II'of Naples, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, via Cintia, 80126 Naples, ITALIE
Résumé / Abstract
The 'extremely diluted solutions' are anomalous solutions obtained through the iteration of two processes: a dilution 1:100 in mass and a succussion. The iteration is repeated until extreme dilutions are reached (less than 1.10-5 mol kg-1) to the point that we may call the resulting solution an extremely diluted solution, namely the composition of the solution is identical to that of the solvent used (e.g. twice distilled water). We conducted thermodynamic and transport measurements of the solutions and of the interaction of those solutions with acids or bases. The purpose of this study is to obtain information about the influence of successive dilutions and succussions on the water structure of the solutions under study. We measured the heats of mixing of acid or basic solutions with such 'extremely diluted solutions', their electrical conductivity and pH, comparing with the analogous heats of mixing, electrical conductivity and pH of the solvent. We found some relevant exothermic excess heats of mixing, higher electrical conductivity and pH than those of the untreated solvent. The measurements show a good correlation between independent physico-chemical parameters. Care was taken to take into account the effect of chemical impurities deriving from the glass containers. Here we thus show that successive dilutions and succussions can permanently alter the physico-chemical properties of the water solvent. The nature of the phenomena here described still remains unexplained, nevertheless some significant experimental results were obtained.
Revue / Journal Title
Journal of thermal analysis and calorimetry ISSN 1388-6150
Source / Source
2004, vol. 75, no3, pp. 815-836 [22 page(s) (article)] (32 ref.)
 
Mojo says that I haven't answered the question "Does homeopathy work?" My references to the randomized double-blind and placebo controlled trials on influenza don't count? How about my references to the work by Dr David Reilly and team on allergy and asthma? And how about the high quality studies on basophils by Ennis and a 4 university laboratories.

As the for BBC's Horizon trial...that one was totally laughable, laughable. This is one reason that I have no respect for James Randi. He has been informed of the "junk science" that the BBC and ABC's 20/20 created, and rather than stand on the side of good science, he stood on the side of "junk science." The producers of these experiments thought they were getting a replication trial of Ennis' work, but that is NOT what they got. According to Wayne Turnbull, the "lab technician" who did the study, he created his own study...but sadly, because he was ill-informed and inexperience (and unpublished) in basophil research, he created many embarrassing mistakes in the trial. For a full critique of Turnbull work, see:
homeopathic.com/articles/media/index.php (cut and paste it).

Note: Wayne Turnbull was the "scientist" (actually, he is a lab technician with no published research on basophils) who Horizon and 20/20 hired.

Briefly, The Horizon and 20/20 experiments used a chemical, ammonium chloride, that is known to destroy basophils, the type of white blood cell that was under study. The experiment was designed to fail even before any homeopathic medicine was administered. Because this chemical was not used in any of the previous studies that have been published in peer-review scientific journals, this study was "junk science" and that any results from this study are of no value.

• The Horizon and 20/20 experiments also used a chemical called "foetal calf serum" (the blood from a calf foetus). According to experts in basophils and experts who had previously conducted this experiment successfully, this chemical complex is not a "recognized medium" for laboratory experiments of this sort, and its effects on basophils are presently unknown. It should also be noted that the experiment produced by Horizon and 20/20 was created by an employee at a London hospital who didn't know the answers to some simple questions about basophils when asked by Professor Ennis. Also, to be done correctly, this experiment requires "clean" basophils, and the use of foetal calf serum alters the binding reactions of the basophils. Whooops.

• The Horizon and 20/20 experimenter left the blood containing basophils to be collected to sit and sediment for 4 hours. It is known that basophils are extremely fragile, thus, leaving them to sit for 4 hours disturbed their viability and rendered them useless for scientific experimental purposes. Whooops.

I will be curious if people on this list will stand with Turnbull. Come on, stand up and be counted. Stand with an unpublished lab tech or four university laboratories who used respected and well-published PhD scientists.

I've already answer Mr. Monkey's questions about which I care...re-read my previous emails.

As for Roy's research, I previously mentioned that he has had over a dozen articles published in NATURE. This fact suggests that he is a highly respected scientist.

One of the ways that I have observed the fundamentalist thinking of the participants on this list is that you NEVER admit error and NEVER admit to ANY studies or replications of studies. I'm still waiting for some critique of the flu trials, the allergy/asthma trials, the thermodynamics research by Elia, good critique of Rey, and good critique of Roy (not just the character assassination baloney that too many of you love to do)...

You've got some work to do. Now, who of you is brave enough to acknowledge that they MAY be some value and logic and science to homeopathy after all?


the skeptics on this board will be the very last people on the face of the earth to finally admit they were wrong. it's like talking to a wall.
 
You do understand that demonstrating that something odd may possibly happen at high dilutions (or, for that matter, proposing a mechanism for how this may occur) does not show that homoeopathy works, don't you?


it's a darn healthy start.





New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions
Auteur(s) / Author(s)
ELIA V. (1) ; NICCOLI M. (1) ;
Affiliation(s) du ou des auteurs / Author(s) Affiliation(s)
(1) Department of Chemistry, University ' Federico II'of Naples, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, via Cintia, 80126 Naples, ITALIE
Résumé / Abstract
The 'extremely diluted solutions' are anomalous solutions obtained through the iteration of two processes: a dilution 1:100 in mass and a succussion. The iteration is repeated until extreme dilutions are reached (less than 1.10-5 mol kg-1) to the point that we may call the resulting solution an extremely diluted solution, namely the composition of the solution is identical to that of the solvent used (e.g. twice distilled water). We conducted thermodynamic and transport measurements of the solutions and of the interaction of those solutions with acids or bases. The purpose of this study is to obtain information about the influence of successive dilutions and succussions on the water structure of the solutions under study. We measured the heats of mixing of acid or basic solutions with such 'extremely diluted solutions', their electrical conductivity and pH, comparing with the analogous heats of mixing, electrical conductivity and pH of the solvent. We found some relevant exothermic excess heats of mixing, higher electrical conductivity and pH than those of the untreated solvent. The measurements show a good correlation between independent physico-chemical parameters. Care was taken to take into account the effect of chemical impurities deriving from the glass containers. Here we thus show that successive dilutions and succussions can permanently alter the physico-chemical properties of the water solvent. The nature of the phenomena here described still remains unexplained, nevertheless some significant experimental results were obtained.
Revue / Journal Title
Journal of thermal analysis and calorimetry ISSN 1388-6150
 
Please explain why "it wasn't blinded" is not a sufficient criticism.

because millions of experiments are performed without being blinded.

i'd bet my life on it that it works just fine blinded.

between roy, rey, ennis -- your days are numbered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom