[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Intuitive, from Dictionary.com

1. perceiving by intuition, as a person or the mind.
2. perceived by, resulting from, or involving intuition: intuitive knowledge.
3. having or possessing intuition: an intuitive person.
4. capable of being perceived or known by intuition.


Please don't tell me you think that means the device can perceive what you meant to sing and fix the sung notes. In the world of computers and electronics, "intuitive controls" usually refer to controls whose function is easy for the operator to perceive.
I quote you,
"Please don't tell me you think that means the device can perceive what you meant to sing and fix the sung notes".
That is precisely what I am telling you.
 
. . .
I asked a maths/ science question on here in the first few pages. The answer to which no one got, because the answer wasn't in Wikipedia. Telling me the level of ignorance on here was acute. When I revealed the answer, that was the first time I came across the mass obfuscation and collective bunker mentality exhibited by some on here.


No. You posted the following:

Thank you for that,
Would you care to comment on,

extension in mm = constant
force in Newtons


The following three posts were made nine days later, after you'd repeated the above several times:

Well, no-one else seems to have done so, so I'll bite. There is no such equation. You have made it up. No-one else in the entire history of the world has ever used, or even written down, that equation. This is because it is wrong. In fact, it is not even wrong, it is complete and utter nonsense.

Units of extension are distance (m). Units of force are Newtons (kg.m.s-2. These are not the same thing. What you call an equation is no such thing because the two sides are not equal. That is what the "equa" part of "equation" means.

What you are probably trying to get at is somthing to do with the extension and compression of springs. But that is not what you have actually said. You are entirely correct that the equations involving springs are incredibly simple schoolboy (or girl) equations. But you are apparently not capable of getting them right.

Now, if you will tell me what the actual equation should be and explain what the terms in it mean, perhaps then we can have a reasonable conversation. Until then you are just making yourself look even more ignorant of basic maths and physics than you are of simple English.


. . . It's not just not right - it's not even wrong. That's a nonsensical, meaningless equation you keep asking about.


So you think he's attempting to refer to Hooke's Law? I can just see him there, posting this stuff, furrowing his brow in a vain attempt to understand what it means. MK, you're way out of your league here. You should stick to the softer material, like who knew what and when. Physics is way beyond your grasp.



. . . This also finally occurred to me when Malcolm posted his "equation" for about the 10th time. I think he's trying to state Hooke's LawWP, but I'm not certain whether Malcolm's problem is merely one comprehension, or of both comprehension and expression. He's either trying to say "extension = a constant * force," in which case he's simply gotten the spring constant on the wrong side of the equation and lost a negative sign, or else he's trying to say exactly what his equation states, which means he's also mistaken "a constant * force" for "a constant force." Note that Hooke's Law could be expressed with the spring constant on the other side of the equation and no negative sign, but the constant would have to be the negative multiplicative inverse of the way it's ordinarily stated in physics. . . .


As these quotes make clear, many of us understand Hooke's Law perfectly well. And despite your silly assertion, not only is it explained in Wikipedia, I even linked to the article in my response, for the benefit of those who might not have understood it. Because you used underlining in place of an actual fraction bar, and wrote "constant" where you should have said "a constant," everyone read what you wrote as:

extension in mm = constant force in Newtons

which makes no sense. As was pointed out to you at the time, there are accepted conventions for writing equations, and you didn't follow them. To paraphrase Lord Justice Aldous, you lack the ability to explain the matter so that a scientist, engineer, or technologist can understand it. Don't take my word for it, though--go to a physics forum and ask if the regular posters there find it confusing.


I suppose you are yet another example of someone probing for a weakness in order to then crow about someones perceived shortcomings. A perceived weakness, that has nothing to do with the argument.


:id:


A group of posters on here have all the answers. They are along the lines of
"You can't prove it as with a scientific law, we can always wriggle our way around it. In effect, THERE'S ALWAYS AN ANGLE."


No. You haven't proven anything to any level greater than "remotely possible," and the majority of your claims can't even clear that extremely low hurdle. You have presented no credible evidence for your conspiracy theory about remote-controlled jets from Offutt AFB.

Keep thinking that, I don't mind. Those guns you can hear (my posts on here) aren't really the enemy surrounding you (poll figures). We have an ideology that will rule the world, if only those people would stop their clamouring.
That isn't going to happen, the cat is out of the bag, the jig is up. Now all you've gotta do, is realise that.


Please tell us how many members of the American Society of Civil Engineers are convinced that the September 11 attacks are an "inside job." Then please explain why the over 70,000 full members continue to belong to an organization that would put out a report on the Pentagon attack that you claim is so obviously flawed that even a rank amateur can see it.

In the meantime, I don't mind playing with you like a cat plays with a mouse.



1706046bb0bf9a4a9a.jpg



(Note: The above should not be construed as threatening, advocating, suggesting, or condoning violence against any real person. And no cats or mice were harmed in the creation of this cartoon, Rolfe :D.)

If two large ships were to park themselves in a harbour (with plenty of water under their keels) 50 ft apart, what would eventually happen and why?
Take note, Rolfe will not be one of the first ones to answer, thus confirming the old saying that empty vessels make the most noise.


An answer cannot be determined without a large amount of additional information. I suspect there are some unstated assumptions above; kindly state them. And Rolfe is a veterinarian; expecting her to jump all over a physics question is extremely unfair.
 
Do you or do you not, now agree that it is possible today, to turn an A into a B by using electronics?
Just this one point, if you don't mind.



You do realize, Malcolm, that you've significantly changed what you were saying. You first claimed that karaoke machines could automatically fix a person's voice to fit the tune of the song in real time. Now, you've changed that to say it's possible to turn "A" into "B". In so doing, you've made a correct statement but one that is devoid of meaning. The answer is: "Yes for some As and some Bs but not for every A or every B."

Just the act of singing into a microphone is enough to turn A into B. A is the sound waves produced by a person's voice. The microphone turns those sound waves into electrical impulses. It then turns those impulses back into soundwaves by vibrating a big diaphragm. Before that, Edison's first phonograph in 1877, turned sound waves into movements of a stylus - A was turned to B.

Heck, right now sitting at my desk, I'm turning A into B. The bagel I had for breakfast is becoming the physical motion of typing. And the physical motion of typing is turning (at least partly) into heat.

So by saying that it is possible to turn A into B, you are speaking truth. It's just worthless truth. Here's why it's worthless: the fact that things turn into other things does not make it more likely that one person's voice can turn into another person's voice or even that one person's voice can be pitch-shifted in real time and remain at all convincing as a natural human voice.

See, I am turning A (my bagel) into B (thoughts in your mind) by using electronics (my computer).

No truer words were ever spoken and no less interesting fact was ever stated.

So stop moving the goalposts back to where you think you can defend them. You said that karaoke machines have for decades had the ability to automatically and in real time adjust a person's voice to be in tune with the music. Evidence has been presented that you are wrong. You have presented no evidence that you are right. In addition, the fact that you want us to concede is meaningless.

Admit you were wrong and move on.
 
me said:
Since we have go back to the drawing board - again - can we at least find some thing to agree on and go from there?

-Do you agree that autopilot exists?
-If yes, do you agree that autopilot engagement does not constitute remote control?


I have many more I'd love to ask you, but that'll do for now.

You tell me, what did Raytheon and Boeing do in Aug 2001? The relevant bit, if you don't mind.


I already have told you Malcolm - many, many times.


Oh and the two questions I asked were not rhetorical, please answer them. Because before we go further, I need to know that you understand what autopilot is and that it exists. Once you have confirmed as much, then we'll go a little deeper.....

As it stands right now, it appears that you can not differentiate between autopilot and remote control. And if you can't do that, then you simply are unfit to make the claims that you have..
 
When I started scrolling up and my finger got sore before I got to the name of the poster, I somehow knew the post was from you. Is there any chance of a fraction less verbosity? You know what I mean, one thing at a time, if you don't mind.
Stop me if I'm wrong, but you seem to contradict yourself in the one post. Which is a pretty neat (I won't say numb) thing to do.
I quote you,
"... able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track..."
Kindly forgo having to call the machine a Karaoke machine or the £500 donation. Can we just sort out this one point.
Do you or do you not, now agree that it is possible today, to turn an A into a B by using electronics?
Just this one point, if you don't mind.


Look, your attention-span problems are your affair, not mine. Hint: posters names appear to the left of their posts, at the top.

Please explain the internal contradiction in the concept of making "an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track."

Let's try this in baby steps.

The concept of "out-of-tune" means that the pitch of the voice is not where it should be in relation to the accompaniment. Short of the singer actually getting a clue and learning to sing in tune, there are two ways one might approach this problem.

First, one might consider fiddling with the accompaniment, which after all is the thing one has under control. And indeed MortFurd (I think it was) explained that this trick was actually possible, in that machines had been developed (though more recently than the 1970s) which allow the karaoke operator to vary the key (pitch) of the accompaniment during a performance, to try to compensate for a singer going off-key.

Second, one might conceivably consider leaving the accompaniment alone and fiddling with the voice. THIS is what you were claiming that the original [TM] karaoke machines could do, automatically, real-time. And which I was specifically asking you to prove.

And this is what you have spent positively days wriggling and obfuscating and squirming and prevaricating about.

Now about whether or not it is possible to change an A to a B using electronics. Would you mind explaining where you got the idea that I didn't think that was possible? Or where I didn't know that it has been possible for quite a long time?

Of course it's possible, you maroon!! Nobody ever said it wasn't!!

Now would you mind explaining how that possibility has any bearing on whether or not karaoke machines, in the 1970s (or indeed even now so far as I can make out) can change the pitch of the singer's voice, real-time, so that a note sung out-of-tune emerges from the speakers in-tune relative to the accompaniment?

If you could just put that to bed, we could get back to the fact that no matter what karaoke machines can or can't do, or could or could not do in the 1970s, there is no publicly-available technology even in 2007 that can realistically change one person's voice to sound convincingly and naturally like another person's. Not even if you can take all the time you like about it, and have the sort of money Hollywood film studios can throw at these things.

Malcolm, the only way you can possibly argue this voice-morphing nonsense is by invoking some sort of sooper-sekrit military technology that still hasn't made it to the public domain even now, six years later, even though it would be worth a fortune in Hollywood.

Get over it.

Rolfe.
 
I quote you,
"Please don't tell me you think that means the device can perceive what you meant to sing and fix the sung notes".
That is precisely what I am telling you.

And you would be precisely wrong

again.............
 
I quote you,
"Please don't tell me you think that means the device can perceive what you meant to sing and fix the sung notes".
That is precisely what I am telling you.

Oh, this is just too good. Not only do we have devices that automatically fix anything you put through them, but they are also psychic.

Out here in the real world, it's called an inferiority complex.

No. An inferiority complex would be where someone thinks they are inferior. What you descibe would be a superiority complex. And mine is better than yours.
 
This probably won't do any good, but I'm willing to give it a shot.

Malcolm, I'm a musician. I can tell you that the word "tone" in music can mean one of four things:

A note*.
An interval (specifically, a major second in one of its many forms).
The quality of sound.
A recitation formula in Gregorian chant.

I think we can safely assume that intuitive tone control doesn't mean that someone is controlling seconds, and has nothing to do with plainchant. So it has something to do with the others.

*Here's the thing: a tone meaning note is not used to refer to a pitch. A and B are both tones, but going from one to the other is not "changing the tone". No musician would say that. It's changing the pitch.

Intuitive pitch control could possibly mean what you think intuitive tone control means. But intuitive tone control does not mean changing the pitch. It is controlling the quality of the sound.
 
I'll try again, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?

Three calls in all. Two by airphone, one by cellphone that didn't really connect.
Thank you for that.

Now that that's out of the way:

How do you think they faked those pre-recorded calls and then somehow managed to make it fit the conversation, real-time ?
 
Now, you've changed that to say it's possible to turn "A" into "B". In so doing, you've made a correct statement but one that is devoid of meaning. The answer is: "Yes for some As and some Bs but not for every A or every B."

Just the act of singing into a microphone is enough to turn A into B. A is the sound waves produced by a person's voice. The microphone turns those sound waves into electrical impulses. It then turns those impulses back into soundwaves by vibrating a big diaphragm. Before that, Edison's first phonograph in 1877, turned sound waves into movements of a stylus - A was turned to B


I think I should clarify what Malcolm meant by "A into B". I understood him but I don't think everyone has.

He's talking about musical notes. A is 440HZ I think (haven't looked it up). B is a tone higher.

Rolfe.
 
"Flight 175: As the World Watched" will be shown on the Discovery-Times channel two times on September 11, at 5:00 AM EST and 8:00 AM EST.

Please watch it, tape it, tell your friends about it. You can't truly understand the sheer immorality of people like "Malcolm Kirkman" until you've looked into the faces of the people whose lives were touched by this horrific event.

Thank you pomeroo. I'll program the recorder when I get home tonight.
 
An answer (regarding the ships question) cannot be determined without a large amount of additional information. I suspect there are some unstated assumptions above; kindly state them. And Rolfe is a veterinarian; expecting her to jump all over a physics question is extremely unfair.


Actually, Spitfire, it's quite simple in general terms. Two large ships (such as oil tankers) that are floating sufficiently close will tend to move closer to each other because of their mutual gravitational attraction. I don't know if 50 feet counts as "sufficiently close" to overcome inertial factors though.

I already answered his freaking irrelevant question!!! (Which I suspect has something else to do with some sort of pressure producing gravity though I'm damned if I can see where he's going, the gravity is a function of the mass of the ships.)

And I repeated a few questions I'd been asking him, for a while. Like, do you still think you have to have a BIG hole in the top of a polythene i/v infusion bag to let gravity in before the fluid can tun out through an open tube in the bottom? Do you still maintain there's no gravity inside a TV tube?

And what did I get?

Just as soon as you tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and on what type of phone?


Malcolm, have I ever said a single word about poor Mrs. Olson and her desperate telephone calls? You know, I don't believe I have.

I do know that several others have already told you the answer to that, and you even read the replies, because you repeated the answer in a post of your own. What is this, keep asking every poster the same question till you've got an answer from every single one, even from people who haven't been depating that point at all?

Way to obfuscate, squirm and wriggle, Malcolm.

I think Bruto has the right idea here.

Are you dodging the question, or is your reading comprehension really that sketchy? Are you really incapable of addressing a very simple question? You have asserted that there can be no gravity within a cathode ray tube. My question is simply this, and no other question: do you still assert that there can be no gravity inside a vacuum? Do you still make that assertion? Can you answer that question without obfuscation, digression, insult and irrelevancy?


Seconded. In spades.

Just as Malcolm suddenly squirmed out of the question when I tried to ask it by shooting off at a tangent and asking about Barbara Olson, I propose we reply to his every post with this question of Bruto's.

If we get an answer, or anything approaching an explanation of Malcolm's position on gravity and vacuums (Malcolm, for heaven's sake look at the guinea and feather demonstrations, and/or the footage from the lunar lander....), then perhaps we can progress to other issues.

Rolfe.

PS. Malcolm, Spitfire successfully found me (the real me) on the web site of the institution where I work. So he can confirm that I'm telling the truth about my identity and profession. You really have no idea what you can find out about people on the Internet with only a little effort.
 
This probably won't do any good, but I'm willing to give it a shot.

Malcolm, I'm a musician. I can tell you that the word "tone" in music can mean one of four things:

A note*.
An interval (specifically, a major second in one of its many forms).
The quality of sound.
A recitation formula in Gregorian chant.

I think we can safely assume that intuitive tone control doesn't mean that someone is controlling seconds, and has nothing to do with plainchant. So it has something to do with the others.

*Here's the thing: a tone meaning note is not used to refer to a pitch. A and B are both tones, but going from one to the other is not "changing the tone". No musician would say that. It's changing the pitch.

Intuitive pitch control could possibly mean what you think intuitive tone control means. But intuitive tone control does not mean changing the pitch. It is controlling the quality of the sound.
You think wrong.
 
Oh, this is just too good. Not only do we have devices that automatically fix anything you put through them, but they are also psychic.



No. An inferiority complex would be where someone thinks they are inferior. What you descibe would be a superiority complex. And mine is better than yours.
1. = pre programmed.
2. = wrong again.
 
A is 440HZ I think (haven't looked it up). B is a tone higher.

Rolfe.
[nitpick]440Hz is theoretically concert A (it's been creeping up over the years--it's generally closer to 444Hz these days). It's not quite accurate to say "A is 440Hz" though, as A is also 220Hz, 110Hz, 55Hz, 880Hz and so on.

Interestingly (or perhaps not) an A on the Great Highland Bagpipe is between 470 and 480Hz, which is more than a half-step sharp.

The point being, A (or any other pitch) is a rather nebulous quantity that has changed its specific value over the years. It's more a question of relativity--A is a whole step higher than G and a whole step lower than B--than an absolute pitch. You get quite a different A depending upon which tuning system you're using.[/nitpick]
 
You're talking about me pal, but you're thinking about the others, no doubt yourself as well.
I have admitted mistakes on here. The only one to do so. I continually assert the levels of 'proof' involved. Whereas others demand absolute proof all the time, for every little thing.
Tell me, what form does your 'worry' take? It wouldn't be along the lines of the scam that was pulled on Ezra Pound would it?

By making a series of bold-faced lies, you just killed your one chance at sympathy from me. There were over a hundred eyewitnesses who saw Flight 175 hit the tower, it's up to you to show why they saw that and not the real deal, and provide the supporting evidence. If I accused you of being a warlock, it would be my job to prove it, not your's to prove it wrong.

Also, one last piece of advice. No conspiracy has the power to hide the laws of physics (eg, gravity needing a hole to get in, or steel not being weakened by heat). They are a part of the universe. You would have an easier time putting the sun in a jar and hiding it in your basement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom