[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it's time to get this post of Malcolm's from P911T on the record in this thread, for the benefit of everyone reading, and for those still posting. For the moment I'll let it speak for itself. Here's the link to the Google cache of the thread is here. It's called "Nothing To Beat On the govt loyalist site, Going on the offensive." Malcolm started it on July 20.


malcolm kirkman said:
NOTHING TO BEAT ON the govt loyalist site.
There’s absolutely nothing to beat on J R E F or any other denier’s website.
It’s way past the time when we should be in amongst these deniers and cleaning their clocks.
You have the truth on your side, you play a Royal flush every hand you put down.
Wherever you start with these people, the response to you will be the same. Paragraph after paragraph of personal attacks and rubbishing of what you say. They’ll drop on you like a pack of dogs. Just weather that storm and then you’ll be able to bring in the calls for a proper investigation.
Why are they opposed to a new and proper investigation? What are they frightened of?
They can only respond with,
“There’s been an investigation and if you don’t like it, hard luck”.
You then come back with something along the lines of,
“That investigation said that this plane went through this hole. Which I have shown to be impossible.”
Just keep going then on why the govt won’t order a new investigation, when so many people want one. Deniers have no answer to that.
Neither do they have an answer to this report that has been sent to the Congress detailing that OKC was also an inside job.
http://independence.net/okc/congressbombreport.htm
I’ve had touching 35,000 views and 3,000 posts and they are now dead in the water. That’s after being moderated from very early doors and now being denied the ability to post photos. The best way to weather the storm they will first throw at you, is with one liners. Don’t allow yourself to be exhausted with long explanations, that is one of their tactics, respond with one liners or little more.
Get in there and take the fight to them.
The truth is that the BushCo/neocon cabal is shrinking and with a bit of help from us the rats will soon start deserting the sinking ship.
Get in amongst them and let them know no peace. This is a prerequisite to breaking them up and winning this battle. Justice will then surely follow, as night follows day.
 
Here is the Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/
Not only did you totally ignore that, but in your very next post you wrote and I quote again,
"You haven't gotten ONE THING right since you showed up on this forum.
Really. Not a SINGLE THING".


Your desperation is showing, Malcolm. You repost an article from 1999 that explains how a speech could be cobbled together--as I wrote in my previous post. OBVIOUSLY, I DID NOT "IGNORE" IT.

You know what "ignore" means," Malcolm? It's what you do with all inconvenient data.

Do you recall the reference to George Papcun in the article you posted? He's the guy who has been gracious enough to explain this voice-morphing stuff to me. Griffin lied in his latest book, just as you are lying now, and I intend to expose him, just as I have exposed you.

IT IS NOT POSSIBLE FOR ANY EXISTING TECHNOLOGY TO "MORPH" VOICES TO ENABLE A CONVERSATION.

IT CANNOT BE DONE.
 
Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/WTC%20construction/normal_trident16.jpg


Fascinating. You are incapable of comprehending the definition of "corrugated," so you post a photo of steel that is NOT corrugated.

You are outdoing yourself, Malcolm.

Corrugated: adj 1. folded into parallel ridges and troughs 2. made from a corrugated material

Malcolm, the steel at the World Trade center was NOT corrugated. Nobody sane thinks it was. Stop it--just stop it.
 
Last edited:
By the shrill almost desperate tone of some recent posts, I am clearly making the neocons on here rattled.
I'm happy to report that in real life, the neocons are even more rattled.
Third vid from the bottom,
Senate Judiciary Cmte on the firing of U S Attorneys.
http://www.c-span.org/videoarchives.asp?CatCodePairs=Current_Event,Congress&ArchiveDays=30


Dismissing the drivel you've linked to as totally irrelevant to the jihadist attacks of 9/11, we can assume that you acknowledge that your falsehoods have been exposed.

You've had your clock cleaned again, Malcolm.

You don't have the slightest idea of what a neocon is.

You still haven't gotten a single thing right.
 
malcolm kirkman said:
I’ve had touching 35,000 views and 3,000 posts and they are now dead in the water. That’s after being moderated from very early doors


Good Lord, he is like Kumar! Beaten to a pulp, and boasting about how many views his thread's had!

This thread, like Kumar's and most of the others, has about the usual posts/views ratio. Malcolm hasn't figured how many "views" posters themselves generate, simply by returning to the thread, and looking up stuff, and linking to previous lies when Malcolm once again boasts about his committment to the "Truth" (hey, how do you do the TM thingie?) I suppose there are some lurkers, but if he thinks 35,000 people are hanging on his every word, he's - well, about as right as he usually is.

Then there's the posts. His own, almost exactly a third of the posts in the thread. And the other two-thirds, that would be where he's been beaten to a pulp. And exposed as a vainglorious liar. And stuff like that.

And the moderation, which was originally put in place to protect him from kitten pictures and recipies and well-deserved abuse, did he but realise it.

I'm not Gravy. I haven't studied the details of this. I was waiting for Malcolm to present his case, and see whether I thought it made any sense. I don't think he's said a single word of sense since he began. And I think Gravy should be canonised. (And I love the avatar, by the way.)

Rolfe.
 
Is it time, yet, to invoke the :socks: used with the immortalized Christophera?

Basically, one and only one discussion point is allowed on the table at a time (posed by whomever has the :socks:), Malcolm's attempts to dodge and weave are disregarded until the point is addressed.

I can't propose this directly to Malcolm, because he has me on ignore. But, then again, since transitive verbs do not exist according to Malcolm, I could not propose the plan, anyway, I guess.


Malcolm won't agree anyway, but the rest of us can. Christopera was banned before I started posting here, and I'd just as soon not torture myself by reading that entire thread (I've read snippets), so please tell me how this would work exactly.
 
Mal, please, not the ol' voice "morphing" nonsense.

Besides, even if it were possible to create one side of a live conversation such that it sounds like the voice of someone else, it is in no way, shape, or form evidence that such a thing transpired on 9/11 or any other time. Proof of that would entail providing...proof.

Really now.
 
Malcolm said:
NOTHING TO BEAT ON the govt loyalist site.


Can I just officially object to being called a government loyalist? I can't stand George Bush. I think he's the worst President in our nation's history. I think he's a moron and I strongly suspect that he cannot read. His manipulation of a real terrorist threat to pursue his insane war against one of the only nations in the Middle East we're sure didn't participate in 9/11 is, in my opinion, criminal in every legal and political sense of the word. He has killed more people for less reason than any other leader in our nation and that includes Jefferson Davis. I hate George Bush so much that I hate George Bush for even having George Bush, and I never really minded George Bush.

Do the Truthers really think that the only way we could believe what we do is if we're so blinded by ideology that we refuse to see their side? It is possible to examine evidence, weigh probabilities and test theories without being a partisan.

Here endeth the rant.
 
I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.


Erm, Malcolm, what's your point here? Are you saying that I'm wrong about how angle of incidence is measured, and that I'm trying to hide the fact? Or are you saying that I'm nitpicking your "argument?"
 
I think it's time to get this post of Malcolm's from P911T on the record in this thread, for the benefit of everyone reading, and for those still posting. For the moment I'll let it speak for itself. Here's the link to the Google cache of the thread is here. It's called "Nothing To Beat On the govt loyalist site, Going on the offensive." Malcolm started it on July 20.


Everything Malcolm has stated has been thoroughly refuted.


He has told many absurd lies and all of them have been exposed.


The title of the thread makes the insane claim that Flight 175 did not hit the South Tower.

Thousands of eyewitnesses observed Flight 175 hit the South Tower.

Wreckage of the aircraft was found.

Remains of the passengers were identified.

Air traffic controllers from Boston and New York tracked the plane's progress very closely.

To all of these FACTS, Malcolm opposes a fantastic and utterly baseless fabrication about imaginary "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB.

Isn't it long past time to bring down the curtain on a rotten show?
 
malcolm kirkman said:
Neither do they have an answer to this report that has been sent to the Congress detailing that OKC was also an inside job.
http://independence.net/okc/congressbombreport.htm


Actually, Malcolm, we just chose not to side-trackl the thread onto another conspiracy theory; however, as you're now proclaiming that as some sort of victory, here's a response for you. The linked report, which you appear to believe is smoking-gun level proof that the Murrah Building bombing was staged by elements of the US government, was written by retired USAF Brigadier General Benton K. Partin. Following are General Partin's views on the September 11 attacks, as reported in an article in The New American:

Partin did not personally witness the crash, but he lives near the Pentagon, is very familiar with the building’s structure, and began studying the evidence immediately after the event. Does he see any problems with the official Flight 77 crash scenario? “No, not at all,” he told THE NEW AMERICAN. “I’ve seen the videos claiming that it was a missile, not a 757, that hit the Pentagon,” he says, angrily dismissing the claim in scatological terms.

“When you slam an aluminum aircraft at high velocity into a concrete structure, it’s going to do exactly what we saw happen at the Pentagon on 9/11,” Partin said. “If you look at a frontal mass cross-section of the plane, you see a cylinder of aluminum skin with stringers. When it impacts with the exterior [Pentagon] wall at 700-800 feet per second, much of the kinetic energy of the plane converts to thermal energy, and much of the aluminum converts to vapor, burning to aluminum oxide. That’s why on the still photos from Pentagon surveillance camera, you first see the frame with that brilliant white luminescent flash just before the frame of the orange fireball, the jet fuel burning. The aluminum cylinder — the plane fuselage — is acting like a shaped charge penetrating a steel plate. It keeps penetrating until it is consumed. The Boeing 757 is over 150 feet long, so it’s going to penetrate quite a ways before it’s spent. The wings have a much lower mass cross-section and are loaded with fuel besides, so there is little left of them except small bits and pieces.”

“Where’s the wreckage?” One of the arguments that appears on the surface to have some merit, is the argument of negative proof: the stunning absence of crash debris. . . .

As Gen. Partin points out, most of the plane penetrated into the Pentagon, burning and shredding as it went. According to the American Society of Civil Engineers study, the plane cut a diagonal swath 230 feet into the first floor, penetrating Rings E, D, and C. “Under these circumstances, you’re just not going to end up with much airplane debris — inside or outside [the building],” says Partin. . . .

General Partin, an Air Force Command Pilot, sums up the case for Flight 77 hitting the Pentagon: “The alternative explanations just get crazier and crazier. In addition to the physical evidence and the photographic evidence supporting the official story, there are literally hundreds of eyewitnesses — including many people I know personally — who saw the 757. Besides that, there are the light poles that were knocked down — which I saw personally and which are in the photographic record — that can’t be accounted for by a missile or small jet wingspan. Then you have the Flight 77 victim remains and the black boxes. If you reject all of that, then you have to come up with an alternative explanation for what happened to Flight 77. I’ve seen the alternative explanations and they’re absurd!”


So, Malcolm, because you uncritically accepted General Partin's opinion about the Oklahoma City bombing, you should also uncritically accept his opinion about the Pentagon attack. Will you now do so? If not, please explain why not.
 
You still haven't gotten a single thing right.


Now, let's give Malcolm a little credit, pomeroo; he did get that Boys Town (now Boys and Girls Town) is 20 minutes away from Offutt AFB. Well, okay, it's actually 29 minutes by car according to Google Maps, but I think we should give that one to him anyway.
 
Mal, please, not the ol' voice "morphing" nonsense.

Besides, even if it were possible to create one side of a live conversation such that it sounds like the voice of someone else, it is in no way, shape, or form evidence that such a thing transpired on 9/11 or any other time. Proof of that would entail providing...proof.

Really now.
There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court.
Probable cause for example. I seem to increasingly be conversing with people in the U K. This complicates explaining things because there are difference. I will just refer to U S law in future.
Probable cause is one first step to arriving at the truth. With that in mind will you kindly peruse the following article,
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html
 
Malcolm, do explain this. You have such a unique insight into the mind of this "Rothschilde" chap who planned all this.

He decided that simply crashing a plane into WTC2 was too complicated and might go wrong, because you know maybe it wouldn't be a nice day, or maybe the copilot would be an ex-boxer, or maybe the hijackers who had trained long and hard to fly and navigate planes wouldn't actually know which way to turn them once they'd taken over. Or maybe they would be stopped at security because they were carrying items which it was perfectly legitimate to carry in 2001. All sorts of pitfalls.

So he decided it would be simple, and neat, and foolproof, to paint another empty plane to look like Flight 175, and crash that into the building by remote control.

So, why did he have to fake the phone calls at all????

Think of all the things that might have gone wrong. Maybe the recipient of the call would realise that the voice was wrong. Maybe the non-sequitur replies would have given the game away. Maybe the secret code word that the chosen passenger had arranged always to give to his mother to identify himself in case of impersonation would be spotted as being absent (hey, it's as likely as the copilot being a retired boxer!).

Why take the chance?

First, they would only take such an appalling risk if the probability of at least some calls making it thorugh from a hijacked aircraft in the NY area was recognised to be so high that their absence would have been remarkable. So, all the arguing that gets done that nobody could have made the calls in the first place is pretty counterproductive, isn't it? To have any sort of case that "Rothschilde" would have faked the calls, it had to have been imperative, so it had to have been really, really likely that a passenger in that situation would have got a call through.

Second, if you've got to do it, is this morphing business the way to go? What if the stilted, unnatural non-sequitur replies make one of the relatives suspicious? You're "Rothschilde", how do you make this plan safe? I can think of a much better way than morphing phone calls, so I can. But it rather depends on what I intend to do with the planeloads of passengers who aren't going to be crashing into any buildings, and so are rather surplus to requirements.

Malcolm, you have the insight into the evil mastermind. You're the one who has so perceptively spotted the foolproof master plan he must have adopted. But you can't have any loose ends, on this foolproof plan.

What are you going to do with the passengers?

Rolfe.
Intelligent of you to accept the principle that remote controlled flights to New York from Offutt are a far safer choice than the idiocy of relying upon the vagaries of 'hijacks' together with the multitudinous possibilities of something going wrong.
The correct line of enquiry now, is to realise that the four flights were the cover story only and instead of being diverted, go on to track down the real attack planes.
Unfortunately, you go down the road of many and enquire about the cover story - the passengers and their real fate. This can only ever be speculation until a proper enquiry uncovers more. At the moment it is not even established that all four planes took off. A transponder that says it's a commercial airliner could just as easily have gone aloft in the back of an executive jets.
I'm rather fond of executive jets with regard to 9/11. For reasons that are not clear, one such executive jet followed 93 and watched it crash, how about that? The executive jet belonged to a company owned by Warren Buffet, how about that?
Just a little thing. Why don't you put your lackey Spitfire on the probabilities involved there.
I have responded to this post because it doesn't include any of your normal banshee bewailling the death of your eliticism. Kindly bear that in mind, if you wish to continue this dialogue.
 
I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.

You got that right!

You even lost your own name.

For shame.
 
Thank you for that.
I'm sure you will agree that any part of either plane, from wingtip to wingtip would most certainly have broken a window.
I know it sounds a ridiculous thing to say. It's just plain silly to say otherwise. oOf course, any part would have broken a window. I hope you will agree?

Sounds fair enough.

However, believe it or not, that is what the OCT tells us.
The width of a 757-223 is 124 ft 10 inches.
That is here,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_757
If there is any part of the following that you want further explanation on, then please feel free to tell me.
I have to do this, so that you and I can agree on the numberring of the pillars
across the front of the Pentagon and the area supposedly affected.
The approach angle was 47 degrees. If you want to alter that, I don't mind.
At the moment the right wingtip touched the face of the building. If you projected forward a line from the LEFT wingtip at 90 degrees. You would have a right angled triangle of 47, 43 and 90 degrees. With one side 124 ft 10ins long.
Using the sine/ cosine rule, I get the hypotenuse to be over 170 ft.
It now follows that the 757 should cover at least 170 ft across the face of the Pentagon.

There are some assumptions in there that I'm not perfectly happy with, but I'll leave that for now, and for the sake of argument accept this.

Finally for now, I seek a simple agreement so that we can identify the pillars, which I will do as soon as you are satisfied that we are together on these points.
If you can imagine a soccer goal. You have two uprights and a cross bar.
In a building like the Pentagon, you have a series of uprights - crossbar - upright - crossbar etc.
Above every upright, there is a column of bricks and above every crossbar, there is a column of windows.
Please don't proceed until you are happy with all I have written,
thank you.
Here are a couple of illustrations of the front of the Pentagon, to highlight the columns of bricks - windows - bricks etc.
http://www.freedomfiles.org/war/pentagon.htm

I'm happy to agree with this description of the pentagon.
 
I think it's time to get this post of Malcolm's from P911T on the record in this thread, for the benefit of everyone reading, and for those still posting. For the moment I'll let it speak for itself. Here's the link to the Google cache of the thread is here. It's called "Nothing To Beat On the govt loyalist site, Going on the offensive." Malcolm started it on July 20.

Are you positive you're not on my side?
 
There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court.
Probable cause for example. I seem to increasingly be conversing with people in the U K. This complicates explaining things because there are difference. I will just refer to U S law in future.
Probable cause is one first step to arriving at the truth. With that in mind will you kindly peruse the following article,
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html


You're always behind the curve, Malcolm. We had a lengthy thread devoted to this topic last month. I managed to contact John Hotard, manager of the Corporate Communications Department for American Airlines, who confirmed that Flight 77 had airphone service on 9/11/01. You might try checking to see if the subject you intend to pontificate about has been the subject of a thread. No, Malcolm, he wasn't lying and he isn't part of your imaginary conspiracy.
 
There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court.
Probable cause for example ...
Probable cause is one first step to arriving at the truth. With that in mind will you kindly peruse the following article,
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html



Oh good, a whole new area for you to be wrong about. Unfortunately for you, Malcolm, you're in my wheelhouse now. I'm a lawyer and I know for a fact that, well, what you just said is nonsense.

Perhaps you can expand on what you mean about probable cause because right now what you've said is gibberish.
 
Can I just officially object to being called a government loyalist? I can't stand George Bush. I think he's the worst President in our nation's history. I think he's a moron and I strongly suspect that he cannot read. His manipulation of a real terrorist threat to pursue his insane war against one of the only nations in the Middle East we're sure didn't participate in 9/11 is, in my opinion, criminal in every legal and political sense of the word. He has killed more people for less reason than any other leader in our nation and that includes Jefferson Davis. I hate George Bush so much that I hate George Bush for even having George Bush, and I never really minded George Bush.


That comment of Malcolm's gave me a moment of revelation this morning. I thought, "who's he calling a government loyalist?!" With me rather sharing Loss Leader's thoughts on the subject of Dubya.

But then, Dubya isn't my government. Even Brown isn't my government. I've been a committed Scottish Nationalist since I can't remember when. And guess what, three months ago we won the election! So, Scotland really does have an SNP government, and strange as it may seem to me after so many years of outsider wannabe status, I am now officially a Government Loyalist! Wow, it's a weird thought. I support Alex Salmond to the hilt, I think he's doing a great job, and the sooner he gets Trident out of the Clyde the happier I shall be.

Not quite sure that's what Malcolm meant, but there you go. And Loss Leader, I'm with you all the way on the above. Please elect somebody better next time (which is not exactly a difficult assignment).

Rolfe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom