[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, you read it again and before you do, look up the meaning of the word 'intuitive'.
Intuitive, from Dictionary.com

1. perceiving by intuition, as a person or the mind.
2. perceived by, resulting from, or involving intuition: intuitive knowledge.
3. having or possessing intuition: an intuitive person.
4. capable of being perceived or known by intuition.


Please don't tell me you think that means the device can perceive what you meant to sing and fix the sung notes. In the world of computers and electronics, "intuitive controls" usually refer to controls whose function is easy for the operator to perceive.
 
But the calls we made in real time. They talked back and forth.

This isn't Mission: Impossible, where everyone reacts in the predicted manner.

I'll try again, how many phone calls did Barbara Olson make and from what type of phone?
 
My post asking you to read an article and offer some serious comment, seems to have passed you by.
Here is the post again. Would you kindly read and (as far as you are able) inwardly digest the contents, so that you might be able to offer reasonable comment?
Hopefully, without your usual and clearly fake assertions that you are somehow 'superior'. Out here in the real world, it's called an inferiority complex.
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html


Er, why did you append this remark to a quote of a post of mine which was entirely about your laughable attempt to pass off a link to an advertisement for a 2007-vintage microphone preamplifier which is not a karaoke machine, does not play a backing track, and does not alter the pitch of the singer's voice, as meeting the challenge I made to you regarding the capabilities of old-style karaoke machines?

Well, never mind.

You obviously failed to notice or read the post in which I addressed the point you make here. For your convenience, here it is again. (The reference to Gravy is that he posted pretty much the same as I did, earlier, but without the links.)

A day late and a dollar short again, Malcolm?

What Gravy is referring to is the thread entitled "On Again Off Again Airfones", which was started on 26th June and has run (so far) for 431 posts, the current last post being made just under 2 days ago. Your obsessive concentration on this one thread is blinding you to the wider discussion on the forum. Here was a thread on something you now reveal as a major plank of your own thesis, running concurrently with this one, and you didn't participate at all. Well, not too late!

Gravy is right, and he's made it easy for you. The earlier part of the thread included a lot of discussion on what turned out to be red herrings (such as a typo that was probably just a printer glitch, and the oddity of two revision dates being the same date several years apart and both being Sundays, simply being explained by an automated revision programme). The real meat starts well into the thread, indeed at post 378.

Why should we repeat everything for you, when you can't be bothered to participate in other relevant threads? I keep telling you you should get out more.

Rolfe.


I for one don't intend to recapitulate everything said in that thread (which I only posted in once, but followed closely), just because Malcolm can't be bothered to get out more. In my opinion further discussion of this point, which seems to be a long way away from the original topic of this thread (Flight 175 and the South Tower), would be better pursued in that thread. However, if we're going to go on about it here, then can we at least take on board where we got to already?

Rolfe.
 
My pleasure,
If there is air around a planet, then that planet will attract that air and cause air pressure. In just the same way you have sea pressure.
In fact you live in a sea of air, in much the same way that fish live in the sea.
I asked a maths/ science question on here in the first few pages. The answer to which no one got, because the answer wasn't in Wikipedia. Telling me the level of ignorance on here was acute. When I revealed the answer, that was the first time I came across the mass obfuscation and collective bunker mentality exhibited by some on here.

Thats a lie Malcolm and one that can be easily checked by anyone having the stamina to wade through your nonsense from the beginning. Several people realised you were naggign about Hooks Law, explained Hooks Law to you, explained a lot of things really. People even figuers out that the erason your version of Hooks Law didnt make any sense was because you copy-pasted a html formated version of the equation, which lost its formatting in the process and thus lacked all readability.

So Malcolm, when will you take your "loadsa dosh" and pay up the 1000$ you owe to a certain charity? That would be a good thing to do before accusing others of skipping out on their bets, don't you think Malcolm?
 
I find your habit of quoting an entire post then responding to only a tiny part of it, or even none, or perhaps an entirely different post, to be disconcerting, however I try to follow you.




I said absolutely no such thing. Please quote, with link, the post where you think I said such a thing.

You should know all about sliding around (I won't say "sliding out", because I haven't actually noticed you getting out of anything) when shown to be wrong. Currently, you're behaving like the Andrex puppy on an ice rink.




What I knew about such machines is irrelevant. At least I had the sense to Google the history of karaoke to see for myself whether your astonishingly improbable claims had any basis in fact - to find, of course, that they hadn't. You yourself appear to have had a vague and mistaken idea of what old-style karaoke machines could do, and not even to have attempted to verify this before sounding off on the subject.

Of course it's possible to change an A to a B electronically. It's much easier to do in these modern days of digital audio, and before then the simple way was of course to speed up the tape or the turntable. However, one of the first things I discovered when checking to see what old-style karaoke machines could actually do was that they incorporated a more sophisticated system for altering the pitch of the backing track while maintaining the original tempo, to allow participants to choose the key they wanted the song played in so that its tessitura suited the range of their voice. Fancy that.

However, it's perfectly clear that they did not (and as far as I can see still do not) alter the pitch of the singer's voice, which is what you were claiming. You were wrong. Time to try to get off the ice rink.




Please quote, with link, the exact post in which I said that air pressure does not neeed gravity.

I didn't say that, and you won't find me saying it, because it's not true. In just the same way that I didn't say that a machine cannot alter an A to B without speeding up the track. Misquoting an opponent and then attacking the misquote is the oldest and most blatant form of the "straw man" fallacy - look it up.

What I said, in fact, was that gravity has nothing to do with air pressure. In context, in the discussion of the Schiehallion experiment, that statement was unambigious. Out of context, some ambiguity might arise as the "has nothing to do with" phraseology is perhaps not inevitably a one-way-street. I therefore clarified the statement to read "gravity is not dependent on air pressure". I further clarified that air (well, atmospheric) pressure is of course dependent on gravity.

Why are you still having trouble with this concept, Malcolm? You're only making yourself look increasingly stupid and increasingly dishonest with this line of argument.

Your entire argument with the i/v infusions and the necessity for a BIG hole "to let gravity in" was that GRAVITY is dependent on AIR PRESSURE. You compounded this with your ludicrous assertions about TV tubes. It has been shown to you countless times that gravity is ENTIRELY INDEPENDENT OFair or atmospheric pressure. Have you got that yet? Constant attempts to avoid admitting it by "squirming" and trying to imply that anyone was suggesting that atmospheric pressure is independent of gravity are only making you look worse and worse.




You might at least get the guy's name right!

What do you know about my relationship with Alex Salmond or anyone in the SNP government? What do you know about anything I'm trying to "force down their throats"? Come on, Malcolm, this sounds like absolutely magnificent gossip, and I'm sure everyone would be thrilled to bits if you shared it!




Does anyone at all have any idea what Malcolm is on about here? If so, would they mind posting a translation?

What happened in Japan in the early 1970s, Malcolm, was that someone had the idea of recording just the backing track alone, so that it could be played through the sound system, allowing anyone who wanted to to sing along with it. (A similar, though independent, idea that came along at about the same time was "music minus one", tapes of classical performances without the solo part to allow performers to rehearse without needing a live accompanist.)

A neat extra trick the karaoke system incorporated was the ability to vary the pitch of the playback of the backing track, to allow singers to choose the key that best suited their vocal range. A feature you appear to have entirely misunderstood.

MortFurd (I think it was) patiently explained to you that a later development of this feature allowed the pitch of the playback to be manually varied during the performance, to compensate for the singer going off-key. However, this was
  • not a feature of the original machines
  • not automatic, it had to be done by someone twiddling a knob
  • and it didn't alter the pitch of the singer's voice
Thus it was almost entirely irrelevant to your completely, totally and comprehensively wrong assertion that the original karaoke [TM] machines were able to shft wrongly-pitched notes to the correct pitch, in real-time, by altering the singer's voice.

So let's look again at exactly what I said, which you seem entirely unable to comprehend.




You have provided precisely NO, ZERO, ZILCH evidence that the machines could do this. For the simple reason that they couldn't. Linking to web pages about modern machines (which still can't do it!) won't cut it. Repeating your original assertion, with no evidence, won't cut it.

If we're getting into accusations of bet-welching, may I (with the mods' permission) please recap the background to this for new readers. Somewhere far, far back in the thread, Malcolm asserted that President Bush's location in a primary school classroom when the news of the Twin Towers attacks came through was planned in advance for publicity purposes, because the President and his advisors knew about the attacks in advance (and had planned them). In the course of this argument, he asserted that the visit on 11th September 2001 was the first time President Bush had visited a primary school since becoming president. (Not actually all that unlikely since he'd only been president for about eight months at the time, but not, as it happens, true.)

Malcolm declared that if anyone could find evidence of Bush, as President, having visited a primary school for a photo-op with the children before 11th September 2001, he would donate $1,000 to the charity of that poster's choice. (This was while Malcolm was still maintaining his persona as a "retired businessman with loadsa dosh", before that was comprehensively busted.) I can't remember who got in first, but the thread was promptly inundated with photos of Bush grinning inanely at the camera surrounded by his intellectual peers, with various dates between January and early September 2001. It was quite startling just how many of these visits he had in fact made.

A charity was named, and a practical way to allow Malcolm to make his donation and have this verified to the winner of the bet was devised.

Malcolm simply refused to pay. He'd changed his mind. He had better things to do with his money.

Now nobody would have insisted that Malcolm was honour bound to pay if all that could be found were pictures of President Bush visiting an old folks' home, in 2006! Which is about comparable with what he's produced in response to my challenge (links to modern digital instruments which have nothing to do with 1970s or 1980s karaoke machines, and in fact aren't even karaoke machines at all!).

I'd certainly pay up if he could meet the terms of my challenge. Which he can't. But the terms of his challenge were met. Comprehensively and overwhelmingly. Malcolm, I suggest you reconsider your decision not to pay up on that one before you even think about accusing anyone of bet-welching.

Hey, Malcolm thinks I'm the leader of you lackeys! Whaddaya think of that, then?

Rolfe.
When I started scrolling up and my finger got sore before I got to the name of the poster, I somehow knew the post was from you. Is there any chance of a fraction less verbosity? You know what I mean, one thing at a time, if you don't mind.
Stop me if I'm wrong, but you seem to contradict yourself in the one post. Which is a pretty neat (I won't say numb) thing to do.
I quote you,
"... able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track..."
Kindly forgo having to call the machine a Karaoke machine or the £500 donation. Can we just sort out this one point.
Do you or do you not, now agree that it is possible today, to turn an A into a B by using electronics?
Just this one point, if you don't mind.
 
There's also the famous footage from Apollo 15 when astronaut Dave Scott held a feather in one hand and a hammer in the other and then let them go at the same time. Both the feather and the hammer hit the moon's surface at exactly the same time.

Unless, of course, one wants to claim the Apollo lunar landings were faked. But even then one has to come up with the method by which they faked that moment...


Here ya go.


Oh, seriously cool! I didn't remember him doing that. Thanks, guys!

Rolfe.
 
She made at least two, because Ted Olson (at least get the spelling right) received two collect calls from her. They were made via Airphone. See the 9/11 Commission report, page 455:

There was also a failed call to the DOJ, where Ted Olson worked, at 9:18. Perhaps that was Olson trying to use her cell phone. That information is in the Moussaoui trial documents.

Now, let's look at what the frauds David Ray Griffin and Rob Balsamo say about making a collect call using one of the on-board phones. From your link:

And the footnote to that claim:



Oh, really? You'd better check that link. On the same page are instructions for calling toll free for dialing assistance:

"For customer service regarding dialing assistance, country codes and directory assistance from the aircraft dial toll free 12#. This will connect you to AIRCOM Customer Service Center. You will not be charged for this call."

What hideous liars. But wait: there's more! When you went to that page about AA phones, what did you see? That's right: the system Griffin and Balsamo base their claims on wasn't even the system in use on 9/11, which was the GTE Airfone.

Okay, so was operator assistance available with the GTE service? Of course it was. Todd Beamer on flight 93 spoke to the GTE operator, Lisa Jefferson, for 19 minutes.

"He told me that he had dialed zero to report his plane was being hijacked," she said. http://www.s-t.com/daily/09-02/09-10-02/a02wn022.htm

On AA 11, Betty Ong called AA, toll free:

"As the hijacking unfolded, Ong punched the number 8 on a seatback GTE Airfone"
http://www.boston.com/news/packages/underattack/news/planes_reconstruction.htm

Malcolm, why do you refuse to seek reliable sources for answers to your questions? Why instead do you rely on nasty, lying idiots for your information? And when you demand that we respond to the liars, and we do so with accurate information, why do you throw a tantrum?
Three calls in all. Two by airphone, one by cellphone that didn't really connect.
Thank you for that.
 
After all the posts on here, you now bring in auto pilot.
It is clear to me that you people on here are intent on rolling matters around in circles until serious people get exasperated and leave. Then you'll all have yourselves a back slapping session, not unlike the situation in the last fascist bunker in Berlin in 1945.


Is that supposed to be a joke? Do you have anterograde grade memory loss or something? Are you reading my replies, at all? I must explained this neat system on airplanes called autopilot at least a dozen times, the first mention being 5 weeks ago in reply 2206......now you pretend that it hasn't been mentioned and are accusing us of running you around in circles?



Clearly, I must be missing something. Here is my summary of where we stand on the Raytheon issue:

1. Malcolm accuses Raytheon of turning airliners into remote controlled drones, implying that their system was guiding whatever hit the twin towers.

2. Malcolm "supports" this claim with press releases and articles explaining the testing done on a military landing guidance system called JPALS. Some are legit and some completely butcher the facts.

3. Myself and several others explain that JPALS is simply a replacement of the existing ILS system and will use the aircrafts own autopilot, along with GPS signals from the landing station, to guide the airplane to an automatic landing.

4. Malcolm insists that Raytheon system is remote control.

5. See 3.

6. See 4.

7. See 5.

8. See 6.

9. See 7.

8. Malcolm states that if a pilots hands are off the controls, the plane is being remote controlled.

9. Myself and funk de fino, again, tell Malcolm about autopilot - this time using pictures, videos, and definitions.

10. Malcolm pretends this is the first time anyone mentions autopilot and accuses of.....something.


Did I miss something? Has Malcolm debunked the existence of autopilot?
 
Hopefully, without your usual and clearly fake assertions that you are somehow 'superior'. Out here in the real world, it's called an inferiority complex.


Oops, missed this bit.

Malcolm, would you please quote exactly, and link to, any post where I asserted that I was "superior"? Whether fake or not?

Like I'm quoting and linking to this vainglorious post of yours.

Over 50 retired businessman with an honours degree in law, loadsa dosh, only learnt the truth about 9/11 when I retired about 6 months ago. Now I listen to Alex Jones everyday and support Ron Paul to the hilt. Can't wait for the proper clean up to start. I hope it doesn't get to violence, but if it does, ce la vie.


A more blatant attempt to assert superiority would be hard to find. Also, a more fake one would be hard to find, as was so decisively proved later.

Still want to impress us with your grasp of French, Malcolm?

Do you have a problem with my mentioning that I'm a veterinary surgeon, in the context of "that's why I might possibly know how i/v infusions are normally given"? Do you have a problem with fls mentioning that she's a doctor, in the same context? Or the other people who have revealed their occupations as evidence that they knew what they were talking about in certain matters?

It's really, really, interesting that you seem to be interpreting these commonplace remarks as "assertions that [the posters] are somehow superior".

I think we can easily see the inferiority complex here.

Rolfe.
 
If I am a liar, then so are Raytheon. They said it first, why don't you take the matter up with them.



:hb:


....Before you do, I suggest you read the relevant articles, instead of firing off half cocked


:brk:


Since we have go back to the drawing board - again - can we at least find some thing to agree on and go from there?

-Do you agree that autopilot exists?
-If yes, do you agree that autopilot engagement does not constitute remote control?


I have many more I'd love to ask you, but that'll do for now.
 
Does Malcolm remind anyone else of Baghdad Bob? "There are no American Tanks in Baghdad!"

Over here we called him "comical Ali". And yes. Malcolm does have the air of "We are achieving victory in the war aganist the american crusaders" about him.
 
Thank you, you say she made two calls. Will you now kindly tell me on what type of phone?

Open your fripping eyes and read, man. Gravy already told you.
57. The records available for the phone calls from American 77 do not allow for a determination of which of four "connected calls to unknown numbers" represent the two between Barbara and Ted Olson, although the FBI and DOJ believe that all four represent communications between Barbara Olson and her husband's office (all family members of the Flight 77 passengers and crew were canvassed to see if they had received any phone calls from the hijacked flight, and only Renee May's parents and Ted Olson indicated that they had received such calls).The four calls were at 9:15:34 for 1 minute, 42 seconds; 9:20:15 for 4 minutes, 34 seconds; 9:25:48 for 2 minutes, 34 seconds; and 9:30:56 for 4 minutes, 20 seconds. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Helen Voss, Sept. 14, 2001;AAL response to the Commission's supplemental document request, Jan. 20, 2004.

58. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001.
Do you just have Gravy on ignore, or what?
 
In the meantime, I don't mind playing with you like a cat plays with a mouse. If two large ships were to park themselves in a harbour (with plenty of water under their keels) 50 ft apart, what would eventually happen and why?
Take note, Rolfe will not be one of the first ones to answer, thus confirming the old saying that empty vessels make the most noise.


Oh no, Malcolm, you go first.
  • Do you need a BIG hole in the top of a polythene bag to let the gravity in before it will empty through a tube leading from the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a cathode ray (old-style TV) tube?
  • What might be a viable source of gravity?
You now appear to be indicating that you do indeed understand that gravity is a property of mass, not of atmospheric pressure. So just to confirm that, would you kindly just answer these questions above, which I might point out have been asked of you before, with no rational answer being forthcoming.

[Just to be sociable, I'll remark that the world and its auntie know that two large ships afloat and close enough together will be pulled closer by their mutual gravitational attraction. That such ships possess significant gravitational fields was discovered after investigations of marine accidents in which sailors' accounts of ships moving together for no readily apparent reason were initially regarded as excuses. I don't know off-hand if 50 feet is close enough to overcome inertial factors however.]

Now, Malcolm, would you mind explaining to us in precisely what way you think this little factoid supports your position? (Actually explaining your position, as opposed to posting increasingly non-sequitur comments and questions, might be nice, too.)

Rolfe.
 
First of all, Malcolm, you utterly ignored my last post to you. That was where I explained again that everything you had said about police behavior was wrong and that you were using the phrase "probable cause" incorrectly.

But, as is your habit, you've moved on without acknowledging your error. Instead, you've made a new error:


When you do step out into the real world, there will be someone like me holding you to account before the law.


What do you mean by this? In what way could anyone on this board be held to account before the law? What do you mean when you say we will be held to account? To which law are you referring? How is there any legal liability for an uninvolved bystander who expresses an opinion?

Moreover, there are some of us posting here who have stepped out into the real world. Gravy, for example, does nothing to hide his identity. His real name and email address are widely available and are easily found by following this link. In fact, here's a whole page of people who debunk conspiracists like yourself.

So, you have issued a challenge: someone like you will hold us to account before the law if we reveal ourselves. Gravy and others have revealed themselves. I'm pretty sure that with enough notice, Gravy will willingly present himself at any public place in New York City. Go to it! Hold them to account before the law!

Of course, you won't. Just like you won't contact the family of 9/11 victims, you are knowingly lying. For you, this is a fun little computer game with fairly sophisticated AI. You don't really care. You could prove me wrong, but you won't.
 
Oh no, Malcolm, you go first.
  • Do you need a BIG hole in the top of a polythene bag to let the gravity in before it will empty through a tube leading from the bottom?
  • Is there gravity inside a cathode ray (old-style TV) tube?
  • What might be a viable source of gravity?
You now appear to be indicating that you do indeed understand that gravity is a property of mass, not of atmospheric pressure. So just to confirm that, would you kindly just answer these questions above, which I might point out have been asked of you before, with no rational answer being forthcoming.

[Just to be sociable, I'll remark that the world and its auntie know that two large ships afloat and close enough together will be pulled closer by their mutual gravitational attraction. That such ships possess significant gravitational fields was discovered after investigations of marine accidents in which sailors' accounts of ships moving together for no readily apparent reason were initially regarded as excuses. I don't know off-hand if 50 feet is close enough to overcome inertial factors however.]

Now, Malcolm, would you mind explaining to us in precisely what way you think this little factoid supports your position? (Actually explaining your position, as opposed to posting increasingly non-sequitur comments and questions, might be nice, too.)

Rolfe.
Just as soon as you tell me how many phone calls Barbara Olson made and on what type of phone?
 
:hb:





:brk:


Since we have go back to the drawing board - again - can we at least find some thing to agree on and go from there?

-Do you agree that autopilot exists?
-If yes, do you agree that autopilot engagement does not constitute remote control?


I have many more I'd love to ask you, but that'll do for now.
You tell me, what did Raytheon and Boeing do in Aug 2001? The relevant bit, if you don't mind.
 
My pleasure,
If there is air around a planet, then that planet will attract that air and cause air pressure. In just the same way you have sea pressure.
In fact you live in a sea of air, in much the same way that fish live in the sea.
I asked a maths/ science question on here in the first few pages. The answer to which no one got, because the answer wasn't in Wikipedia. Telling me the level of ignorance on here was acute. When I revealed the answer, that was the first time I came across the mass obfuscation and collective bunker mentality exhibited by some on here.
I suppose you are yet another example of someone probing for a weakness in order to then crow about someones perceived shortcomings. A perceived weakness, that has nothing to do with the argument.
A group of posters on here have all the answers. They are along the lines of
"You can't prove it as with a scientific law, we can always wriggle our way around it. In effect, THERE'S ALWAYS AN ANGLE."
Keep thinking that, I don't mind. Those guns you can hear (my posts on here) aren't really the enemy surrounding you (poll figures). We have an ideology that will rule the world, if only those people would stop their clamouring.
That isn't going to happen, the cat is out of the bag, the jig is up. Now all you've gotta do, is realise that.
In the meantime, I don't mind playing with you like a cat plays with a mouse. If two large ships were to park themselves in a harbour (with plenty of water under their keels) 50 ft apart, what would eventually happen and why?
Take note, Rolfe will not be one of the first ones to answer, thus confirming the old saying that empty vessels make the most noise.

For a complete non answer that's a lot of words, and nonsensical ones at that. Are you dodging the question, or is your reading comprehension really that sketchy? Are you really incapable of addressing a very simple question? You have asserted that there can be no gravity within a cathode ray tube. My question is simply this, and no other question: do you still assert that there can be no gravity inside a vacuum? Do you still make that assertion? Can you answer that question without obfuscation, digression, insult and irrelevancy?

It is very difficult to take seriously the complex and detailed arguments of somebody who cannot make a simple, clear statement about something as simple as that. You demand too much if you expect others to believe you are right about large and highly technical subjects when you repeatedly demonstrate that you cannot understand a simple question about a simple fact of everyday physics. If you can't even understand the question, how are we ever to know if you can understand the answer, and if you cannot understand one thing, why on earth should we believe you can understand anything else?

I would not hire a carpenter who held up a hammer and said "this is a chisel and I know more about chisels than anybody else." I am not arguing to your conspiracy theory here. It's far too early for that as far as I am concerned. I am exploring a basic question of competence.
 
Oops, missed this bit.

Malcolm, would you please quote exactly, and link to, any post where I asserted that I was "superior"? Whether fake or not?

Like I'm quoting and linking to this vainglorious post of yours.




A more blatant attempt to assert superiority would be hard to find. Also, a more fake one would be hard to find, as was so decisively proved later.

Still want to impress us with your grasp of French, Malcolm?

Do you have a problem with my mentioning that I'm a veterinary surgeon, in the context of "that's why I might possibly know how i/v infusions are normally given"? Do you have a problem with fls mentioning that she's a doctor, in the same context? Or the other people who have revealed their occupations as evidence that they knew what they were talking about in certain matters?

It's really, really, interesting that you seem to be interpreting these commonplace remarks as "assertions that [the posters] are somehow superior".

I think we can easily see the inferiority complex here.

Rolfe.
Why don't you go the whole hog and identify yourself properly?
 
Oh dear, it seems as if Malcolm still hasn't got it about the "Studiomaster" thingie.

You owe the charity of my choice £500 pal.
Three little words, 'intuitive tone control'.
http://www.studiomaster.com/vms.html


MortFurd actually explained this device more clearly than I did.

Read the bleeding site, Somerled. That "intuitive tone control" relates to the 7 band equalizer that brackets the voice range. "Intuitive," because some of the controls are marked in simple words for non-technical people. Such as the microphone gain selector - it's marked from "soft" to "loud" instead of having the gain marked in dB.

The DSP functions are simple ones, mostly related to chorus and echo.

It's a freaking microphone pre-amplifier with a few useful (industry standard) DSP tricks integrated. It's marketed at people who don't have much understanding of the technology.

It is a FAR cry from being a voice morpher. Heck, it doesn't even HAVE a pitch shift function. Guess why? It'd sound like $$%#$^, and the point of this device is to make it easier for the singer to sound good.


But Malcolm shows no evidence of even having read that, much less understood it.

This is the last time I'll correct you. The argument about which you have posted, involves a machine that can automatically turn an A into a B in real time. Your ability to get it wrong and then crow about it is a measure of the bunker mentality on here....


Why don't you go back and read the web site again? It says bloody zip about pitch changing.


No, you read it again and before you do, look up the meaning of the word 'intuitive'.


Malcolm, just to start with, two other tiny little points, in relation to your claim that this bit of kit somehow meets the challenge I posed you.
  • First, this isn't a karaoke machine. It doesn't play the backing track.
  • Second, it's a modern digital piece of kit, not a 1970s or 80s instrument.
But really, the most important thing about it in the context of your argument is that
  • IT DOES NOT ALTER THE PITCH OF THE NOTE!!!
Some of the kiddies' toys you linked to earlier did claim to be able to do that, though as other posters remarked, the quality of the result was bloody awful, and the toys were pretty irrelevant to your arguments about sophisticated "voice morphing" technology.

However, the "Studiomaster" thing DOESN'T DO THAT!!!!

"Intuitive tone control" means what MortFurd says it means. As both of us already explained to you. "Intuitive", as in, easy for a non-techie person to operate. As in "Windows is an intuitive user interface". (Debatable, I know, but the example will serve.) Tone control, as in - well, tone controls. Bass and treble controls at the most basic, though in this case the thing has a graphic equaliser.

So, it means "easy-to-operate graphic equaliser".

Wow.

You can come on and assert that no it doesn't, it means that the machine "can automatically turn an A into a B in real time" till you're blue in the face, but that doesn't make it so. Any more than asserting that there's no gravity inside a TV tube makes it so.

Does the absence of the word "pitch" possibly have any relevance to this matter? ("Intonation" does indeed imply pitch, but "tone" doesn't. As the pdf of the brochure explains, the vendors mean that the thing can make the voice sound "sweeter".)

Malcolm, you've claimed on someone's blog page to have some sort of connection to music. Drummer, even. And to have worked with someone who appears to be a singer of some sort. Victor Brox. Why don't you ask him about electronic instruments that can correct the pitch of an out-of-tune singer, and see what he says?

Rolfe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom