[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Malcolm, this whole thing is painful enough for me to read, and I've got absolutely no personal involvement in the events of 9/11. I'm also coming to realise that you absolutely believe what you say when you claim to be demolishing the OCT, and that you don't think anyone has provided any evidence to the contrary.

All that's fine on a message board like this. In general, people seem to be amused by your particular, shall we say, view of reality. But please, don't start seeking out people who's children died on that day and spout your theories to them. That just wouldn't be right.
ps,
You mean people like Donna Marsh O'Connor.
What makes you think they don't already know?
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3438968102444045267
http://www.911truth.org/article.php?story=20041026093059633
http://www.911truthmovement.org/cgi-bin/mt-search.cgi?IncludeBlogs=2&search=families+for+truth
http://www.ny911truth.org/
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/april2007/110407familysupports.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jersey_Girls
If that's not enough, let me know. There's plenty more where these came from. Fire fighters, police, first responders, people in critical condition with respiratory failure and cancers etc.
When I want lessons in morality, I'll let you know.
 
I posted the following as a separate thread, but it certainly belongs here:

Last night I viewed, for the third or fourth time, the Discovery-Times documentary "Flight 175: As the World Watched."

I can't begin to describe how intensely moving I found the experience. It's one of the main reasons I got into the debunking business. If you haven't already seen this extraordinary short film, please make every possible effort to do so.

Is this documentary available on the web, or where else can I find it?
 
Well, it depends on what Malcolm is actually correcting. If Malcolm is attempting to correct my misunderstanding of his (mis)conception of how objects behave when striking planar surfaces, then yes, it's not "obviously wrong." However, if Malcolm is confused about how angle of incidence is measured, then it is "obviously wrong." I think from Malcolm's previous posts that the latter is the case, but I could be mistaken.


It's possible I didn't look back far enough. I just read what you wrote, that Malcolm was suggesting that a ricochet would occur if the angle of incidence was greater than 45 degrees (or whatever), and as I hadn't noticed him wrong on that point (that is, actually saying "greater than"), I just thought, Spitfire has had a slip of the fingers, he meant to type "less than".

However, given Malcolm's barely penetrable presentation of his argument, I can well believe that something he said implied that he thought that the greater the angle of incidence the more likely a ricochet, rather than the opposite. Nevertheless, since his more recent posts suggest that this wasn't his understanding, and Malcolm has never been known to correct an error without mega-doses of the clue bat, I think maybe you just didn't pick him up the first time.

Hardly matters, since we're apparently now all in agreement on this point! :)

Rolfe.
 
Malcolm, this whole thing is painful enough for me to read, and I've got absolutely no personal involvement in the events of 9/11. I'm also coming to realise that you absolutely believe what you say when you claim to be demolishing the OCT, and that you don't think anyone has provided any evidence to the contrary.

All that's fine on a message board like this. In general, people seem to be amused by your particular, shall we say, view of reality. But please, don't start seeking out people who's children died on that day and spout your theories to them. That just wouldn't be right.
I have no personal involvement in 9/11. I'm making it my business.
I do agree this topic can be 'painful'. I can't bring anybody back, but maybe I can cheer you up a bit.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np1sBnJUShg
 
I mean the fuselage (please spell correctly, I gave you examples) of the 757 that impacted the building.

If you can find me a photograph of another 757 that impacted a solid object at 450 to 500 mph, and survived roughly intact, then you might have a point.

Otherwise, you're simply throwing up nonsense by other mouth-breathers with no understanding of the subject matter. I take comments like this as a direct insult to my intelligence. If you can't actually make a valid point, please refrain from posting.
If you wish to speak 'directly', kindly send me a personal message.
 
Do it or don't do it. Just don't waste time arguing with me about whether you're going to do it. That's time you could be spending contacting the church about Reverand Grogan.
I have been reliably informed that this organisation has the matter in hand.
If you scroll down the page you will see an old list with already over 50 relatives on it. Apparently, the truth groups have since multipied and are now in every town. Why don't you join one?
http://www.911truth.org/article.php?story=20041026093059633
 
If you wish to speak 'directly', kindly send me a personal message.

No. I have no desire to have any communication with you outside here. There's nothing I have to say that I feel needs to be hidden from other posters.

As I see you made no response to my actual point, I assume this means you concede you had no purpose in posting that video, and it has no relevence to the discussion at hand?

Good, glad to see we can agree on something. Now, if you believe there is some sort of problem with the fuselage, I'd be glad to hear any actual point you might be able to make.
 
Of course, in that case the better word would in fact have been "not corrugated".
Hows about I wrote box columns of pre ordained strength. Four times stronger than the specifications required. The aluminium wing has had to cut through the front of the box girder, down both sides and then the back of the box girder. Not to mention the cladding. It has then had to cut through the steel spandrel and the next box girder and so on.
Brevity is a necessity when making a point in these posts.
Do you see how these people forever leap on what they consider to be the weakest point, with no inkling of the big picture.
I wonder if you would be so kind as to read the exchange involved in posts 3537 and 3547. You will read a perfect example of someone squirming out of a clear mistake and then being assisted by another squirmer.
It's anything but the truth you see. They then congratulate each other on having dodged the truth. People who do too much of that end up not knowing the truth at all. Beware you don't end up like that.
If you stay tuned, you will see me clean their collective clocks right around the dial. I shall do it with the one thing that they have completely lost touch with, namely - the truth.
 
Malcolm, you can't be serious. We had this conversation:

The parishoners at Holy Cross are under the impression that their church leader, Rev. Francis Grogan, died on September 11, 2001 when his plane, United Flight 175, was hijacked and crashed into the World Trade Center. If you believe in what you have written, you should have no trouble letting them know that their friend and mentor did not die in this manner.
But I bet you don't.
What would you care to bet?
Do it or don't do it. Just don't waste time arguing with me about whether you're going to do it. That's time you could be spending contacting the church about Reverand Grogan.


But then you answer me with this:


I have been reliably informed that this organisation has the matter in hand.
If you scroll down the page you will see an old list with already over 50 relatives on it.


So then I win my bet. Despite your bluster, you are now refusing to contact Holy Cross Church. After going on and on how the first thing you would tell a relative is "that in over 3,500 posts on here, no one has put up one scintilla of evidence that 175 hit the south tower or that 175 even took off." But now, you claim that some organization has the matter in hand and you don't have to do the very same thing you just said you would do.

More than anything, Malcolm, this marks you as a coward and a game player. You do not believe the words you write. You do not stand up for your own ideas. And you do not care one bit whether your actions have any effect upon the world.
 
No. I have no desire to have any communication with you outside here. There's nothing I have to say that I feel needs to be hidden from other posters.

As I see you made no response to my actual point, I assume this means you concede you had no purpose in posting that video, and it has no relevence to the discussion at hand?

Good, glad to see we can agree on something. Now, if you believe there is some sort of problem with the fuselage, I'd be glad to hear any actual point you might be able to make.
What are you trying to say?
Are you saying that the whole plane folded up and got through a 16 ft x 16 ft space. Because if that's what a Boeing does when it hits something, how come that didn't happen in New York?
If the wings didn't fold back and the tail fold down. Then where are they?
If the wings didn't fold in and stayed outside, then how come they didn't even break a window and where are they?
Where are the engines? The seats and the dead passengers? The luggage and all the fuel. There's a photo somewhere I can't be bothered to find, of an open book on a stool. The book is untouched.
What are you saying?
 
What I'm saying is:

What are you trying to say?
Are you saying that the whole plane folded up and got through a 16 ft x 16 ft space.
No. YOU are trying to say that. This is what we refer to as a "Strawman Argument".
Because if that's what a Boeing does when it hits something, how come that didn't happen in New York?
Actually, it did. Only the outer surface had the larger area of impact damage, thinning down to a narrower "point" along the path of the fuselage.
If the wings didn't fold back and the tail fold down. Then where are they?
I didn't say anything about whether they folded or not. I'm sure they deformed intensly, and the evidence shows pieces of them scattered all over.
If the wings didn't fold in and stayed outside, then how come they didn't even break a window and where are they?
This is a flat-out lie. I would appreciate it if you could at least have the decency not to insult my intelligence, and to do basic checking on the accuracy of your claims before spouting nonsense. There was a large area of damage across the front of the building. The picture you posted and asked about, that I answered about, was on the interior of the Pentagon, between two of the rings. It was NOT on the outer impact area, but an area significantly inside the building complex.
Where are the engines?
Several pieces were recovered. The engines were destroyed in the impact. Expecting them to be intact after hitting a reinforced concrete wall at bullet velocities is, well, silly.
The seats and the dead passengers?
The remains were recovered from the crash site.
The luggage and all the fuel.
Again, remains were recovered. The fuel was scattered all throughout the outer ring. Many of the survivors mentioned the fuel, as they smelled it in the building after impact. It also fed the fires that burned for some time after the impact.
There's a photo somewhere I can't be bothered to find, of an open book on a stool. The book is untouched.
Since you can't be bothered to provide any evidence, I can't be bothered to consider you in any way, shape, form or fashion to be remotely credible, or to have any valid expertise that would qualify you to provide an authoritive answer on anything...including how to tie shoes. Don't bring it up if you can't find the evidence.

On this specific point, though, a tornado went over my house a few years back. We were in the direct line of it. The house across the street lost it's roof. The building behind us was levelled. We had several shingles torn off. Yet we had a very light plastic chair that wasn't even budged. My point? A crash, like a tornado, is a chaotic event. It won't destroy everything in an area, and some things will be amazingly untouched. It is routine for investigators to find the explosive packaging and pieces of detonators and triggering devices at the site of explosions, for example. Something which, I might add, was NOT found at the Pentagon site or the WTC. No detonators, no missile fuses, nothing.

What are you saying?

I'm saying you've presented no credible evidence at all. I'm saying you seem to be unable to construct an argument, understand and/or use logic, or otherwise make a valid point at all. Instead, you post unresearched, poorly thought out propoganda pieces. You mis-label pictures to further your own ends. You present evidence you think supports your pre-determined concluison without checking its credibility or even the basic circumstances surrounding it. I'm saying you are intellectually dishonest, morally deficient, and ethically bankrupt. I'm saying you've yet to present an argument worhty of consideration, so far your ENTIRE theory boils down to "But I don't think so".

It is an insult to the intelligence of everyone here that you "refute" reasoned, well-thought arguments with nonsense such as the youtube video you posted to me. Is is a sign of your own lack of integrity that you post a picture of damage to an interior ring as "evidence" that the wings did no damage. It is a sign of the amount of "research" you seem willing to do on a toipic that is "important" to you that you continually make the false claim that there was no damage outside of a 16'x16' hole on the exterior. It is a statement of your lack of understanding and lack of education in physics and your general ignorance of impact results that you seem to believe there should be a full, intact wing lying on the lawn.

Was that clear enough?

Now, do you have an actual point, or will you continue to simply assert things as true in contradicton to all available evidence?
 
Last edited:
A demonstrably ignorant and insensitive person.






Mrs. Sweeney spoke with her son right before he died. You see, HE CALLED HER FROM AN AIRPHONE ON FLIGHT 175.

And, no, the voice-morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist.







You have ignored or, more likely, are incapable of comprehending the overwhelming evidence that destroys your pernicious fantasy. Air traffic controllers from Boston and New York tracked Flight 175 very closely. Remains of the passengers were identified at the crash site by forensic specialists. Wreckage of the aircraft was found.






Edited by chillzero: 
Edit for civility
Your obtuseness is no excuse.






Why would anyone ever believe you? You're a proven liar, remember?
I quote you,
"And, no, the voice-morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist."
Everything the military knows, then we know do we? If that's the case, then why does the military bother with - Top Secret - Secret - Classified etc.
Is that what you would have us believe?
Is it likely that a passenger would phone his mother and say,
"Mom, this is Mark Bingham, you believe me don't you"?
Here you will here that cell phonecalls were impossible.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fbP1lvmBY8
I quote you again,
"...the voice morphing technology imagined by fantasists does not yet exist."
Here is the Washington Post February 1st 1999,
http://www.public-action.com/911/voice-simulation/
 
Malcolm makes me sad yet i want to laugh too. Hmmm.

Is he a joke you made up for when it gets a bit quiet? Perhaps you all take it in turns to play at being "Malcolm" and wait to see if the new members fall for it?

Do i win?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom