[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Malcolm seems to have lost interest in audio technology. I think he has me back on ignore too, as he's simply ignored the last few posts I made on the subject. However, just to summarise.

Pitch changing by electronic means has of course been possible for about as long as audio recording, first by simply altering the playback speed, but later by more sophisticated electronic means that don't require the speed of the music to change. I know nothing and care less about pop music, but avant-garde classical musicians have been doing this in electronic compositions for a long time. Deliberately changing an A to a B in this way is a piece of cake. You can alter the pitch of drum sounds too, I've heard it done, and some of the results are, well, "interesting".

Pitch correction, as opposed to simply learning to sing in tune, has been around for about ten years. However, it is almost exclusively an editing tool, not a live-performance tool. Earlier methods took time to process the signal, which excluded live-performance use. More recent methods have processing times fast enough to be incorporated in a live system, however other problems such as background noise (including the sounds from other musicians on-stage) make the exercise problematic.

A system like this would not of course be able to change an A to a B, as that would alter the music. What it will do is correct a note which is slightly off-pitch (by no more than a quarter tone) to be in tune according to the scale being used. If the singer (or instrumentalist) is more than a quarter-tone out, the correction is likely to be to the wrong note.

I am unsure as to whether such systems are yet able to be used live, in a practical way. The problems seem quite formidable, but if the will is there then I have little doubt that some boffin could accomplish it.

This technology is professional stuff, dedicated to producing recordings or professional performances. No professional is interested in a system which, rather than simply being pre-programmed with the key of the performance to optimise pitch, actually tries to sing a specific pre-programmed song, which is what Malcolm seems to have been imagining.

Only amateurs would be interested in a system that allowed them to pretend to sing a pre-determined song, and have the machine in effect sing it for them, pitching the notes correctly no matter what came out of their mouths. (Interestingly, what this implies is in a sense the opposite of "voice-morphing" - improving the intonation while keeping the individual character and timbre of the voice, so that it still appears to be the individual's own performance.) It might have an application in karaoke, and as I said I imagine someone will sooner or later attempt to do this (taking most of the fun out of it in the process). However, to the best of my knowledge this has not yet been done.

Malcolm's mistake was to say, repeatedly, that pitch-correction or pitch-changing was possible, and then immediately try to "prove" this by citing an invalid example. First it was 1970s karaoke machines (which didn't do it), then it was some silly kiddie toys (which don't do anything very usefully), then it was the "StudioMaster", which again doesn't alter pitch in any way.

Perhaps it was a mistake to spend so long debunking Malcolm's incompetent examples, but really, Malcolm, even when you come along claiming something which is absolutely correct, if you try to demonstrate this by referring to example cases which don't do what you're claiming, you're going to get called on it.

I've no idea where you dredged the StudioMaster up from, but you could try doing the obvious - Googling "automatic pitch correction" - and see what you get.

So, what has this to do with faking the 11th September telephone calls? Apparently, nothing at all, according to you. So why, then, did you bring it up in the first place? Enquiring minds would like to know.

If you're really talking about the possibilities for faking telephone calls, the only possible game in town is Dr George Papcun's system, which is not in the public domain. Now there are reasons why that didn't do it and that couldn't do it, but at least it's a rational avenue to explore. So could we maybe cut down a bit on the red herrings?

Then you just have the utter impossiblilty of actually gathering the information to impart in these faked voice calls to contend with. As others have mentioned, Elsa Strong "heard" her sister Linda Gronlund's voice on the telephone from Flight 93 tell her the location and secret combination of her personal safe, so that she could find her will. Just think about that one for a minute or two.

Oh, is this getting a bit too tricky for you? Back to the lamp-posts in the hope that you've obfuscated enough to muddy the waters?

Well, if you still want to ask questions, remember there are some you still haven't answered yourself.
  • Is it necessary for a polythene infusion bag to have a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in before it can empty through a tube in the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a TV tube?
  • What is a viable source of gravity?
Easy questions, I even gave you the answers a couple or three pages ago. You demand answers from others - goose and gander sauce, you know.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Allow me to apologise for confusing your column 14 with column 17. I was actually referring to a previous post, no matter, you did say column 14 and I should have acknowledged that.

Thanks

I suspect that there has been some confusion over the meaning of the word 'deactivated', so I won't pursue you on that one for the moment.

No confusion, you are wrong, all you have to do is speak to Mr Hotard at AA, they were also definately not removed from the seats, so you were wrong again

What I would like to explore is your contention that column 14 was the impact point

Not my contention malcolm, the NIST report contention, you also claimed earlier that it was 11 where the initial fuselage hit, are you admitting this is wrong also?

The total impact area was 175 ft. Half of that is 87 1/2 ft. Let's say 87 ft. I will be corrected on this, but my recollection is that the columns were 10 ft apart. That's 10 ft max for space plus one column.
I make the distance between column 7 and 14, 70 ft max.
The window between 6 and 7 is not broken.
You're 17 ft short pal.

You better get those measurements correct before you post stuff like this, they were either 10 ft or not, which is it?

Who says the wing had to hit the window and if it could have broken it?

You are going by the NIST report.
Their diagram 6.1 on page 35, Depicts a wingspan of 125 ft.
Using those figures and going off their diagram, the left wing stretches to column 2.
Their own photograph fig 3.6 pg 16, shows unbroken windows from 7 down and an unbroken fence from 6 down.
That is called IMPOSSIBLE.

The unbroken fence is across from column 4 malcolm

How far is the fence from the wall malcolm, this may help you with visualising it? The report says the left wing may have touched the ground before the wall therefore spreading debris along the face of the wall

To the right, their diagram 6.1. on page 35, shows the right wing cutting through 1st floor windows between columns 20, 21 and 22.
Those windows aren't broken, as you can clearly see here,

it does not show it cutting through, it shows it hitting this area

also left wing, from report

The size and position of the actual opening in the
facade of the building (from column line 8 to column line 18)
indicate that no portion of the outer two-thirds of the right wing
and no portion of the outer one-third of the left wing actually
entered the building.

I have to be careful what I say, because I had one post vapourised for "taunting". Suffice it for me to say, that the same is true for the tail and I won't mention the underslung engines digging a furrow or two in the lawn.
You have at least two impossibles there. Two that I have shown conclusively.
The real question isn't whether 9/11 was an inside job, because it obviously was. The real question is, why do posters on here deny it?

again, you have shown nothing
 
I tell you that remote control of bombers over German occupied France in WW2 was on the cards and you retort with the bunkeresque,
"No 757 has been flown by remote".
Read the links I posted. Both 757's and 767's were pre programmed to be taken over in the event of a hijack and controlled remotely from the ground.
I have posted evidence that shows it's a small matter to take over the control of a 757 from the ground. I have posted evidence that both 757's and 767's were so pre programmed that their controls could be taken over from the ground - IN THE EVENT OF A HIJACK.
Lies only work in the dark.

Malcolm, you've also provided 'evidence' that 1970's karioke machines could operate as voice morphers, that 757s did not have airphones and that gravity doesn't act in a vacuum.

I also understand that you have disproved the existence of transative verbs, and you consider Rolfe to be 'foisted on her own petard'. These all have one thing in common. They are entirely wrong. I didn't think it was possible for one person to be wrong in everything they say, but based on your posts, you've managed it. If you want further evidence of your errors, start at the beginning of this thread, and read everything you've written. It's wrong.

Ah well, c'est la vie.

p.s. If you wanted to ask me how many calls Ms Olson made, I have absolutely no idea. If you want me to make an estimate, I'll have a go. If you could think of nine numbers between one and ten, I'll pick the remaining one. I think the odds are on my side.
 
<snip>

This essay is by Joe Vialls . . .

The man is clearly out of his mind. But you can ask him yourself by writing Joe Vialls, 45 Merlin Drive, Carine, Perth, Western Australia 6020. You won't, though.

<snip>


Unfortunately, Joe Vialls, like Generalissimo Francisco Franco, is still dead. :(

July 18, 2005 – Mike Macaulay

It is with great sadness that I pass on to you the information that my friend Joe Vialls passed away suddenly and unexpectedly last night in Perth Western Australia after a period of illness.

His wife Marilyn rang me early this morning to tell me the sad news. I was very surprised as I talked to him only a few days ago and he said he felt a little better.
As we all know Joe made a large contribution to Internet Journalism, in an effort to reveal the truth that the media fails to print.

The irony is that about 5 years ago I suggested to Joe that he get onto the net. He replied ' what on earth would I do on the Internet'? The rest is history, he got on the net and found his place there.

Farewell Joe - at this very moment he's probably checking behind Gods [sic] throne to see if the Mossad are there!

We who knew him will miss him greatly.

Regards,
Mike Macaulay.
Perth Western Australia. [emphasis added]
 
None of your links provide evidence that "757's and 767's were pre programmed to be taken over in the event of a hijack and controlled remotely from the ground." The very links that you posted do not say what you claim they do.

1. Your first link: http://georgewashington.blogspot.com/2006/01/wheres-remote-control.html

This essay by a conspiracy fanaticist states that planes could be controled from the ground. It states:

And one day after 9/11, an article appeared on the top science and technology news service stating "hijackings could be halted in progress with existing technologies, say aviation researchers".

The article it refers to states:

Aeroplane hijackings could be halted in progress with existing technologies, say aviation researchers, but the attempt would be risky. "Most modern aircraft have some form of autopilot that could be re-programmed to ignore commands from a hijacker and instead take direction from the ground," says Jeff Gosling of the Institute of Transportation Studies at the University of California, Berkeley. source

Nowhere does this article ever say that 757's and 767's were pre-programmed so that their controls could be taken over from the ground. It does not say what you claim it does. It only says it would be possible, not that it had ever been done - not even once.

As always, you can contact the Institute for Transportation Studies at UC Berkley to find out for yourself at 109 McLaughlin Hall, Mail Code 1720, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-1720. 510-642-3585/510-643-3955 (fax). [email protected]

As always, you won't.

Were you lying when you claimed that the essay said this? Were you incapable of reading? Was your brain actively fooling you to keep you from feeling bad about yourself?

2. The second link you claim shows that 757s and 767s were pre-programmed to be controled from the ground is http://www.geocities.com/mknemesis/homerun.html

This essay is by Joe Vialls and claims that DARPA designed back-doors into new aircraft computers allowing them to be controled in the event of a hijacking.

Vialls faces two problems. First, not even he can figure out why this would ever be a good idea. He writes, "Using the perfectly reasonable assumption that hijackers only carry a limited number of bullets, and many aircraft nowadays carry in excess of 300 passengers, Home Run could be used to fly all of the survivors to a friendly airport for a safe auto landing." Taking control of an aircraft in mid-hijack would likely enrage the hijackers and make them start killing passengers until control is released. Vialls gets around this by claiming that hijackers wouldn't carry more than 300 bullets so they'd be unable to kill all of the passengers. This is ... well, it's insane.

Which is Vialls' second problem. He cites absolutely no sources. In your first article, the guy at least cited real people. Vialls cites nothing to show that what he is saying could at all be true. What are his qualifications? He doesn't claim to have any. But he does write a lot. He believes that cancer can be prevented by an imaginary vitamin. He's a rabid antisemite, blaming Israel for the crash of Pan Am flight 103. He thinks that George Bush and Hollywood colluded to use mind control hidden in TV pictures to force people to vote for him. He also sent a letter to Mohammed Al Fayed claiming Princess Diana was killed by a secret beam weapon. "Many years ago a LTL (Less-Than-Lethal) weapon was designed at the Los Alamos National Laboratories for exactly this purpose, and what little evidence I have 10,000 miles away from the scene of the crime, indicates a high probability of its deployment near the Paris tunnel crash site."

The man is clearly out of his mind. But you can ask him yourself by writing Joe Vialls, 45 Merlin Drive, Carine, Perth, Western Australia 6020. You won't, though.

3. Your last source is http://www.public-action.com/911/robotplane.html

This essay was written by another prolific web publisher, Carol Valentine. Just like Joe Vialls, a quick perusal of her website shows a deeply disturbed person. Antisemitism and Holocaust denial play large parts as her main website attests: http://www.public-action.com/ Links on the main page lead to the Institute for Historical Review. She writes, "Zionist Fundies will do anything for Israel and "the Jews," whom they worship as God or God's little brother. They are only too happy to be the Jews' slaves, and insist we all join in their bondage. Certainly their beliefs are anti-Christian. More to the point: Zionist "Christians" are traitors to America. Along with Jews, they wave the American flag, urging us to spill the blood of any who stand in the way of Israeli ambition."

And she provides zero evidence that 757s and 767s were equipped with remote control that allowed them to be taken over from the ground. What she does state is that, by 2001, the US had developed the Global Hawk. The Global Hawk is 44 1/2 feet long and weighs 22,900 pounds. Most importantly, it was designed from the very beginning to be an autonomous aircraft - every system was engineered with that in mind. It was not a passenger plane converted to robotic control. source. In contrast, the 757 is is 155 feet long and weighs 255,000 pounds. That's over ten times as much.

Carol then goes on to cite as "evidence" that a 757 had remote control capability, the fact that several sources state that it did not have remote control capability. She writes, "Robert Ayling, a former boss of British Airways, suggested in The Financial Times this week that aircraft could be commandeered from the ground and controlled remotely in the event of a hijack ...." She then cites a New York Times article reporting that George Bush on September 28, 2001, wanted "government grants ... to pay for video monitors that would be placed in the cockpit to alert pilots to trouble in the cabin; and new technology, probably far in the future, allowing air traffic controllers to land distressed planes by remote control." The article she cites says such technology would be "far in the future." She even put that sentence in bold.

So, Carol Valentine offers zero evidence that 757s and 767s could be flown remotely in 2001. She actually offers evidence that they could not be. What was she thinking? Ask her yourself at: [email protected]
or write her at PO Box 15430 Wedgwood Station, Seattle, WA 98115. You won't, though.

The sources that you posted do not provideany evidence for your claims. I am torn, Malcolm. I cannot decide if you a are purposefully lying, if your reading comprehension is just that abysmal, or if your psychological makeup actually is protecting your ego by not letting you perceive reality.

In 2001, neither a 757 or 767 had never been flown by remote control and, to this day, still have not. You can write to the authors yourself as well as their sources (but you won't). You will find no evidence contradicting this statement.
Oi vey,
Im wondering if a fear of (increased) anti semitism plays a part in your clear refusal to see the truth. Aaron Russo is jewish, as I have already said, there's good and bad in all. Whatever your reasons for 'govt loyalty', you are on the wrong side. There are plenty of jews in the truth movement and they agree with me. The bottom line to all this is pure and simple gangsterism. Gangsterism that has reached into banking and the MSM. If you want to throw yourself under the wheels of justice over these mass murders then carry on. Quite simply, you are wrong.
False flag operations have been going for centuries. My second link will point that out.
Then Aaron Russo's 'From Freedom to Fascism'. One thing the film won't tell you, is that this would be elite can only work if you are skint. The name of their game is to keep everybody skint, then you can find enough semi intelligent people to keep it going. If you want to be two pence half penny looking down on tuppence, then carry on. Apart from breaking the law on a daily basis, because you will be offending someones dignity, you'll have people like me seeking to track you down and haul you before the courts.
At the end of it all, you'll get no thanks from the gangsters and you'll end your days strapped down in a bed somewhere and fed drugs, because it's cheaper to do that than give you regular food.
Here is proof positive, for those who want to see, of remote control of 757's,
it is followed by proof of false flags and then Aaron Russo's excellent film.
http://www.911-strike.com/remote_bb.htm
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...36&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...26&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
 
Malcolm is trying to figure out how to enroll George Papcun, the creator voice-morphing technology, in his imaginary, mathematically impossible conspiracy. You see, Malcolm made a huge mistake in linking to a 1999 article that mentions Dr. Papcun, who is writing a series of essays (the first appears here on the JREF conspiracy forum) explaining why the phone calls from the hijacked planes could not have been faked.

It is my guess that Malcolm will be reduced to pretending that Dr. Papcun is lying. Lying is a subject Malcolm understands very well.
 
False flag operations have been going for centuries. My second link will point that out.
Then Aaron Russo's 'From Freedom to Fascism'. One thing the film won't tell you, is that this would be elite can only work if you are skint. The name of their game is to keep everybody skint, then you can find enough semi intelligent people to keep it going. If you want to be two pence half penny looking down on tuppence, then carry on.


Don't deflect attention, Malcolm. We're talking about remote control in 757s and 767s. Don't change the subject to international banking or whatever. It won't work. I posted a lengthy dissection of your claims that certain websites supported your preposterous theories about the planes. You failed to answer my objections. Your failure is noted.


Apart from breaking the law on a daily basis, because you will be offending someones dignity, you'll have people like me seeking to track you down and haul you before the courts.


Respectfully, Malcolm, stop making this threat. First of all, I am breaking no law. If you think I am, outline your case. Second of all no one like you is going to track me down and haul me before the courts. The reason I know this is that you are not tracking anyone down and you are not hauling anyone before the courts. You are typing on the internet and nothing else. You haven't contacted a District Attorney. You haven't stood at the grocery store getting names on a petition. You haven't written a letter to the local paper. The biggest crime in history was committed six years ago and you have done nothing about it at all.

So stop with the meaningless threats. You're a grown man. If you have beliefs act on them. That's what grownups do.


Here is proof positive, for those who want to see, of remote control of 757's, it is followed by proof of false flags and then Aaron Russo's excellent film.
http://www.911-strike.com/remote_bb.htm
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...36&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...26&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0


You post one more link, calling it "proof positive" of "remote control of 757s." Of course, a quick look at your link shows it to be the opposite.

The author is Jerry Russell. Nothing on his website lists what, if any, qualifications he may have to determine how 757s may or may not operate. He believes the general "NWO is taking control of the world" nonsense, but I have to say that he is surprisingly moderate and thoughtful in his analysis. Heck, he even subtitles his site with the downright friendly, "A wakeup call for non-violent political action."

Here is what Russell says about remote control on 757s and 767s: it was probably possible but there's no evidence it had ever been done. Here's his most damning statement: "A review of Boeing documentation shows that in fact, the 757/767 flight computer has nearly all of the required capabilities as standard equipment, including guidance, communications, GPS navigation, and traffic control functions."

That's it. They had "nearly all" of the capabilities.

He never waivers from his speculative stance that it might have been possible. Read: "Here we find the solution to the question of how a hijack recovery system could be implemented using a central control facility .... The technology would be implemented using satellite communications links ...." (bolding mine)

At the end of the article, he even adds comments based on objections he's received. Here, he confesses that the fact that 757s and 767s are not "fly by wire" is problematic for his theory:

"I recently received some mail from a reader that pointed out another possible problem for the remote control theory. The 777 was Boeing's first true fly-by-wire design. The 757 and 767 apparently used a mechanical linkage with hydraulic power assist. Although the 757 and 767 are equipped with fully automatic flight controls, the pilot can always over-ride the automatic systems."


And here he does something honestly anazing. He debunks Joe Vialls. You remember poor, dead Joe Vialls. He's one of the people whose article you posted as proof that the planes were flown by remote control. Now another article you post as proof the planes were flown by remote control disagrees with the previous one you posted.

Russell (on whom I'm beginning to kind of have a heterosexual guy crush) says:

Vialls imagines a system where the airplane flies itself regardless of pilot input. But implementation of such a system in the 757/767 would require a complete overhaul of the aircraft control systems, to create a means to disable the mechanical linkage.

It would probably be possible to add a remote control to the 757/767 with software changes only, but such a system would only be effective if the crew (and presumably the hijackers) were somehow disabled or detained or otherwise prevented from wrestling with the yoke to override the computer controls.

This isn't necessarily a fatal objection to remote control theory, but we would need to explain how both the original crew and the hijackers (if any) were prevented from attempting to override the system.


So, Malcolm, once again your article provides zero proof of anything other than what we already knew: No 757 has ever been flown by remote control. Ever.

By all means, respond to me with some worthless threats, a mangled Yiddish phrase and a derail about the 16th Amendment. We know you won't post any actual evidence.
 
UPDATE 5/26/2002
I recently received some mail from a reader that pointed out another possible problem for the remote control theory. The 777 was Boeing's first true fly-by-wire design. The 757 and 767 apparently used a mechanical linkage with hydraulic power assist. Although the 757 and 767 are equipped with fully automatic flight controls, the pilot can always over-ride the automatic systems. Normally this is done by simply disabling the automatic systems, but in any event the mechanical linkage would always allow the pilot to wrestle control by applying sufficient force to the yoke. It would be like driving a car with a power steering pump failure.


Also a discussion here, much of which I don't agree with, but possibly some good info about how the standard control system is designed


Vialls imagines a system where the airplane flies itself regardless of pilot input. But implementation of such a system in the 757/767 would require a complete overhaul of the aircraft control systems, to create a means to disable the mechanical linkage.

It would probably be possible to add a remote control to the 757/767 with software changes only, but such a system would only be effective if the crew (and presumably the hijackers) were somehow disabled or detained or otherwise prevented from wrestling with the yoke to override the computer controls.

This isn't necessarily a fatal objection to remote control theory, but we would need to explain how both the original crew and the hijackers (if any) were prevented from attempting to override the system.

For more on Vialls and the remote control theory, also see my earlier article "New questions on remote control and 9/11".

Malcolm see quotes from your second link that refutes your theory, you have done it again and debunked yourself

The pilot can always overirde the autopilot just by pushing the stick, like cruise control in your car

Myself and another aircraft technician have alreadt told you this is impossible yet you continued to believe Mr Vialls instead of us. Now it seems the guy who qoted Mr Vialls has seen the error of Vialls ways.

you cannot remote control standard 757 or 767 from the ground or from another aircraft, it is impossible, give it up

own goal time sunshine
 
You ans Pomeroo should form a duo, violin and washboard.
Where is the competition now? Is this the best you can muster?
I tell you that remote control of bombers over German occupied France in WW2

Remote control. Of planes. In world war 2 ?

Whatever your reasons for 'govt loyalty', you are on the wrong side.

And once again, the poster formerly known as Malcolm Kirkman confuses the issue by attacking the poster instead of the argument.

I'd like to echo Loss Leader's remark:

The biggest crime in history was committed six years ago and you have done nothing about it at all.
 
Don't deflect attention, Malcolm. We're talking about remote control in 757s and 767s. Don't change the subject to international banking or whatever. It won't work. I posted a lengthy dissection of your claims that certain websites supported your preposterous theories about the planes. You failed to answer my objections. Your failure is noted.





Respectfully, Malcolm, stop making this threat. First of all, I am breaking no law. If you think I am, outline your case. Second of all no one like you is going to track me down and haul me before the courts. The reason I know this is that you are not tracking anyone down and you are not hauling anyone before the courts. You are typing on the internet and nothing else. You haven't contacted a District Attorney. You haven't stood at the grocery store getting names on a petition. You haven't written a letter to the local paper. The biggest crime in history was committed six years ago and you have done nothing about it at all.

So stop with the meaningless threats. You're a grown man. If you have beliefs act on them. That's what grownups do.





You post one more link, calling it "proof positive" of "remote control of 757s." Of course, a quick look at your link shows it to be the opposite.

The author is Jerry Russell. Nothing on his website lists what, if any, qualifications he may have to determine how 757s may or may not operate. He believes the general "NWO is taking control of the world" nonsense, but I have to say that he is surprisingly moderate and thoughtful in his analysis. Heck, he even subtitles his site with the downright friendly, "A wakeup call for non-violent political action."

Here is what Russell says about remote control on 757s and 767s: it was probably possible but there's no evidence it had ever been done. Here's his most damning statement: "A review of Boeing documentation shows that in fact, the 757/767 flight computer has nearly all of the required capabilities as standard equipment, including guidance, communications, GPS navigation, and traffic control functions."

That's it. They had "nearly all" of the capabilities.

He never waivers from his speculative stance that it might have been possible. Read: "Here we find the solution to the question of how a hijack recovery system could be implemented using a central control facility .... The technology would be implemented using satellite communications links ...." (bolding mine)

At the end of the article, he even adds comments based on objections he's received. Here, he confesses that the fact that 757s and 767s are not "fly by wire" is problematic for his theory:

"I recently received some mail from a reader that pointed out another possible problem for the remote control theory. The 777 was Boeing's first true fly-by-wire design. The 757 and 767 apparently used a mechanical linkage with hydraulic power assist. Although the 757 and 767 are equipped with fully automatic flight controls, the pilot can always over-ride the automatic systems."


And here he does something honestly anazing. He debunks Joe Vialls. You remember poor, dead Joe Vialls. He's one of the people whose article you posted as proof that the planes were flown by remote control. Now another article you post as proof the planes were flown by remote control disagrees with the previous one you posted.

Russell (on whom I'm beginning to kind of have a heterosexual guy crush) says:

Vialls imagines a system where the airplane flies itself regardless of pilot input. But implementation of such a system in the 757/767 would require a complete overhaul of the aircraft control systems, to create a means to disable the mechanical linkage.

It would probably be possible to add a remote control to the 757/767 with software changes only, but such a system would only be effective if the crew (and presumably the hijackers) were somehow disabled or detained or otherwise prevented from wrestling with the yoke to override the computer controls.

This isn't necessarily a fatal objection to remote control theory, but we would need to explain how both the original crew and the hijackers (if any) were prevented from attempting to override the system.


So, Malcolm, once again your article provides zero proof of anything other than what we already knew: No 757 has ever been flown by remote control. Ever.

By all means, respond to me with some worthless threats, a mangled Yiddish phrase and a derail about the 16th Amendment. We know you won't post any actual evidence.
Let's do this by the numbers and we'll see who is first to drift off topic.
Your biggest blunder is to misunderstand or misconstrue the bit about pilot over ride.
Russell argues that a problem with remote control would be a pilot (or a hijacker) physically wrestling the controls his way. Thus (albeit sluggishly) retakeing control of the aircraft. I'm sure you would agree with that.
The bit that has passed you by, is that such a case would not arise, if there was no one onboard from the start. Do you agree with that?
 
Malcolm see quotes from your second link that refutes your theory, you have done it again and debunked yourself

The pilot can always overirde the autopilot just by pushing the stick, like cruise control in your car

Myself and another aircraft technician have alreadt told you this is impossible yet you continued to believe Mr Vialls instead of us. Now it seems the guy who qoted Mr Vialls has seen the error of Vialls ways.

you cannot remote control standard 757 or 767 from the ground or from another aircraft, it is impossible, give it up

own goal time sunshine
With regard to the over ride issue, I refer you to my previous post. I hope you will be man enough to acknowledge your error on this point.
 
Oi vey,
Im wondering if a fear of (increased) anti semitism plays a part in your clear refusal to see the truth. Aaron Russo is jewish, as I have already said, there's good and bad in all. Whatever your reasons for 'govt loyalty', you are on the wrong side. There are plenty of jews in the truth movement and they agree with me. The bottom line to all this is pure and simple gangsterism. Gangsterism that has reached into banking and the MSM. If you want to throw yourself under the wheels of justice over these mass murders then carry on. Quite simply, you are wrong.
False flag operations have been going for centuries. My second link will point that out.
Then Aaron Russo's 'From Freedom to Fascism'. One thing the film won't tell you, is that this would be elite can only work if you are skint. The name of their game is to keep everybody skint, then you can find enough semi intelligent people to keep it going. If you want to be two pence half penny looking down on tuppence, then carry on. Apart from breaking the law on a daily basis, because you will be offending someones dignity, you'll have people like me seeking to track you down and haul you before the courts.
At the end of it all, you'll get no thanks from the gangsters and you'll end your days strapped down in a bed somewhere and fed drugs, because it's cheaper to do that than give you regular food.
Here is proof positive, for those who want to see, of remote control of 757's,
it is followed by proof of false flags and then Aaron Russo's excellent film.
http://www.911-strike.com/remote_bb.htm
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...36&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...26&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0


Is that it? For his one post of the night, that's what Malcolm thinks it appropriate to say?

Antisemitic ad hominem innuendo, gangsterism, false flag, would-be elite - then it gets so rabidly confused, I simply give up.

Not even the vaguest attempt to address any of the points he's already tried to bring up, or anybody's replies to them? I think we might preduct imminent melt-down here.

I'm sure I've missed some, but what points did he have in the first place?
  • "Military bad boys" which actually couldn't fly if built to Malcolm's specifications
  • Remote control of jumbo jets, shown to be impossible
  • An i/v infusion that was supposed to prove a picture staged, but which was in fact absolutely normal practice
  • A piece of wreckage in a photograph that didn't appear in a video - except it probably did, as the video was in quite long shot and the debris was only 2 or 3 feet wide
  • The phone calls couldn't possibly have been made - so they were faked to make the scenario more believable! :rolleyes:
  • Voice morphing technology which didn't in fact have anything to do with the music audio gear he kept arguing about, and he doesn't want to talk about Dr. Papcun
  • Telephone calls that must have been faked - but which conveyed information only the passengers themselves could have known
  • Stuff about pillars and lamp posts that doesn't make any remote sort of coherent sense
Not one coherent point that stands up to even the most idle scrutiny. But Malcolm still wants to believe he's "winning" (Malcolm, it's not a game you know), so resorts to bluster and accusations.

Malcolm, if you still believe in this preposterous mountain of improbability, can you not show us, simply and clearly, on what you base that belief?

There's no point just linking to web sites set up by other rabid believers. My old biochemistry professor, talking about written lab reports which might or might not correctly describe what was actually in the sample, said, "paper takes on anything".

He meant, you have to read everything critically and bear in mind that it might not be what it seems. Just as it's possible to pick up a pen and write a lab report saying anything you like, without bothering to analyse the actual sample, you can write any sort of drivel you like, and post it on the Internet.

If I felt like it, I could post a web page saying the earth was flat, or the universe began 6,000 years ago, or Manchester doesn't exist, it's just an illusion created by the NWO in London and Washington. And I could invent or misquote anything I liked to support these assertions. So if anyone came by, looking for evidence to support one of these assertions, hey, here's a good link for him!

And those who have a bit of education and knowledge of the subjects can argue themselves blue in the face, that web page will always be there to be linked to again and again, because it says what's wanted, and hell with any rational evidence that might indicate otherwise.

Have you tried reading any of Gravy's articles? Or even opening the window, taking a deep breath of fresh air, and trying to regain some sort of contact with reality?

Rolfe.
 
With regard to the over ride issue, I refer you to my previous post. I hope you will be man enough to acknowledge your error on this point.

malkie, wrong again

even if you are now claiming that there was not one person onboard the planes it is still impossible to remote control a 757/767 from the ground or other aircraft

apathoid is a aircraft tech, i am an aircraft tech, why do you not believe us when we are the experts and all you have is a dead anti-semite for your supposed evidence who was not an aircraft tech

you have still not acknowledged the fence at column 4 pal?
 
Let's do this by the numbers and we'll see who is first to drift off topic.


And the first to drift off topic, Malcolm, was you.

In case you forgot, here was the topic. Incidentally, it is a topic you personally chose and demanded to talk about, leaving your voice morphing behind:

Here is proof positive, for those who want to see, of remote control of 757's
And again:
Read the links I posted. Both 757's and 767's were pre programmed to be taken over in the event of a hijack and controlled remotely from the ground.... I have posted evidence that both 757's and 767's were so pre programmed that their controls could be taken over from the ground - IN THE EVENT OF A HIJACK.


But you've sensed that the definitive statements you made are losers, so now you are trying to shift focus:


SOMERLED said:
Your biggest blunder is to misunderstand or misconstrue the bit about pilot over ride. Russell argues that a problem with remote control would be a pilot (or a hijacker) physically wrestling the controls his way. Thus (albeit sluggishly) retakeing control of the aircraft. I'm sure you would agree with that. The bit that has passed you by, is that such a case would not arise, if there was no one onboard from the start. Do you agree with that?


Now you just want to get someone to agree that an airplane with hydraulic controls could be flown remotely if there was no one onboards from the start.

But that wasn't your point. Your point, which you stated without qualification, was that 757s and 767s had been flown by remote control. You have drifted off point.

This is exactly the same as your behavior regarding karaoke machines. You stated as a fact that the Japanese have had karaoke machines for decades that automatically corrected the pitch of the singer in real time. When this was questioned and you were unable to support your own statement, you changed it to try to get people to agree that some machine exists somewhere in the world that can change the note A to the note B with some amount of time and effort.

Falling back to a more defensible position is understandable from the view of a person trying to protect his ego from feeling inadequate. However, it doesn't help your point.

But, just to be sociable, I will meet you halfway. If you admit that there is no evidence that a 757 or 767 has ever in all of history been flown by remote control, I'll answer your question about how one might theoretically rig such a thing.

Take advantage of my generosity. I doubt many other posters would extend such an offer.
 
And the first to drift off topic, Malcolm, was you.

In case you forgot, here was the topic. Incidentally, it is a topic you personally chose and demanded to talk about, leaving your voice morphing behind:


And again:



But you've sensed that the definitive statements you made are losers, so now you are trying to shift focus:





Now you just want to get someone to agree that an airplane with hydraulic controls could be flown remotely if there was no one onboards from the start.

But that wasn't your point. Your point, which you stated without qualification, was that 757s and 767s had been flown by remote control. You have drifted off point.

This is exactly the same as your behavior regarding karaoke machines. You stated as a fact that the Japanese have had karaoke machines for decades that automatically corrected the pitch of the singer in real time. When this was questioned and you were unable to support your own statement, you changed it to try to get people to agree that some machine exists somewhere in the world that can change the note A to the note B with some amount of time and effort.

Falling back to a more defensible position is understandable from the view of a person trying to protect his ego from feeling inadequate. However, it doesn't help your point.

But, just to be sociable, I will meet you halfway. If you admit that there is no evidence that a 757 or 767 has ever in all of history been flown by remote control, I'll answer your question about how one might theoretically rig such a thing.

Take advantage of my generosity. I doubt many other posters would extend such an offer.
I quote you,
Now you just want to get someone to agree that an airplane with hydraulic controls could be flown remotely if there was no one onboards from the start.

But that wasn't your point.

That has been my point right from the start as well you know. Your obfuscating tactics ahould be clear to any unbiased observers by now.
You noticed what you thought was the weakest bit = a hijacker might override the remote by brute strength. You used that as an argument, without realising that it was irrelevant, because there were no people on board in the first place. There might have been a fly, perhaps that had enough strength to affect the remote control?
Instead of admitting your clear mistake, you obfuscate some more. This is the bunker mentality par excellence.
With regard to meeting you halfway, I'll dispense with the adjectives in the sure knowledge that the post will be vapourised and simply tell you that there are some people there is no talking to and you are one of them.
If there are any non dyed in the wool neocons reading this thread, then I shall get my remaining points over by answering existing posts and generally ignore the frantic obfuscation I have encountered. I will answer polite and reasonable posts, but that's all.
The well known by now, obfuscating and diversionary tactics might put off the faint hearted but to me, they're water off a duck's back.
I have done two things whilst here. I have got my points across and I have exposed the bunker mentality.
To the unbiased observer, I hope you have noticed the four words I have been empasising, they are CONTRADICTORY, IMPOSSIBLE, IMPLAUSIBLE ANS FRAUDULENT.
Any one of those are grounds for 'probable cause'.
I have no intention of being drawn around in circles by someone who doesn't know the difference between the criminal law and civil law.
I shall get my remaining points out as best as I can and then leave the bunker residents to congratulate each other on what a fine job they're doing.
If there are any unbiasec 'lurkers' who wish to engage in reasonable debate, then it would be a breath of fresh air for me.
 
I quote you,
Now you just want to get someone to agree that an airplane with hydraulic controls could be flown remotely if there was no one onboards from the start.

I have no intention of being drawn around in circles by someone who doesn't know the difference between the criminal law and civil law.
I shall get my remaining points out as best as I can and then leave the bunker residents to congratulate each other on what a fine job they're doing.
If there are any unbiasec 'lurkers' who wish to engage in reasonable debate, then it would be a breath of fresh air for me.

Malcolm could you please make one point. None of us care what that point is but we really are waiting for this devastating proof that you have. You keep promising it could you please present it to us so that we may be proven to be neocon hacks.
 

Due to the nature of the personalities involved, this thread has remained a moderated thread, which is taking up a significant amount of the mod team's time in processing. Unfortunately, the posts being made quite frequently demonstrate that this thread still cannot be taken off moderation.

Since no new material has been presented in here for quite some time, I am closing this thread.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom