[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
All that and you still have not answered the question.
I won't say ignore, because it's hardly possible to ignore thousands of words in multitudinous posts. What I will say is nil respondo.
You will get no response from me, until you answer those two questions.


Malcolm, this is really bizarre, even for you.
 
You think wrong.

That's very ironic.

1. = pre programmed.

Pre-programmed to handle a real-time song ?

2. = wrong again.

No, no. An Inferiority complex is exactly what it says.

Because I have issues to deal with, I have a message to get across

You've gotten it across very well, Malcolm. Please understand that I'm being completely serious, here:

You don't know anything.

Period.

Far more than 100 people saw a plane hit the south tower. Now show me one piece of evidence that it was 175.

Of course, since no amount of evidence will ever convince you.

Also, I've answered your sig, already, and you still use it:

If you all are such avid skeptics, how come you're not skeptical about 9/11?

We are, and we determined how it happened through skepticism, not anti-establishment paranoia.
 
Not one lie in there and most were spot on. Thanks for keeping the list.

Malcolm, THEY WERE ALL WRONG.

What about the word "fantastical" ? Did you even remember that ? You said the word didn't exist but it sure as hell does.

How can you continue to be so consistently wrong ?

Are you seriously trying to tell me, that after all the evidence I've put up on this thread, you believe the OCT?

What evidence ? All you've put forth is your ignorance.
 
I've answered those questions until I'm blue in the face. For the last time, any errors I may have made would have been caused because I was hurrying to go out to dinner.
Oops, have I knicked that line off you?
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility


Malcolm, you haven't got even close to a straight answer to any one of those questions. With the possible exception of "air pressure" in answer to no. 3, which is what's currently getting you a landslide in the July Stundies, it's so wrong. This is your big chance to amend that and say something sensible.

The answers aren't long. They're simple. They're straightforward. So, why not have a go.
  • Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What is a viable source of gravity?
By the way, your question about the ships contained a BIG hint about an acceptable answer to no. 3.

Don't tell Malcolm, but the answers are this easy.
  • No
  • Yes
  • Any sufficiently large mass
One day we may find out why he doesn't just say so.
Oh, Malcolm, if you want to bring up my conversation with Fachverwirrt, you might notice that I wasn't actually wrong when I stated that A was 440Hz. That is indeed the standard definition. Fachverwirrt simply added lots and lots of extra detail and information to that bald statement, detail I had neither the time nor the inclination to post myself.

However, if I had been wrong (which was always possible, as I was posting from memory and didn't take time to look it up to check), I would simply have acknowledged my error. No biggie. Launching into a month-long defence about how A was somehow "really" 400Hz because that's what I'd accidentally typed would be a bit of a waste of time, don't you think?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
What about the word "fantastical" ? Did you even remember that ? You said the word didn't exist but it sure as hell does.


Every time that one comes up I'm reminded of Susannah Clarke's Hugo Award acceptance speech at the 2006 Worldcon. She won for Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell. The book was marketed mainstream and got mainstream reviews, however Susannah did refer to it in the blurb as "a fantasy novel". A mainstream colleague of hers praised the book, but said to her, why do you call it a "fantasy novel"? At least say it's a "novel of the fantastical"!

Susannah remarked that the book had wizards and fairies and talking statues and all the rest, so if that wasn't a fantasy novel she didn't know what was. And suggested he get over himself.

Rolfe.
 
I personally wouldn't say anything about someone else without their permission, but then, I know the law on privacy. You clearly do not.


Well, I know the law on privacy and it has nothing whatsoever to do with saying "anything about someone else without their permission." No laws have been broken here regarding privacy. If you believe they have, go to the police. You won't, though, because you know you're wrong.


In your case, tell me how one would copyright a song and I'll accept that you are what you say you are.


I know how one would assert one's copy rights to a song but you won't believe me. The answer is that you have a copyright in anything you fix in a perceptible form. If you write your song down on a cocktail napkin, you have a copyright to the song even if you then lose the cocktail napkin. Sound recordings are also a perceptible form.

This type of copyright is known as common law copyright.

What you are probably trying to ask is how one registers one's copyright with the government. Registration of a copyright allows greater protections from infringement and higher damages if infringed. But it's not necessary.

You will, of course, either claim that this is not true or you will ignore this post altogether. In the first case, you would be wrong. In the second, you would be foolish.
 
Loss Leader, remember where the question about copyrighting "a song" came from.

<.... snip lots of information about why the word "tone" deosn't imply "pitch" in the StudioMaster blurb ....>

I'm a university level voice teacher with a Master's in vocal performance. I spend my days around musicians and with music. You are wrong.

Malcolm originally announced that he wouldn't believe that fachverwirrt was telling the truth about his/her (sorry, I've heard both baritones and sopranos singing O Helga Natt, so I still can't tell) qualifications and expertise unless he/she revealed his/her identity.
Edited by chillzero: 

Edited for civility, regarding previous advice.


However, he reconsidered his position, and we got....

I've had a think about my previous response to you and I'm not happy that I should challenge you to give up the privacy of your forum name before I believe you. There are other ways of establishing a persons abilities, without obliging them to give up their privacy.
In your case, tell me how one would copyright a song and I'll accept that you are what you say you are. I think this is an improvement on my previous post.


Fachverwirrt is a high-level singing teacher. Not a composer. Why on earth would anyone expect a singing teacher would inevitably be familiar with the law on music copyright?

What's "a song"? Words? Music? The entire concept, or just the melody? What if you just wrote a new arrangement of Down by the Sally Gardens? What if you wrote the music and someone else wrote the words, but both were original? What if you wrote a completely new melody for someone else's words to an existing song?

And what if you were a professional singing teacher and voice coach, why the hell would you care?

Malcolm once more illustrates his lack of grasp of any subject he encounters, by posing a test not relevant to what he is aiming to test.

Even if he did actually know the right answer, which judging by his track record, is a bit of a long shot.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've had a think about my previous response to you and I'm not happy that I should challenge you to give up the privacy of your forum name before I believe you. There are other ways of establishing a persons abilities, without obliging them to give up their privacy.
In your case, tell me how one would copyright a song and I'll accept that you are what you say you are. I think this is an improvement on my previous post.
I'm not a composer, I'm a singer. I also feel no strong compulsion to actually prove myself to you. I know who and what I am, and am quite satisfied with my knowledge on the subject. But this is a pretty easy question to answer, so I'll go ahead. LossLeader already covered some relevant points: copyright exists the moment you create a work. However, for legal protection (if you want to sue), you need to register it with the copyright office. Otherwise you would have no direct proof that you created the work before someone else stole it. You can retroactively copyright a work if you have some proof that you wrote it at an earlier date; a common way to do this is to mail a copy of the work to yourself and then keep the sealed envelope so that the postmark stands as proof of date.

Registering a work is simple. You fill out an application and mail it, a copy of the work, and a fee to the copyright office.
 
Loss Leader, remember where the question about copyrighting "a song" came from.



Malcolm originally announced that he wouldn't believe that fachverwirrt was telling the truth about his/her (sorry, I've heard both baritones and sopranos singing O Helga Natt, so I still can't tell) qualifications and expertise unless he/she revealed his/her identity.
He. Baritone.



Fachverwirrt is a high-level singing teacher. Not a composer. Why on earth would anyone expect a singing teacher would inevitably be familiar with the law on music copyright?
Fortunately, I've done a little bit of composing and taken enough education classes to know a bit about it.

What's "a song"? Words? Music? The entire concept, or just the melody? What if you just wrote a new arrangement of Down by the Sally Gardens? What if you wrote the music and someone else wrote the words, but both were original? What if you wrote a completely new melody for someone else's words to an existing song?
A new arrangement of Down by the Sally Gardens would be copyrighted just like anything else. The words and melody are both in the public domain, so there's no existing claim on them. If you're arranging a melody that's still under copyright, things get more complicated. You need to secure permission from the copyright holder; if you get it and complete an arrangement, the copyright holder of the melody now owns copyright on your arrangement (making such a thing generally more hassle than its worth).

Assuming that you had permission to use that person's words, you would simply both apply for copyright of your respective parts. They would hold copyright on the words, you on the music. You would divide any royalties in whatever way you agreed upon.

The last case depends again upon whether the words are in the public domain or not. If not, you need to secure permission, which may get complicated if there are joint royalty claims on the piece. But if you can secure permission (which usually involves paying either a one time fee or a percentage of royalties) then any piece you compose belongs to you free and clear.

A rather long answer that Malcolm probably won't read, but I'm sometimes a foolishly optimistic person.
 
There was once a thread started by a Christophera about concrete cores. The OPer couldn't accept fact, logic or evidence. That thread grew and grew. Eventually I stopped reading it as I realised nothing that wa siad or done in that thread would lead to any resolution with even a toehold in reality. This thread is going the same way. You all know that even if we could transport Malcolm back in time and place him on the flight deck of the planes about to hit the WTC buildings and they were the flights identified by all the investigations carried out since, he still wouldn't believe it. His POV is not factually based, it is a belief system. We should all do what we did in the Christophera thread. Stop feeding the craziness. Let it die a natural death. I intend to do that from now on.
 
He. Baritone.



Fortunately, I've done a little bit of composing and taken enough education classes to know a bit about it.

A new arrangement of Down by the Sally Gardens would be copyrighted just like anything else. The words and melody are both in the public domain, so there's no existing claim on them. If you're arranging a melody that's still under copyright, things get more complicated. You need to secure permission from the copyright holder; if you get it and complete an arrangement, the copyright holder of the melody now owns copyright on your arrangement (making such a thing generally more hassle than its worth).

Assuming that you had permission to use that person's words, you would simply both apply for copyright of your respective parts. They would hold copyright on the words, you on the music. You would divide any royalties in whatever way you agreed upon.

The last case depends again upon whether the words are in the public domain or not. If not, you need to secure permission, which may get complicated if there are joint royalty claims on the piece. But if you can secure permission (which usually involves paying either a one time fee or a percentage of royalties) then any piece you compose belongs to you free and clear.

A rather long answer that Malcolm probably won't read, but I'm sometimes a foolishly optimistic person.
Not quite what I had in mind really.
Original words and original music. No need for any complications. Now the actual mechanics of obtaining copyright on such a song, if you don't mind.
 
I'm not a composer, I'm a singer. I also feel no strong compulsion to actually prove myself to you. I know who and what I am, and am quite satisfied with my knowledge on the subject. But this is a pretty easy question to answer, so I'll go ahead. LossLeader already covered some relevant points: copyright exists the moment you create a work. However, for legal protection (if you want to sue), you need to register it with the copyright office. Otherwise you would have no direct proof that you created the work before someone else stole it. You can retroactively copyright a work if you have some proof that you wrote it at an earlier date; a common way to do this is to mail a copy of the work to yourself and then keep the sealed envelope so that the postmark stands as proof of date.

Registering a work is simple. You fill out an application and mail it, a copy of the work, and a fee to the copyright office.
Kindlt ignore my previous post. I scroll to the bottom of the page and then work my way up, my apologies. Now you were certain that no one qould use tone instead of note or similar. How can you be sure that everybody around the world accepts your wording?
 
Well, I know the law on privacy and it has nothing whatsoever to do with saying "anything about someone else without their permission." No laws have been broken here regarding privacy. If you believe they have, go to the police. You won't, though, because you know you're wrong.





I know how one would assert one's copy rights to a song but you won't believe me. The answer is that you have a copyright in anything you fix in a perceptible form. If you write your song down on a cocktail napkin, you have a copyright to the song even if you then lose the cocktail napkin. Sound recordings are also a perceptible form.

This type of copyright is known as common law copyright.

What you are probably trying to ask is how one registers one's copyright with the government. Registration of a copyright allows greater protections from infringement and higher damages if infringed. But it's not necessary.

You will, of course, either claim that this is not true or you will ignore this post altogether. In the first case, you would be wrong. In the second, you would be foolish.
What have the police got to do with infringements of civil law.
Stick with the copyright bit, you are on firmer ground.
 
fachverwirrt said:
However, for legal protection (if you want to sue), you need to register it with the copyright office.


This is absolutely not true. Registering your work provides enhanced protections and greater damages but is in no way necessary if you want to sue.


Otherwise you would have no direct proof that you created the work before someone else stole it.


This is a matter of proof, not of rights. What you can prove has nothing to do with what rights the law affords you.


You can retroactively copyright a work if you have some proof that you wrote it at an earlier date


Sorry. You have a copyright the moment you fix an original work in a perceptible form. There's no such thing as a retroactive copyright.


a common way to do this is to mail a copy of the work to yourself and then keep the sealed envelope so that the postmark stands as proof of date.


It may be common but it is far and away the stupidest, most half-assed, poorly reasoned and unsafe method of proving anything to anybody. Why this persists in the public consciousness as a valid way to do anything is absolutely beyond me. Never, ever do this. Just pay the $30.00 (in America) and send the thing in to the Copyright Office. Doing it right is so cheap and easy, I cannot fathom why people still insist on doing it wrong.


Registering a work is simple. You fill out an application and mail it, a copy of the work, and a fee to the copyright office.


You're right about that. It's simple and it's inexpensive. Any serious artist should be doing this automatically.



A new arrangement of Down by the Sally Gardens would be copyrighted just like anything else. The words and melody are both in the public domain, so there's no existing claim on them.


Understand that the only thing you have a copyright on is the original aspect you've added to the work. You can't just register a copyright for a work in the public domain and suddenly own it. So, the concept of Tinkerbell belongs to everyone. The concept of a Tinkerbell that looks like Marilyn Monroe belongs to Disney.


If you're arranging a melody that's still under copyright, things get more complicated. You need to secure permission from the copyright holder; if you get it and complete an arrangement, the copyright holder of the melody now owns copyright on your arrangement (making such a thing generally more hassle than its worth).


Not really. You're in partnership with the original copyright holder. She owns the song, you own that particular arrangement. Neither of you can do a thing with the new work without the consent of the other. Still, such collaborations are common and profitable. You probably should secure the permission of the copyright holder first so you don't waste your time. Do you have a Superman comic you wrote. Throw it out. You can't do a darn thing with it.


Assuming that you had permission to use that person's words, you would simply both apply for copyright of your respective parts. They would hold copyright on the words, you on the music. You would divide any royalties in whatever way you agreed upon.


Well, you can do anything the two of you agree on. If the guy sells you his words, he doesn't have to register his copyright at all. In fact, neither of you ever have to register your copyrights.


The last case depends again upon whether the words are in the public domain or not. If not, you need to secure permission, which may get complicated if there are joint royalty claims on the piece. But if you can secure permission (which usually involves paying either a one time fee or a percentage of royalties) then any piece you compose belongs to you free and clear.


Well, it belongs to you to the extent of whatever contract you have. A person may grant a limited license to use the words just for a song (but not as the basis of a movie) or just for ten years but not forever. It depends on the deal you make.
 
Malcolm, THEY WERE ALL WRONG.

What about the word "fantastical" ? Did you even remember that ? You said the word didn't exist but it sure as hell does.

How can you continue to be so consistently wrong ?



What evidence ? All you've put forth is your ignorance.
I refer you to my previous post, with an extra couple of squirms just for you.
 
Your evasions have been duly noted, and the silyl question above, answered.

So when will you fess up and admit that there where phones installed on the planes, and that the cell phone calsl where more than possible. Hey, yuo do not need to take my word for it, go check out those specifications I pointed out for you. Be a researcher... Or, is 3GPP also "in on it"?

I refer you to my previous two posts.
 
There was once a thread started by a Christophera about concrete cores. The OPer couldn't accept fact, logic or evidence. That thread grew and grew. Eventually I stopped reading it as I realised nothing that wa siad or done in that thread would lead to any resolution with even a toehold in reality. This thread is going the same way. You all know that even if we could transport Malcolm back in time and place him on the flight deck of the planes about to hit the WTC buildings and they were the flights identified by all the investigations carried out since, he still wouldn't believe it. His POV is not factually based, it is a belief system. We should all do what we did in the Christophera thread. Stop feeding the craziness. Let it die a natural death. I intend to do that from now on.
Afore ye go, answer the two Olson questions.
Rather than do that, you turn up and encourage others to flee.
There is no hiding place on this one pal, no hiding place.
 
Does Malcolm remind anyone else of Baghdad Bob? "There are no American Tanks in Baghdad!"
Regarding Barbara Olson's phone calls, you said at least two plus an incomplete to the DoJ.
Is two your definitive answer (plus the DoJ one)?
 
Kindlt ignore my previous post. I scroll to the bottom of the page and then work my way up, my apologies. Now you were certain that no one qould use tone instead of note or similar. How can you be sure that everybody around the world accepts your wording?


Ah, Malcolm approaches everything back-to-front. Might explain quite a lot.

So, Fachverwirrt has given an apparently acceptable answer as regards music copyright. And that proves he's a voice teacher at university level exactly how? And if he hadn't given you that answer, how would it have proved he wasn't?

So now, he has to prove that the entire world uses the terminology in question in the normal way, and that your fantasies about what "intuitive tone controls" might mean are unique to you. So how does he do that? Go round everyone in the world asking them to come and post on this thread explaining it to you?

I wouldn't bother, Fachverwirrt. When Malcolm announced that every doctor and nurse in the world would know a certain photograph was a set-up because of the way the i/v infusion was being given, doctors and emergency medicine technicians and paramedics and even a vet and lots of people who had just been around hospitals and seen that the picture represented normal practice were summarily dismissed. He called the doctor "crazy" when she tried to explain it to him. (He finally accepted it only when a qualified military emergency responder posted chunks of the actual training manual, but it was like battering sense into a stone.)

He can't seem to understand that "intuituve", when applied to controls and knobs and things, means "will do what you think it will do even if you haven't read the manual from cover to cover", and "tone controls" are - well, tone controls! Just like the "tone controls" on any domestic amplifier with a bass and a treble knob, except in this case it's a graphic equaliser rather than just the two knobs.

When he first read the words, looking for a magic machine that would alter the pitch of a note, he jumped to the conclusion that's what these words meant, because that's what he wanted them to mean. And no matter how many people come and explain that no, they don't mean that, it's perfectly clear from the context and the rest of the brochure that there's nothing there that even claims to change the pitch, hell, even if the inventor and the manufacturer of the instrument came here and said that, he's just say, how do you know there's not someone somewhere in Lisbon who thinks the words mean pitch variation, so I'm right and the machine can do what I say.

Malcolm, it doesn't matter a damn what anybody else thinks the words mean. What matters is what the people who are selling the machine meant when they used these words. This is perfectly clear from the context of the brochure, if you actually bothered to read it. They mean that it has a graphic equaliser which is easy for a non-techie person to use without reading reams of instructions.

The relevant fact is that even if that machine could change the pitch of a note (which is perfectly possible in 2007, it's just that that particular machine doesn't have that capability), this has absolutely bugger-all to do with whether or not there existed in 2001 technology capable of faking someone's speaking voice, in real time, so convincingly that his mother believed she was having a live telephone conversation with her son.

That's what Malcolm is really trying to prove, and that's what we know doesn't exist. Finding other things that do different magic tricks isn't going to change that.

Now, Malcolm, how about it.
  • Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What is a viable source of gravity?
Just three little answers. What's so hard about that?

Rolfe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom