Was Gully considered to be a homoeopath?
Over on the Quackometer blog, Dana Ullman wrote,
It is shocking that you still think that Gully wasn't a homeopath, even though most respected biographies on Darwin that discuss his health acknowledge that Gully was a homeopath and that Darwin respected Gully more than any other physician (he didn't have much respect for most physicians, though Gully was an exception). Read Quammen's book or Desmond & Moore's, amongst many others.
I was intending to post this on thread that quotation comes from, but while I was tracking down the biographies Dana recommended the thread was closed because Dana kept regurgitating the same trials that have already been stomped on here, so I'll post it here instead.
OK, I’ve checked out Quammen and Desmond & Moore, at least as far as mentions of Gully and homoeopathy are concerned. Let’s examine Dana’s claim that Gully was "
Darwin’s homeopath", and his claim that "most respected biographies on Darwin that discuss his health acknowledge that Gully was a homeopath", using his suggested sources.
Both works discuss Darwin’s health.
Desmond & Moore’s
Darwin (London : Michael Joseph, 1991) mainly discusses Gully in a chapter titled "My Water Doctor", in which Gully’s regime is referred to as "the water cure", or "the cold water cure". The only mentions of homoeopathy in connection with Gully, as far as I can see, are on pages 364, which mentions that Gully believed in "all manner of unorthodox practices - homoeopathy, hydropathy, mesmerism – none of which Charles shared. Charles never overcame his distrust of homoeopathy", and page 365, which repeats the quotation we have already seen from Darwin’s letters about Gully giving Darwin homoeopathic medicines and Darwin taking them "without an atom of faith".
On Page 366 is a sentence that looks familiar: "Feeling good, Charles had to admit that the water cure was no quackery after all". A very similar passage appears
here: "And after just a month of treatment, Charles had to admit that Gully’s treatments were not quackery after all." Note how the words "the water cure" have been replaced by "Gully’s treatments". The chapter goes on to describe how Darwin continued Gully’s treatments after returning home: sweating under blankets, showers, cold baths, scrubbing, but no mention of homoeopathy.
Nowhere do Desmond and Moore describe Gully as a homoeopath. Dana has
alleged that the reason Gully is invariably described as hydropath rather than a homoeopath is because "this is just the historians way of writing homeopathy out of history". Desmond and Moore appear to have no problem with referring to people as homoeopaths: on page 238 a Quaker doctor called John Epps is referred to as "a London phrenologist, homoeopathist and disestasblishment campaigner", and John Chapman is described on page 392 as "Gully’s homoeopathist", so it’s highly unlikely that they don’t refer to Gully as a homoeopath because of some sort of desire to write homoeopathy out of history.
David Quammen’s
The Kiwi’s Egg: Charles Darwin and Natural Selection (London: Weidenfield & Nicolson, 2007) mentions Gully on pages 111-112 and 117. Quammen introduces Gully on page 111 thus:
[Darwin] packed up Emma, the children, the butler, the governess, and several maids, and went off to a water-cure establishment run by James Gully in the town of Malvern…
The only mention of homoeopathy is at the foot of the same page, where he says that Darwin
…was skeptical of Gully’s belief in Homeopathy (not to mention mesmerism and clairvoyance, two of the doctor’s other enthusiasms). But he persuaded himself that the water-torture was working.
Interestingly, Quammen (who Dana evidently regards as a reliable source, otherwise he would not have referred me to him) also gives a brief description of the "theory" relied upon by Gully in prescribing treatments Darwin’s condition:
The theory behind Gully’s so-called cure was that excess blood, congested in vessels servicing the stomach, caused "nervous dyspepsia" such as Darwin’s. The solution to that, Gully thought, lay in drawing blood away from the stomach to the skin and extremities by means of cold water and friction, generating just enough chilly irritation to cause a rash.
Gully thought that the condition was caused by excess blood, and the solution was to draw the blood away. Nothing to do with "like cures like" there, is there? In fact, that sounds suspiciously like allopathy.
It also looks as if the rash referred to by Dana
here as "a common "healing crisis" observed in people undergoing homeopathic treatment" may have simply been brought on by all that scrubbing.
It appears from the above that Quammen is, to say the least, somewhat skeptical as to whether Gully’s treatments provided Darwin with any real benefit: "so-called cure," "he persuaded himself that the water-torture was working" – these are certainly not endorsements of Gully’s treatments.
There is certainly nothing in either book to support Dana’s claim that Gully was Darwin’s homoeopath, or his claim that "most respected biographies on Darwin that discuss his health acknowledge that Gully was a homeopath".
I’m currently reading volume 1 of Janet Browne’s biography of Darwin (Janet Browne:
Charles Darwin: Voyaging, London: Jonathan Cape, 1995). In this, too, Gully’s treatments are referred to as the "water cure", and his regime is described in terms of "cold showers and baths, but also through a wide variety of esoteric techniques such as wet-sheet packing and wrapping, steam baths, friction, and rubbing", and also "a strict routine of early rising, a multitude of walks on the Malvern Hills, a little plain food, and spring water to drink. Everything was designed to fulfil Gully’s spartan promise of "pure air, pure water, and dietic rule"". Needless to say, like the other "respected biographies" Dana refers to, this book fails to refer to Gully as a homoeopath.
All may not be lost for Dana though: it appears that Darwin’s father, who was a doctor, may have advocated the use of homoeopathic techniques. On page 44 he is described giving advice to Darwin and his elder brother Erasmus, who at that point were both planning to become doctors themselves, about "the psychology of local practice":
the doctor’s advice was practical, if brusque: white lies and sympathy were usually all that was needed.
…
The best remedy, he told the boys, was to let people talk.
