When I started scrolling up and my finger got sore before I got to the name of the poster, I somehow knew the post was from you. Is there any chance of a fraction less verbosity? You know what I mean, one thing at a time, if you don't mind.
Stop me if I'm wrong, but you seem to contradict yourself in the one post. Which is a pretty neat (I won't say numb) thing to do.
I quote you,
"... able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track..."
Kindly forgo having to call the machine a Karaoke machine or the £500 donation. Can we just sort out this one point.
Do you or do you not, now agree that it is possible today, to turn an A into a B by using electronics?
Just this one point, if you don't mind.
Look, your attention-span problems are your affair, not mine. Hint: posters names appear to the left of their posts, at the top.
Please explain the internal contradiction in the concept of making "an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track."
Let's try this in baby steps.
The concept of "out-of-tune" means that the pitch of the voice is not where it should be in relation to the accompaniment. Short of the singer actually getting a clue and learning to sing in tune, there are two ways one might approach this problem.
First, one might consider fiddling with the
accompaniment, which after all is the thing one has under control. And indeed MortFurd (I think it was) explained that this trick was actually possible, in that machines had been developed (though more recently than the 1970s) which allow the karaoke operator to vary the key (pitch) of the accompaniment during a performance, to try to compensate for a singer going off-key.
Second, one might conceivably consider leaving the accompaniment alone and fiddling with the
voice. THIS is what you were claiming that the original [TM] karaoke machines could do, automatically, real-time. And which I was specifically asking you to prove.
And this is what you have spent positively
days wriggling and obfuscating and squirming and prevaricating about.
Now about whether or not it is possible to change an A to a B using electronics. Would you mind explaining where you got the idea that I didn't think that was possible? Or where I didn't know that it has been possible for quite a long time?
Of course it's possible, you maroon!! Nobody ever said it wasn't!!
Now would you mind explaining how that possibility has any bearing on whether or not karaoke machines, in the 1970s (or indeed even now so far as I can make out) can change the pitch of the singer's
voice, real-time, so that a note sung out-of-tune emerges from the speakers in-tune relative to the accompaniment?
If you could just put that to bed, we could get back to the fact that no matter what karaoke machines can or can't do, or could or could not do in the 1970s, there is no publicly-available technology even in 2007 that can realistically change one person's voice to sound convincingly and naturally like another person's. Not even if you can take all the time you like about it, and have the sort of money Hollywood film studios can throw at these things.
Malcolm, the only way you can
possibly argue this voice-morphing nonsense is by invoking some sort of sooper-sekrit military technology that
still hasn't made it to the public domain even now, six years later, even though it would be worth a fortune in Hollywood.
Get over it.
Rolfe.