[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
That comment of Malcolm's gave me a moment of revelation this morning. I thought, "who's he calling a government loyalist?!" With me rather sharing Loss Leader's thoughts on the subject of Dubya.

But then, Dubya isn't my government. Even Brown isn't my government. I've been a committed Scottish Nationalist since I can't remember when. And guess what, three months ago we won the election! So, Scotland really does have an SNP government, and strange as it may seem to me after so many years of outsider wannabe status, I am now officially a Government Loyalist! Wow, it's a weird thought. I support Alex Salmond to the hilt, I think he's doing a great job, and the sooner he gets Trident out of the Clyde the happier I shall be.

Not quite sure that's what Malcolm meant, but there you go. And Loss Leader, I'm with you all the way on the above. Please elect somebody better next time (which is not exactly a difficult assignment).

Rolfe.
Will the real Rolfe please stand up.
You've gone from the Yorkshire Dales, to Surrey or somewhere down there and now you're a Scots Nat and have been since you can't remember when.
 
You're always behind the curve, Malcolm. We had a lengthy thread devoted to this topic last month. I managed to contact John Hotard, manager of the Corporate Communications Department for American Airlines, who confirmed that Flight 77 had airphone service on 9/11/01. You might try checking to see if the subject you intend to pontificate about has been the subject of a thread. No, Malcolm, he wasn't lying and he isn't part of your imaginary conspiracy.

You're always coming out with some imaginary support aren't you?
'We debunked this last year'.
'Joe Bloggs debunked this to everybody's satisfaction'
This time it is,
"...a lengthy thread...last month..."
In a nutshell, I'll take all the info collected by David Ray Griffin against your John Hotard boloney.
Stay tuned, I've got absolute proof on faked phone calls, when I find it.
It's to do with an air hostess overhearing something she couldn't possibly have overheard. I don't think I'll bother looking for it. I'll just wait for Spitfire to throw it up.
Watching you sqirm out of that will be a laugh.
 
Actually, Malcolm, we just chose not to side-trackl the thread onto another conspiracy theory; however, as you're now proclaiming that as some sort of victory, here's a response for you. The linked report, which you appear to believe is smoking-gun level proof that the Murrah Building bombing was staged by elements of the US government, was written by retired USAF Brigadier General Benton K. Partin. Following are General Partin's views on the September 11 attacks, as reported in an article in The New American:




So, Malcolm, because you uncritically accepted General Partin's opinion about the Oklahoma City bombing, you should also uncritically accept his opinion about the Pentagon attack. Will you now do so? If not, please explain why not.
I've already partially dealt with the light poles and the black boxes are concrete stand alone proof of an inside job. Thanks for reminding me.
When did the general make that statement and would he say the same thing now if presented with all the new evidence, including the flight recorder?
 
That comment of Malcolm's gave me a moment of revelation this morning. I thought, "who's he calling a government loyalist?!" With me rather sharing Loss Leader's thoughts on the subject of Dubya.

But then, Dubya isn't my government. Even Brown isn't my government. I've been a committed Scottish Nationalist since I can't remember when. And guess what, three months ago we won the election! So, Scotland really does have an SNP government, and strange as it may seem to me after so many years of outsider wannabe status, I am now officially a Government Loyalist! Wow, it's a weird thought. I support Alex Salmond to the hilt, I think he's doing a great job, and the sooner he gets Trident out of the Clyde the happier I shall be.

Not quite sure that's what Malcolm meant, but there you go. And Loss Leader, I'm with you all the way on the above. Please elect somebody better next time (which is not exactly a difficult assignment).

Rolfe.

It is not and was not my comment.
I wrote JREF in my post. When the post appeared JREF had magically turned into 'the official government loyalist site' or words to that effect, clever eh?
 
step out from behind your eucalyptus tree and call me insane.



Making a medical diagnosis is not something I'm qualified to do. If you understand that you've presented no facts here, that you've ignored all the inconvenient evidence that refutes your fantasies, that you have continually fabricated the support for the myths you promote, and that you resolutely refuse to acknowledge the findings of genuine authorities, preferring to cite discredited charlatans who write for crank sites--well, if you understand all of that, you're not necessarily insane. Questions about your motives arise, but we'll pass those by.

I and others have concluded that your paranoia runs so deep that you can't escape the fantasy world you've confined yourself to. Admittedly, it is bizarre that you manage to get almost everything wrong. It's a phenomenon I can't explain satisfactorily. You seem to want to remain in error. You seem more comfortable being wrong all the time.
 
I suppose I should have guessed, sarcasm is totally lost on you, isn't it?

You're the guy who claims to have this great insight into this "simple, foolproof" plan. But no plan is either simple or foolproof until all the details are attended to. Seems to me that accounting for three jet airliners and their crew and passengers is more than a minor detail. If you can't explain how that was handled, then your so-called simple foolproof plan isn't getting off the drawing board.

Now, quit ignoring my main point, Malcolm.

Why was it necessary to complicate this simple and foolproof plan by faking any phone calls at all??



Oh dear, I must crank up the banshee wail system, it's clearly underperforming. "The death of your eliticism"? What the hell does that mean? Once more, Malcolm's superb command of English finds a new word. You mean, the elitism you tried to claim by coming here and boasting of your riches and your education and your intellect, all killed to death by the simple revelation that you were lying? Funny how you go right off the idea of elitism once that's been exposed, isn't it?

Rolfe.
I'm going to have to stop firing from the hip and think a bit.
Your question,
Why was it necessary to complicate this simple and foolproof plan by faking any phone calls at all??
My answer,
In order to immediately tell the world, that all four planes had been hijacked by arab/moslem terrorists.
 
Making a medical diagnosis is not something I'm qualified to do. If you understand that you've presented no facts here, that you've ignored all the inconvenient evidence that refutes your fantasies, that you have continually fabricated the support for the myths you promote, and that you resolutely refuse to acknowledge the findings of genuine authorities, preferring to cite discredited charlatans who write for crank sites--well, if you understand all of that, you're not necessarily insane. Questions about your motives arise, but we'll pass those by.

I and others have concluded that your paranoia runs so deep that you can't escape the fantasy world you've confined yourself to. Admittedly, it is bizarre that you manage to get almost everything wrong. It's a phenomenon I can't explain satisfactorily. You seem to want to remain in error. You seem more comfortable being wrong all the time.
I will acknowledge that there is one point that I have neglected to address properly.
That is the difference between morphed voice phone calls as shown here
Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/
And a REAL TIME conversation.
A scientist will use another route, but I’ll get through to more people by explaining it this way.
In order to understand, you first need to understand what genuine karaoke is.
In most pubs and clubs it’s a simple case of belting a song out through a regular microphone. That’s so common that it’s practically all we see.
However, a genuine karaoke machine actually puts an off note back on track.
It’s clever and expensive technology. Provided the note sung is near enough, a genuine karaoke machine will put that note in tune.
The next time you see an artiste with a mike the size of a vacuum cleaner handle, it’s actually a very expensive ‘karaoke’ mike. The mike needs a box on the floor, but a large mike as described, is a sign of a genuine karaoke machine at work.
You will find that the longer conversations are with people not known to the caller.
So there you have a better explanation of the ability to hold REAL TIME morphed conversations.
 
I'm grateful to you for that, thank you.
I hope you don't consider me exacting, but these points are important. Would you kindly expand on your not being happy with some 'assumptions'.

For one, the assumption that the body of the aircraft would continue to colide with the building without being damaged, in such a way that the 'total' width of damage possible is obtained.

But, as I said, this isn't all that important, and I'd prefer to just move in for now, if that is alright with you.
 
You're always coming out with some imaginary support aren't you?


No, Malcolm, you're the proven liar here. NOTHING that supports the rationalist position is imaginary. EVERYTHING that supports your fantasies is.


'We debunked this last year'.
'Joe Bloggs debunked this to everybody's satisfaction'
This time it is,
"...a lengthy thread...last month..."


Yes, we do debunk the frauds, know-nothings, and charlatans with regularity. You should know.


In a nutshell, I'll take all the info collected by David Ray Griffin against your John Hotard boloney.



Yes, of course you will--you have no choice. Your mind is shackled to your fantasies. You must reject real evidence and embrace fabrications and falsehoods. Griffin got caught swallowing Bollyn's nonsense and made a fool of himself.

John Hotard really does work for AA. Griffin is a glib charlatan who peddles rubbish to gullible paranoiacs.


Stay tuned, I've got absolute proof on faked phone calls, when I find it.
It's to do with an air hostess overhearing something she couldn't possibly have overheard. I don't think I'll bother looking for it. I'll just wait for Spitfire to throw it up.
Watching you sqirm out of that will be a laugh.


No, Malcolm, you have never managed to produce a shred of proof for any of your childish fables. You have been repeatedly exposed as a teller of tall tales and a snake oil salesman. No phone calls were faked--NONE.

You won't be smearing the victims of the jihadists much longer. Your evil movement is dying. The good guys have you on the run, Malcolm.
 
You say you are a lawyer. Why won't you properly identify yourself and prove it? People can be what they like on here. Just because a shiny avatar says it's a lawyer doesn't make ir so. If you wish to engage in a legal exchange with me, then identify yourself as a lawyer otherwise kindly stick to the substance of the thread.


First of all, Malcolm, I am sticking to the substance of the thread. This is what you yourself wrote shortly before my post:


There are degrees of proof and more than one way to satisfy a court. Probable cause for example. I seem to increasingly be conversing with people in the U K. This complicates explaining things because there are difference. I will just refer to U S law in future. Probable cause is one first step to arriving at the truth. With that in mind will you kindly peruse the following article, http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html


So, when I asked why you thought the concept of "probable cause" helped your argument, I was responding to your very comments. I read the article you linked to with "probable cause" in mind, and I have no idea what you think the two have to do with each other. I was (and still am) asking you to clarify your own point.

Second of all, my being or not being a lawyer doesn't actually change anything. You have an argument about "probable cause." It is either true or not. My qualifications don't have any effect on the truthfulness of your argument. If I am insufficiently qualified to understand it, I'll bring it to someone who is. Telling me that you doubt my credentials is: 1) hypotritical because you lied about your own credentials; and 2) irrelevant because it does not change the strength of your argument.


In conclusion, it wasn't vital to concoct the morphed phone calls. It's just an extra touch to add strength, a bit of realism, to the hijack claims.


How can having phone calls that were impossible to make add a bit of "realism" to anything? How can something be both impossible and realistic at the same time?
 
I've already partially dealt with the light poles and the black boxes are concrete stand alone proof of an inside job. Thanks for reminding me.
When did the general make that statement and would he say the same thing now if presented with all the new evidence, including the flight recorder?


The article is dated May 2005. And you haven't "dealt with" the light poles at all--you merely parroted Jack White's claim that pole no. 2 is still standing. I believe someone else pointed out that there are other light poles in the area. But here's a satellite photo showing two other poles that it could be. I think it's most likely the one indicated in red, but it might also be the one in yellow. I'll look for some more photos when I have a chance and see if I can narrow it down.

As for the flight data recorder, here are beachnut's comments in another thread. Hopefully he can expand on this.

Lyte, the FDR does not tell anyone where the plane is. The position data from the plane puts the aircraft south of CITGO. You use the heading with the DME of 1.5 from DCA and you get a position over 3000 feet from the Pentagon at 273 feet above the ground, and it matches the pressure altitude at that point. Bad for you since north of the CITGO station no terrain matches the Radar Altimeter of 273 feet with the pressure altitude recorded. Proof your north flight path, a manuver 77 could not fly due to g force, never happened.

The standard navigation data on the FDR had the plane 1000 or 2000 feet off of its final position. You and JDX need to ignore JREF and sell your lies. Your lies and JDX junk is too easy to show in error. Since your own witnesses saw 77 hit the light post, you and JDX are proven wrong with your witnesses. One stop shopping for lies at the Pentacon.

Oh, the FDR is faked. Then why are there over 24 hours of this flight and previous flights which match 77 flights. Gee, the day before flight is on the FDR, and it goes back 24 hours to other flight flown by this very plane, and that data matches what the plane had done. WRONG again. Why do you lie so much. Tell the rest of the story. The FDR has the exact flights of 77, over 24 hours of data from multiple flights. Proves you last statement is false. At least you are always making up lies. Poor JDX does not have the capability to use his brain and figure out 9/11, or is he just trying to sell misinformation for 15.99?


However, the above is beside the point. Did you question General Partin's analysis of the Murrah building bombing even one small bit? Did you ask if he'd changed his views in light of new evidence? No, you didn't. You simply uncritically trumpeted Partin's report as evidence that the US government has engaged in a pattern of staging fake terror attacks. Now, Malcolm, why didn't you question Parton's Oklahoma City bombing report, which fits perfectly into your preconceptions about the US government, but you now question his opinions about the Pentagon attack, which refute one of your pet conspiracy theories. Please explain why anyone should take you or your arguments seriously, when it's abundantly clear that you're only interested in finding evidence that supports your predetermined conclusion, and ignoring or handwaving away all evidence that does not support that conclusion.
 

Attachments

  • Light Pole 2.jpg
    Light Pole 2.jpg
    81.7 KB · Views: 4
It is not and was not my comment.
I wrote JREF in my post. When the post appeared JREF had magically turned into 'the official government loyalist site' or words to that effect, clever eh?

What exactly are you saying here, Somerled?
 
However, a genuine karaoke machine actually puts an off note back on track. It’s clever and expensive technology. Provided the note sung is near enough, a genuine karaoke machine will put that note in tune. The next time you see an artiste with a mike the size of a vacuum cleaner handle, it’s actually a very expensive ‘karaoke’ mike. The mike needs a box on the floor, but a large mike as described, is a sign of a genuine karaoke machine at work.


Malcolm, do you have any evidence whatsoever for this claim?

I have been researching karaoke machines and I have found absolutely no mention of any system that adjusts the pitch of the note the person is singing. The most expensive system I can find, about $5,000.00, does not mention such a thing.

What they do mention is "pitch control." Pitch control helps adjust the pitch of the pre-recorded song to match the singer's range. (source) But even that isn't automatic. A human has to turn the knob.

And It Only Works On The Pre-Recorded Music, Not The Person's Live Voice.

If you have any evidence of your claim, please post it.
 
What exactly are you saying here, Somerled?
Exactly what I said.
If you type JREF into a post on PilotsRus (Pilots for 911 truth), it will show as
"the official govt loyalty site" or words very close to that. A bit of electronic wizardry.
 
Malcolm, do you have any evidence whatsoever for this claim?

I have been researching karaoke machines and I have found absolutely no mention of any system that adjusts the pitch of the note the person is singing. The most expensive system I can find, about $5,000.00, does not mention such a thing.

What they do mention is "pitch control." Pitch control helps adjust the pitch of the pre-recorded song to match the singer's range. (source) But even that isn't automatic. A human has to turn the knob.

And It Only Works On The Pre-Recorded Music, Not The Person's Live Voice.

If you have any evidence of your claim, please post it.
Put some fuel in your tank = put some petrol into your car.
Thsi is decades old The japanese (Honolulu lulu doesn't like 'japs') did it years ago. Ask any musician etc.
 
For one, the assumption that the body of the aircraft would continue to colide with the building without being damaged, in such a way that the 'total' width of damage possible is obtained.

But, as I said, this isn't all that important, and I'd prefer to just move in for now, if that is alright with you.
Thanks for that.
If you will go to page 88, post 3504, Blackwell has a dinky little diagram behind some clever flap. It shows that the left wingtip will hit the wall 170 beyond where the right wingtip hits. It doesn't matter about the fusilage at all. It's to do with the hypotenuse of a right angled triangle being longer than any side.
If you're still not happy with it after Balckwells explaination, then we'll continue with 125 ft. Thank you.
 
Me said:
Malcolm, do you have any evidence whatsoever for this claim?
Put some fuel in your tank = put some petrol into your car.
Thsi is decades old The japanese (Honolulu lulu doesn't like 'japs') did it years ago. Ask any musician etc.



So, is that a no, then? You cannot post a single link to any source on the internet selling any level of karaoke machine with the capability you claim is "decades old"?

Then I must once again call "Nanners!"

You are caught in yet another lie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom