[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just one?



























There's a few to hold you over, Malcolm.
Not one lie in there and most were spot on. Thanks for keeping the list.
I wonder how far I need to track back to recall what I banjaxed you with last time? Anyway no matter really, you've recovered now just in time to tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?
 
OK, OK, OK!! I was hurrying to go out to dinner! At least I was close-ish on the frequency.
Heh, sorry. I just find the subject of tuning systems and temperament endlessly fascinating (I should have been a theorist).

Come and meet the organ in All Saints Church, Faringdon, in Oxfordshire. Tuned in the 1920s I believe, and a good tone above concert pitch. Try singing Barber's Adagio there, not meant for singing anyway, that takes the sopranos up to an exposed top C. And try it when you've just spent the week touring Wales and are frankly knackered. (Hah, Crispian S-P the trumpeter had it worse. He had to play half his programme transposing at sight - now Malcolm's imaginary machine would have come in handy there! - and the "authentic" part on a hunk of bent piping, as the version with the three holes that made it actually playable couldn't be brought into tune with the organ.)
I used to sing every Christmas at my mother's church. For a couple of years they insisted on bringing in a couple of handbells which I found rather irritating. They'd just sit there for most of the service, then occasionally peal a piercing ring right into my ear. It was always out of place, and I saw no need for them.

Then they had the organ refurbished, and it ended up a quarter tone sharp. No more handbells!:) Of course then they asked me to sing "O Holy Night" with a high B-flat at the end, which is bad enough when the organ isn't sharp.


Good luck trying to get Malcolm to understand the subtleties of definition. This is the guy who has stated categorically that there's no such thing as a transitive verb. I see what you mean about A to B being a "tone". It's so easy to use the words when you're familiar with them, and not see that an outsider with only a smattering of knowledge, like Malcolm, may be misunderstanding in spades.
Think I should start talking about major tones and minor tones and totally break his brain? Or would that just be mean?
Does he really think "intuitive tone control" means it can read your mind and change your pitch by a major second if necessary? Hey, that's a good one!
I prefer to think of a machine that can anticipate which plainchant tune you're planning on singing, and then correct that. But hey, I'm a geek.
 
Malcolm, don't be so quick to say you are winning. I believe you DON'T have truth on your side. I also believe that 10, 20, 30, 40 years from now people will be debating the '911 hoax' just like they do the 'Moon Hoax' and JFK; in relative obscurity and completely away from the mainstream.

So, your arrogance may make you feel better, but in the end we shall see, won't we?
Do you really think this will go 20 years, do you?
Because the MSM says it's not there, then it'll just go away eh?
Are you seriously trying to tell me, that after all the evidence I've put up on this thread, you believe the OCT?
At the risk of yet another post failing to get past the monitor, quite simply, I don't believe you.
For reasons best known to yourself, you deny the truth. Yuo do have a bunker mentality. Is it too much for you to tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?
Or do you wish to avoid answering that, because you know very well that by trying to answer that question, you will show 9/11 to be an inside job?
 
Actually, Spitfire, it's quite simple in general terms. Two large ships (such as oil tankers) that are floating sufficiently close will tend to move closer to each other because of their mutual gravitational attraction. I don't know if 50 feet counts as "sufficiently close" to overcome inertial factors though.

I already answered his freaking irrelevant question!!! (Which I suspect has something else to do with some sort of pressure producing gravity though I'm damned if I can see where he's going, the gravity is a function of the mass of the ships.)

And I repeated a few questions I'd been asking him, for a while. Like, do you still think you have to have a BIG hole in the top of a polythene i/v infusion bag to let gravity in before the fluid can tun out through an open tube in the bottom? Do you still maintain there's no gravity inside a TV tube?

And what did I get?




Malcolm, have I ever said a single word about poor Mrs. Olson and her desperate telephone calls? You know, I don't believe I have.

I do know that several others have already told you the answer to that, and you even read the replies, because you repeated the answer in a post of your own. What is this, keep asking every poster the same question till you've got an answer from every single one, even from people who haven't been depating that point at all?

Way to obfuscate, squirm and wriggle, Malcolm.

I think Bruto has the right idea here.




Seconded. In spades.

Just as Malcolm suddenly squirmed out of the question when I tried to ask it by shooting off at a tangent and asking about Barbara Olson, I propose we reply to his every post with this question of Bruto's.

If we get an answer, or anything approaching an explanation of Malcolm's position on gravity and vacuums (Malcolm, for heaven's sake look at the guinea and feather demonstrations, and/or the footage from the lunar lander....), then perhaps we can progress to other issues.

Rolfe.

PS. Malcolm, Spitfire successfully found me (the real me) on the web site of the institution where I work. So he can confirm that I'm telling the truth about my identity and profession. You really have no idea what you can find out about people on the Internet with only a little effort.
What you can find out on the internet and what you do with it are two different things. I personally wouldn't say anything about someone else without their permission, but then, I know the law on privacy. You clearly do not.
 
This probably won't do any good, but I'm willing to give it a shot.

Malcolm, I'm a musician. I can tell you that the word "tone" in music can mean one of four things:

A note*.
An interval (specifically, a major second in one of its many forms).
The quality of sound.
A recitation formula in Gregorian chant.

I think we can safely assume that intuitive tone control doesn't mean that someone is controlling seconds, and has nothing to do with plainchant. So it has something to do with the others.

*Here's the thing: a tone meaning note is not used to refer to a pitch. A and B are both tones, but going from one to the other is not "changing the tone". No musician would say that. It's changing the pitch.

Intuitive pitch control could possibly mean what you think intuitive tone control means. But intuitive tone control does not mean changing the pitch. It is controlling the quality of the sound.
I've had a think about my previous response to you and I'm not happy that I should challenge you to give up the privacy of your forum name before I believe you. There are other ways of establishing a persons abilities, without obliging them to give up their privacy.
In your case, tell me how one would copyright a song and I'll accept that you are what you say you are. I think this is an improvement on my previous post.
 
This should get us started:


One barefaced lie you told was that imaginary "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB participated in the jihadist attacks of 9/11/01, substituting for the real planes that were hijacked by terrorists.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 175 was not identified.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 77 was not identified.

Another was that karaoke machines permit "voice-morphing."

Shall we go on?





Uh, Malcolm, the plane that hit the South Tower was identified. It was also tracked very closely from Boston until it crashed.
Identify 175 from the serial numbers on the engine that landed in Murray Street and I'll go away.
 
Open your fripping eyes and read, man. Gravy already told you.

Do you just have Gravy on ignore, or what?
Actually, all that Gravy has said is "at least two".
That isn't really a proper answer is it?
It is however, better than anything you have put up.
How hard can it be to answer the question? How many calls do you say she made and from what type of phone?
 
I quote you,
"I'm a university level voice teacher with a Master's in vocal performance. I spend my days around musicians and with music".
What is it with you lot? I have a masters in this, I'm an expert in that, therefore I'm right and you're wrong. Prove it, identify yourself as others have done and your quali's can then be taken into account.
No positive I.d. = you're aspersions fall on stony ground.

Somerled, As you wish to preserve your own anonimity, stop challenging other people on their's. Any further discussion of anyone's identity, not just your own, will not be approved.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero

"I felt a distrubance in the Forum, as if millions of irony meters suddenly cried out in terror, and were suddenly silenced."
 
Malcolm, I hope you will read this sequence of posts carefully and think very hard about your behavior. You seem to be having a great deal of trouble with reality. I'm genuinely concerned for you.

What I propose, is a proper, genuine look at Barbara Olsen's phone calls on 9/11. You will see a clear demonstration of something badly wrong.

I would be grateful if you would do something that very few posters on here do and that is actually read a link. Kindly read this one, http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html

What built in phones are you talking about?
757's didn't have built in phones. Don't take my word for it, read what AA say. http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html

Let's see who is being "bloody ridiculous". Give us the benefit of your reasoning skills on this piece. Let's see just how jaundiced you are. ps,
Try to read it all before firing off. I will be marking you on it.
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html

I replied:
Debunked to smithereens. Read from post 378 to end of thread. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=85833&page=10

Seeing as you are totally au fait with the 'debunking', you should have no difficulty in telling me how many phone calls Barbara Olsen made and from what type of phone.

I replied:
She made at least two, because Ted Olson (at least get the spelling right) received two collect calls from her. They were made via Airphone. See the 9/11 Commission report, page 455:

57. The records available for the phone calls from American 77 do not allow for a determination of which of four "connected calls to unknown numbers" represent the two between Barbara and Ted Olson, although the FBI and DOJ believe that all four represent communications between Barbara Olson and her husband's office (all family members of the Flight 77 passengers and crew were canvassed to see if they had received any phone calls from the hijacked flight, and only Renee May's parents and Ted Olson indicated that they had received such calls).The four calls were at 9:15:34 for 1 minute, 42 seconds; 9:20:15 for 4 minutes, 34 seconds; 9:25:48 for 2 minutes, 34 seconds; and 9:30:56 for 4 minutes, 20 seconds. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Helen Voss, Sept. 14, 2001;AAL response to the Commission's supplemental document request, Jan. 20, 2004.

58. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001.
There was also a failed call to the DOJ, where Ted Olson worked, at 9:18. Perhaps that was Olson trying to use her cell phone. That information is in the Moussaoui trial documents.
Now, let's look at what the frauds David Ray Griffin and Rob Balsamo say about making a collect call using one of the on-board phones. From your link:
The claim that she must have called collect because she did not have her credit card, however, does not make any sense, because a credit card is needed in order to activate a passenger-seat phone. 8

And the footnote to that claim:
8 The American Airlines website entitled “Onboard Technology” says: “Slide your credit card through the side of the phone and then dial 00 + country code + area or city code + number followed by the # key”
http://www.aa.com/content/travelInfo...chnology.jhtml

Oh, really? You'd better check that link. On the same page are instructions for calling toll free for dialing assistance:

"For customer service regarding dialing assistance, country codes and directory assistance from the aircraft dial toll free 12#. This will connect you to AIRCOM Customer Service Center. You will not be charged for this call."

What hideous liars. But wait: there's more! When you went to that page about AA phones, what did you see? That's right: the system Griffin and Balsamo base their claims on wasn't even the system in use on 9/11, which was the GTE Airfone.

Okay, so was operator assistance available with the GTE service? Of course it was. Todd Beamer on flight 93 spoke to the GTE operator, Lisa Jefferson, for 19 minutes.

"He told me that he had dialed zero to report his plane was being hijacked," she said. http://www.s-t.com/daily/09-02/09-10-02/a02wn022.htm

On AA 11, Betty Ong called AA, toll free:

"As the hijacking unfolded, Ong punched the number 8 on a seatback GTE Airfone"
http://www.boston.com/news/packages/...nstruction.htm


Despite being reminded more than once of my post, you chose to continue asking the same question.

1)
That is not what you were asked. Kindly stop squirming. How many calls did she make and on what type of phone?

2)
Thank you, you say she made two calls. Will you now kindly tell me on what type of phone?

3)
I'll try again, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?

After being repeatedly reminded of your behavior, you finally made this acknowledgement:

Three calls in all. Two by airphone, one by cellphone that didn't really connect.
Thank you for that.

But somehow it didn't affect your behavior.

4)
Just as soon as you tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and on what type of phone?

5)
Last chance, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?
If you can't answer a simple question like that, then you can't expect me to waste any more time on you.

6)
You know so much about aircraft, then tell me this. Did AA 757's have seat back phones in sept 2001?

7)
how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?

8)
Is it too much for you to tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?

Finally, you are reduced to lying:

9)
Actually, all that Gravy has said is "at least two".
That isn't really a proper answer is it?
It is however, better than anything you have put up.
How hard can it be to answer the question? How many calls do you say she made and from what type of phone?

I don't believe that you are capable of explaining your behavior, but I wanted to make you aware of it.
 
Last chance, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?
If you can't answer a simple question like that, then you can't expect me to waste any more time on you.


You know so much about aircraft, then tell me this. Did AA 757's have seat back phones in sept 2001?


.... tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?


.... Is it too much for you to tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?
Or do you wish to avoid answering that, because you know very well that by trying to answer that question, you will show 9/11 to be an inside job?


Identify 175 from the serial numbers on the engine that landed in Murray Street and I'll go away.


Actually, all that Gravy has said is "at least two".
That isn't really a proper answer is it?
It is however, better than anything you have put up.
How hard can it be to answer the question? How many calls do you say she made and from what type of phone?


All these questions, Malcolm! With such clear ideas about what happened, I'm surprised you need all this information fed to you.

Anyway, you first, remember? We've been asking for answers on the gravity thing long before you even brought up the subject of Mrs. Olson. You can hardly expect do demand answers from others when you persistently evade simple questions asked of you. So here we go again.
  • Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What are viable sources of gravity?
"How hard can it be to answer the questions?" I mean, "if you can't answer simple questions like these, then you can't expect us to waste any more time on you."

Rolfe.
 
What did Raytheon and Boeing do in August 2001?


Why are you unwilling to answer my very simple questions? A yes or a no would suffice for both. Here they are again:

-Do you agree that autopilot exists?
-If yes, do you agree that autopilot engagement does not constitute remote control?

Answer the questions and we'll go from there....but if you were so inclined, you could find the answer to your own question with a simple forum search....
 
What you can find out on the internet and what you do with it are two different things. I personally wouldn't say anything about someone else without their permission, but then, I know the law on privacy. You clearly do not.


Malcolm, I don't think you have the foggiest idea of the law on anything at all. You could try looking up the meaning of "information in the public domain". Which nobody would have even bothered looking for if it hadn't been for your boasting.

Chillzero has barred any further discussion on identities and I think she's right. Though I do think it's hysterical that after scuttling away sideways denying your own name, you start demanding that others should reveal their true identities before you'll believe anything they say. A bit of advice. The way to be believed is to tell the truth, be honest about what you know and don't know, and to acknowledge the expertise of others when they share that expertise. You should try it sometime.

However, what I really meant to say was, if you think any post of mine has broken any law, feel free to report it.

Rolfe.
 
False again malcolm

not peppered in serial numbers
One serial number is enough. Why won't the govt tip this engine up?
Why won't they tip up the Pentagon cctv films. etc etc etc.
Right now, how many phone calls do they (the government) say Barbara Olson made and from what type of phone?
You all are in a corner now and this time I'm not letting you out.
 
Prevarication. A fancy word for lying, to those who have studied the classics. Or read Billy Bunter, whatever. You wouldn't know the truth if it came up and bit you on the ankle, you're so unused to telling it.

Asking about Barbara Olson again, I see - the question that has been answered for you about six times already.

No, like I said, you first.
  • Is it necessary to have a BIG hole in the top of a polythene infusion bag to let gravity in before the contents can run out of a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What are viable sources of gravity?
We've been asking these questions well before you brought up the subject of Mrs. Olsen.

You go first.

Rolfe.

I've answered those questions until I'm blue in the face. For the last time, any errors I may have made would have been caused because I was hurrying to go out to dinner.
Oops, have I knicked that line off you?
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Malcolm, I hope you will read this sequence of posts carefully and think very hard about your behavior. You seem to be having a great deal of trouble with reality. I'm genuinely concerned for you.









I replied:




I replied:



Despite being reminded more than once of my post, you chose to continue asking the same question.

1)

2)

3)

After being repeatedly reminded of your behavior, you finally made this acknowledgement:



But somehow it didn't affect your behavior.

4)

5)

6)

7)

8)

Finally, you are reduced to lying:

9)

I don't believe that you are capable of explaining your behavior, but I wanted to make you aware of it.

All that and you still have not answered the question.
I won't say ignore, because it's hardly possible to ignore thousands of words in multitudinous posts. What I will say is nil respondo.
You will get no response from me, until you answer those two questions.
 
First things first.
You haven't told me how many phone calls she made and from what type of phone yet.
How hard can that be. Kindly stop prevaricating and answer the question.

Your evasions have been duly noted, and the silyl question above, answered.

So when will you fess up and admit that there where phones installed on the planes, and that the cell phone calsl where more than possible. Hey, yuo do not need to take my word for it, go check out those specifications I pointed out for you. Be a researcher... Or, is 3GPP also "in on it"?
 
Why are you unwilling to answer my very simple questions? A yes or a no would suffice for both. Here they are again:

-Do you agree that autopilot exists?
-If yes, do you agree that autopilot engagement does not constitute remote control?

Answer the questions and we'll go from there....but if you were so inclined, you could find the answer to your own question with a simple forum search....
It depends how picky you want to be. We both should know that auto pilot should not be a part of this discourse, so why do you bring it in if not to cloud the issue.
Auto pilot can be viewed as a form of remote control, in so far as the pilot is detached from permanent hands on control. As I say , it has no place with what went on in Aug 2001.
All that I am seeking here is an explanation of what happened in Aug 2001 and I'm prepared to use your terminology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom