[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
At last an intelligent response. Suppose I now said that your reply didn't matter because you can't prove anything. What would you say to that?


I'd ask you what the hell you meant by that. Whose reply doesn't matter? Who couldn't prove anything?

Mark's Mum accepted that she was talking live to her son. She had a conversation with him. How did the conspirators know what to have their fake voice say so that they had a convincing line for him at every turn? Because if they sounded unconvincing, then his mother would be the person most likely to suspect something!

The phone calls weren't an essential part of the plot. First, if making them was inpossible, it was damn stupid to fake them in the first place, as the very fact of impossible phone calls being reported would be suspicious. Second, unless they could be guaranteed perfect, and remember that we need a plan that is guaranteed not to fail, otherwise we won't go with it, then it's an entirely unnecessary hostage to fortune to take the risk of a relative realising that the responses were unnatural.

Your all-seeing "Rothschilde" would never countenance that! Be grateful everybody knows you can't make a phone call from a plane, avoid unnecessary complications, and keep it simple stupid - no?

Do we have a smilie for someone hoist by his own petard?

Rolfe.
 
At last an intelligent response. Suppose I now said that your reply didn't matter because you can't prove anything. What would you say to that?

I'd say, what on earth are you blithering on about. You're claiming the calls are faked, the onus is on you to prove this. You haven't lowering the standard of proof to "well nobody knows anything do you", might suit you but I seriously doubt anyone who has a law degree would try and argue that, you'd get laughed out of court.

So again Malcolm aside from an oddly phrased sentence by a man afraid for his life, and a piece of technology that doesn't work how you think it works, what other proof do you have?
 
Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/normal_trident16.jpg

Only if we're talking about single piece of stuff.

A line of carboard boxes with gaps between could not be described as "a corrugated line of boxes", although the carboard within each individual box might well be corrugated.

Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility[edit]
 
I'm curious as to why, Malcolm, you don't have a smart-alec remark to a video that was posted of Mark's own mother stating that his usage of his first and last name was normal.

Does that sound like the voice of a mother who wouldn't even recognize the voice of her own son? Does that LOOK like a person who could be fooled into thinking her son was talking to her, in a very stress-filled atmosphere by some kind of freakin' voice morphing technology?

And who, when faced with this fact, not only refused to acknowledge it, but CHANGED THE SUBJECT immediately?

What planet do you live on?
 
Um, no, Malcolm. Corrugated is not even remotely an accurate description of the WTC steel, nor of the photo you posted. It is, in fact, completely, utterly, fantastically inaccurate.
By the shrill almost desperate tone of some recent posts, I am clearly making the neocons on here rattled.
I'm happy to report that in real life, the neocons are even more rattled.
Third vid from the bottom,
Senate Judiciary Cmte on the firing of U S Attorneys.
http://www.c-span.org/videoarchives.asp?CatCodePairs=Current_Event,Congress&ArchiveDays=30
 
Malcolm said:
At last an intelligent response.

Which is, amazingly, the same as my EARLIER response, which you've ignored.

Suppose I now said that your reply didn't matter because you can't prove anything. What would you say to that?

That you're playing games and aren't interested in debate.

Funny you should mention a dictionary. The dictionary definition of corrugated is "alternate furrows and ridges". Pretty accurate really.

No, not at all, because the WTC exterior walls were NOT a continuous surface. Please stop trying to dodge. Why don't you simply admit that you were wrong ? What's so frightning about that ?
 
By the shrill almost desperate tone of some recent posts, I am clearly making the neocons on here rattled.

Where do you think you are, anyway ? The DoD forum ?

This is the JREF, where people of a large variety of nations meet to chat.

So why do you continue to think that people who disagree with you are evil ?

Is it because it's "so obvious" that it's an inside job that no one could disagree with you honestly ?

Or is it because you're so engaged to your theory, but have been so consistently proven wrong that all you have left is to attack your opponents ?

What's so difficult about admitting to being wrong ? Or admitting defeat ? Or conceding a simple point such as your ridiculous "corrugated" steel claim or the IV claim ?

I'm happy to report that in real life, the neocons are even more rattled.

I'm sure they barely noticed that you guys exist.
 
You are now telling us that a Boeing travelling at 450 mph wouldn't necessarily break a window.
I can't even be bothered going back to what was said about aluminium travelling at that speed going through anything.
I just know that some 'lurkers' will remember.


First, you said "any part" of the aircraft. I assumed you meant small pieces of debris in addition to the intact aircraft, particularly as there are broken windows all along the area directly struck. I'm not sure of the point you're trying to make, but we'll examine the facade damage in any case. And no one said that aluminum traveling "at that speed" would penetrate any material. Several people stated that an object made of relatively weaker material could penetrate an object made of stronger material, if the penetrating object had sufficient energy (or words to that effect).

From the ASCE report, pp. 35-36:

An examination of the area encompassed by extending the line of travel of the aircraft to the face of the building shows that there are no discrete marks on the building corresponding to the positions of the outer third of the right wing. The size and position of the actual opening in the facade of the building (from column line 8 to column line 18) indicate that no portion of the outer two-thirds of the right wing and no portion of the outer one-third of the left wing actually entered the building.

It is possible that less of the right wing than the left wing entered the building because the right wing struck the facade crossing the level of the second-floor slab.The strength of the second-floor slab in its own plane would have severed the right wing approximately at the location of the right engine.The left wing did not encounter a slab, so it penetrated more easily.

In any event, the evidence suggests that the tips of both wings did not make direct contact with the facade of the building and that portions of the wings might have been separated from the fuselage before the aircraft struck the building. This is consistent with eyewitness statements that the right wing struck a large generator before the aircraft struck the building and that the left engine struck a ground-level, external vent structure. It is possible that these impacts, which occurred not more than 100 ft before the nose of the aircraft struck the building, may have damaged the wings and caused debris to strike the Pentagon facade and the heliport control building. [emphasis added]


Now, Malcolm, you claim that The TruthTM is so blindingly obvious that anyone who's not a shill or a moron should be able to see it. Why aren't all (or even some) of the civil engineers (not just in America, but all over the world) who've read this report up in arms? Could it be because they accept the above explanation for the width of the damaged area as perfectly reasonable? Why can't they see The TruthTM, Malcolm? Why aren't they speaking out? Please comment.

Also, Malcolm, if you would, please view the attached detail from a photo on p.28 of the report. Look, if you would, at the limestone broken off the front of the column next to the half-broken window. If the aircraft in question actually flew over the Pentagon, please explain how this damage was caused, and how the two large chunks of limestone got onto the ledge underneath the window.
 

Attachments

  • south side facade damage.JPG
    south side facade damage.JPG
    42.3 KB · Views: 8
I'd say, what on earth are you blithering on about. You're claiming the calls are faked, the onus is on you to prove this. You haven't lowering the standard of proof to "well nobody knows anything do you", might suit you but I seriously doubt anyone who has a law degree would try and argue that, you'd get laughed out of court.

So again Malcolm aside from an oddly phrased sentence by a man afraid for his life, and a piece of technology that doesn't work how you think it works, what other proof do you have?
As always, plenty more where these came from,
http://physics911.net/projectachilles
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQTuZxybRVM
 
By the shrill almost desperate tone of some recent posts,

Eh? I pointed out that your uneducated take on "corrugated" steel is wrong, because it is, wholly, utterly, fantastically wrong. How on earth can that be construed as "shrill" or "desperate"? It is merely correcting yet another of your glaring errors. You really should educate yourself about the topics on which you opine.

I am clearly making the neocons on here rattled.

I sincerely doubt that you could "rattle" anyone, at least not with the poor level of knowledge or comprehension that you have displayed here. I am not aware of any "neocons" here, but I would wager that neocons are the last people who would be upset by your poor showing.

Do you serioualy not understand why your description of the steel at the WTC towers as "corrugated" is wrong?
 
Ahh, project achilles. The unscientific experiment that was nothing like the environment of 9/11.
This is amazing since in 2000 (pre 9/11) the FCC found out a different story.
An FCC study in 2000 found that cell-phone use aboard aircraft increases the number of blocked or dropped calls on the ground. That's because at high altitude, cellular signals are spread across several base stations, preventing other callers within range of those base stations from using the same frequencies.
Hmm. If cell-phone calls were not possible at altitude, why would it be a problem?
While you're at it, please explain this.
to respond to far more dire circumstances, as was the case with Chicago resident Matthew Downs on Sept. 11, 2001.

Downs, a software salesman, learned of the terrorist attacks while on a commercial flight returning home from South America. The captain explained that "terrorist attacks on airplanes" meant they were making an emergency landing. People on board using cell phones soon discovered the true nature of the day's events.

"We found out from people using their phones that the World Trade Center was hit, and some unspecified area in Washington," Downs recalls.
 
First, you said "any part" of the aircraft. I assumed you meant small pieces of debris in addition to the intact aircraft, particularly as there are broken windows all along the area directly struck. I'm not sure of the point you're trying to make, but we'll examine the facade damage in any case. And no one said that aluminum traveling "at that speed" would penetrate any material. Several people stated that an object made of relatively weaker material could penetrate an object made of stronger material, if the penetrating object had sufficient energy (or words to that effect).

From the ASCE report, pp. 35-36:




Now, Malcolm, you claim that The TruthTM is so blindingly obvious that anyone who's not a shill or a moron should be able to see it. Why aren't all (or even some) of the civil engineers (not just in America, but all over the world) who've read this report up in arms? Could it be because they accept the above explanation for the width of the damaged area as perfectly reasonable? Why can't they see The TruthTM, Malcolm? Why aren't they speaking out? Please comment.

Also, Malcolm, if you would, please view the attached detail from a photo on p.28 of the report. Look, if you would, at the limestone broken off the front of the column next to the half-broken window. If the aircraft in question actually flew over the Pentagon, please explain how this damage was caused, and how the two large chunks of limestone got onto the ledge underneath the window.
Here's a bit more 9/11 truth, it just keeps rolling in,
as always, plenty more where these came from.
http://www.ae911truth.org/
http://patriotsquestion911.com/engineers.html
http://www.911blogger.com/node/8507
 
As always, plenty more where these came from,
http://physics911.net/projectachilles


Brilliant, Malcolm, you've cracked the case. :rolleyes: A. K. Dewdney's "experiment" is laughable. He didn't fly in the same type of aircraft, over the same routes, or at the same altitudes or speeds as the hijacked airliners. Further, he flew over an urban area. Cells in rural areas have completely different reception characteristics, as they are typically much farther apart then those in cities. But Dewdney's silly project is irrelevant in any case, as almost all of the calls were made with Airfones installed on the planes; only a very few were made with cells (and those were in the final moments of their respective flights). Some of the calls were erroneously reported as having been made from cell phones initially, but according to the Airfone logs, they were actually made from Airfones.

From an article about the Zacharias Moussaoui trial:

When New Jersey State Police Sgt. Ray Guidetti testified last month in the trial of Sept. 11 conspirator Zacarias Moussaoui, his job was to describe the final moments and phone conversations of passengers and crew aboard United Airlines Flight 93. . . .

"There were 30 air phone and two cellular phone calls placed by flight attendants and passengers," Guidetti said.


Also, you can download a flash presentation used in the trial from here that details exactly which phone on each plane was used to make each call.



Yet another example of Dylan Avery and company [expletive deleted]ing on the graves of the victims. Words fail me. :mad:
 
Malcolm, do explain this. You have such a unique insight into the mind of this "Rothschilde" chap who planned all this.

He decided that simply crashing a plane into WTC2 was too complicated and might go wrong, because you know maybe it wouldn't be a nice day, or maybe the copilot would be an ex-boxer, or maybe the hijackers who had trained long and hard to fly and navigate planes wouldn't actually know which way to turn them once they'd taken over. Or maybe they would be stopped at security because they were carrying items which it was perfectly legitimate to carry in 2001. All sorts of pitfalls.

So he decided it would be simple, and neat, and foolproof, to paint another empty plane to look like Flight 175, and crash that into the building by remote control.

So, why did he have to fake the phone calls at all????

Think of all the things that might have gone wrong. Maybe the recipient of the call would realise that the voice was wrong. Maybe the non-sequitur replies would have given the game away. Maybe the secret code word that the chosen passenger had arranged always to give to his mother to identify himself in case of impersonation would be spotted as being absent (hey, it's as likely as the copilot being a retired boxer!).

Why take the chance?

First, they would only take such an appalling risk if the probability of at least some calls making it thorugh from a hijacked aircraft in the NY area was recognised to be so high that their absence would have been remarkable. So, all the arguing that gets done that nobody could have made the calls in the first place is pretty counterproductive, isn't it? To have any sort of case that "Rothschilde" would have faked the calls, it had to have been imperative, so it had to have been really, really likely that a passenger in that situation would have got a call through.

Second, if you've got to do it, is this morphing business the way to go? What if the stilted, unnatural non-sequitur replies make one of the relatives suspicious? You're "Rothschilde", how do you make this plan safe? I can think of a much better way than morphing phone calls, so I can. But it rather depends on what I intend to do with the planeloads of passengers who aren't going to be crashing into any buildings, and so are rather surplus to requirements.

Malcolm, you have the insight into the evil mastermind. You're the one who has so perceptively spotted the foolproof master plan he must have adopted. But you can't have any loose ends, on this foolproof plan.

What are you going to do with the passengers?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Is it time, yet, to invoke the :socks: used with the immortalized Christophera?

Basically, one and only one discussion point is allowed on the table at a time (posed by whomever has the :socks:), Malcolm's attempts to dodge and weave are disregarded until the point is addressed.

I can't propose this directly to Malcolm, because he has me on ignore. But, then again, since transitive verbs do not exist according to Malcolm, I could not propose the plan, anyway, I guess.
 
JREFers: carefully constructed argument that wipes Malcolm's clock clean away. Lots of them. All his vague notions and baseless assumptions, just demolished.

Malcolm:
By the shrill almost desperate tone of some recent posts, I am clearly making the neocons on here rattled.
I'm happy to report that in real life, the neocons are even more rattled.
Third vid from the bottom,
Senate Judiciary Cmte on the firing of U S Attorneys.
[URL="http://www.c-span.org/videoarchives....ArchiveDays=30"]http://www.c-span.org/videoarchives....ArchiveDays=30[/URL]




Here's a bit more 9/11 truth, it just keeps rolling in,
as always, plenty more where these came from.
http://www.ae911truth.org/
http://patriotsquestion911.com/engineers.html
[URL="http://www.911blogger.com/node/8507"]http://www.911blogger.com/node/8507[/URL]


This really looks like a classic example of punch-drunk to me.

Rolfe.
 
Here's a bit more 9/11 truth, it just keeps rolling in,
as always, plenty more where these came from.
http://www.ae911truth.org/
http://patriotsquestion911.com/engineers.html
http://www.911blogger.com/node/8507


I asked you to answer the question, Malcolm, not link to the AE911T web site. They list only a handful of people claiming to be civil engineers; the American Society of Civil Engineers has over 70,000 full members. In any case, there's nothing about the Pentagon on AE911T's web site.

Now, I'll re-pose the question: Malcolm, you claim that The TruthTM is so blindingly obvious that anyone who's not a shill or a moron should be able to see it. Why aren't all (or even some significant number) of the civil engineers (not just in America, but all over the world) who've read this report up in arms? Could it be because they accept the ASCE's explanation for the width of the damaged area as perfectly reasonable? Why can't they see The TruthTM, Malcolm? Why aren't they speaking out? Please comment.
 
Nothing like a drone believing everything he reads on a website and mindlessly regurgitating it on discussion forums.

Nice Job, Malcolm. If only you would give those sites and videos the critical eye you give the 'official story' instead of believing them as if they were the words of God, no questions asked because they support your worldview, you'd actually learn a few things.
 
Huh. Hit "send" too soon. Five typos in post now in moderation. Time for beauty sleep. Post not modded. No chance to fix typos, if post not modded within 2 hours. [Hah, made it!]

Grumble, grumble.... Is there no justice....

By the way, in a post in Forum Management, Malcolm declares:

You can't find one place where I have lied.


I'm sure someone, somewhere, has a Larsen List on this, with appropriate references. It may be exceeding the post length limit for the forum though....

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom