[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kindlt ignore my previous post. I scroll to the bottom of the page and then work my way up, my apologies. Now you were certain that no one qould use tone instead of note or similar. How can you be sure that everybody around the world accepts your wording?
No, I said that no one (at least, no musician) would use say "changing tone" or "controlling tone" instead of "controlling" or "changing pitch". In colloquial terms, if I want to know what a certain pitch is, I'll probably ask "what note is that". But in technical discussions (like those that you will see in product specs) the terms are not really interchangeable. What you have to understand is that "notes" (or "tones") don't have definite pitch. Have a clarinetist play an "A" for you sometime, then see what that note corresponds to on a piano. "Pitch" is a very specific, quantifiable concept. "Tone" is not.

Musical nomenclature is, by necessity, relatively consistent. Music is an international business, and of a nature that people must be able to communicate quickly and effectively. What differences there are are well know, and anyone with the proper education and experience can easily recognize those differences. Almost always, those differences consist of using different words to refer to the same thing, not using the same word to refer to different things. For example, British musicians generally use "crotchet", "quaver" and "semi-quaver" to refer to what Americans call "quarter notes", "eighth notes" and "sixteenth notes". These are well known, and British and American musicians can communicate with one another using their own terminology with ease. There is one glaring exception to this: the German "B" is what the rest of the Western world calls a "B-flat" (the Germans use "H" to refer to "B"), but again, this is well known.

The Studiomaster is produced by a British company. I know and work with many British musicians. They would not use "tone" to mean "pitch". The two words are related but they are not the same thing. A tone has pitch, but it is only one aspect of the concept. It refers to other things such as duration and quality. The specific quality which we hear as how high or low a tone is (the fundamental frequency and its overtones) is referred to as "pitch". "Tone control" simply can't be used as you're thinking of it. It makes no sense. It makes a great deal of sense to use it to refer to the quality of a sound.

All of which continues to be perfectly irrelevant as far as voice-morphing goes. Changing the pitch of someone's voice doesn't make them sound like someone else, it just makes them sound like they're on a different pitch. In other words, this entire discussion is largely useless.
 

Attachments

  • ramp pole photo.JPG
    ramp pole photo.JPG
    107.3 KB · Views: 6
What about this probability stuff? You wouldn't want me to sack you as my chief researcher now, would you?


Sorry; it's on my computer at work, and I'm off today and tomorrow (unless I happen to have some free time tomorrow to go in and work on a project). I didn't think to bring a copy home with me when I left yesterday. So I'll probably finish it Sunday during my lunch break.
 
Regarding Barbara Olson's phone calls, you said at least two plus an incomplete to the DoJ.
Is two your definitive answer (plus the DoJ one)?

Does anyone else think of a 2 year old asking the same question over and over again. How many times does he need to have it answered? Is there where he tells us that groundbreaking piece of information he has been promising for dozens of pages?
 
This is absolutely not true. Registering your work provides enhanced protections and greater damages but is in no way necessary if you want to sue.
Direct from the US Copyright Office:
In general, registration is voluntary. Copyright exists from the moment the work is created. You will have to register, however, if you wish to bring a lawsuit for infringement of a U.S. work.

This is a matter of proof, not of rights. What you can prove has nothing to do with what rights the law affords you.
Of course it is. However, it's difficult to claim protection if you can't prove that you're entitled to it. That's my point.

Sorry. You have a copyright the moment you fix an original work in a perceptible form. There's no such thing as a retroactive copyright.
Poor choice of words. I meant retroactively register.

It may be common but it is far and away the stupidest, most half-assed, poorly reasoned and unsafe method of proving anything to anybody. Why this persists in the public consciousness as a valid way to do anything is absolutely beyond me. Never, ever do this. Just pay the $30.00 (in America) and send the thing in to the Copyright Office. Doing it right is so cheap and easy, I cannot fathom why people still insist on doing it wrong.
$45. I never said this was a good idea, although I know many people who do it.


Understand that the only thing you have a copyright on is the original aspect you've added to the work. You can't just register a copyright for a work in the public domain and suddenly own it. So, the concept of Tinkerbell belongs to everyone. The concept of a Tinkerbell that looks like Marilyn Monroe belongs to Disney.
Yes, you own copyright on the arrangement, which is exactly what I said. Obviously copyright to the original aspect doesn't devolve to you. If it did, Rolfe's example of Down by the Sally Garden would belong to Benjamin Britten (and to Herbert Hughes before him, and any number of other people).

Not really. You're in partnership with the original copyright holder. She owns the song, you own that particular arrangement. Neither of you can do a thing with the new work without the consent of the other. Still, such collaborations are common and profitable. You probably should secure the permission of the copyright holder first so you don't waste your time. Do you have a Superman comic you wrote. Throw it out. You can't do a darn thing with it.
I haven't been able to dig up a cite for this, but I've been told this by two professors who have gone through the process. At any rate, even if the original copyright holder doesn't have legal control of your arrangement, they would have de facto control, as you would need to abide by any terms and conditions that the original copyright holder sets forth. I shouldn't have said "generally" more hassle than it's worth. It would be better to say that it can be more hassle than its worth.

Well, you can do anything the two of you agree on. If the guy sells you his words, he doesn't have to register his copyright at all. In fact, neither of you ever have to register your copyrights.
True.


Well, it belongs to you to the extent of whatever contract you have. A person may grant a limited license to use the words just for a song (but not as the basis of a movie) or just for ten years but not forever. It depends on the deal you make.
Right. I was a little sloppy on that one. Sometimes a poet (or foundation) will only allow one person to set text, as I believe was the case with Robert Frost (whose foundation allowed only Randall Thompson to set his works until recently), although I've seen other versions of Stopping by woods on a snowy evening that predated the release of part of his library for composition, so it's possible that I'm misinformed. The point is, you have to secure permission (unless blanket permission has already been given) then abide by whatever terms are set.
 
It depends how picky you want to be. We both should know that auto pilot should not be a part of this discourse, so why do you bring it in if not to cloud the issue.
Auto pilot can be viewed as a form of remote control, in so far as the pilot is detached from permanent hands on control. As I say , it has no place with what went on in Aug 2001.
All that I am seeking here is an explanation of what happened in Aug 2001 and I'm prepared to use your terminology.

It seems to me that autopilot means (in layman's term) the plane is flying itself, that is, maintaining course, altitude, attitude as preset. The pilot can't remotely control it. In fact, I think he has to turn it off before he can control the plane at all. He certainly doesn't sit there with a little remote control flying it. He'd use the stick and pedal thingies.
 
There was once a thread started by a Christophera about concrete cores. The OPer couldn't accept fact, logic or evidence. That thread grew and grew. Eventually I stopped reading it as I realised nothing that wa siad or done in that thread would lead to any resolution with even a toehold in reality. This thread is going the same way. You all know that even if we could transport Malcolm back in time and place him on the flight deck of the planes about to hit the WTC buildings and they were the flights identified by all the investigations carried out since, he still wouldn't believe it. His POV is not factually based, it is a belief system. We should all do what we did in the Christophera thread. Stop feeding the craziness. Let it die a natural death. I intend to do that from now on.

It's because of Christophera that I've cringed every time the word "concrete" has come up in this thread :D . Even when it has nothing to do with cement, gravel and water.
 
fachverwirrt said:
If you're arranging a melody that's still under copyright, things get more complicated. You need to secure permission from the copyright holder; if you get it and complete an arrangement, the copyright holder of the melody now owns copyright on your arrangement (making such a thing generally more hassle than its worth).
Not really. You're in partnership with the original copyright holder. She owns the song, you own that particular arrangement. Neither of you can do a thing with the new work without the consent of the other. Still, such collaborations are common and profitable. You probably should secure the permission of the copyright holder first so you don't waste your time. Do you have a Superman comic you wrote. Throw it out. You can't do a darn thing with it.
Alright, I tracked down a cite for this: from Harmony Central:

You may not create an arrangement of a copyrighted work without written permission from the copyright holder (usually the music publisher in this case). This permission must be obtained before starting work. If permission is granted to do an arrangement, it will allow the arrangement and a limited number of copies to be made in exchange for a fee. It is important to remember that even if permission is granted, YOU DO NOT OWN YOUR ARRANGEMENT. It remains the property of the copyright holder. If a greater number of copies were made of the arrangement than permission was given for, they would be regarded the same as any other illegal copies.

I'd dearly love to find specific language for this on the US Copyright page, but have been unable to do so thus far.
 
Wow. I'm going to leave the legal arguings to the legal eagles, and just comment that I can't see how fachverwirrt's knowledge on that can possibly prove or disprove what he says about being a professional voice teacher. The manner of his conversation and his general familiarity with the subject incline me to believe him, and I see no reason not to. You see, Malcolm, it's like I said. If you're honest about what you do and what you know and don't know, this shows in your posts. You should try it some time.

I've been trying to think of a question that really might test whether someone is or is not a voice professional. My mother was a professional singer and I've had singing lessons from a professional teacher, and I can't think of anything. Facts are easy to look up. The first thing I thought of came up on the third link of my first Google search! I could ask Mum tomorrow if there's any "secret knowledge", like a handshake or something....

Malcolm, I've got a bit more to say, don't go away, will you?

Rolfe.
 
Direct from the US Copyright Office:
In general, registration is voluntary. Copyright exists from the moment the work is created. You will have to register, however, if you wish to bring a lawsuit for infringement of a U.S. work.


As near as I can tell, the Copyright Office is probably referring to suits in federal court. By codifying copyright law, the feds more or less killed common law copyright at the federal level. But it's not true for state courts. You should be able to sue in just about every state court to enforce a copyright even if not registered. I think whomever wrote the FAQ figured that erring on the side of just getting everybody to register their copyrights was easier than explaining the difference between state and feredal law.

On every other point, we agree well enough to make argument unnecessary.


Alright, I tracked down a cite for this: from Harmony Central:

You may not create an arrangement of a copyrighted work without written permission from the copyright holder (usually the music publisher in this case). This permission must be obtained before starting work. If permission is granted to do an arrangement, it will allow the arrangement and a limited number of copies to be made in exchange for a fee. It is important to remember that even if permission is granted, YOU DO NOT OWN YOUR ARRANGEMENT. It remains the property of the copyright holder. If a greater number of copies were made of the arrangement than permission was given for, they would be regarded the same as any other illegal copies.

I'd dearly love to find specific language for this on the US Copyright page, but have been unable to do so thus far.


Okay, I have no idea what the author thinks he's talking about. It seems to be regarding a very specific example that he doesn't bother to explain - maybe arranging a piece for your own performance of it. But it doesn't cover something like an arrangement for a book of music to be published for however many copies they can sell (like Big Note Beatles or some such).

It's a mix of law (which is indisputable), good advice (which is just smart) and personal preference (which doesn't matter). The sentence, "permission must be obtained before starting a work" is just good advice. If you have no intention of ever playing your arrangement for anybody, feel free to arrange the heck out of it without permission from anybody. The sentence, "YOU DO NOT OWN YOUR ARRANGEMENT" is flat wrong. I think he means that you do not own the entire work which is (generally) right. Absent a contract to the contrary, you own the unique, creative aspect of your arrangement of the work. No one may perform your arrangement of that work without your permission.

So, um, you won't find the US Copyright Office agreeing with every word of that quote. It's decent advice for performers of covers and is what you would expect from a well-informed non-lawyer.
 
But if no flight 175 hit the south tower, were are the passengers? Did I miss that? And why are you claiming victory after you have lost ever single battle here at JREF?
malc kirkman



NOTHING TO BEAT ON JREF.
There’s absolutely nothing to beat on JREF or any other denier’s website.
It’s way past the time when we should be in amongst these deniers and cleaning their clocks.
You have the truth on your side, you play a Royal flush every hand you put down.
Wherever you start with these people, the response to you will be the same. Paragraph after paragraph of personal attacks and rubbishing of what you say. They’ll drop on you like a pack of dogs. Just weather that storm and then you’ll be able to bring in the calls for a proper investigation.
Why are they opposed to a new and proper investigation? What are they frightened of?
They can only respond with,
“There’s been an investigation and if you don’t like it, hard luck”.
You then come back with something along the lines of,
“That investigation said that this plane went through this hole. Which I have shown to be impossible.”
Just keep going then on why the govt won’t order a new investigation, when so many people want one. Deniers have no answer to that.
Neither do they have an answer to this report that has been sent to the Congress detailing that OKC was also an inside job.
http://independence.net/okc/congressbombreport.htm
I’ve had touching 35,000 views and 3,000 posts and they are now dead in the water. That’s after being moderated from very early doors and now being denied the ability to post photos. The best way to weather the storm they will first throw at you, is with one liners. Don’t allow yourself to be exhausted with long explanations, that is one of their tactics, respond with one liners or little more.
Get in there and take the fight to them.
The truth is that the BushCo/neocon cabal is shrinking and with a bit of help from us the rats will soon start deserting the sinking ship.
Get in amongst them and let them know no peace. This is a prerequisite to breaking them up and winning this battle. Justice will then surely follow, as night follows day.
​
​
 
All of which continues to be perfectly irrelevant as far as voice-morphing goes. Changing the pitch of someone's voice doesn't make them sound like someone else, it just makes them sound like they're on a different pitch. In other words, this entire discussion is largely useless.


Er, yes. Exactly. As we've been mentioning to Malcolm for a while now....

Malcolm, you like to accuse others of obfuscating and squirming away, but what is your purpose in making such a big deal about pitch changing technology? You get so bogged down in details that have absolutely bugger-all to do with the point you apparently started to make, I can't decide whether you just have a pathological fixation on irrelevancies, or are deliberately dragging the discussion away from the point.

Remember what you started by trying to assert? You've probably forgotten, but it was this. That it was possible, in 2001, using publicly-available technology, to fake someone's speaking voice so convincingly that his mother could be convinced she was having a real-time telephone conversation with her son.

That's what you have to demonstrate. Not any irrelevant and silly detail you might have got wrong on the way.

You launched into your argument by referring to musical technology that was capable of altering the pitch of a sung note. However, your choice of examples was pretty unfortunate. Your first attempt was to assert that the original karaoke machines in the 1970s had this capability, which was absolute nonsense, but you wasted an inordinate amount of time trying to prove otherwise.

You wandered past a few kiddies' toys which I suspect even you could see were in the chocolate teapot category, then latched on to this StudioMaster gadget. Which again, unfortunately, didn't actually do what you wanted it to do. Rather than try to find something that did, you again wasted an inordinate amount of time trying to defend your misapprehension that a plug for user-friendly graphic equaliser controls meant that the machine could read the singer's mind!

I've been wondering just how long this was going to go on, but heck, let's try a short-cut.

Psssst, Malcolm. I'll let you into a secret. Electronic instruments capable of changing the pitch of a singer's voice do exist. It's just that the StudioMaster doesn't happen to be one of them. I'm just gobsmacked you haven't been able to track one down.

And yes, the technology is about ten years old, so some sort of instrument of that nature would have been available in 2001. It just wasn't available in a useful form in the 1970s, and it most certainly wasn't incorporated into a karaoke machine of that period.

However, so what? Where does that get you?

First, these things are primarily editing tools. The idea is that you record the voice as it really is, then sit down and fiddle. For one thing, you probably won't be happy with your first try and will want to revise it. And for another, you want a pure sound, and the instruments and background noise will interfere a lot with that.

Could they be used live? Maybe, the electronic response is fast enough. However, problems with ambient noise, and the possibility of the instrument latching on to the wrong sound and trying to "pitch" that, make it unlikely to be terribly satisfactory. Has anything like that yet been incorporated into a karaoke machine? No, though I'm sure someone will give it a try some time. There's never any shortage of takers for a bad idea.

And finally, they're about singing. Not speaking. They're not trying to make one person sound like another, they're about making one person sound a bit better.

Speech recognition is a whole other ball game, and even if you did find the web sites advertising the most sophisticated pitch correction software on the market (no link, find it yourself), you'd have advanced your argument barely a millimetre. You're still several parsecs from actually getting there.

What is it about the sound of someone's voice that allows you to recognise them? It's extraordinarily subtle. The brain isn't algorithmic, it's a pattern-recognition device, and the hearing system is sensitive to the most minute nuances of pattern.

I mentioned my mother was a professional singer. She has spent the last several decades listening to all the best singers of the generations, mainly through Radio 3. She can listen to only a few notes of a song, and tell you who is singing it. And it has nothing to do with pitch. Give her five recordings of the same song, in the same key, and she'll tell you who is singing each one. It's positively uncanny. She can be caught out with recordings of very new artists, but she's particularly rock-solid with people she knew and worked with personally. There's no sort of electronics can turn Richard Lewis into Peter Pears, to the ear of someone who knew them both.

But spoken voices are what we're really talking about, and what's more, spoken voices in a situation where the speaker isn't seen.

I remember idly listening to the car radio one evening, half-hearing a worthy debate among doctors about the ethics of euthanasia. Suddenly my ear was caught and before I even knew why, the image of the face of a close colleague of mine flashed into my mind. Why? Because the producer had decided to get a vet's perspective on the subject, and had brought my colleague into the discussion. Same sort of voice, male, middle-aged, upper-middle-class, all talking about the same thing, but the minute Bob's voice came in, I "saw" his face.

Another example. A weird scene in an episode of Babylon 5, where the director had disguised an actress so that she was visually unrecognisable. She said just four words. ("You are the hand.") Much discussion about who this mystery woman actually was. My godson was adamant. I was unsure. "Stop looking at her face," he said. "Play the tape again, but don't look at the screen." I did as I was told. Immediately I heard the voice, the image of the actress as she usually looked flashed into my mind. Without the distraction of the disguise, voice recognition systems were spot on.

This is what would have to be achieved in order to fake phone calls. Not anything so mundane as pitch shifting, but the whole subtle pattern of the voice which is a combination of so many things, only starting with pitch, local accent, choice of vocabulary and so on. And not a caricature either. Not Rory Bremner doing Tony Blair, give us a break. Change Peter Pears into Richard Lewis so you fool my mother, just see if you can! (And those two voices are about as similar as you're likely to find.)

And do it live, real-time. Because there's no way you can pre-record stock phrases and be sure you'll have one for every eventuality in the conversation (and remember, Malcolm, Rothschilde doesn't approve plans that might go wrong....). And do it with the right choice of words and mannerisims so that the mother is convinced it's her son.

With a system that was publicly available in 2001.

No way. 8den's point about Hollywood film companies still "looping" inaudible dialogue even in 2007 proves that, even if nothing else does.

This idea is as far into fantasy-land as the idea that a plastic surgeon can sculpt the extra's flesh so that she looks like Marilyn Monroe - and not just on film, under the makeup, but up close and personal to her nearest and dearest.

Maybe one day both will be possible. But not today. And not on 11th September 2001.

Get over it, Malcolm.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Sorry; it's on my computer at work, and I'm off today and tomorrow (unless I happen to have some free time tomorrow to go in and work on a project). I didn't think to bring a copy home with me when I left yesterday. So I'll probably finish it Sunday during my lunch break.
In that case, I'll put you back on the payroll.
I'm sure you can answer the Olson questions, in particular what type of phone she made the calls on. Seeing as it's weekend, here's a vid I would, in all seriousness, appreciate your opinion of,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1656880303867390173
 
Ooops wrong again Kirkman. Thats the pole from the on-ramp in the background growing out of that guys head.
Read the last line of my signature Smith. Answer the Olson questions, then we'll discuss other stuff - not before.
 
Or even, don't bother. Just mirror the discussion on this thread.

I know we discussed the Washington Post article and Dr. Papcun's system earier in the thread, and remarked on all the problems with that one too. It's certainly much more what Malcolm's after than the musical manipulation technology. It was the "sooper-sekrit military system" that was always his only realistic hope, but I'd forgotten that we'd previously had that much detail on it.

I've sort of forgotten why Malcolm stopped talking about it.

Maybe because it's not publicly available, and I don't believe it's ever fooled a close relative in a real-time conversation (it sounds "remarkably like" the person to the general public, is what we're told), and of course there are all the problems of prior sampling of the voice and setting up the programme and so on, and as Dr. Papcun says, the suggestion involves accusing him personally of a heinous crime.

Mind you, accusing all and sundry of heinous crimes hasn't yet stopped Malcolm, so it can't have been that.

But seeing that thread reminded me that this was what we were talking about a gadzillion pages ago, so why did we get sidetracked into bloody karaoke machines and StudioMasters anyway.

Come on, Malcolm, get with the programme.

If you really think Dr. Papcun is just a helluva lot better at this than he admitted, and somehow acquired samples of completely ordinary people's voices weeks before they happened to fly on the planes in question, and researched all their common phraseology and speech patterns (even so far as making some of them seem to say things that on the face of it no forger would think of having them say, but the relatives agreed were in character), and he's guilty of a crime beyond imagining, just say so.

It's your best and only chance of defending your filthy position, and constructing a case that's even borderline coherent.

Then maybe we can get on with this.

:hb:

I can't believe I fell for that rubbish about karaoke machines and StudioMasters, and forgot what we'd been over before. There was a reason for it? Or was it just to keep me entertained in a dead week at work when movement restrictions meant we had little material coming in?

I can't believe I'm putting together his case for him just to get out of this rut.

But do you know, I think I am.

Done the probabilities for him yet, Spitfire?

Rolfe.
 
I am perfectly happy with the explanation.
The weekend is upon us and I hope you have a bit of spare time. I'm not happy with my last post to you. I'd like to take things a bit slower.
The link I have included is the government's own report.
If you scroll down to page 16, figure 3.8 you will see a photo of the face of the Pentagon showing and namimg columns 8 and 11.
All I want to establish in this post, is that if the nose of the plane hit at column 11 or anywhere between 8 and 11, then the windows to the left of column 8 would be broken and the fence knocked down.
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf
Once you are happy with that, let me introduce four words and their dictionary definitions to you.
The words are contradictory, implausible, impossible and fraudulent.
Contradictory.
To assert the opposite. In other words, to say one thing when the facts show the opposite.
Implausible.
Not having the appearance of truth or credibility.
Impossible.
Unable to be done.
Fraudulent.
Any deception or trickery.
Thanking you in advance.
 
No, I said that no one (at least, no musician) would use say "changing tone" or "controlling tone" instead of "controlling" or "changing pitch". In colloquial terms, if I want to know what a certain pitch is, I'll probably ask "what note is that". But in technical discussions (like those that you will see in product specs) the terms are not really interchangeable. What you have to understand is that "notes" (or "tones") don't have definite pitch. Have a clarinetist play an "A" for you sometime, then see what that note corresponds to on a piano. "Pitch" is a very specific, quantifiable concept. "Tone" is not.

Musical nomenclature is, by necessity, relatively consistent. Music is an international business, and of a nature that people must be able to communicate quickly and effectively. What differences there are are well know, and anyone with the proper education and experience can easily recognize those differences. Almost always, those differences consist of using different words to refer to the same thing, not using the same word to refer to different things. For example, British musicians generally use "crotchet", "quaver" and "semi-quaver" to refer to what Americans call "quarter notes", "eighth notes" and "sixteenth notes". These are well known, and British and American musicians can communicate with one another using their own terminology with ease. There is one glaring exception to this: the German "B" is what the rest of the Western world calls a "B-flat" (the Germans use "H" to refer to "B"), but again, this is well known.

The Studiomaster is produced by a British company. I know and work with many British musicians. They would not use "tone" to mean "pitch". The two words are related but they are not the same thing. A tone has pitch, but it is only one aspect of the concept. It refers to other things such as duration and quality. The specific quality which we hear as how high or low a tone is (the fundamental frequency and its overtones) is referred to as "pitch". "Tone control" simply can't be used as you're thinking of it. It makes no sense. It makes a great deal of sense to use it to refer to the quality of a sound.

All of which continues to be perfectly irrelevant as far as voice-morphing goes. Changing the pitch of someone's voice doesn't make them sound like someone else, it just makes them sound like they're on a different pitch. In other words, this entire discussion is largely useless.
In conclusion you said,
"Changing the pitch of someone's voice doesn't make them sound like someone else, it just makes them sound like they're on a different pitch. In other words, this entire discussion is largely useless."
You forget that two arguments are rolling along here.
1. Is it possible to pre programme a machine with a particular song, where for example A G F B is a part of that song.
Our singer then sings A G F A, yet it somes out A G F B.
Is that possible?
2. Voice morphing is a separate argument.
 
As near as I can tell, the Copyright Office is probably referring to suits in federal court. By codifying copyright law, the feds more or less killed common law copyright at the federal level. But it's not true for state courts. You should be able to sue in just about every state court to enforce a copyright even if not registered. I think whomever wrote the FAQ figured that erring on the side of just getting everybody to register their copyrights was easier than explaining the difference between state and feredal law.
That makes sense to me. I'm perfectly willing to defer to your expertise.

FYI, this seems to be the relevant language from the US Copyright Code (Section 411(a)):
(a) Except for an action brought for a violation of the rights of the author under section 106A(a), and subject to the provisions of subsection (b), no action for infringement of the copyright in any United States work shall be instituted until registration of the copyright claim has been made in accordance with this title. In any case, however, where the deposit, application, and fee required for registration have been delivered to the Copyright Office in proper form and registration has been refused, the applicant is entitled to institute an action for infringement if notice thereof, with a copy of the complaint, is served on the Register of Copyrights. The Register may, at his or her option, become a party to the action with respect to the issue of registrability of the copyright claim by entering an appearance within sixty days after such service, but the Register's failure to become a party shall not deprive the court of jurisdiction to determine that issue.

Section 106A(a) states:

(a) Rights of Attribution and Integrity. — Subject to section 107 and independent of the exclusive rights provided in section 106, the author of a work of visual art —
(1) shall have the right —
(A) to claim authorship of that work, and
(B) to prevent the use of his or her name as the author of any work of visual art which he or she did not create;
(2) shall have the right to prevent the use of his or her name as the author of the work of visual art in the event of a distortion, mutilation, or other modification of the work which would be prejudicial to his or her honor or reputation; and
(3) subject to the limitations set forth in section 113(d), shall have the right —
(A) to prevent any intentional distortion, mutilation, or other modification of that work which would be prejudicial to his or her honor or reputation, and any intentional distortion, mutilation, or modification of that work is a violation of that right, and
(B) to prevent any destruction of a work of recognized stature, and any intentional or grossly negligent destruction of that work is a violation of that right.


Unless I'm misreading something, that sounds like it refers only to visual arts.

At any rate, it makes sense that you would be able to sue in state court as long as you can prove copyright.

Okay, I have no idea what the author thinks he's talking about. It seems to be regarding a very specific example that he doesn't bother to explain - maybe arranging a piece for your own performance of it. But it doesn't cover something like an arrangement for a book of music to be published for however many copies they can sell (like Big Note Beatles or some such).

It's a mix of law (which is indisputable), good advice (which is just smart) and personal preference (which doesn't matter). The sentence, "permission must be obtained before starting a work" is just good advice. If you have no intention of ever playing your arrangement for anybody, feel free to arrange the heck out of it without permission from anybody. The sentence, "YOU DO NOT OWN YOUR ARRANGEMENT" is flat wrong. I think he means that you do not own the entire work which is (generally) right. Absent a contract to the contrary, you own the unique, creative aspect of your arrangement of the work. No one may perform your arrangement of that work without your permission.

So, um, you won't find the US Copyright Office agreeing with every word of that quote. It's decent advice for performers of covers and is what you would expect from a well-informed non-lawyer.
What I've been able to find in the Copyright Code seems to agree with you. I'm not terribly good at reading legalese, and I should probably leave off here and leave the law to the lawyers.
 
Pole No 2, is the first one past the bridge.
Squirm out of this.
Here it is seemingly sticking out of a blokes head. Photo No 5. There's no mistake, so behave yourself and give up.
http://911review.org/brad.com/pentagon/lightpoles/
As for OKC.
Now hear this.
The Murragh Bldg is at 12 o clock.
McVeighs van is at noon.
A bdlg at 6 o clock had debris from the Murragh bldg on its roof.
Proof positive that the Murragh bldg was blown from inside to out.
You'll be telling me next that this bloke committed suicide,
http://www.apfn.org/APFN/yeakey.htm

Ooops wrong again Kirkman. Thats the pole from the on-ramp in the background growing out of that guys head.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=8034&d=1186767282

Read the last line of my signature Smith. Answer the Olson questions, then we'll discuss other stuff - not before.

I answered and debunked your light pole assertion Kirkman. Aversion noted. If your not man enough to admit you are wrong. Thats OK.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom