More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

A lengthy interview of Dana by Louise McLean.


As posted by Sue Young, who is taking a leaf out of Dana's book by posting ever more tenuous links of famous people with homoeopathy.

Her post about P. G. Wodehouse is a classic. Here's what it says about Wodehouse and homoeopathy:
Pelham Grenville Wodehouse wrote Homeopathic Treatment for the Boy Scout Magazine Boy’s Life in 1931, volume 21, number 4, with illustrations by Enos B Comstock.

Frederick Hervey Foster Quin, George Atkin, John Chapman and Robert Ellis Dudgeon, John Rutherford Russell, James W Metcalf and an anonymous ‘friend’ put together a Directory of British and Foreign Homeopaths and their supporters to counter the suppression of all mention of homeopaths and their supporters by the editors of the London and Provincial Medical Directory in 1853. This directory mentions Wodehouse’s father Henry Ernest Wodehouse 1845–1929 who was a British judge in Hong Kong, listing him as Lord Wodehouse, Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs.

As can be seen from the link she provides, Homeopathic Treatment is a short story.

As far as the mention of Wodehouse's father in The British and Foreign Homœopathic Medical Directory and Record is concerned, The implication is clearly that Wodehouse senior was either a homoeopath or a supporter of homoeopathy (she specifically describes it as "a Directory of British and Foreign Homeopaths and their supporters"). He's in fact listed in an almanac section, simply because he was a member of the government at the time. It has nothing whatsoever to do with any connection between Wodehouse and homoeopathy.

There's no other mention of a link with homoeopathy in the article.

So she's claiming Wodehouse for homoeopathy on the basis of the title of a short story published in a boy scout magazine, and the fact that his father was Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in 1853.
 
Last edited:
So she's claiming Wodehouse for homoeopathy on the basis of the title of a short story published in a boy scout magazine, and the fact that his father was Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in 1853.

Mojo, give her a break, there's more evidence there than for homeopathy itself. :D
 
:D :D :D

Sue Young would do well to read the story.

It's here: Homoeopathic Treatment: A School Story.

It's a simple story of schoolboys annoying each other. One boy (Buxton) annoys all those around him with the odours of cheap scent on his handkerchief, until another boy gives him a dose of his own medicine: treating like with like. There is absolutely nothing there that suggests Wodehouse was supporting homeopathy.
 
:D :D :D

Sue Young would do well to read the story.

It's here: Homoeopathic Treatment: A School Story.

It's a simple story of schoolboys annoying each other. One boy (Buxton) annoys all those around him with the odours of cheap scent on his handkerchief, until another boy gives him a dose of his own medicine: treating like with like. There is absolutely nothing there that suggests Wodehouse was supporting homeopathy.

Well I say that this is "homeopathic evidence". I also note, that on the same basis, all medical magazines and professional societies in the World support this sham because at one time thay all have mentioned homeopathy!
 
I don't have access to how respectable a journal is the J Clin Epidem, but as the article is still to be published its pretty moot.
Well it's a real enough journal, it's got an impact factor of 2.565, 22nd in its ISI category (Public, environmental & occupational health). For comparison Lancet's impact factor is 28.638. But I doubt the article Dana refers to will be published, or for that matter has been submitted or even written.
 
:D :D :D

Sue Young would do well to read the story.

It's here: Homoeopathic Treatment: A School Story.

It's a simple story of schoolboys annoying each other. One boy (Buxton) annoys all those around him with the odours of cheap scent on his handkerchief, until another boy gives him a dose of his own medicine: treating like with like. There is absolutely nothing there that suggests Wodehouse was supporting homeopathy.

Ha, that's awesome.

I genuinely can't fathom the mindset that just thinks "Oooh, a story called Homoeopathic Treatment - I bet that clearly shows Wodehouse was a fan of homeopathy", writes an article predicated on that assumption and then publishes it - all without, y'know, actually bothering to check.
 
In fact they had a remark in the Shang article published in the Lancet, where they specifically made reference to trials on respiratory ailments and that the results were robust, but they said they couldn’t trust them because there were only 8 studies. But then again they based their entire analysis on 8 homeopathic studies and 6 conventional ones. So they can’t have it both ways and this new journal article in the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology which is ranked as one of the top international journals of reviews of research, has accepted the new studies.

This just shows that Ullman still doesn't understand the Shang study, despite having it explained it to him all over the internet. But I'm sure no-one here is surprised to hear that.

The point Shang et al. made regarding the eight trials of homeopathy for respiratory ailments was that meta-analyses of small numbers of trials would be likely to miss the evidence of bias that they found in their dataset of 110 trials. They are not trying to have it both ways at all.


In fact there is a new study that is coming out shortly which is a re-analysis of the 2005 Lancet review of Shang. The researchers got it accepted in a major international journal of research. What they have finally done is what Shang didn’t do. He didn’t review ALL of the high calibre research but only a small part of it. He ignored comprehensive analysis entirely. I think he knew exactly what it was but he didn’t want to report on it, as it was too positive. Instead he only reported on trials with very large numbers of subjects because when you do that, most of those studies use one remedy for everybody without any degree of individuality.

I find it irritating that Ullman is happy to essentially accuse Shang and his co-workers of research misconduct, based on a total misunderstanding of what they did.

And of course, the whole individualisation thing is a red herring. Not only did Shang et al. include a number of papers that tested individualised remedies, it showed that these had no better results than trials of homeopathy without individualisation. But anyway, Ullman is only against non-individualised remedies when it suits him:

I think the attacks are taking place because of homeopathy’s integration within the mainstream, that it is being taught in various Universities and the medicines are being sold in Boots and various mainstream pharmacies. So that is threatening.
 
This just shows that Ullman still doesn't understand the Shang study, despite having it explained it to him all over the internet. But I'm sure no-one here is surprised to hear that.

Oh, I think he does. Its illuminating that he now only comes out with this crap when amongst his woo friends and knows he won't be challenged.

The best he can come up with elsewhere is that there were 8 high quality homeopathy trials and only 6 high quality conventional trials and therefore homeopathy is better. :eye-poppi
 

I love playing "How long has the Doctor been dead?" when they wheel out the quotes from MDs

den151banl said:
“Those who say they have tested Homeopathy and it is a failure have only exposed their own ignorance.”
J. T. Kent, MD

Who I'm guessing is this guy, so that's nearly a century.
 
:D :D :D

Sue Young would do well to read the story.

It's here: Homoeopathic Treatment: A School Story.

It's a simple story of schoolboys annoying each other. One boy (Buxton) annoys all those around him with the odours of cheap scent on his handkerchief, until another boy gives him a dose of his own medicine: treating like with like. There is absolutely nothing there that suggests Wodehouse was supporting homeopathy.
I was also confused, but not in the manner of our dear Sue Young.
"'Boy,' he said, 'what -- what is this abomination on your handkerchief?'
"'Simpkins Idle Moments, sir,' I said.
I guess they didn't have Kleenex back in those days.
 
Perhaps Dana is realising that there is nothing in Homeopathy. He seems to be branching out.
How to Create Your Own Pandemic: Infectious Creativity Used by Big Pharma

Sadly and predictably, using Tamiflu for treating the common flu will tend to increase the chances of creating super-viruses that will become immune to anti-viral drugs. It is almost as though this drug has the capacity to create thousands (or millions) of "terrorist cells" that could threaten the body (and the body politic).

Unfortunately he has carried his old mistakes with him, cherry picking studies and comments, not understanding arithmetic etc.
 
Regarding "Tamiflu"

From wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oseltamivir#Resistance

The genetic sequence for the neuraminidase enzyme is highly conserved across virus strains. This means that there are relatively few variations, and there is also evidence that variations that do occur tend to be less "fit." Thus, mutations that convey resistance to oseltamivir may also tend to cripple the virus by giving it an otherwise less-functional enzyme. The lack of variation in neuraminidase gives two advantages to oseltamivir and zanamivir, the drugs that target that enzyme. First, these drugs work on a broader spectrum of influenza strains. Second, the development of a robust, resistant virus strain appears to be less likely. It is worth noting that the oseltamivir-resistant strains detected by Kiso et al. all appeared within individual children after treatment with oseltamivir – the children did not catch the resistant strains in human-to-human or bird-to-human transmission.


This seems to contradict what you said Ullman said*.


*Disclaimer:
I have not actually read what Ullman said. :cool:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom