Rolfe
Adult human female
Malcolm seems to have lost interest in audio technology. I think he has me back on ignore too, as he's simply ignored the last few posts I made on the subject. However, just to summarise.
Pitch changing by electronic means has of course been possible for about as long as audio recording, first by simply altering the playback speed, but later by more sophisticated electronic means that don't require the speed of the music to change. I know nothing and care less about pop music, but avant-garde classical musicians have been doing this in electronic compositions for a long time. Deliberately changing an A to a B in this way is a piece of cake. You can alter the pitch of drum sounds too, I've heard it done, and some of the results are, well, "interesting".
Pitch correction, as opposed to simply learning to sing in tune, has been around for about ten years. However, it is almost exclusively an editing tool, not a live-performance tool. Earlier methods took time to process the signal, which excluded live-performance use. More recent methods have processing times fast enough to be incorporated in a live system, however other problems such as background noise (including the sounds from other musicians on-stage) make the exercise problematic.
A system like this would not of course be able to change an A to a B, as that would alter the music. What it will do is correct a note which is slightly off-pitch (by no more than a quarter tone) to be in tune according to the scale being used. If the singer (or instrumentalist) is more than a quarter-tone out, the correction is likely to be to the wrong note.
I am unsure as to whether such systems are yet able to be used live, in a practical way. The problems seem quite formidable, but if the will is there then I have little doubt that some boffin could accomplish it.
This technology is professional stuff, dedicated to producing recordings or professional performances. No professional is interested in a system which, rather than simply being pre-programmed with the key of the performance to optimise pitch, actually tries to sing a specific pre-programmed song, which is what Malcolm seems to have been imagining.
Only amateurs would be interested in a system that allowed them to pretend to sing a pre-determined song, and have the machine in effect sing it for them, pitching the notes correctly no matter what came out of their mouths. (Interestingly, what this implies is in a sense the opposite of "voice-morphing" - improving the intonation while keeping the individual character and timbre of the voice, so that it still appears to be the individual's own performance.) It might have an application in karaoke, and as I said I imagine someone will sooner or later attempt to do this (taking most of the fun out of it in the process). However, to the best of my knowledge this has not yet been done.
Malcolm's mistake was to say, repeatedly, that pitch-correction or pitch-changing was possible, and then immediately try to "prove" this by citing an invalid example. First it was 1970s karaoke machines (which didn't do it), then it was some silly kiddie toys (which don't do anything very usefully), then it was the "StudioMaster", which again doesn't alter pitch in any way.
Perhaps it was a mistake to spend so long debunking Malcolm's incompetent examples, but really, Malcolm, even when you come along claiming something which is absolutely correct, if you try to demonstrate this by referring to example cases which don't do what you're claiming, you're going to get called on it.
I've no idea where you dredged the StudioMaster up from, but you could try doing the obvious - Googling "automatic pitch correction" - and see what you get.
So, what has this to do with faking the 11th September telephone calls? Apparently, nothing at all, according to you. So why, then, did you bring it up in the first place? Enquiring minds would like to know.
If you're really talking about the possibilities for faking telephone calls, the only possible game in town is Dr George Papcun's system, which is not in the public domain. Now there are reasons why that didn't do it and that couldn't do it, but at least it's a rational avenue to explore. So could we maybe cut down a bit on the red herrings?
Then you just have the utter impossiblilty of actually gathering the information to impart in these faked voice calls to contend with. As others have mentioned, Elsa Strong "heard" her sister Linda Gronlund's voice on the telephone from Flight 93 tell her the location and secret combination of her personal safe, so that she could find her will. Just think about that one for a minute or two.
Oh, is this getting a bit too tricky for you? Back to the lamp-posts in the hope that you've obfuscated enough to muddy the waters?
Well, if you still want to ask questions, remember there are some you still haven't answered yourself.
Rolfe.
Pitch changing by electronic means has of course been possible for about as long as audio recording, first by simply altering the playback speed, but later by more sophisticated electronic means that don't require the speed of the music to change. I know nothing and care less about pop music, but avant-garde classical musicians have been doing this in electronic compositions for a long time. Deliberately changing an A to a B in this way is a piece of cake. You can alter the pitch of drum sounds too, I've heard it done, and some of the results are, well, "interesting".
Pitch correction, as opposed to simply learning to sing in tune, has been around for about ten years. However, it is almost exclusively an editing tool, not a live-performance tool. Earlier methods took time to process the signal, which excluded live-performance use. More recent methods have processing times fast enough to be incorporated in a live system, however other problems such as background noise (including the sounds from other musicians on-stage) make the exercise problematic.
A system like this would not of course be able to change an A to a B, as that would alter the music. What it will do is correct a note which is slightly off-pitch (by no more than a quarter tone) to be in tune according to the scale being used. If the singer (or instrumentalist) is more than a quarter-tone out, the correction is likely to be to the wrong note.
I am unsure as to whether such systems are yet able to be used live, in a practical way. The problems seem quite formidable, but if the will is there then I have little doubt that some boffin could accomplish it.
This technology is professional stuff, dedicated to producing recordings or professional performances. No professional is interested in a system which, rather than simply being pre-programmed with the key of the performance to optimise pitch, actually tries to sing a specific pre-programmed song, which is what Malcolm seems to have been imagining.
Only amateurs would be interested in a system that allowed them to pretend to sing a pre-determined song, and have the machine in effect sing it for them, pitching the notes correctly no matter what came out of their mouths. (Interestingly, what this implies is in a sense the opposite of "voice-morphing" - improving the intonation while keeping the individual character and timbre of the voice, so that it still appears to be the individual's own performance.) It might have an application in karaoke, and as I said I imagine someone will sooner or later attempt to do this (taking most of the fun out of it in the process). However, to the best of my knowledge this has not yet been done.
Malcolm's mistake was to say, repeatedly, that pitch-correction or pitch-changing was possible, and then immediately try to "prove" this by citing an invalid example. First it was 1970s karaoke machines (which didn't do it), then it was some silly kiddie toys (which don't do anything very usefully), then it was the "StudioMaster", which again doesn't alter pitch in any way.
Perhaps it was a mistake to spend so long debunking Malcolm's incompetent examples, but really, Malcolm, even when you come along claiming something which is absolutely correct, if you try to demonstrate this by referring to example cases which don't do what you're claiming, you're going to get called on it.
I've no idea where you dredged the StudioMaster up from, but you could try doing the obvious - Googling "automatic pitch correction" - and see what you get.
So, what has this to do with faking the 11th September telephone calls? Apparently, nothing at all, according to you. So why, then, did you bring it up in the first place? Enquiring minds would like to know.
If you're really talking about the possibilities for faking telephone calls, the only possible game in town is Dr George Papcun's system, which is not in the public domain. Now there are reasons why that didn't do it and that couldn't do it, but at least it's a rational avenue to explore. So could we maybe cut down a bit on the red herrings?
Then you just have the utter impossiblilty of actually gathering the information to impart in these faked voice calls to contend with. As others have mentioned, Elsa Strong "heard" her sister Linda Gronlund's voice on the telephone from Flight 93 tell her the location and secret combination of her personal safe, so that she could find her will. Just think about that one for a minute or two.
Oh, is this getting a bit too tricky for you? Back to the lamp-posts in the hope that you've obfuscated enough to muddy the waters?
Well, if you still want to ask questions, remember there are some you still haven't answered yourself.
- Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
- Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
- What is a viable source of gravity?
Rolfe.
Last edited: