More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Does anyone know what the criteria were for membership of the British Homoeopathic Society at this date? This (from the website of a long-established international homoeopathic society) describes it as a "lay/medical society" formed to raise funds to found a hospital, so they may well have been happy to let anyone pay a subscription. It certainly looks as if membership wasn't restricted to physicians. We already know that Gully was interested in homoeopathy, but this isn't the same thing as actually being a homoeopath. Indeed, Dana himself is on record as saying that the fact that someone prescribes homoeopathic medicines doesn't mean they are a homoeopath.

Looking at Gully's own writings, and in particular at the very footnote that Dana is so fond of quoting parts of, we find that in 1856 (i.e. 8 years after he joined the society and 7 years after he was alleged to have been Darwin's "homeopathic physician"), Gully wrote of homoeopathy:

Gully, The water cure in chronic disease, 5th ed. London: John Churchill, 1856, p 48n.

Is it normal for "homeopathic physicians" of at least 8 years standing to profess ignorance of homoeopathy?

If they can get away with it. Homeopaths generaly avoid takeing a position since a position can be attacked and destroyed.
 
I have left comments on Huff Po, but I stopped because its software is annoying. Which fits, because it is an annoying place. Quoting Monty Python and the Holy Grail: 'Tis a silly place

Dana got upset when I mentioned his lies here:
http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=35#comment-1184

He did not respond back when I amended it to him being silly and stupid.

I've also deployed the sure-fire Ullman-repellent that is calling him to account on Roy's dud 'bomb'.
 
That set of blogs HCN has led us to

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=42

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=48


about Bayesian inferences is an excellent introduction to the area and it has crystallised a lot of what I have been thinking recently, which is that it really is time to call a halt to more useless clinical trials of homeopathy. The only purpose they serve is to allow the homs to eke out the occasional low-grade 'positive' result that certain turds of our acquaintance then pimp across the internet as if they were the absolute final truth.

Homeopathy behaves exactly in the way that you would expect for something that is no different from a placebo.

We need to emphasise a small number of facts;

1. Homeopathy is inconsistent with all of the rest of science. There is no basis to think it could work. Its Bayesian prior probability is vanishingly tiny.
2. Homeopathic clinical experience is explained exactly by the operations of placebo effect, bias and disease natural history. An effect from homeopathy is simply a superfluous hypothesis.
3. Most especially, homeopathy has never produce any of its allegedly dramatic effects when its claims have been assessed objectively. We are left with people like Ullman touting Oscillococcinum because it maybe possibly produced a tentative 86 minute shortening in the course of flu. Is that the best they can do? It seems to be.If it really worked they should be able to better than this.
4. They cannot produce a set of well-documented cases of serious non-self-limiting diseases responding to homeopathy even outside the situation of a controlled trial.Even if you lower the bar sufficiently to admit uncontrolled case records they still can't demonstrate the effect they are so keen to assert. Again, the homs lack even basis for suggesting their hypothesis in the first place.
5. Homeopathy is littered with internal contradictions. Because homeopaths believe in something that is false they can make up the rules as they go along and never tidy up after themselves. So, they have no means of weeding out 'false' homeopathic doctrine from 'true' homeopathic doctrine.Perhaps we have not yet met that True Homeopath. More likely he or she does not exist because there is no True Homeopathy.
 
I've turned up something relevant to another of Dana's claims.
Darwin wrote that he was so sick that he was “unable to do anything one day out of three.” He was so ill that he wasn’t even able to attend his father’s funeral when he died on November 13, 1848.

In fact, it is not entirely clear that Darwin was, as Dana claims, "so ill that he wasn't even able to attend his father's funeral".

According to Janet Browne's biography of Darwin, when Darwin heard the news of his father's death,
He felt sad and ill, to ill to move. Erasmus would go straight to Shrewsbury for the funeral. he would have to follow on afterwards alone.
Whatever happened next is not certain. Darwin definitely stayed at Down for a few days before setting out for Shrewsbury, waiting for Emma to return from a visit to her sister's, and he definitely passed through Erasmus's house in London the day before the funeral. He may have missed his Midlands train or been delayed. Either way, he arrived in Shrewsbury after the cortege had left the family home for the church of St. Chad's.
According to Erasmus, Darwin therefore remained at The Mount with their sister Marianne Parker, who was too upset to attend the burial service. "Charles did not arrive till too late", Erasmus wrote to Fanny.

Janet Browne, Charles Darwin: Voyaging, p. 490.

It does go on to say that Darwin later stated "I was at the time so unwell that I was unable to travel which added to my misery", but in view of the documented fact that he arrived at his father's house in time to be there with his sister during the funeral, this appears to be something of an exaggeration.

As Browne observes, "no one really wants to go to a funeral".
 
Last edited:
I've turned up something relevant to another of Dana's claims.

In fact, it is not entirely clear that Darwin was, as Dana claims, "so ill that he wasn't even able to attend his father's funeral".

According to Janet Browne's biography of Darwin, when Darwin heard the news of his father's death,

Janet Browne, Charles Darwin: Voyaging, p. 490.

It does go on to say that Darwin later stated "I was at the time so unwell that I was unable to travel which added to my misery", but in view of the documented fact that he arrived at his father's house in time to be there with his sister during the funeral, this appears to be something of an exaggeration.

As Browne observes, "no one really wants to go to a funeral".

You're like a little rabid terrier gnawing at Dana's leg. Well done.
 
Homeopathy is actually too scientific for one to assume that there is a single medicine appropriate for everyone. In homeopathy it is essential that the medicine be individually prescribed for the sick person.

(From here: http://www.homeopathic.com/articles/view,26)

This can't be the same website selling non-individualised domestic homeopathic medicine kits then, surely?

Portable and Miniature Homeopathic Medicine Kits!

We are very excited to announce the availability of the 3 mini-kits:
[snip]
This new super-miniature kit with FIVE spray bottles is PERFECT for travel, for putting in your purse, your pocket, or your car's glove compartment! Although this kit was initially designed for treating pets, it can be used in treating anyone. A great product at a fantastic price...and a great gift!

The First Year’s Kit: This kit's five medicines in this mini-kit are: Chamomilla (teething), Ledum, (puncture wounds and post-vaccination syndrome), Aconitum (fear, anxiety, restlessness, & the 1st stages of infection), Cocculus (travel sickness), and Calendula (wounds and post-surgical healing)...all in the 30C potency.
etc. etc.


Erm, yes. Yes it is. Who'd have thought it?
 
That's a one for all.
But all for one seems to work equally well if you read the different replies given by different homoeopaths to a single indiviual asking for advice on a homoeopathic forum.

No sense.
 
Last edited:
Sccientific basis of Homoeopathy

Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Scientific Basis of Homoeopathy-2

Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Professor Louis Rey, Doctor of Sciences, Lausanne, a specialist in low temperature thermoluminescence, has published on this topic in the international journals Nature (1988; 391: 418) and C.R.Physique (2000; 1: 107-110). He presented the latest results of the experiments he carried out together with Dr. Philippe Belon on the thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride. Ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride (10-30 g cm-3) were irradiated by X- and gamma-rays at 77K, then progressively re-warmed to room temperature.

During that phase, their thermoluminescence was studied and it was found that, despite their dilution beyond the Avogadro number, the emitted light was specific of the original salts dissolved initially. Much to the authors’ surprise, the experimental results showed, without ambiguity, the specificity of the contained information. The findings proved to be reproducible in the course of many different identical experiments.
This exceptional finding that flies against known physics has not been reproduced by independent parties since this was published many years ago.

The working hypothesis would be that Rey et al. have somehow contaminated their samples. Only independent confirmation of such a finding can turn physics upside down.
 
This new paradigm is needed to explain the experimental facts and to understand the failure of research models that do not fit it.
What experimental facts?

There is no reason to speculate on the theory of homoeopathy as long as it is not possible to show that homoeopathy works at all. Properly controlled tests have time and again shown that the normal scientific explanation for homoeopathic findings are satisfactory: Misdiagnosis, spontaneous healing that would have occurred anyway, temporary improvement, no actual healing, and placebo effect.

In homoeopathic practice homoeopathy works all the time, but when homoeopaths conducts tests properly controlled against placebo there is no effect at all, or an effect that is insignificant compared to what they get without controls. This should cause homoeopaths to pause, but instead it causes them to wish the controls away.
 
Example: Rubella in a normal subject: no apparent sickness. Rubella in immuno-deficient subject: symptoms, apparent sickness. For the allopathic research approach, the symptoms are pathognomonic, specific to the illness; they are used to diagnose the pathology. When the diagnosis of the pathology is performed, the treatment is chosen accordingly; classical therapy may be also targeted against symptoms. For the homeopathic research approach, considered symptoms are idiosyncratic; specific to the patient. They are the personal ex-pression of the sickness by the patient. They are used to choose the specific remedy according to the similarity of the symptoms observed by "proving" in a healthy subject.

In homeopathy, the originator of the information is the starting material of the remedy; succussed dilutions of the starting material in a solvent are mediators. High dilutions contain only information from that material and no molecules remain. This mediation results from the succussed solvent being in a specific state, implying perhaps electro-magnetic processes. The receiver (the whole living body) receives and processes the information in the remedy according to its state, whether healthy ("proving") or sick (therapy).

This new paradigm is needed to explain the experimental facts and to understand the failure of research models that do not fit it.

Homeopathy can be similar or better in effectiveness than conventional treatment and, where it has been studied, it is cheaper in the long run. Many interesting questions not even asked should be prioritized, such as the potential of homeopathy to avoid invasive procedures in children and, in primary care settings, the long-term effect of homeopathy in preventing chronic complications.

Is this a cut and paste argument?

from here: https://secureweb.activeisp.com/w00384425/liga letter engl 2_05.pdf


MADELEINE BASTIDE [France] quoted Claude Benard: “When the
observed facts do not support a well established theory, the facts have to
be accepted and the theory rejected.” One principle of homeopathy is the
use of very high dilutions, which cannot be explained by the mechanistic
paradigm, the “well established theory” of modern science. In homeopathy,
the originator of the information is the starting material of the remedy;
succussed dilutions are mediators. High dilutions contain only information
from that material, no molecules. The receiver processes the information
according to its state, whether healthy [proving] or sick [therapy].
As for your part 1, which says:

The use of preparations that are diluted beyond Avogadro’s number (i.e. potencies greater than C10) happens in only 25% of the prescribed homeopathic medications. Nevertheless, for some people this question is the most important obstacle to the acceptance of homeopathy.

What is the real relevance of Avogadro’s number in evaluating the precise pattern of molecules? Can a dilution work without any molecule? One of the most innovative perspectives in this last decade was the demonstration that high dilutions have as much activity and effectiveness in an organized structured solvent without any solute molecule as they do when molecules are present (even only some molecules).

Professor Louis Rey, Doctor of Sciences, Lausanne, a specialist in low temperature thermoluminescence, has published on this topic in the international journals Nature (1988; 391: 418) and C.R.Physique (2000; 1: 107-110). He presented the latest results of the experiments he carried out together with Dr. Philippe Belon on the thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride. Ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride (10-30 g cm-3) were irradiated by X- and gamma-rays at 77K, then progressively re-warmed to room temperature. etc.


This all seems very familiar to this page...

http://www.cure4incurables.com/homeo.htm

including

First question addressed: The activity of very highly diluted preparations. Homeopathic practitioners will argue that the use of preparations that are diluted beyond Avogadro’s number (i.e. potencies greater than C10) happens in only 25% of the prescribed homeopathic medications. Nevertheless, for some people this question is the most important obstacle to the acceptance of homeopathy. The experimental model that is cheapest, most reproducible and also the most easily researched is probably the "acetylcholine-induced contraction of the rat ileum". It is a well recognized scientific model (Chang FY, Lee SD, et al. Rat gastrointestinal motor responses mediated via activation of neurokinin receptors. J.Gastroenterol Hepatol 1999; 14: 39-45).
and
Second question addressed: The content of very highly diluted homeopathic preparations. Professor Jean Cambar introduced the theme by asking what are the contributions of the different spectroscopies (Raman, Ultraviolet, X-ray or Magnetic Nuclear Resonance) in revealing the structure of water and solvents in high dilutions? What is the real relevance of Avogadro’s number in evaluating the precise pattern of molecules? Can a dilution work without any molecule? One of the most innovative perspectives in this last decade was the demonstration that high dilutions have as much activity and effectiveness in an organized structured solvent without any solute molecule as they do when molecules are present (even only some molecules). Professor Louis Rey, Doctor of Sciences, Lausanne, a specialist in low temperature thermoluminescence, has published on this topic in the international journals Nature (1988; 391: 418) and C.R.Physique (2000; 1: 107-110). He presented the latest results of the experiments he carried out together with Dr. Philippe Belon on the thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride. Ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride (10-30 g cm-3) were irradiated by X- and gamma-rays at 77K, then progressively re-warmed to room temperature.
 
Actually, this page rocks. http://www.cure4incurables.com/homeo.htm

I mean it, this is totally awesome

On request you can also: Learn Meditation, control Stress, improve Memory & Concentration, find a most satisfying job without much effort, learn speed reading, learn remote viewing/see places far away (sitting wherever you are - with eyes closed), learn Telepathy (mind reading/sending messages), stop smoking, lose/gain weight, improve confidence, regress to a past life (especially to solve problems that you have in this life related to a past life), find lost objects, get answers for the unsolvable, get whatever through guided visualization (a car, a house, money etc.), E.S.P. (Clairvoyance, Sixth sense, Intuition etc.) and so on. We have a team of specialists with rich experience in various specialised fields for curing various ailments.
And not only that, they cure AIDS! Diabetes! Cure all heart problems! Quit alcohol, smoking, bad habits! AND they can help you avoid divorce! Dig around, and you can find anthrax prevention! (My advice... burn the CDs, ha ha)

If you want to be cured permanently, check out the contacts:
Dr. R. JHINGADÉ
M.D.(Hom.)
'Incurable' Healer, Hypnotherapist, Qualified Doctor and Homoeopath.


I want that on my business card... 'Incurable' Healer.... I'm jealous.

ETA: I forgot to add... all consultations with R. Jhingadé are by email. What a cushy job.
 
Last edited:
Aw. I thought we had a new homoeopath to play with, even though the technique of argument by blatant assertion is a bit like being lectured to by a brick wall.

But all it is, is cut-and-paste. What a shame.

Rolfe.
 
Aw. I thought we had a new homoeopath to play with, even though the technique of argument by blatant assertion is a bit like being lectured to by a brick wall.

But all it is, is cut-and-paste. What a shame.

Rolfe.

And now a spamming cut and paste job. I'm sad.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom