More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Perhaps you should wind the clock back a bit more to arrive at the etymologically true term, namely "phoetus".


Well, I was just joking around, but all I was saying was that down here the spelling is, and always has been in my lifetime, "foetus". So I'm happy to stay with that. Hell, even if there is an official change here, I'm still staying with it.
 
Phoetus, foetus, fetus....
I suppose the yanks won't be happy until just the last two letters remain.
 
Dana Ullman's criticism of some aspects of conventional medicine are like the proverbial man trying to remove a splinter from someone else's eye with a beam in his own. :D
 
In his never ending quest to ply his trade, Ullman has stumbled into NESS and received a gentle but irrefutable lesson from Stephen Novella.


Oh dear, Ullman's citing Frass again. He can't be unaware of the criticisms of this study (try as he might to ignore them).

And he's citing the rest of his usual suspects: Kleijnen 1991, Linde 1997, Taylor 2004, Jacobs 2003...

His grasp of statistics seems to be as good as ever:
Dana Ullman said:
According to the Kaiser Foundation, every man, woman, and child in the US in 2006 was prescribed 12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone...
 
Last edited:
Mojo said:
His grasp of statistics seems to be as good as ever:
Dana Ullman said:
According to the Kaiser Foundation, every man, woman, and child in the US in 2006 was prescribed 12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone...

How incredibly blind do you have to be to be unable to see that that statistic cannot possibly be true? How can you possibly think that anyone should take you seriously when you choose to say something so stupid?

These questions are of course rhetorical, since we are inundated with examples of the blindness and stupidity passing unnoticed. It still boggles, though.

Linda
 
I haven't read the original but, just off the top of my head, considering that most prescriptions are for chronic conditions, and since each prescription for a chronic condition generally lasts one month, and considering that there are 12 months in a year, "12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone" might actually translate to "12.4 prescriptions for a drug in that year alone", meaning about "1 prescription drug in that year alone". Also, considering that the word "alone" at the end of the sentence is largely superfluous, this reduces to "1 prescription drug per year".

So, "12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone" actually means more like "1 prescription drug per year".

Is that about right?
 
I haven't read the original but, just off the top of my head, considering that most prescriptions are for chronic conditions, and since each prescription for a chronic condition generally lasts one month, and considering that there are 12 months in a year, "12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone" might actually translate to "12.4 prescriptions for a drug in that year alone", meaning about "1 prescription drug in that year alone". Also, considering that the word "alone" at the end of the sentence is largely superfluous, this reduces to "1 prescription drug per year".

So, "12.4 prescription drugs in that year alone" actually means more like "1 prescription drug per year".

Is that about right?

Further thought... are birth control pills in the US prescription only?
 
Oh dear, Ullman's citing Frass again. He can't be unaware of the criticisms of this study (try as he might to ignore them).

And he's citing the rest of his usual suspects: Kleijnen 1991, Linde 1997, Taylor 2004, Jacobs 2003...

His grasp of statistics seems to be as good as ever:

Of course he's aware of the weaknesses in his arguments, he is just stupid enough to believe he can con Steven Novella. :jaw-dropp
 
Of course he's aware of the weaknesses in his arguments, he is just stupid enough to believe he can con Steven Novella. :jaw-dropp

He's still at it. Given Dr Novella's thoroughness and history of in depth responses to critics on his blog, I suspect there may be a fairly comprehensive riposte being written at the moment.
 
Originally Posted by Dana Ullman
Acerlon has been shown that he doesn’t learn, despite my and others efforts.

I'm hurt, truly hurt. All those years of study and then an enormously respected academician, whose own work has shown that all that is known in chemistry, physics and biology (mathematics too) is just plain wrong has told me I haven't learned anything. I suppose I'd better find something to do that makes money but doesn't require any knowledge or logic.

Hmmm, homeopathy looks attractive :D
 
Books are good but I think I've a more profitable idea.

Now all the air in the atmosphere must have been in contact with everything at one time or another and thus must carry a memory. So, I'll take a 100ml flask and 1 ml of water. Thats my first 1C dilution of the cure to everything. (Note to self, must shake vigorously, the flask not me :)). Now add water to make up to 100 ml, thats the 2C dilution. Easy from now on just 1/100 dilutions to about 30C. Make the last two 10 ml to a litre and 1 litre to 100 litres and I've got enough to make 10,000 10ml doses. Now at £5 a dose that's a tidy profit for an afternoon's work.

Sorry, what's that you are saying? It's in contact with air all the way through the process so it isn't getting diluted? Tut, tut, you are employing those outmoded and discredited systems called logic and skepticism. You are saying it won't work? Just do 100 trials (at your cost), at a confidence level of 5%, then 2.5% will work, the other 97.5% can be forgotten (hmm, must find a reason for that (hmm don't need reason)). And before anybody else criticises this wonderful preparation, just remember that billions of people have found water to be literally life-saving and Galileo wasn't believed either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom