More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Oops, 8 posts.
One of those three "copy and paste" posts has just been pasted in a third thread!
 
Someone has been spamming Wikipedia with stuff from that page. They've done it at least three times, from at least two different accounts.

They've already made it into the "Homoeopaths say the darndest things" thread.

Ha ha, I like the end

P.S.: I have removed all references to other web-sites, but if someone really wants to, I'm sure they can find the same matter posted above, from our web-sites on the Internet
I'm sure they can! Gah. So this guy is just trying to advertise his cure for diabetes, AIDS, bad gas after burritos, paranoia that your boss is secretly a space alien, and everything else under the sun?
 
She seems to like Rhus Tox 30. Sadly, she never says if its 30X, 30C, or 30M. I find it funny that in her post, she claims that only 25% of remedies are beyond Avogadro. In that cache page, almost all of her recommendations are beyond 23^10 (30, 30, 200, 10M, 30... I see a 6, but no idea if that's X, C, or M)
 
From her site:

sir, my father (age 67yr) have got inguinal hernia,in left side.Only 15 days earlier this problem started. Is there any treatment for this in homeopathy? If yes please advise us. thankyou shyam V.
Rx. Nux Nomica 30, single dose every alternate day for 15 days.
Hi, My 10 year old son has been diagnosed with right inguinal hernia. He is asymptomatic. The mass in his scrotum almost goes away when he is asleep, but slowly returns during the day. Which homeopathic remedy might will help him? Kindly advise.
Rx. Lycopodium 30 single dose every alternate day for 15 days.


Does this mean the treatment for inguinal hernia is different depending on whether it is on the left or right side?

Well, apparently it is....

I have ingunial hernia. Pl tell me how it be treated without involving surgery?
Yes it can be treated without surgery but kindly give me the details like: is it on right side or left side?, and other detauils about the patient.


I wonder how she would treat a strangulated hernia? :eek:
And would it make a difference if it was on the left or right side? :cool:
 
Reading this blog post about the RTE's coverage of homoeopathy, And things started looking a little familiar:
"Homeopathy was first introduced to Ireland by Dr. Charles W. Luther in 1839. Dr. William Walter was instructing Dr. Joseph Kidd in Dublin in 1842. Kidd later had great success with homeopathy in the Irish Potato Famine of the 1840s, and later became the physician to Benjamin Disraeli."

I wanted to do some digging on Joseph Kidd, but there appears to be nothing about him online except for some homeopathists book, which I'm not going to buy.


Guess who pops up in the comments.

Dana Ullman said:
Then came the infamous Irish potato famine of 1845–1849, when Kidd was challenged to show that homeopathy can be effective in the most adverse conditions. He moved to the rural areas where the worst starvation was happening, and he kept an active record of all of his patients and their diseases and deaths. He recorded 1.8 percent mortality, while the local hospital’s rate was 36 percent.


Wow! People who were sick enough to be admitted to a hospital were more likely to die than a homoeopath's patients.

Then he cites Frass et al again.
 
Homoeopathy is symptom based. The symptoms accompanies with it have varied characteristics. So u could have (not neccessarily for every disease) a different medicine for left and right side.
 
[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Science progress from the known to the unknown and the model that is built up, for all intents and purposes, are linear in nature. And when it is used to study a system that is non-linear it is often found wanting. When science failed to find evidence it is the failure of science. Science is blind and if you know why this is so then you would be a bit more circumspect in the conclusion that science offer.[/FONT]
 
[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Homoeopathy had often been accused of not being scientific or do not conform to the gold standard set out by modern medicine. And as a result many homoeopathic researches had often taken the position that the evidence-based medicine is the only viable model for research. In trying to force fit the various aspects of homeopathy into this model we came up with some successes and also some failures. The failure is not in homoeopathy as a therapeutic modality but in the failure of the model in which we use.[/FONT]
 
Science progress from the known to the unknown and the model that is built up, for all intents and purposes, are linear in nature. And when it is used to study a system that is non-linear it is often found wanting. When science failed to find evidence it is the failure of science. Science is blind and if you know why this is so then you would be a bit more circumspect in the conclusion that science offer.
In other words, if a homoeopathy cannot be shown to work, we just say that it is non-linear, and then, presto, we can claim it works?

What utter BS!
 
Homoeopathy had often been accused of not being scientific or do not conform to the gold standard set out by modern medicine. And as a result many homoeopathic researches had often taken the position that the evidence-based medicine is the only viable model for research. In trying to force fit the various aspects of homeopathy into this model we came up with some successes and also some failures. The failure is not in homoeopathy as a therapeutic modality but in the failure of the model in which we use.
Do you deny that some illnesses cure themselves when untreated? How will you make sure that your research is not mistaking this effect for an effect of the treatment? Do you have a better method than "science"?

When you quote other people, you could at least acknowledge the quote. In this case, the quote seems to be taken from the NCH forum. Are you chiongguo? Do you have any opinion that is your own rather than what you can dig up on the net?
 
30 means 30C by default, until it is stated as 30X or something else

Even at 30C, do you not see the contradiction? Before, you just blindly copied and pasted this:

The use of preparations that are diluted beyond Avogadro’s number (i.e. potencies greater than C10) happens in only 25% of the prescribed homeopathic medications. Nevertheless, for some people this question is the most important obstacle to the acceptance of homeopathy.


Most of your recommendations to sick people are at 30C, which is indeed greater than C10.


Do you deny that some illnesses cure themselves when untreated? How will you make sure that your research is not mistaking this effect for an effect of the treatment? Do you have a better method than "science"?

When you quote other people, you could at least acknowledge the quote. In this case, the quote seems to be taken from the NCH forum. Are you chiongguo? Do you have any opinion that is your own rather than what you can dig up on the net?

I found those arguments, too, and thought that Nancy Malik was chiongguo. Only after checking your link, did I notice the date of these posts. Oi.
 
Science progress from the known to the unknown and the model that is built up, for all intents and purposes, are linear in nature. And when it is used to study a system that is non-linear it is often found wanting. When science failed to find evidence it is the failure of science. Science is blind and if you know why this is so then you would be a bit more circumspect in the conclusion that science offer.

Cut-n-paste from : http://www.otherhealth.com/research.../9000-homeopathy-some-issues-4.html#post77132
and : http://www.otherhealth.com/research.../9000-homeopathy-some-issues-5.html#post77383

Homoeopathy had often been accused of not being scientific or do not conform to the gold standard set out by modern medicine. And as a result many homoeopathic researches had often taken the position that the evidence-based medicine is the only viable model for research. In trying to force fit the various aspects of homeopathy into this model we came up with some successes and also some failures. The failure is not in homoeopathy as a therapeutic modality but in the failure of the model in which we use.

Cut-n-paste from : http://nch.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=1263&view=findpost&p=12922

I assume 'chiongguo' is you (if not, then there are other issues ;)) . If you're going to simply copy previous arguments because they are useful, you may want to get them checked for spelling and grammar, as there are a few mistakes in yours - nothing major, but they stand out when repeated.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom