[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I smell an argument from ignorance coming...



Malcolm, simple, serious question: have you EVER been in a traumatic situation where your imminent death was certain ?



Which is ridiculous. Besides they had PHONES ON the plane.



Voice SIMULATION. It's not REAL-TIME, Malcolm.

Do you EVER get anything right ?
What is this REAL TIME nonsense you're coming out with now?
They quite simply recorded the voice in the airport or before the flight took off and then morphed it and played it to his mother at the set time.
That's what morphing is.
 
Yes. Your entire movement has perfected that debate technique to before unknown heights.

When was the last time YOU admitted one of your many errors, hmmmm?
Is there any chamce of you making one of your many one-liners a fraction amusing?
 
I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.


No, Malcolm, you still don't get it. SpitfireIX wasn't wrong. You were. I made the same mistake as you, and so mistakenly thought you were right when you "corrected" him. I see that now, and I've agreed it. I've also learned something (or perhaps relearned something I'd forgotten, Maths with Nellie Murdoch - 1967 was so long ago....) - you should try it some time.

I don't think there's anything we can teach you about dodging the truth - about i/v infusions, gravity, aeroplane construction, corrugated steel, Mensa membership, honours law degrees, vast personal fortunes with which you could buy all our houses out from under us, routine air crew conduct, the appearance of tracks in the grass, the relative sizes of the same piece of wreckage intwo different pictures, the list is endless.


One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.


Oh, another irony meter bites the dust!

:id:

Order me up another half dozen, Hector!

Rolfe.
 
Hows about I wrote box columns of pre ordained strength. Four times stronger than the specifications required. The aluminium wing has had to cut through the front of the box girder, down both sides and then the back of the box girder. Not to mention the cladding. It has then had to cut through the steel spandrel and the next box girder and so on.
Brevity is a necessity when making a point in these posts.

But not brevity to the point of falsity. The towers were not corrugated. The word "corrugated" has never been the best word to describe them, as implied by your "for want of a better word". In fact, "corrugated" is just about one of the worst words possible to describe the towers because it actually describes a real situation that metal can find itself in and is therefore not obvsiouly wrong to everyone who prefers reality to your special world. A better word to describe them would have been "rainbows". At least that would not mislead people.

Do you see how these people forever leap on what they consider to be the weakest point, with no inkling of the big picture.
I wonder if you would be so kind as to read the exchange involved in posts 3537 and 3547. You will read a perfect example of someone squirming out of a clear mistake and then being assisted by another squirmer.
It's anything but the truth you see. They then congratulate each other on having dodged the truth. People who do too much of that end up not knowing the truth at all. Beware you don't end up like that.
If you stay tuned, you will see me clean their collective clocks right around the dial. I shall do it with the one thing that they have completely lost touch with, namely - the truth.

I've read the whole thing. I haven't seen you being assisted by another squirmer yet, but I should warn you that if your clock gets any cleaner it will start wearing through.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.

Interestingly, I just checked my dictionary. Apparently the definition of "irony" is in fact "Malcolm Kirkman".
 
Is there any chamce of you making one of your many one-liners a fraction amusing?

Not that I could make anything any more amusing than your ludicrous theories or arrogant hypocrisy, but I'll try harder next time, k?
 
What is this REAL TIME nonsense you're coming out with now?
They quite simply recorded the voice in the airport or before the flight took off and then morphed it and played it to his mother at the set time.
That's what morphing is.

Several points.

1) Are you saying that they recorded his whole side of the conversation and played it back to his mother, not knowing what she would say, but miraculously every single one of his sentence fits ?

2) Are you saying that this voice morphing technology you fancy is so perfect as to fool his own mother ?

3) If what you say is true, why would "they" have him say the man's full name instead of just 'Mark' ?

4) How do you know this technology even exists ?

5) Normally, an investigator interested in the truth would find such a hurdle is a problem to his theory. But not you. No, you just make up an explanation, which is itself an assumption without supporting evidence, to explain away the fact that there IS evidence against your theory.
 
What is this REAL TIME nonsense you're coming out with now?
They quite simply recorded the voice in the airport or before the flight took off and then morphed it and played it to his mother at the set time.
That's what morphing is.

And how could they predict what his mother would say? Or even that his mother would be in?
 
Of course SOMERLED doesn't know that Mark quite often referred to himself by his full name, even to his family. It was kind of an inside joke.

Of course, THEY would know that so of course They would include that in the 'fake so good even his mother didn't know it wasn't him'.

Unless she was in on it....[cue evil laughter]
 
Forgot to add link to my above post:
“Once in a while he would say that. He would call up, and he was, he was a young businessman, and used to, used to introduce himself on phone as Mark Bingham, and he was trying to be, uh, strong, and level-headed, and, and strictly business.”

http://www.911myths.com/Hoglan.avi
 
From the article



So it cannot be done automatically, cannot be done real time.

YOU FAIL AGAIN MALCOM.
Not really, the whole idea of morphing is to have a recording ready to play at the set time. Real time doesn't come into it, as I think you probably already know.
 
And how could they predict what his mother would say? Or even that his mother would be in?
At last an intelligent response. Suppose I now said that your reply didn't matter because you can't prove anything. What would you say to that?
 
You're worth your weight in gold to me. You stick up a NIST image showing that even they can't get a head on 757 to fit, without vapourising one of the engines and forgetting half of each wing. . . .


First, the aircraft is aligned with the hole, but it is also on its correct approximate ground track; the damage area appears foreshortened because we're seeing the Pentagon from an angle (this should be obvious from the shadowed areas). Second, the outer parts of the wing are the lightest, and least likely to have penetrated the wall. Third, the alignment of the model may not be exact. Fourth, as noted, the wings might already have twisted out of alignment when the struck the wall, due to the Finally, the left engine is there; it's just partly concealed by the steam vault right in front of the building (the computer model does not show the damage to the steam vent).

What happened with that probability stuff, I'll make good use of that.


I haven't had time to work on it; I've been extremely busy with work and helping a friend move. Remember, when I do post it, though, that you asked for it.

Then there'a the Bob Pugh video. Are you sure that you're not on my side?


Yes, we've seen how you've already managed to twist the video; claiming that part of the generator was actually a dumpster, and refusing to admit to having been mistaken even when shown photos and other parts of the same video that proved you wrong. By all means continue making such use of the references provided; you're only demonstrating to any undecided lurkers who read this thread how ridiculous and intellectually dishonest the claims of the "truth" movement are.
 
Is it likely that a passenger would phone his mother and say,
"Mom, this is Mark Bingham, you believe me don't you"?


Ah, here I came to discuss this nonsense, and here are a few others already on to it....

If you were going to fake a phone call from mark to his Mum, then would you be likely to include that sentence in it? Not on a bet! It does sound odd and contrived - and for that reason much more likely to be genuine.

Yes, I know this sounds like the sort of things the CTers say, but it really is the case here. Anyone faking up such a conversation would invent a far more natural-sounding line.

Mark's Mum accepted that it was her son - why should she, if it was unlikely that he would say such a thing? But apparently, this slightly odd way of addressing her wasn't especially out of character.

the poster formerly known as Malcolm Kirkman said:
They quite simply recorded the voice in the airport or before the flight took off and then morphed it and played it to his mother at the set time.
That's what morphing is.


Er, care to elaborate? Whose voice did they record, and how did they know what to get it to say? This was a conversation, remember! He didn't just ring up his Mum, recite his lines and ring off, you know. And she said she recognised the voice as his. How reliable do you think a mother is at recognising her own adult son's voice on the telephone?

Rolfe.
 
But not brevity to the point of falsity. The towers were not corrugated. The word "corrugated" has never been the best word to describe them, as implied by your "for want of a better word". In fact, "corrugated" is just about one of the worst words possible to describe the towers because it actually describes a real situation that metal can find itself in and is therefore not obvsiouly wrong to everyone who prefers reality to your special world. A better word to describe them would have been "rainbows". At least that would not mislead people.



I've read the whole thing. I haven't seen you being assisted by another squirmer yet, but I should warn you that if your clock gets any cleaner it will start wearing through.



Interestingly, I just checked my dictionary. Apparently the definition of "irony" is in fact "Malcolm Kirkman".
Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.
normal_trident16.jpg
 
Malcolm, just tell us. Supposing anyone was mad enough to put you in touch with this poor woman who lost her son on Flight 175, and you started to tell her that the flight didn't crash, and didn't even take off, and so on, what would you tell her when she asked you, as she inevitably would, what actually happened to her son that day, and where is he now?

Since Malcolm has me on ignore, would someone else he's still talking to ask him that?


Whether he has me on ignore or not, he's ignoring that.

Malcolm, what would you tell her? Enquiring minds want to know.

Rolfe.
 
Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/normal_trident16.jpg


Oh no you don't. "Corrugated iron" or "corrugated steel" has a specific meaning, and well you know it. It's a process done to these metals to help them resist buckling. And it refers to single sheets. You said "for strength, the steel was 'corrugated'." No, absolutely flat wrong. The aesthetic design of the towers gave a striped pattern of raised and depressed sections. This was in no way related to "corrugated steel", and it was not done for strength.

Abandoned the subject of the phone calls now? After your clock's been wiped spotless?

the poster formerly known as Malcolm Kirkman said:
One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.


What a classic example.

Rolfe.
 
First, the aircraft is aligned with the hole, but it is also on its correct approximate ground track; the damage area appears foreshortened because we're seeing the Pentagon from an angle (this should be obvious from the shadowed areas). Second, the outer parts of the wing are the lightest, and least likely to have penetrated the wall. Third, the alignment of the model may not be exact. Fourth, as noted, the wings might already have twisted out of alignment when the struck the wall, due to the Finally, the left engine is there; it's just partly concealed by the steam vault right in front of the building (the computer model does not show the damage to the steam vent).




I haven't had time to work on it; I've been extremely busy with work and helping a friend move. Remember, when I do post it, though, that you asked for it.




Yes, we've seen how you've already managed to twist the video; claiming that part of the generator was actually a dumpster, and refusing to admit to having been mistaken even when shown photos and other parts of the same video that proved you wrong. By all means continue making such use of the references provided; you're only demonstrating to any undecided lurkers who read this thread how ridiculous and intellectually dishonest the claims of the "truth" movement are.
Anything you post will be just fine by me. You're one of my best sources of material. A dumpster is known as a skip in the UK. If you check the video, you can clearly see the open top, that's where the flames are. Then the sloping side, so that it can be hauled onto a skip waggon. Best of all, everyone can see that it sure aint the Pentagon or fuel from the 'plane', that's giving out with all the smoke. Thanks again,
6 mins 10 secs to 6 mins 50secs, kindly listen on.
Then again 7.34 to 7.46.
Also, please note the black 4x4 at 7.29.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
 
Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/WTC%20construction/normal_trident16.jpg[/qimg]

Um, no, Malcolm. Corrugated is not even remotely an accurate description of the WTC steel, nor of the photo you posted. It is, in fact, completely, utterly, fantastically inaccurate.
 
Whether he has me on ignore or not, he's ignoring that.

Malcolm, what would you tell her? Enquiring minds want to know.


He wouldn't tell her anything. This has been conclusively demonstrated. I gave him the phone number, fax, address and email address of the church where Reverand Grogan worked. He actually offered to bet me that he would contact them. And then ... he claimed some other truther group had the matter "well in hand" and refused to do it.

He lied. He is a liar. This is not an issue of misunderstanding a picture or misreading a report. He stated that he would do something and then refused to do it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom