MALCOLM KIRKMAN
PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
- v -
SKIPTON BUILDING SOCIETY
DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
Lord Justice Aldous: .... The district judge had difficulty in understanding the grounds upon which it was suggested that there was a bona fide dispute as to the debt, .... He dismissed the application. The fact that the district judge had difficulty in understanding his case was probably Mr Kirkham's [electronic typo for "Kirkman", the identity is not in doubt] fault. He lacks the ability to explain the matter so that a judge can understand it....
Mr Kirkham appealed. I need not dwell on the procedural difficulties that resulted....
He (His Honour Judge Hegarty QC ) dealt with those issues at length and concluded that there was no possibility of Mr Kirkham succeeding on them....
I have tried to set out the argument which Mr Kirkham put forward. I suspect that he has not analysed it in that way....
I must urge Mr Kirkham to obtain legal advice. Having heard him address this Court, I have a feeling that, if he does not do so, it is likely his appeal will fail.