geni
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2003
- Messages
- 28,209
Does anyone know what the criteria were for membership of the British Homoeopathic Society at this date? This (from the website of a long-established international homoeopathic society) describes it as a "lay/medical society" formed to raise funds to found a hospital, so they may well have been happy to let anyone pay a subscription. It certainly looks as if membership wasn't restricted to physicians. We already know that Gully was interested in homoeopathy, but this isn't the same thing as actually being a homoeopath. Indeed, Dana himself is on record as saying that the fact that someone prescribes homoeopathic medicines doesn't mean they are a homoeopath.
Looking at Gully's own writings, and in particular at the very footnote that Dana is so fond of quoting parts of, we find that in 1856 (i.e. 8 years after he joined the society and 7 years after he was alleged to have been Darwin's "homeopathic physician"), Gully wrote of homoeopathy:
Gully, The water cure in chronic disease, 5th ed. London: John Churchill, 1856, p 48n.
Is it normal for "homeopathic physicians" of at least 8 years standing to profess ignorance of homoeopathy?
If they can get away with it. Homeopaths generaly avoid takeing a position since a position can be attacked and destroyed.