Kindlt ignore my previous post. I scroll to the bottom of the page and then work my way up, my apologies. Now you were certain that no one qould use tone instead of note or similar. How can you be sure that everybody around the world accepts your wording?
Ah, Malcolm approaches everything back-to-front. Might explain quite a lot.
So, Fachverwirrt has given an apparently acceptable answer as regards music copyright. And that proves he's a voice teacher at university level exactly how? And if he hadn't given you that answer, how would it have proved he wasn't?
So now, he has to prove that the entire world uses the terminology in question in the normal way, and that your fantasies about what "intuitive tone controls" might mean are unique to you. So how does he do that? Go round everyone in the world asking them to come and post on this thread explaining it to you?
I wouldn't bother, Fachverwirrt. When Malcolm announced that every doctor and nurse in the world would know a certain photograph was a set-up because of the way the i/v infusion was being given, doctors and emergency medicine technicians and paramedics and even a vet and lots of people who had just been around hospitals and
seen that the picture represented normal practice were summarily dismissed. He called the doctor "crazy" when she tried to explain it to him. (He finally accepted it only when a qualified military emergency responder posted chunks of the actual training manual, but it was like battering sense into a stone.)
He can't seem to understand that "intuituve", when applied to controls and knobs and things, means "will do what you think it will do even if you haven't read the manual from cover to cover", and "tone controls" are - well, tone controls! Just like the "tone controls" on any domestic amplifier with a bass and a treble knob, except in this case it's a graphic equaliser rather than just the two knobs.
When he first read the words, looking for a magic machine that would alter the pitch of a note, he jumped to the conclusion that's what these words meant, because that's what he wanted them to mean. And no matter how many people come and explain that no, they don't mean that, it's perfectly clear from the context and the rest of the brochure that there's nothing there that even
claims to change the pitch, hell, even if the inventor and the manufacturer of the instrument came here and said that, he's just say, how do you know there's not someone somewhere in Lisbon who thinks the words mean pitch variation, so I'm right and the machine can do what I say.
Malcolm, it doesn't matter a damn what anybody else thinks the words mean. What matters is what the
people who are selling the machine meant when they used these words. This is perfectly clear from the context of the brochure, if you actually bothered to read it. They mean that it has a graphic equaliser which is easy for a non-techie person to use without reading reams of instructions.
The relevant fact is that even if that machine could change the pitch of a note (which is perfectly possible in 2007, it's just that that
particular machine doesn't have that capability), this has absolutely bugger-all to do with whether or not there existed in 2001 technology capable of faking someone's speaking voice, in real time, so convincingly that his mother believed she was having a live telephone conversation with her son.
That's what Malcolm is really trying to prove, and that's what we know doesn't exist. Finding other things that do different magic tricks isn't going to change that.
Now, Malcolm, how about it.
- Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
- Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
- What is a viable source of gravity?
Just three little answers. What's so hard about that?
Rolfe.