More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

After looking at your analysis there is no need to see the full paper, any other criticism would just be nit-picking.

Fair point, but I'd still like to add it to my archive of "Homeopaths Say the Stupidest Things" to be quoted from whenever any of that decerebrated gang turn up to dispute the Shang paper.
 
I have access to the full text, if anyone is interested enough PM me with an e-mail address. I had a quick look, and picked out the most obvious brain-dead error in the paper here.


Wilsontown, do you still have my email address? If so, pretty please? If not, PM me for it.

Rolfe.
 
After looking at your analysis there is no need to see the full paper, any other criticism would just be nit-picking.

Oh, there is quite a bit of stuff in the paper, (including some repetition of the Ludtke and Rutten paper in J Clin Epidemiol), but nothing that convinced me that Shang is a bad and fraudulent paper, which is what the homeopaths seem to want to show. And it would help to have read Shang properly if you're going to criticise it...

One noticeable thing is that in Homeopathy that authors seem perfectly happy to fling accusations of bias and fraud around, whereas the J Clin Epidemiol paper is much more measured. I suspect this is because J Clin Epidemiol has considerably higher standards of review.
 
Oh, there is quite a bit of stuff in the paper, (including some repetition of the Ludtke and Rutten paper in J Clin Epidemiol), but nothing that convinced me that Shang is a bad and fraudulent paper, which is what the homeopaths seem to want to show. And it would help to have read Shang properly if you're going to criticise it...

One noticeable thing is that in Homeopathy that authors seem perfectly happy to fling accusations of bias and fraud around, whereas the J Clin Epidemiol paper is much more measured. I suspect this is because J Clin Epidemiol has considerably higher standards of review.

Agreed, I should have expanded slightly. Once you established they hadn't read the central point of the Shang analysis, ie the selection process, the rest of the paper is irrelevant because that is what they are criticising.

On another point. Do these people ever present at scientific conferences? Unless conferences have changed a lot in recent years, presenters of rubbish would be torn to shreds.
 
Agreed, I should have expanded slightly. Once you established they hadn't read the central point of the Shang analysis, ie the selection process, the rest of the paper is irrelevant because that is what they are criticising.

On another point. Do these people ever present at scientific conferences? Unless conferences have changed a lot in recent years, presenters of rubbish would be torn to shreds.

I suspect that the conferences they choose to present at are similar to the journals they choose to publish in (and vice versa - the conferences/journals that accept their work).

Linda
 
fls said:
I suspect that the conferences they choose to present at are similar to the journals they choose to publish in (and vice versa - the conferences/journals that accept their work).

Indeed. In fact, there was a conference entitled "Scientific Research in Homeopathy", held by the Complementary Medical Association (CMA) at the University of Westminster (God help us) earlier in the year. If you go here, you can find links to several blog posts debunking various aspects of it (sorry to pimp my blog yet again, but I can't be bothered to copy all the links here). You don't get the impression that there was much in the way of critical appraisal going on.
 
the usual trail of half-truths, complete fabrication, and bizarre metaphors.

...in homeopathy, we're too scientific to assume....
...homeopathic textbooks provide the most detailed information on toxicology presently available...

it's good for a laugh isn't it ;)

Slightly puzzled by the bit where he was claiming the wonderful scientific basis that homeopathy has, and he seemed to correct himself.

several hundred clinical science studie....errr....clinical practice

what was that about?

I particularly liked the way he moved from submarine radio communication, then compared that to communicating with the blood ?? somehow made it equivalent to nano-doses of homepathic medecine, and then also suggested that natural harmonics are 'ultra-sensitive' ... it's like a magical mystery tour of scientific stupidity.....
 
If I was in the studio, I would have been hard pressed not to lift that flower pot and crack it over his thick skull.

Yes, I know, it would have made no difference.
He would just have kept on talking as if nothing had happened.

:rolleyes:
 
If I was in the studio, I would have been hard pressed not to lift that flower pot and crack it over his thick skull.

Yes, I know, it would have made no difference.
He would just have kept on talking as if nothing had happened.

:rolleyes:

Naw, he would have seemlessly woven the incident into an analogy of how proper medicine works.
 
Ugh, yes...Ullman found me right away...perhaps he doesn't remember who i am. Or alternatively, he's an idiot, like Egnor...Egnor who is a brain surgeon, but whose best argument is that I'm anonymous and that's mean...and I'm not even anonymous.
 
For you entertainment. Ullman has wandered over to Science Based Medicine, where Harriet Hall made this comment:

.... He is like a child butting into an adult discussion to say “There really is a Tooth Fairy and I can prove it because here’s the money she left me.” He is not even capable of understanding why his arguments fail to convince us, even though it has been explained to him many times in great detail. We should have compassion and be kind to the handicapped, but we shouldn’t have to pay any attention to their ravings.
 
Before I reference some of the clinical trials, I thought I would first focus our discussion on a more difficult subject: how homeopathic medicines may work.

I still find it interesting that no one is responding to my references to the high quality basic science research published in grade A science journals, specifically the work of Rey, Elia, and Roy. Roy's work on the "structure of water" seems to be too technical for some of you. That's OK...I don't expect everyone to understand every area of science, but just because you don't understand how you can "write" on homeopathy doesn't mean that it doesn't happen.

P.W. Bridgman, PhD, former professor of physics at Harvard for a couple of decades, and he is a Nobel Laureate. He wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE. He found that whenever one takes water to certain altitudes and freeze it, it freezes in a different pattern based on the high pressure of altitude. However, he found that once water is frozen at one altitude, it "remembers" the structure of the water and refreezes in a similar pattern at a different altitude. Water does seem to have a memory, and you can seem to "write" on it.

Since some of you claim to be literate on homeopathy, I challenge you to answer one of the most basic questions about homeopathy: HOW DOES A HOMEOPATH DETERMINE WHAT A MEDICINE IS EFFECTIVE IN TREATING?

Several years ago, I debated Saul Green, PhD, a chemist and skeptic of homeopathy. He thoroughy embarrassed himself and fellow skeptics by answering this question by saying that it was "folk wisdom." Needless to say, that is not the right answer.

What do YOU think is the right answer?


excellent!
 
1) Are you suggesting that the properties of homoeopathic remedies will vary according to the altitude at which they were manufactured rather than the alleged active ingredient?

2) Are homoeopathic remedies frozen at any stage of their manufacture?

3) Can you produce any evidence that Bridgman wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE?

4) While we're on the subject of Nobel Laureates, have you managed to track down the citation for "nobel winning prize chemist" Dr. Rey yet?
 
Last edited:
In that case, you'd better acknowledge as error pretty much everything you ever wrote, because pretty much all of that has been subjected to massive amounts of criticism. Elia, Rey, Roy, Benveniste, Ennis, Milgrom, Walach, all their publications (on homoeopathy) have been torn to shreds.

Rolfe.

you are clearly delusional if you really believe this.

meow meow
 
1) Are you suggesting that the properties of homoeopathic remedies will vary according to the altitude at which they were manufactured rather than the alleged active ingredient?

2) Are homoeopathic remedies frozen at any stage of their manufacture?

it's just one more piece of evidence that water has a memory of some sort or another.

another thing to remind us that what we think we know about water may be very far from the truth.


you people are close to being defeated. there's just too much evidence coming in from way too many leading universities from around the world.



meow meow
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom