[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh good, a whole new area for you to be wrong about. Unfortunately for you, Malcolm, you're in my wheelhouse now. I'm a lawyer and I know for a fact that, well, what you just said is nonsense.

Perhaps you can expand on what you mean about probable cause because right now what you've said is gibberish.

You won't mind stepping out from behind your forum name then will you?
 
Everything Malcolm has stated has been thoroughly refuted.


He has told many absurd lies and all of them have been exposed.


The title of the thread makes the insane claim that Flight 175 did not hit the South Tower.

Thousands of eyewitnesses observed Flight 175 hit the South Tower.

Wreckage of the aircraft was found.

Remains of the passengers were identified.

Air traffic controllers from Boston and New York tracked the plane's progress very closely.

To all of these FACTS, Malcolm opposes a fantastic and utterly baseless fabrication about imaginary "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB.

Isn't it long past time to bring down the curtain on a rotten show?
step out from behind your eucalyptus tree and call me insane.
 
Can I just officially object to being called a government loyalist? I can't stand George Bush. I think he's the worst President in our nation's history. I think he's a moron and I strongly suspect that he cannot read. His manipulation of a real terrorist threat to pursue his insane war against one of the only nations in the Middle East we're sure didn't participate in 9/11 is, in my opinion, criminal in every legal and political sense of the word. He has killed more people for less reason than any other leader in our nation and that includes Jefferson Davis. I hate George Bush so much that I hate George Bush for even having George Bush, and I never really minded George Bush.

Do the Truthers really think that the only way we could believe what we do is if we're so blinded by ideology that we refuse to see their side? It is possible to examine evidence, weigh probabilities and test theories without being a partisan.

Here endeth the rant.
There's hope for you yet.
 
Where do you think you are, anyway ? The DoD forum ?

This is the JREF, where people of a large variety of nations meet to chat.

So why do you continue to think that people who disagree with you are evil ?

Is it because it's "so obvious" that it's an inside job that no one could disagree with you honestly ?

Or is it because you're so engaged to your theory, but have been so consistently proven wrong that all you have left is to attack your opponents ?

What's so difficult about admitting to being wrong ? Or admitting defeat ? Or conceding a simple point such as your ridiculous "corrugated" steel claim or the IV claim ?



I'm sure they barely noticed that you guys exist.
I quote you,
"Is it because it's "so obvious" that it's an inside job that no one could disagree with you honestly" ?
Correct.
 
Mal, please, not the ol' voice "morphing" nonsense.

Besides, even if it were possible to create one side of a live conversation such that it sounds like the voice of someone else, it is in no way, shape, or form evidence that such a thing transpired on 9/11 or any other time. Proof of that would entail providing...proof.

Really now.
There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court.
Probable cause for example. I seem to increasingly be conversing with people in the U K. This complicates explaining things because there are difference. I will just refer to U S law in future.
Probable cause is one first step to arriving at the truth. With that in mind will you kindly peruse the following article,
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html
What?

Simply put: no. If I, for instance, have probable cause to suspect you are a wife-batterer it doesn't prove you are. Just because you've latched onto the fantasy of voice-morphing in an attempt to cast suspicion on the events of 9/11 doesn't make it true. Both offerings would find their advocates laughed out of court, much less in the position of satisfying it.

Remember, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Evidence, Mal, not fictional daydreams.
 
There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court.


Oh dear Malcolm, and you do know about satisfying a court, don't you!


MALCOLM KIRKMAN
PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT


- v -


SKIPTON BUILDING SOCIETY

DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
​

Lord Justice Aldous: .... The district judge had difficulty in understanding the grounds upon which it was suggested that there was a bona fide dispute as to the debt, .... He dismissed the application. The fact that the district judge had difficulty in understanding his case was probably Mr Kirkham's [electronic typo for "Kirkman", the identity is not in doubt] fault. He lacks the ability to explain the matter so that a judge can understand it....

Mr Kirkham appealed. I need not dwell on the procedural difficulties that resulted....

He (His Honour Judge Hegarty QC ) dealt with those issues at length and concluded that there was no possibility of Mr Kirkham succeeding on them....

I have tried to set out the argument which Mr Kirkham put forward. I suspect that he has not analysed it in that way....

I must urge Mr Kirkham to obtain legal advice. Having heard him address this Court, I have a feeling that, if he does not do so, it is likely his appeal will fail.​
​
​


With a track record like that, I'm sure we can all look forward to your imminent victory - NOT!

Rolfe.
 
Sounds fair enough.



There are some assumptions in there that I'm not perfectly happy with, but I'll leave that for now, and for the sake of argument accept this.



I'm happy to agree with this description of the pentagon.
I'm grateful to you for that, thank you.
I hope you don't consider me exacting, but these points are important. Would you kindly expand on your not being happy with some 'assumptions'.
 
Intelligent of you to accept the principle that remote controlled flights to New York from Offutt are a far safer choice than the idiocy of relying upon the vagaries of 'hijacks' together with the multitudinous possibilities of something going wrong.
The correct line of enquiry now, is to realise that the four flights were the cover story only and instead of being diverted, go on to track down the real attack planes.
Unfortunately, you go down the road of many and enquire about the cover story - the passengers and their real fate. This can only ever be speculation until a proper enquiry uncovers more. At the moment it is not even established that all four planes took off. A transponder that says it's a commercial airliner could just as easily have gone aloft in the back of an executive jets.
I'm rather fond of executive jets with regard to 9/11. For reasons that are not clear, one such executive jet followed 93 and watched it crash, how about that? The executive jet belonged to a company owned by Warren Buffet, how about that?
Just a little thing. Why don't you put your lackey Spitfire on the probabilities involved there.


I suppose I should have guessed, sarcasm is totally lost on you, isn't it?

You're the guy who claims to have this great insight into this "simple, foolproof" plan. But no plan is either simple or foolproof until all the details are attended to. Seems to me that accounting for three jet airliners and their crew and passengers is more than a minor detail. If you can't explain how that was handled, then your so-called simple foolproof plan isn't getting off the drawing board.

Now, quit ignoring my main point, Malcolm.

Why was it necessary to complicate this simple and foolproof plan by faking any phone calls at all??

I have responded to this post because it doesn't include any of your normal banshee bewailling the death of your eliticism. Kindly bear that in mind, if you wish to continue this dialogue.

Oh dear, I must crank up the banshee wail system, it's clearly underperforming. "The death of your eliticism"? What the hell does that mean? Once more, Malcolm's superb command of English finds a new word. You mean, the elitism you tried to claim by coming here and boasting of your riches and your education and your intellect, all killed to death by the simple revelation that you were lying? Funny how you go right off the idea of elitism once that's been exposed, isn't it?

Rolfe.
 
There's hope for you yet.



Well, that makes one of us.


Was that too easy? That was too easy, wasn't it. Now I feel bad. ... not bad enough to go back and erase it, mind you, but bad nonetheless. Maybe the mods will save me from myself.



By the way, Malcolm, you still haven't responded to my question about probable cause. Just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause does to help your argument? For that matter, just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause is?

Oh, and how are you coming with contacting Reverand Grogan's church? You had planned out exactly what you were going to tell them. Was that another lie, like your wealth and education? Or was that a misunderstanding like your ideas about gravity?


Yeah, now I'm back on track.
 
What?

Simply put: no. If I, for instance, have probable cause to suspect you are a wife-batterer it doesn't prove you are. Just because you've latched onto the fantasy of voice-morphing in an attempt to cast suspicion on the events of 9/11 doesn't make it true. Both offerings would find their advocates laughed out of court, much less in the position of satisfying it.

Remember, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Evidence, Mal, not fictional daydreams.


"Pyramid Patchouli? There's only one joker in L.A. sensitive enough to wear that scent--and I had to find out who he was."

Happy Birthday, Meester Dayn-ger!
 
"Is it because it's "so obvious" that it's an inside job that no one could disagree with you honestly" ?

Correct.



Correct? So you are saying that all 129,000 members of the American Society of Civil Engineers(minus perhaps the 2 or 3 from AE911) are terror supporting "neocons" - them along with around a 1,000,000 of their counterparts outside the US, along with every structural/civil engineering professor in the world..........all terror supprting neocons?

Really?
 
Correct? So you are saying that all 129,000 members of the American Society of Civil Engineers(minus perhaps the 2 or 3 from AE911) are terror supporting "neocons" - them along with around a 1,000,000 of their counterparts outside the US, along with every structural/civil engineering professor in the world..........all terror supprting neocons?

Really?

That is a good point. Malcolm can you put forward any institute of professional engineers or architects from anywhere on the planet that support you?

Can you name one that supports the CD theory and openly opposes NIST?

Anywhere? Anybody?
 
By the way, Malcolm, you still haven't responded to my question about probable cause. Just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause does to help your argument? For that matter, just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause is?

I seem to remember giving him the definitions back here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2654514&postcount=1174.

In case he forgot.
Reasonable suspicion is a low standard of proof used in the United States to determine whether a brief investigative stop or a brief search by a police officer or any government agent is warranted. In Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968), the United States Supreme Court determined that reasonable suspicion requires specific, articulable, and individualized suspicion that crime is afoot. A mere guess or "hunch" is not enough to constitute reasonable suspicion. As a result of the low threshold requirement for reasonable suspicion, the level of intrusiveness of the search and/or seizure allowed is lower than the level of intrusiveness allowed when a government agent has probable cause to suspect evidence of a crime will be found.

A good illustration of this is the continuum of a typical police/citizen interaction:

Consensual encounter between officer and citizen (no level of suspicion required): a stop initiated by the officer that would cause a reasonable person to feel that he/she is not free to leave (reasonable suspicion required) :arrest (probable cause required).

Probable cause is a relatively low standard of proof, which is used in the United States to determine whether a search, or an arrest, is warranted. It is also used by grand juries to determine whether to issue an indictment. In the civil context, this standard is often used where plaintiffs are seeking a prejudgment remedy.

In the criminal context, the U.S. Supreme Court in United States v. Sokolow, 490 U.S. 1 (1989), determined that probable cause requires "a fair probability that contraband or evidence of a crime will be found." Courts vary when determining what constitutes a "fair probability," some say 30%, others 40%, others 51%.
 
Well, that makes one of us.


Was that too easy? That was too easy, wasn't it. Now I feel bad. ... not bad enough to go back and erase it, mind you, but bad nonetheless. Maybe the mods will save me from myself.



By the way, Malcolm, you still haven't responded to my question about probable cause. Just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause does to help your argument? For that matter, just what do you think the legal concept of probable cause is?

Oh, and how are you coming with contacting Reverand Grogan's church? You had planned out exactly what you were going to tell them. Was that another lie, like your wealth and education? Or was that a misunderstanding like your ideas about gravity?


Yeah, now I'm back on track.
You say you are a lawyer. Why won't you properly identify yourself and prove it? People can be what they like on here. Just because a shiny avatar says it's a lawyer doesn't make ir so. If you wish to engage in a legal exchange with me, then identify yourself as a lawyer otherwise kindly stick to the substance of the thread.
 
Correct? So you are saying that all 129,000 members of the American Society of Civil Engineers(minus perhaps the 2 or 3 from AE911) are terror supporting "neocons" - them along with around a 1,000,000 of their counterparts outside the US, along with every structural/civil engineering professor in the world..........all terror supprting neocons?

Really?
Not at all. There is every reason and every excuse for an otherwise busy individual to rely upon an occassional listen to the MSM for their daily dose of world events/news. That is why the MSM is such a valuable tool in all this.
An article in AE911 tells how whole firms of architects are signing up on simply a lunch time half hour presentation. The MSM has played a leading role in all this. Indeed in England, the BBC is being sued for public deception. I will be lending my support to that.
What I do say, is that it is not possible to be au fait with the events of 9/11, to have 'studied' the topic for any length of time, without knowing the truth.
The truth being that 9/11 was an inside job.
The proof of that on here is straightforward enough. If you are all such proud skeptics, then how come you are not skeptical about 9/11?
 
That is a good point. Malcolm can you put forward any institute of professional engineers or architects from anywhere on the planet that support you?

Can you name one that supports the CD theory and openly opposes NIST?

Anywhere? Anybody?

I'm glad you put this post up. Because Apathoid is replying to post No. 3612.
Although you'd never believe that 3612 contains this,
http://www.ae911truth.org/
http://patriotsquestion911.com/engineers.html
http://www.911blogger.com/node/8507
 
I suppose I should have guessed, sarcasm is totally lost on you, isn't it?

You're the guy who claims to have this great insight into this "simple, foolproof" plan. But no plan is either simple or foolproof until all the details are attended to. Seems to me that accounting for three jet airliners and their crew and passengers is more than a minor detail. If you can't explain how that was handled, then your so-called simple foolproof plan isn't getting off the drawing board.

Now, quit ignoring my main point, Malcolm.

Why was it necessary to complicate this simple and foolproof plan by faking any phone calls at all??



Oh dear, I must crank up the banshee wail system, it's clearly underperforming. "The death of your eliticism"? What the hell does that mean? Once more, Malcolm's superb command of English finds a new word. You mean, the elitism you tried to claim by coming here and boasting of your riches and your education and your intellect, all killed to death by the simple revelation that you were lying? Funny how you go right off the idea of elitism once that's been exposed, isn't it?

Rolfe.
I didn't say that the plan was simple or foolproof.
I said that with the towers primed and ready to explode, you would choose the most certain hit.
You would choose the two middle of the night lift offs of remote controlled planes from Offutt and a nice quiet flight east, with the approach beacons waiting.
You are now going to need a cover story. You can't just leave it at that. Although you have control of the MSM etc, somebody might just ask where the planes came from. Where was air traffic control and Norad etc?
Now therei s indeed a lot of planning to do. But the stakes are high. The U S taxpayer is now borrowing $100 billion a year from the Banksters.
Obviously you will get Bush to immediately declare war. That is where the Pentagon comes in. Then you can insist on 'war censorship' etc to keep any rogue reporters out of the mainstream.
That is what happened. Criminals make mistakes, it happens all the time.
The cover story will be arab/moslem hijackers in four planes.
When you look at the cover story, it has more holes than a collander.
In conclusion, it wasn't vital to concoct the morphed phone calls. It's just an extra touch to add strength, a bit of realism, to the hijack claims. Don't forget, you've got the MSM to highlight things you want and suppress stuff you don't want. Like the screaming that came from a jet on the ground at Cleveland. There's only the MSM keeping this thing afloat and people like Rosie O'D are dismantling that.
Tell me, if you're such a skeptic, then how come you're not skeptical about 9/11?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom