[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know if the original post of this reconstruction was lost in the ether, lost during moderation, or simply modded into oblivion. If I seriously thought the last, I wouldn't repost, but as I question whether the whole post would simply have been deleted with no warning or mod box, I'm guessing it was one of the first two. Therefore, I'm trying it again. In particular, because I agree with Malcolm that there may be lurkeers here. And they may not be realing the entire 100+ pages. And so they may not be aware of the limits of Malcolm's vaunted dedication to the Truth.

A recent poster just said that he had been at this for four years. It is not possible to be made aware of the facts of 9/11 for that length of time without knowing the truth.


It is not possible to contemplate the name "Malcolm Kirkman", especially in the context of "Manchester" for four weeks without becoming aware of the person we're talking to. At this point we realise that earlier in the thread this poster has volunteered a lot of information about himself that is verifiably UNtrue. Examples:
  • He said he was a successful businessman
  • He said he was extremely rich
  • He said he had an honours degree in Law
  • He said he was a member of Mensa (or had a Mensa-level IQ)
Every single one of these statements has been proven to be false.

Try a bit of truth, I promise you, you won't burst into flames.


You might have thought of that before you tried to fill us up with a pack of lies about your status, finances, qualifications and personal circumstances. If you can't even be true about yourself, why should anyone assume you're true to anything else?

My name is Somerled, you do believe me, don't you?


In a word, no.

Malcolm, just tell us. Supposing anyone was mad enough to put you in touch with this poor woman who lost her son on Flight 175, and you started to tell her that the flight didn't crash, and didn't even take off, and so on, what would you tell her when she asked you, as she inevitably would, what actually happened to her son that day, and where is he now?

Since Malcolm has me on ignore, would someone else he's still talking to ask him that?

Rolfe.
 
I have been reliably informed that this organisation has the matter in hand.
If you scroll down the page you will see an old list with already over 50 relatives on it. Apparently, the truth groups have since multipied and are now in every town. Why don't you join one?

False. I have contact in person and in writing with families of 9/11 victims on a regular basis. Not a single one that I've met or corresponded with believes the desperate lies of the 9/11 deniers. The only family member I've ever met who believed any of this nonsense was a young guy named Dan Wallace – and he knew next to nothing about the facts. He had simply swallowed the truther lies he was fed. I was glad to have a chance to correct him.

You should see the firefighters jeer at the "truthers" at Ground Zero. They hate these creeps.
 
I wonder if you would be so kind as to read the exchange involved in posts 3537 and 3547. You will read a perfect example of someone squirming out of a clear mistake and then being assisted by another squirmer.


Ah, possibly not on ignore at all, then? No matter.


It's anything but the truth you see. They then congratulate each other on having dodged the truth. People who do too much of that end up not knowing the truth at all. Beware you don't end up like that.
If you stay tuned, you will see me clean their collective clocks right around the dial. I shall do it with the one thing that they have completely lost touch with, namely - the truth.


Malcolm, don't make me bring this up again. Not twice in such quick succession. You are such a stranger to the truth that you thought it was just fine to come on here and "impress" us with tales of your high status and great wealth and starry IQ and impressive qualifications. All of which were discovered to be false, because you didn't even have the sense to check what was on the web about you before registering in your own name. As if changing to "Somerled" (how are you getting on with the burger-flipping anyway?) is fooling anyone for a microsecond.

People who pretend to be what they're not, end up not knowing the truth at all. You have completely lost touch with it, so completely that your posts about "truth" are beyond parody.

Rolfe.
 
Malcolm makes me sad yet i want to laugh too. Hmmm.

Is he a joke you made up for when it gets a bit quiet? Perhaps you all take it in turns to play at being "Malcolm" and wait to see if the new members fall for it?

Do i win?
What prize would you like?
 
I don't know who Mrs Sweeney is, but from your description it sounds as if she was told her son was on 175 and that 175 hit tower two.
I'd be grateful if you could seek her out or otherwise put me in touch with her. The first thing I would tell her is that in over 3,500 posts on here, no one has put up one scintilla of evidence that 175 hit the south tower or that 175 even took off. I would then ask truthers near to her to bring her up to date. I would also tell her that I am in the process of demolishing the OCT on this forum and at the moment I'm showing that 77 did not hit the Pentagon and I won't be deflected.


You know, this is really, really disturbing.

Kindly put me in touch with Ace ....


Malcolm, you really need to get out more.

Rolfe.
 
Is this documentary available on the web, or where else can I find it?

"Flight 175: As the World Watched" will be shown on the Discovery-Times channel two times on September 11, at 5:00 AM EST and 8:00 AM EST.

Please watch it, tape it, tell your friends about it. You can't truly understand the sheer immorality of people like "Malcolm Kirkman" until you've looked into the faces of the people whose lives were touched by this horrific event.
 
Hows about I wrote box columns of pre ordained strength. Four times stronger than the specifications required. The aluminium wing has had to cut through the front of the box girder, down both sides and then the back of the box girder. Not to mention the cladding. It has then had to cut through the steel spandrel and the next box girder and so on.
Brevity is a necessity when making a point in these posts.
Do you see how these people forever leap on what they consider to be the weakest point, with no inkling of the big picture.
I wonder if you would be so kind as to read the exchange involved in posts 3537 and 3547. You will read a perfect example of someone squirming out of a clear mistake and then being assisted by another squirmer.
It's anything but the truth you see. They then congratulate each other on having dodged the truth. People who do too much of that end up not knowing the truth at all. Beware you don't end up like that.
If you stay tuned, you will see me clean their collective clocks right around the dial. I shall do it with the one thing that they have completely lost touch with, namely - the truth.


But, Malcolm, you've been badly beaten in every debate you've had. You've had your clock cleaned repeatedly.

You haven't gotten ONE THING right since you showed up on this forum.
Really. Not a SINGLE THING.

You have been exposed, again and again, as an ignoramus and a liar. The truth is not included in your bag of tricks.

We notice that you still haven't bothered to read The Pentagon Building Performance Report (http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/art017.html.)

Why do you persist in peddling your silly fabrications and falsehoods when the truth is readily available?
 
Malcolm makes me sad yet i want to laugh too. Hmmm.

Is he a joke you made up for when it gets a bit quiet? Perhaps you all take it in turns to play at being "Malcolm" and wait to see if the new members fall for it?

Do i win?
Yeah, but don't tell the other noobs. Send a carrier pigeon with a note marked with "@VVDW46^*" and your present location, and one of our trained squirrels will deliver your prize.

And welcome to the forum.
 
I quote you,
"And, no, the voice-morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist."
Everything the military knows, then we know do we? If that's the case, then why does the military bother with - Top Secret - Secret - Classified etc.
Is that what you would have us believe?



Yes, I would have you believe that the voice-morphing technology imagined by the fantasists doesn't exist. It doesn't, and it won't for quite some time.



Is it likely that a passenger would phone his mother and say,
"Mom, this is Mark Bingham, you believe me don't you"?

Your obscene insinuation has been refuted:

http://911myths.com/html/the_9_11_calls_weren_t_real.html



Here you will here that cell phonecalls were impossible.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fbP1lvmBY8



No, we will hear falsehoods because cell phone calls were possible, as everyone who has made them understands perfectly well. I remember a New York-Fort Lauderdale flight in June 2000 on which passengers almost came to blows when two clowns refused to stop making cell phone calls.

Anyone who pretends that cell phone calls from an airliner are impossible is simply lying.




I quote you again,
"...the voice morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist."
Here is the Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/


The story you use to mislead us explains how a speech could be cobbled together. It certainly doesn't try to pretend that any technology exists that could permit a conversation, including specific questions and answers, between family members.

See George Papcun's site for more details.
 
Are you saying that the whole plane folded up and got through a 16 ft x 16 ft space. Because if that's what a Boeing does when it hits something, how come that didn't happen in New York?



I believe this is yours.

If the wings didn't fold back and the tail fold down. Then where are they?
If the wings didn't fold in and stayed outside, then how come they didn't even break a window and where are they?

They DID break windows.

Where are the engines?

They're not made of Adamantium, Malcolm.

There's a photo somewhere I can't be bothered to find, of an open book on a stool. The book is untouched.

I'm surprised such a truthseeker as yourself didn't find an answer to this dilemma of yours.
 
"And, no, the voice-morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist."
Everything the military knows, then we know do we?

I smell an argument from ignorance coming...

Is it likely that a passenger would phone his mother and say,
"Mom, this is Mark Bingham, you believe me don't you"?

Malcolm, simple, serious question: have you EVER been in a traumatic situation where your imminent death was certain ?

Here you will here that cell phonecalls were impossible.

Which is ridiculous. Besides they had PHONES ON the plane.

Here is the Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/

Voice SIMULATION. It's not REAL-TIME, Malcolm.

Do you EVER get anything right ?
 
It's possible I didn't look back far enough. I just read what you wrote, that Malcolm was suggesting that a ricochet would occur if the angle of incidence was greater than 45 degrees (or whatever), and as I hadn't noticed him wrong on that point (that is, actually saying "greater than"), I just thought, Spitfire has had a slip of the fingers, he meant to type "less than".

However, given Malcolm's barely penetrable presentation of his argument, I can well believe that something he said implied that he thought that the greater the angle of incidence the more likely a ricochet, rather than the opposite. Nevertheless, since his more recent posts suggest that this wasn't his understanding, and Malcolm has never been known to correct an error without mega-doses of the clue bat, I think maybe you just didn't pick him up the first time.

Hardly matters, since we're apparently now all in agreement on this point! :)

Rolfe.


I'd better clarify this for everyone's (including Malcolm's) benefit. Angle of incidenceWP is measured with respect to the surface normal, that is, a ray perpendicular to the surface at the point of contact. Therefore, an object striking with zero angle of incidence is striking dead on, and an object striking near 90 degrees angle of incidence is very likely to ricochet. (The angle measured with respect to the surface itself, 90 degrees - angle of incidence, is known as the graze angle, but this term is common only in a few specialized branches of physics.)

A funny side story: Once I was waiting to talk to my physics professor, and the student ahead of me was complaining that he didn't understand part of an assignment. "'Surface normal??' I don't know what a 'surface normal' is!"

I put in, "We just talked about surface normals this morning in Linear Algebra--weren't you paying attention?"

"Hey, man, I was trying to sleep!" :D
 
I'd better clarify this for everyone's (including Malcolm's) benefit. Angle of incidenceWP is measured with respect to the surface normal, that is, a ray perpendicular to the surface at the point of contact. Therefore, an object striking with zero angle of incidence is striking dead on, and an object striking near 90 degrees angle of incidence is very likely to ricochet. (The angle measured with respect to the surface itself, 90 degrees - angle of incidence, is known as the graze angle, but this term is common only in a few specialized branches of physics.)

A funny side story: Once I was waiting to talk to my physics professor, and the student ahead of me was complaining that he didn't understand part of an assignment. "'Surface normal??' I don't know what a 'surface normal' is!"

I put in, "We just talked about surface normals this morning in Linear Algebra--weren't you paying attention?"

"Hey, man, I was trying to sleep!" :D


OK, OK, I was beginning to wonder if I'd got it wrong. It appears that I was making the same mistake as Malcolm.

I find this concept much less alarming than the concept that Malcolm was actually right about something. It's far less of an upset to normality!

Rolfe.
 
But, Malcolm, you've been badly beaten in every debate you've had. You've had your clock cleaned repeatedly.

You haven't gotten ONE THING right since you showed up on this forum.
Really. Not a SINGLE THING.

You have been exposed, again and again, as an ignoramus and a liar. The truth is not included in your bag of tricks.

We notice that you still haven't bothered to read The Pentagon Building Performance Report (http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/art017.html.)

Why do you persist in peddling your silly fabrications and falsehoods when the truth is readily available?
Here is the Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/
Not only did you totally ignore that, but in your very next post you wrote and I quote again,
"You haven't gotten ONE THING right since you showed up on this forum.
Really. Not a SINGLE THING".
 
I'd better clarify this for everyone's (including Malcolm's) benefit. Angle of incidenceWP is measured with respect to the surface normal, that is, a ray perpendicular to the surface at the point of contact. Therefore, an object striking with zero angle of incidence is striking dead on, and an object striking near 90 degrees angle of incidence is very likely to ricochet. (The angle measured with respect to the surface itself, 90 degrees - angle of incidence, is known as the graze angle, but this term is common only in a few specialized branches of physics.)

A funny side story: Once I was waiting to talk to my physics professor, and the student ahead of me was complaining that he didn't understand part of an assignment. "'Surface normal??' I don't know what a 'surface normal' is!"

I put in, "We just talked about surface normals this morning in Linear Algebra--weren't you paying attention?"

"Hey, man, I was trying to sleep!" :D

I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.
 
No, I wouldn't agree with that. The first link you provide shows that the last 20' or so of the wings did not cut cleanly through the steel.



As to the second link you provide, I would need a better photo of the actual damage to be sure, but it looks as if here, too, the outermost portions of the wings did not sever the steel, but rather badly buckled it.
I hope I haven't frightened you off with talk of sines and cosines etc.
If you're not happy with that or anything else, then we'll leave that part out. There's loads of stuff to bat at.
 
There are clearer photos than the one on this page. Would you like me to fond one?

Why don't you answer my points instead of dodging, Malcolm ?

I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

Of course, because all you have ARE weak points.
 
I've already emphasised the "pick on the weakest part and drive it home to the exclusion of the truth" tactic. I'm sure the reader is familiar with that tactic by now.

It's every trick in the book, in order to dodge the truth.

One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.

Pot meet Kettle
 
One of the simplest tactics is to be shown to be wrong and then just change the subject. Never admit an error, just blithely move on.

Yes. Your entire movement has perfected that debate technique to before unknown heights.

When was the last time YOU admitted one of your many errors, hmmmm?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom