[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I already have told you Malcolm - many, many times.


Oh and the two questions I asked were not rhetorical, please answer them. Because before we go further, I need to know that you understand what autopilot is and that it exists. Once you have confirmed as much, then we'll go a little deeper.....

As it stands right now, it appears that you can not differentiate between autopilot and remote control. And if you can't do that, then you simply are unfit to make the claims that you have..
What did Raytheon and Boeing do in August 2001?
 
Yes, why don't you Malcolm?
Because I have issues to deal with, I have a message to get across, which has been heavily clouded by your assorted prevarication.
I'm winning and you are losing. That's because I have the truth on mu side and you have nothing more than a collection of childish tricks. Along the way, you all are becoming increasingly desperate for diversions.
How many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?
 
You think wrong.
I used the word think precisely once in my post, which was saying that tone control was probably not referring to Gregorian chant or in controlling major seconds (which is a thoroughly nonsensical thing to say).

As to the rest: I don't think this, I know it. No musician (or anyone marketing to musicians) would refer to going from A to B as "changing tone". They would say "changing pitch".

I'm a university level voice teacher with a Master's in vocal performance. I spend my days around musicians and with music. You are wrong.
 
Malcolm, don't be so quick to say you are winning. I believe you DON'T have truth on your side. I also believe that 10, 20, 30, 40 years from now people will be debating the '911 hoax' just like they do the 'Moon Hoax' and JFK; in relative obscurity and completely away from the mainstream.

So, your arrogance may make you feel better, but in the end we shall see, won't we?
 
By making a series of bold-faced lies, you just killed your one chance at sympathy from me. There were over a hundred eyewitnesses who saw Flight 175 hit the tower, it's up to you to show why they saw that and not the real deal, and provide the supporting evidence. If I accused you of being a warlock, it would be my job to prove it, not your's to prove it wrong.

Also, one last piece of advice. No conspiracy has the power to hide the laws of physics (eg, gravity needing a hole to get in, or steel not being weakened by heat). They are a part of the universe. You would have an easier time putting the sun in a jar and hiding it in your basement.
Tell me one bare faced lie I have told.
Guess what you can do with your sympathy.
Far more than 100 people saw a plane hit the south tower. Now show me one piece of evidence that it was 175.
If the government can identify a van from its axle, why can't that same government identify an aircraft engine that is peppered in serial numbers?
Finally, you've got the gall to quote the laws of physics.
Join your pals in the bunker.
 
Asked of Malcolm: The question is, do you still believe that gravity requires air pressure? That's a different question. Can you answer that question in a simple and clear way? Or, as you so elegantly put it, "something resembling an answer to the question that you were asked?"

Malcolm: My pleasure,
If there is air around a planet, then that planet will attract that air and cause air pressure. In just the same way you have sea pressure.
In fact you live in a sea of air, in much the same way that fish live in the sea.


Malcolm, sorry, but you didn't answer the question that was asked. You simply reaffirmed that gravity is a cause of air pressure (and water pressure in the sea), which everybody already knows and agrees with.

For convenience, I will restate my questions from this post. A simple yes-or-no answer will suffice for each. Thank you.

1. Are you claiming that gravity is affected by air pressure? Yes or no.

2. Where there is no air pressure, is there no gravity? Yes or no.
 
Tell me one bare faced lie I have told.

Just one?

There are flight engineers on every commercial long haul flight.

Don't forget, it's a cloudy september day.

NY is 200 miles away and covered by clouds.

Govt policy is, because there's a war on, that all hardwear is obsolete after two years.

That's why the twins went UP, before they came down.

You know very well that the supposed hijackers couldn't fly a kite.

No such a thing as a transitive verb

Verb transitive = correct.
Transitve verb = incorrect.

Ce la vie = short for C'est la vie.

There is no such word as 'fantastical'.

Fire alone has never dropped a steel framed building and never will.

There was practically nothing to burn in the building at all. The corridors were not carpeted, neither were the bulk of the offices.

I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.

There's a few to hold you over, Malcolm.
 
[nitpick]440Hz is theoretically concert A (it's been creeping up over the years--it's generally closer to 444Hz these days). It's not quite accurate to say "A is 440Hz" though, as A is also 220Hz, 110Hz, 55Hz, 880Hz and so on.

Interestingly (or perhaps not) an A on the Great Highland Bagpipe is between 470 and 480Hz, which is more than a half-step sharp.

The point being, A (or any other pitch) is a rather nebulous quantity that has changed its specific value over the years. It's more a question of relativity--A is a whole step higher than G and a whole step lower than B--than an absolute pitch. You get quite a different A depending upon which tuning system you're using.[/nitpick]


OK, OK, OK!! I was hurrying to go out to dinner! At least I was close-ish on the frequency.

Come and meet the organ in All Saints Church, Faringdon, in Oxfordshire. Tuned in the 1920s I believe, and a good tone above concert pitch. Try singing Barber's Adagio there, not meant for singing anyway, that takes the sopranos up to an exposed top C. And try it when you've just spent the week touring Wales and are frankly knackered. (Hah, Crispian S-P the trumpeter had it worse. He had to play half his programme transposing at sight - now Malcolm's imaginary machine would have come in handy there! - and the "authentic" part on a hunk of bent piping, as the version with the three holes that made it actually playable couldn't be brought into tune with the organ.)

So OK, 440 Hz is just the first approximation, to give Loss Leader the idea.

Good luck trying to get Malcolm to understand the subtleties of definition. This is the guy who has stated categorically that there's no such thing as a transitive verb. I see what you mean about A to B being a "tone". It's so easy to use the words when you're familiar with them, and not see that an outsider with only a smattering of knowledge, like Malcolm, may be misunderstanding in spades. Does he really think "intuitive tone control" means it can read your mind and change your pitch by a major second if necessary? Hey, that's a good one!

I thought he might be confusing "intonation" and "tone". But I've put him right on that (as on so much else) and he just doesn't seem capable of getting it.

I'm going for the direct approach.

Malcolm, repeat after me. The "StudioMaster" does not change the pitch of the singer's voice. Not by a tone, or a half-tone, or even a perfect fifth.

And again.

And again.

Rolfe.
 
Tell me one bare faced lie I have told.

This should get us started:


One barefaced lie you told was that imaginary "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB participated in the jihadist attacks of 9/11/01, substituting for the real planes that were hijacked by terrorists.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 175 was not identified.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 77 was not identified.

Another was that karaoke machines permit "voice-morphing."

Shall we go on?


Guess what you can do with your sympathy.
Far more than 100 people saw a plane hit the south tower. Now show me one piece of evidence that it was 175.
If the government can identify a van from its axle, why can't that same government identify an aircraft engine that is peppered in serial numbers?
Finally, you've got the gall to quote the laws of physics.
Join your pals in the bunker.


Uh, Malcolm, the plane that hit the South Tower was identified. It was also tracked very closely from Boston until it crashed.
 
I already have told you Malcolm - many, many times.


Oh and the two questions I asked were not rhetorical, please answer them. Because before we go further, I need to know that you understand what autopilot is and that it exists. Once you have confirmed as much, then we'll go a little deeper.....

As it stands right now, it appears that you can not differentiate between autopilot and remote control. And if you can't do that, then you simply are unfit to make the claims that you have..


Apathoid, you deserve a medal for your patience.
 
You think wrong.


No Malcolm, he's perfectly correct. Please tell us now whether you're just stringing on this nonsense for a laugh. You see, you've said such preposterous things before that we thought you had to be having a laugh, but then you demonstrated (against all the odds) that you were actually serious. So it's awful hard to tell.

Now could we get back to the questions you're still wriggling out of? You know, the ones about gravity?

1. = pre programmed.
2. = wrong again.


You're just making this up as you go along, aren't you? If this wonder-machine can be pre-programmed to know what the singer intends, and play that note instead of the note sung, why doesn't the advertisement say so? How would it know, anyway, since it's just an amplifier? You know, it doesn't have a repertoire of songs, and it doesn't play the accompaniment.

No, don't answer any of that. Answer the ones about gravity first.


No, I am precisely right. Look back through the posts. Try to do something other than pontificate on something you know nothing about.


What, you are precisely right that this StudioMaster (for that is what funk de fino was talking about) can read minds?

Maybe you should tell the manufacturer, he might have a shot at the JREF million with that one!

What did Raytheon and Boeing do in August 2001?


Oh no Malcolm, you answer first. I hope we're all agreed on that, aren't we?
  • Is it necessary to have a BIG hole in the top of a polythene infusion bag "to let gravity in" before the contents can run out of a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there any gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What are viable sources of gravity?
Extra marks for explaining the guinea and the feather, the Schiehallion experiment, what was seen in that YouTube video of the lunar landing posted earlier, and the collapsibility of polythene containers.

If you're having real problems with the test, then a rational reply to the second question alone will be considered for a possible bare pass mark.

We WILL be grading your replies.

Rolfe.
 
Because I have issues to deal with, I have a message to get across, which has been heavily clouded by your assorted prevarication.
I'm winning and you are losing. That's because I have the truth on mu side and you have nothing more than a collection of childish tricks. Along the way, you all are becoming increasingly desperate for diversions.
How many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?


Prevarication. A fancy word for lying, to those who have studied the classics. Or read Billy Bunter, whatever. You wouldn't know the truth if it came up and bit you on the ankle, you're so unused to telling it.

Asking about Barbara Olson again, I see - the question that has been answered for you about six times already.

No, like I said, you first.
  • Is it necessary to have a BIG hole in the top of a polythene infusion bag to let gravity in before the contents can run out of a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What are viable sources of gravity?
We've been asking these questions well before you brought up the subject of Mrs. Olsen.

You go first.

Rolfe.
 
Tell me one bare faced lie I have told.
Guess what you can do with your sympathy.
Far more than 100 people saw a plane hit the south tower. Now show me one piece of evidence that it was 175.
If the government can identify a van from its axle, why can't that same government identify an aircraft engine that is peppered in serial numbers?
Finally, you've got the gall to quote the laws of physics.
Join your pals in the bunker.


Just one? VespaGuy has come up with quite an impressive list. I'll add a few more. (No links, you know where you said it.)
  • That you are extremely rich
  • That you have an honours degree in Law
  • That you are a member of Mensa (or perhaps it was that you have a Mensa-level IQ)
Busted, Malcolm, completely and utterly. The second being particularly ironic in view of what Lord Justice Aldous said. (I'll leave the bit about being a "retired businessman", because even old man Steptoe might reasonably claim that after he sold the rag-and-bone cart.)

Now if you really want to go on to consider any further questions, there are just these few little ones outstanding for you to deal with.
  • Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What are viable sources of gravity?
You know, simple laws of physics. A child could do this easily Malcolm, what's your problem?

Rolfe.
 
Trouble is, even if Spitfire can find you that smilie, it wouldn't fit the context of "foisted on one's own petard," as was used here http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2836857#post2836857

:D


Sorry, sorry, it's late, I couldn't think what you were on about for a minute!

Tessitura, how long did it take you to find that?
Foisted on your own petard yet again. The machine knows the note coming in, it's then a tiny adjustment to lift or lower it a couple on notes. I'd use top C as a marker myself.
The mike Spitfire put up was a kids toy. The real deal costs a lot more that that. There you go, any machine that can do as above, could easily alter incoming by a couple of notes. I've been shown to right again - that's what you get when you tell the truth. You should try it sometime.


The master of English language gets it wrong again!!!

Malcolm, I'll ask you again, go and talk to your mate Victor Brox about these magic machines that can correct a bad singer's intonation/pitch. Hey, maybe he has one himself! He might even let you play with it!! Then you can come back and tell us all about it, and even link to the right web site this time! Wouldn't that be fun?

And it still would prove precisely nothing about what 1970s karaoke machines could do, or whether it was possible in 2001 to fake a person's voice in such a natural way that his mother believes she's talking to her own son, in a real-time conversation.

Then maybe you could start telling the truth, breaking the habit of a lifetime we know, but you might be surprised how far it'll get you.

And of course, these little questions. You know, the gravity thing.

We're waiting, you know.

Rolfe.
 
I used the word think precisely once in my post, which was saying that tone control was probably not referring to Gregorian chant or in controlling major seconds (which is a thoroughly nonsensical thing to say).

As to the rest: I don't think this, I know it. No musician (or anyone marketing to musicians) would refer to going from A to B as "changing tone". They would say "changing pitch".

I'm a university level voice teacher with a Master's in vocal performance. I spend my days around musicians and with music. You are wrong.
I quote you,
"I'm a university level voice teacher with a Master's in vocal performance. I spend my days around musicians and with music".
What is it with you lot? I have a masters in this, I'm an expert in that, therefore I'm right and you're wrong. Prove it, identify yourself as others have done and your quali's can then be taken into account.
No positive I.d. = you're aspersions fall on stony ground.

Somerled, As you wish to preserve your own anonimity, stop challenging other people on their's. Any further discussion of anyone's identity, not just your own, will not be approved.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This should get us started:


One barefaced lie you told was that imaginary "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB participated in the jihadist attacks of 9/11/01, substituting for the real planes that were hijacked by terrorists.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 175 was not identified.

Another was that wreckage from Flight 77 was not identified.

Another was that karaoke machines permit "voice-morphing."

Shall we go on?





Uh, Malcolm, the plane that hit the South Tower was identified. It was also tracked very closely from Boston until it crashed.
Last chance, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?
If you can't answer a simple question like that, then you can't expect me to waste any more time on you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom