More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Books are good but I think I've a more profitable idea.

Now all the air in the atmosphere must have been in contact with everything at one time or another and thus must carry a memory. So, I'll take a 100ml flask and 1 ml of water. Thats my first 1C dilution of the cure to everything. (Note to self, must shake vigorously, the flask not me :)). Now add water to make up to 100 ml, thats the 2C dilution. Easy from now on just 1/100 dilutions to about 30C. Make the last two 10 ml to a litre and 1 litre to 100 litres and I've got enough to make 10,000 10ml doses. Now at £5 a dose that's a tidy profit for an afternoon's work.

Sorry, what's that you are saying? It's in contact with air all the way through the process so it isn't getting diluted? Tut, tut, you are employing those outmoded and discredited systems called logic and skepticism. You are saying it won't work? Just do 100 trials (at your cost), at a confidence level of 5%, then 2.5% will work, the other 97.5% can be forgotten (hmm, must find a reason for that (hmm don't need reason)). And before anybody else criticises this wonderful preparation, just remember that billions of people have found water to be literally life-saving and Galileo wasn't believed either.

Better yet, do a one-sided test. You only care that your troposphere 30C solution is better than placebo. You'll double the number of trials that work! Huzzah! Can I get in on the action?
 
Better yet, do a one-sided test. You only care that your troposphere 30C solution is better than placebo. You'll double the number of trials that work! Huzzah! Can I get in on the action?

You do the trials and my accountant will work out 10% for you.

So, 10% of nothing is ... Hey wait, put the nothing I've given you and shake it about a little bit and it becomes whatever you want to believe it is.
 
Good old Dana is still hanging about at Wikipedia, talking total rubbish about Roy's now-infamous spectrophotometry, and giving criticisms of the Shang et al. paper that have been rebutted here, among other places. But it seems as if he's running into some trouble.
 
Good old Dana is still hanging about at Wikipedia, talking total rubbish about Roy's now-infamous spectrophotometry, and giving criticisms of the Shang et al. paper that have been rebutted here, among other places. But it seems as if he's running into some trouble.

And just as he is having a problems at Wikipedia, he pops up on the Quackometer blog still trying to claim that Darwin was saved by homeopathy.
 
Dana's input to Wikipedia is being seriously criticised.

But someone admires him.

Dana Ullman has found many errors of fact and some missing information on various wikipedia articles on homeopathy and has sought to correct them with verifiable, notable information from reliable sources and has often provided secondary sources. Despite having to deal with many editors who have expressed open skepticism and strong antagonism towards homeopathy and even offensively referred to homeopathic physicians as "quacks" and "promoters of pseudoscience," Dana has maintain civility and has often found ways to obtain consensus. Even though numerous editors have wiki-stalked him and others who have been antagonistic to Dana's work have later been found to be socks or multiple socks, Dana has maintained civility.

I wonder who this supporter could be?

Why it's none other that Dana himself :covereyes
 
Dana's input to Wikipedia is being seriously criticised.

But someone admires him.



I wonder who this supporter could be?

Why it's none other that Dana himself :covereyes

13601480f21e37497a.gif


Amazing. Baron Samedi finds this quite amusing. Just like DanaJames, Baron Samedi shall start referring to himself in the third person.
 
Dana's input to Wikipedia is being seriously criticised.

But someone admires him.

I wonder who this supporter could be?

Why it's none other that Dana himself :covereyes


Looking back at the first page of this thread, I find that he had a supporter here as well:
I appreciate good skeptical thinking, and yet, am I the only one who thinks that no one responded to the numerous basic science and clinical studies that Dana Ullman referenced?

Am I the only one who think that Ullman also gave a good, solid critique of that questionably done "meta-analysis" that sought to compare 110 homeopathic and allopathic studies? Am I the only one who is surprised that even the skeptics who did this study found that the homeopathic studies had a larger number of higher percentage of higher quality studies than the allopathic studies (by THEIR own definition of high quality studies).

At first blush, homeopathy seems weird to me too, but heck, nature is full of mysteries. Humility is a healthy scientific attitude.

:D
 
Looking back at the first page of this thread, I find that he had a supporter here as well:

:D

When I first joined the thread I quickly and obviously inadequately scanned the first posts. I hadn't realised Gully had tried to pass himself off as anyone other than Ullman.

One of Dana's many endearing traits is to quickly accuse others of any fault found in himself. I had wondered why he made such a big deal on Wikipedia of presenting himself as Ullman and not using a pseudonym. Now we know, thanks Mojo.
 
Oh, they banned him then? Good!

For a so-called eminent figure, Dana has an awful lot of spare time to wander round the internet pushing homoeopathy.

Rolfe.
 
Oh, they banned him then?


No, they're still posting evidence and discussing possible options. I'm not quite sure how the arbitration is going to work, or how long it takes. As far as I can see the possible scope of the arbitration has been widened form Dana to all articles relating to homoeopathy and (I think) all the users who have been editing/discussing them.
 
For a so-called eminent figure, Dana has an awful lot of spare time to wander round the internet pushing homoeopathy.


He has a lot of time because he does not actually practise homoeopathy and hasn't done so for decades!
All he needs to do is write a book every now and then.
 
Dana has been banned at Wikipedia from all homeopathy related articles for three months.

The reasons for the ban are very strongly worded by Wikipedia standards.

You have persisted in disrupting homeopathy-related topics, including tendentious arguments, soapboxing, and accusations against other editors. For example, your behavior (both over the long-term and more recently) at Potassium dichromate (edit|talk|history|links|watch|logs) is completely unacceptable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom