More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Cut-n-paste from : http://www.otherhealth.com/research.../9000-homeopathy-some-issues-4.html#post77132
and : http://www.otherhealth.com/research.../9000-homeopathy-some-issues-5.html#post77383



Cut-n-paste from : http://nch.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=1263&view=findpost&p=12922

I assume 'chiongguo' is you (if not, then there are other issues ;)) . If you're going to simply copy previous arguments because they are useful, you may want to get them checked for spelling and grammar, as there are a few mistakes in yours - nothing major, but they stand out when repeated.

Which Zep and MRC_Hans have already dealt with back in August. Even if this is chiongguo, isn't this just a case of argumentum ad infinitum?
 
I don't think she is chiongguo. He/she is in Malaysia, whereas Nancy seems to be in India. Do you have any original thoughts of your own Nancy?
 
It is 'Wholistic'. You have misssed W. We have no compartments in homoeopathy, unlike allopathy


No I haven't. The word is "holistic". Consult a dictionary.

And I suppose you don't realise that modern medicine is not the same as the 18th and early 19th century medicine that Hahnemann derided as "allopathy". Ironic, really, that homoeopaths apply this derogatory term to modern medicine, but have no problem with medical systems that actually have a great deal more in common with the "allopathy" of Hahnemann's day, such as Ayurveda or TCM, both of which, like the medicine Hahnemann opposed, rely on the idea of "humours".

Homoeopathy is not holistic. It doesn't consider the organism as a whole, the way metabolism works. It considers the patient to be nothing more than a collection of symptoms.

The claim that real doctors don't consider the whole patient is a slander put about by sCAMsters. Any decent doctor will look at the whole patient, rather than just the particular symptoms they happen to be complaining about.
 
Last edited:
Good grief! Here's the proof: http://www.wholisticfitness.com/
:D
and "homo-eopathy"? "misssed", needs another "s". I better sell all my dictionrarries!

They use homepathic 30C dictionary , that is they take 1 page from a normal dictionary at random, then mix it with 100 blank pages. Then they repeat this 30 times. The final result is a woolistic homeopathetic dictionary.
 
The word "homoeopathy" is the original spelling and is still acceptable.
I use that spelling all the time to emphasise the archaic nature of homoeopathy.
 
There are a lot of words where spelling differs (mainly between UK and US, but the Uk seems to be adopting the US spelling a lot in many cases) because originally a different vowel letter (a ligature - a grapheme which combines two letters as a single letter) was used, eg homœopathy; fœtus; diarhœah; cœliac. In the UK it was (but is becoming less so) usual practice is to render œ as oe especiallywhere it is difficult to use the original (eg when typing). In the US e is used. There is a similar occurance with the letter æ as used in the words encyclopaedia; æsthetic; anæmia; Cæsar; mediæval.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%86

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Œ

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_words_that_may_be_spelled_with_a_ligature#.C3.86
 
Last edited:
I don't know what's happening in the UK but, in Australia, all those spellings - foetus, diarrhoea, coeliac, encyclopaedia, anaesthetic, aesthetic, anaemia, Caesar, mediaeval (hmmm, not too sure about that one) - are the correct spellings of those words. The alternative spellings just look and feel wrong.

Then, of course, there is colour, rumour, clamour etc.
 
Last edited:
In the UK the medical powers that be have decided on some americanisation. Fetus is now the accepted term I believe.
 
Science progress from the known to the unknown and the model that is built up, for all intents and purposes, are linear in nature.

Try calculating the effects of octupole fields on beam dynamics, then try saying science only deals with linear models.

In some cases it's because English isn't their first language, which is excusable.

It's excusable right up until they try correcting the native English speakers, especially in such an arrogant manner.
 
According to Etymology Online It derives from the greek 'holos' which means 'whole'

First used in 1926 apparently.

Interestingly, the same source clearly records 'allopathy' as "The term applied by homeopathists to traditional medicine"

;)
 
In the UK the medical powers that be have decided on some americanisation. Fetus is now the accepted term I believe.

Yeah, I noticed this on our recently done scans; they used "fetus", much to my horror ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom