More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Ullman will probably try that debating technique but the arbitrators on that case had nothing to do with the editing of the homeopathy articles.

After being warned, tutored and restricted, he attacked other editors for bias and lack of assumption of good faith. Banning him for one year just gives wiki an all too brief rest from him.

1 year bans have a habit of being extended.
 
Not all that interesting but I've just come across an audio interview of Ullman (#48 in the list).

He trots out all the well known falsehoods.

Conventional medicine causes mental disease by suppressing symptoms.
Homeopathy must be good because it has no side-effects.
Must work because many people use it.

And from the 'I'm so humble author': 'I stand on the shoulders of giants'. This last one is apparantly because he has a library of homeopathy books :eye-poppi

Couldn't work out who was more nauseous, Ullman or the sycophantic interviewer, Mike Adams. :throwing up
 
There's a recent (at least I think it's recent: Google News says it went up on ‎ the 9th of July) article by Ullman on that site as well: http://www.naturalnews.com/023595.html

Interestingly, Ullman is touting over-the-counter, non-individualised homeopathy:
In addition to homeopathic medicines that are composed of specific single ingredient substances, there are also "homeopathic formulas," that is, combinations of 2 to 10 ingredients. These formulas are very simple to use because they are usually made with some of the most commonly prescribed remedies known to be effective in treating people with a specific ailment, and these products are marketed based on a specific disease name (Because the FDA recognizes homeopathic medicines are "over-the-counter drugs," it is perfectly legal for homeopathic manufacturers to give a disease indication on the label, as long as the disease is self-limiting and does not require a medical diagnosis).


He can have no objection to DBPC testing of these for their target conditions. On the other hand, he's previously objected to trials in which non-individualised homoeopathy has failed to show an effect above placebo on the grounds that that isn't proper homoeopathy.

But wait, there's more:
Homeopaths generally find that the individually-chosen single ingredient homeopathic remedy is more apt to provide faster and more certain results...


"Individually-chosen" remedies provide more certain results! So they should show even better results in DBPC trials.
 
Last edited:
There's a recent (at least I think it's recent: Google News says it went up on ‎ the 9th of July) article by Ullman on that site as well: http://www.naturalnews.com/023595.html

Interestingly, Ullman is touting over-the-counter, non-individualised homeopathy:


He can have no objection to DBPC testing of these for their target conditions. On the other hand, he's previously objected to trials in which non-individualised homoeopathy has failed to show an effect above placebo on the grounds that that isn't proper homoeopathy.

But wait, there's more:


"Individually-chosen" remedies provide more certain results! So they should show even better results in DBPC trials.

In this forum he has made it very clear, homeopathy only works when used in an individualised way, unless of course he wants to promote a trial that he can quote, or a product he can sell.

For a long time I couldn't decide if Ullman was delusional or a charlatan. Now it's quite clear, it's just the money.
 
In this forum he has made it very clear, homeopathy only works when used in an individualised way, unless of course he wants to promote a trial that he can quote, or a product he can sell.

For a long time I couldn't decide if Ullman was delusional or a charlatan. Now it's quite clear, it's just the money.

I wondered the same; I think there's a fair percentage of homeopaths out there who are "just" deluded.

With Ullman, however, there's no question in my mind that he knows he's spouting nonsense. The approach he takes - on Wikipedia, for example - is frequently sly; he tried to smuggle stuff in the back door.

More damning, however, is the way he repeats things as fact that he *knows* aren't true. The whole Darwin and homeopathy thing, for example; it's been pointed out to him on numerous occasions that his claims on the subject are patently and demonstrably untrue. But he still makes them. That, for me, means there's no doubt the man isn't deluded, he's just in it for the cash.
 
Last edited:
For a long time I couldn't decide if Ullman was delusional or a charlatan. Now it's quite clear, it's just the money.

I don't think he's just there for the money. His behaviour is typical of a deluded person: he's so sure of his delusions that he doesn't see reason even if it's pushed right under his nose, and he's blind to logic if it contradicts his cherished ideas.

If he was just after making money, he wouldn't spend so much time making lengthy posts on blogs, forums or Wikipedia: this is not an efficient method for getting rich. OK, he often plugs his books when he posts, but I think that is due more to vanity than to business sense.

A cynical charlatan who wants to get rich on the homeopathy bandwagon won't bother wasting time on evangelical activties: they'll just set up an online pharmacy where they pass off un-prepared sugar pills as homeopathic remedies, in the full knowledge that there is in fact no difference. Or they will sell something like this voice-programmed homeopathic remedy maker.
 
I don't think he's just there for the money. His behaviour is typical of a deluded person: he's so sure of his delusions that he doesn't see reason even if it's pushed right under his nose, and he's blind to logic if it contradicts his cherished ideas.

The behaviour of a somebody trying to flog a worthless product would be much the same, that's why I was initially undecided.

If he was just after making money, he wouldn't spend so much time making lengthy posts on blogs, forums or Wikipedia: this is not an efficient method for getting rich. OK, he often plugs his books when he posts, but I think that is due more to vanity than to business sense.

I agree. Vanity and a streak of arrogance a mile wide are part of it. As for business sense, he is promoting his own woo.

A cynical charlatan who wants to get rich on the homeopathy bandwagon won't bother wasting time on evangelical activties: they'll just set up an online pharmacy where they pass off un-prepared sugar pills as homeopathic remedies, in the full knowledge that there is in fact no difference. Or they will sell something like this voice-programmed homeopathic remedy maker.

But he has set up his own pharmacy.

It was his promotion of non-individualised preparations and his activity on Wikipedia that finally swung the balance for me. He has claimed that individualisation is a necessary part of homeopathy except for certain cases when it suits him. OK, this could be argued that in these cases the symptoms are so clear cut that individual diagnosis is unnecessary. But when he pops up selling nearly every known homeopathic product from a web site?
Access Homeopathic Medicines!

Did you know that we at Homeopathic Educational Services now sell EVERY homeopathic medicine sold by Hahnemann Laboratories, Boiron, and Standard?

That's just deceit.
 
But he has set up his own pharmacy.
Yes, he can earn money with that. But he can't earn money from all his Wikipedia activities, or all the posts he makes on various forums. So why does he spend so much time on these activities? It could be that it is just thirst for fame, but I still consider it highly probable that he really believes the stuff he writes.

The inconsistency between his insistence on the importance of individualised homeopathy and the fact that he sells ready-made remedies is glaringly obvious to us, but he is incapable of seeing it. His mind will find all sorts of convoluted and nonsensical ways to rationalise the problem.

Look at his crusade for Dr Gully and his supposed homeopathic treatment of Charles Darwin. He's not making money with this. His stubborn refusal to accept the obvious evidence against his claims is typical of a deluded person. Here, taken from the Wikipedia article on the subject, are the criteria for delusion that were laid down by the psychiatrist Karl Jaspers:

  • certainty (held with absolute conviction)
  • incorrigibility (not changeable by compelling counterargument or proof to the contrary)
  • impossibility or falsity of content (implausible, bizarre or patently untrue)

That fits Dana to a T.
 
Yes, he can earn money with that. But he can't earn money from all his Wikipedia activities, or all the posts he makes on various forums. So why does he spend so much time on these activities? It could be that it is just thirst for fame, but I still consider it highly probable that he really believes the stuff he writes.

Publicising your own business is an essential part of making money. Remember, he isn't trying to convince us or the majority of those who read Wikipedia but that small minority who will buy his books and potions.

The inconsistency between his insistence on the importance of individualised homeopathy and the fact that he sells ready-made remedies is glaringly obvious to us, but he is incapable of seeing it. His mind will find all sorts of convoluted and nonsensical ways to rationalise the problem.

This is the crux of the matter. Ullman is obviously an intelligent man. He argues his points with logic but uses false premises and quote mining to win. Here, he totally contradicts himself. I might just be convinced he is only delusional if he or someone can produce some half assed reasoning that can justify the juxtaposition of 'most homeopathic medicines must be individualised' and 'I sell almost any homeopathic medicine on a non-individualised basis'.

Look at his crusade for Dr Gully and his supposed homeopathic treatment of Charles Darwin. He's not making money with this. His stubborn refusal to accept the obvious evidence against his claims is typical of a deluded person. Here, taken from the Wikipedia article on the subject, are the criteria for delusion that were laid down by the psychiatrist Karl Jaspers:

  • certainty (held with absolute conviction)
  • incorrigibility (not changeable by compelling counterargument or proof to the contrary)
  • impossibility or falsity of content (implausible, bizarre or patently untrue)

That fits Dana to a T.

It also fits a salesman.

Just as an anecodote: I knew a research chemist who left research to make money selling a slightly dubious product. He exhibited exactly the same characteristics as you have listed. Later, he left that endeavour and when I questioned him about that episode in his life he freely admitted the product was junk but said 'I couldn't possibly admit it at the time'.
 
But he can't earn money from all his Wikipedia activities...

...

Look at his crusade for Dr Gully and his supposed homeopathic treatment of Charles Darwin. He's not making money with this.


The Darwin/Gully stuff was one of the hooks he used to publicise his book promoting homoeopathy. Promoting homoeopathy makes him money. A certain amount of his Wikipedia activities involved editing articles (in particular to do with Darwin and Gully) so that they supported the claims in his book. He's also tried to get studies that he hawks around as showing homoeopathy is effective into articles there. Again, this would give him apparently supporting evidence when he uses these to promote homoeopathy.
 
The Darwin/Gully stuff was one of the hooks he used to publicise his book promoting homoeopathy.
Did he not also brag on other forums how he had floored the skeptics with his research on homoeopathy and Darwin?
 
Looks like Dana will have to produce a revised edition of his book:

The healer on the 73 bus, Europe's most wanted man

When the policemen got on the bus at a stop between Belgrade and the town of Batanica, they showed him their badges and the man who called himself Dragan Dabic, practitioner of alternative medicine, went with them without a struggle. With that quiet exchange Radovan Karadzic's 12 years on the run came to an anticlimactic end.

...

As Dabic, he set up a website called Psy Help Energy which advertised the David Wellbeing Programme which offered help from "experienced experts from pioneering areas of science where there are immense possibilities for interaction with natural forces in and around us".

Among other services offered were acupuncture, homeopathy, "quantum medicine" and traditional cures.
 
Damn you, Mojo, I spent an hour yesterday hoping to find that very fact.

No, well done :D

Moi aussi.

Well there you have it, genocidal nutjob and homeopath. All you need to do is shrug off the fetters of rationality and both career paths lie open to you.
 
I thought of this thread as well when I saw that on the news.

Too caught up with the Tour of France to post though.
 
I didn't want to start a new thread to add this comment, and this is on my subscribe list, so by default this is where it ends up :)

Just thought I'd mention that I was having a very nice day today, with the weather being nice and friendly for once, reading a new book I just picked up

The Pirates! In An Adventure with Napoleon by Gideon Defoe

This is only one of a series :

The Pirates! In An Adventure with Scientists
The Pirates! In An Adventure with Whaling
The Pirates! In An Adventure with Communists

as you may have gathered, these books are thoroughly silly, with much conversation consisting of 'arrrrrr' and discussions about ham, luxurious beards, and barnacles.

However, there is a very keen wit working through them, and to actually get to the point and stop this reading like a cheap plug for some (very funny) books, this sentence made me laugh out loud.

For reasons that don't really bear explaining (it would take too long, but suffice to say bees, pictures of monsters, and british colonial etiquette figure quite heavily) a Pirate Captain and Napoleon are discussing the lessons they have learned from life.

Pirate Captain : Self-worth shouldn't come from awards and trinkets and getting the respect of your peers, it should come from within.
Napoleon : Surely by that logic, anybody can declare themselves a success no matter how useless and ineffectual they are? You know, like homeopathy.

It's nice to see that there is some kind of general acceptance of such attitudes :)
 
He's shown up on youtube now:



He posted that last month, and he's still spouting the stuff about Darwin that he's seen thoroughly torn apart.
 
Figured out how to use the YT tag properly (I think):

He's shown up on youtube now:



He posted that last month, and he's still spouting the stuff about Darwin that he's seen thoroughly torn apart.


ETA: Yes, it works now.
 
Last edited:
A lengthy interview of Dana by Louise McLean.

Includes such gems as
Ultimately if you think of what an ideal drug should do, to me an ideal drug should be something that augments immuno-competence and that’s what homeopathy does.

Followed by
I also want to let you know there have been a number of new plant studies that some Swiss and Italian researchers have conducted, showing powerful effects of homeopathic doses on plants.

Hmm, plants with immune systems?

He also repeats claims he made in these forums that an exposé of Shang's analysis is about to be published.

In fact they had a remark in the Shang article published in the Lancet, where they specifically made reference to trials on respiratory ailments and that the results were robust, but they said they couldn’t trust them because there were only 8 studies. But then again they based their entire analysis on 8 homeopathic studies and 6 conventional ones. So they can’t have it both ways and this new journal article in the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology which is ranked as one of the top international journals of reviews of research, has accepted the new studies.

I don't have access to how respectable a journal is the J Clin Epidem, but as the article is still to be published its pretty moot. On the other hand I'm unlikely to be impressed by a recommendation by Ullman.

If you have read the journal Homeopathy of the UK Faculty of Homeopathy, it is the best academic journal with the best information on research.

As usual, Ullman's eloquence is only exceeded by his lack of knowledge and understanding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom