[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can't break a window? Lots of windows were broken on the first floor. In both cases, it was the damage from the crash and the resulting fires that caused the collapses.

So, where is your proof that the armored bad boys existed?
With regard to the Pentagon, I don't have any.
 
I blame nineteen terrorists, and others who abetted them. Were/are they Muslims? I do remember reading that somehwere, as a matter of fact. Does that matter? Would blame them less if they were Buddhists or Seventh Day Adventists? I blame them for what they did, not for what they were.

However, that's not the point you were trying to make, was it? You're warning me that I could be wrong. (Well, you're telling me I am wrong, but I don't have any reason to take your word for it in the face of the contrary evidence. So I'll take your statement, instead, as a polite warning that I could be wrong.) The important thing in any case is that if I am wrong, there are consequences.

This is called responsibility, and it's something people encounter and deal with as they gain experience with the real world. In the real world there are always consequences. People get hurt when you make bad decisions or mistakes. If I drive carelessly, I could kill people including my own passengers who are trusting me to keep them safe. If as a lab technician I make certain mistakes, I could injure or even kill a test subject (a healthy volunteer, no less), and even small injury resulting from such an error could ruin the research program and the careers of the senior researchers. That means those researchers must trust me with their own livelihoods. And that's nothing, compared with the level of responsibility assumed by the people here who have worked in such positions as air traffic controllers, military officers, engineers, and doctors.

Young people live in a sheltered world with few consequences, where no one is relying on them, or trusting them to make any important decisions, or really, paying much attention to them at all. Perhaps this accounts for why you have not yet learned the importance of keeping your word, as evidenced by your "change of mind" concerning the donation offer you chose not to honor. For most young people, no one has any reason to care if they keep their word or not, and short of going out and committing actual crimes, their decisions have few consequences more severe than a bad grade, or being grounded, or being seen as uncool by their peers.

So, yes, if I'm wrong about my conclusions about 9/11, I'm partly responsible for the real perpetators' benefit and for the real suffering of the ones I wrongly blame, here in the real world. And I actually care whether or not I make that mistake and cause that harm. That's why I evaluate the evidence in the most effecitve way available, using reason, scientific knowledge, and critical thinking. That's why I don't pay attention to what I want to be true, or whom I wish might be at fault, or which theory makes me feel better, or which theory is more fun to argue, or which theory the cool kids are promoting.

To most kids, no consequences appear more severe than being thought uncool by their peers. (The ones for whom that's not true are often called nerds, geeks, dweebs, etc.) So, it's right, in a way, that kids will favor the cool theory every time, without regard to critical thought or for any other reason than that it's cool.

But that's also why grown-ups shouldn't give them the car keys, let alone the machinery of legal retribution, until they show some capacity for responsibility.

That's also why debate techniques that undermine your own credibility, however clever they might seem to you, won't ever win you the retribution you claim to be seeking.

Respectfully,
Myriad
We'll see.
 
Oh dear, how sad.

Misdirection didn't work, veiled threats didn't work, righteous indignation didn't work, moving goalposts didn't work. So what's left in your bag of clever?

Apparently, transparently false claims of misquoting and misrepresentation.

Unless, perchance, you can cite where I misquoted you.

Or you can show how this:

(emphasis added)







... is anything other than an unusually blatant textbook example of moving the goalposts. In fact, I won't be surprised if future discussions on this forum, about what "moving the goalposts" means, link to this post as an example.

What is obvious is exactly which points you asked me to focus my attention on, and that I responded exactly as you requested.




Feel free to keep asking me to apologize, without justification.

Perhaps you're not as good at this as you thought.

Respectfully,
Myriad

PS If you're not really left-handed, now's the time to reveal it!
Left handed = ?
 
Why would a scientist, let's just say for instance, have concerns about radiation in this situation? Unless he/she knew something already, he/she wouldn't even suspect radiation. All he/she knows at that time is planes have crashed into the towers, exploded, and subsequently, the buildings came down. Here was the catalyst, no reason to suspect nukes.

I'm not an expert, but by reading different forums and learning (I don't take one theory and run with it, I try to determine whether or not it can be ruled out) about what is being presented, I soon get an understanding about what I'm learning.
Greenings (Apollo20) findings have shown there to be a high amount of chlorinated species from the USGS reading, from the New York Board of Health 's data of the rubble pile, and the EPA's data. You can rule out thermite with these high amounts of chlorine. Thermite needs a certain aluminum to aluminum oxide ratio to remain energetic, but the one thing that will upset this ratio is chlorination. The nukes? These things have been banned for years, even the testing of them.
High levels of tritium? Exit signs have tritium in them, how many exit signs was there per floor in these towers? Melted cars? Chloroform is very corrosive, and as mentioned before, the high amounts chlorinated species found in the data would be a determining factor for that. There are chemical reactions of the metals involved and how they react to the heat, eventually becoming fuel itself. Chemistry reveals the true answer as to what happened with the collapse of the towers, not speculation and a Geiger counter.

I have already read those sites you linked to Me, last year. If you really believe that the govt. could plant nukes, or any other type of demolition device in a civilian building, for what purpose does it serve to go to such extreme lengths if they just LIHOP?
I'm assuming that our amateur scientist went to the sites as a seasoned poster on web sites - hence my statement. I say that because a previous post said so and so WENT to the sites. It is highly unlikely to me, that anyone so interested would be unfamiliar with the net and the debates.
I don't know how t owrite this next bit without cringing, it's to do with too many initials. Here goes, LIHOP is dead and buried, everyone is MIHOP these days.
You rule out thermite ? So what is pouring from the north east corner of tower 2 ?
 
So how come the wing didn't even knoch down the fence ?
[qimg]http://www.911review.org/images/snopes/car-whitep.JPG[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.911review.org/images/snopes/car911.JPG[/qimg]
Uh, did you link to the wrong pictures? Because I see a fence knocked down in those photos. Quite visibly so.
 
If you look at 'my' video more closely, you will see material being ejected above the surrounding smoke.

Aside from explosives, can you think of a reason why ?

You make no mention of the two demolition squids

The word you're looking for is "squib", and it's not used in demolitions. More evidence that you haven't researched this subject very thoroughly.

Also, some still burning steel being hurled outwards with far greater force than would be possible in a conventional collapse.

What's the maximum force that would be possible in a conventional collapse ?

Calculations, please.

Here is more white demolition smoke, do you have an alternative explanation for this ?

Right, so...

Black smoke = oxygen-starved
White smoke = demolition
Grey smoke = everything normal.

Is that it ?

Also, if you look closely into the shadow on the north side of tower 2, you will see steel on FIRE.

Steel. On fire. How do you know it's on fire ? How do you know it's not just fire from a window... or hot steel ? Or what ?
 
Can I precis your post as follows,
In New York a commercial jetliner can bring down a skyscraper, in Washington the same plane can't break a window.

How do you truthers manage to tie your shoes every day ?

First, "precis" isn't an English word.

Second, a 767 and a 757 aren't the same plane.

Third, a whole side of the Pentagon collapsed. Isn't that "damage" ?

How do you manage to make so many mistakes about everything ? Don't you research this stuff ?

Subterrainean burning? Undergound coal fires?
Manhattan Island is waterlogged. They had to excavate down to bed rock and then build a reinforced concrete 'bathtub'.
Consequently, there is absolutely no possibility of any other source of these fires other than due to the demolition.

Explosives ARE NOT INCENDIARIES, Malcolm. It's not the movies where every bomb in the universe procuces a fireball.

You make the everlasting mistake, which to be fair to you, is common in the USA, of picking on what you think is the weakest point and ignoring the rest.

Be careful about those goalposts, Malcolm. Don't drop it on your foot.

For example, ask questions like what were the hijackers carrying? Box cutter in one pocket, GPS in another, flight maps stuck down their shirts etc. Box cutters, by the way, were a banned item prior to 9/11 - see what I mean.

Patently false. Are you lying, here ? Or was it just poor research ?

And pilots in WWI didn't need GPS. I wonder why.

Or do you mean 'called out' on, for example, the one webpage of 250 smoking guns

Just because Killclown can come up with stuff he doesn't understand by the hundreds doesn't make a case for the truth movement.
 
To most kids, no consequences appear more severe than being thought uncool by their peers. (The ones for whom that's not true are often called nerds, geeks, dweebs, etc.) So, it's right, in a way, that kids will favor the cool theory every time, without regard to critical thought or for any other reason than that it's cool.

But that's also why grown-ups shouldn't give them the car keys, let alone the machinery of legal retribution, until they show some capacity for responsibility.

Nominated. It's a good thing I never had this "cool kid" phase.
 
If the left wing hit the ground as you say, what happened to the underslung engine?

Well it didn't bounce on the lawn and remain intact in the process.

Feel free to apologise

Well, isn't that cute.

kindly tell me why the Boeing didn't go through the wall

Kindly stop using that word.

Boeings are not bullets, Malcolm. They're made of several parts and are less compact. Thank you.

Also,

Ground.

So what is pouring from the north east corner of tower 2 ?

Yes, indeed. Only thermite can pour. Other molten materials just... er.... what do they do ?
 
I write
Now that you have cleared that up how about you supply the NOTAM I requested near the beginning of this thread, concerning flight restrictions at Offut. Please, no conjecture pieces by Killtown of any theorist, just the hard facts, just the NOTAM.

Next you can supply the evidence that "bad boy" versions of civilian jets such as you have described, actually exist. No conjecture, just the facts.

malcolm answers with;

Do you remember these words, they are part of your post 2592
-----
Obviously you would agree that a bullet can penetrate a plaster wall. A bullet is made of soft lead, is not as sharply pointed as a dart and has less mass than a dart. A .22 caliber bullet has a muzzle velocity of just under 1100 fps, less than 60% greater than a dart travelling at 700 fps.

If a dart has 1.54 times the mass of a bullet and is travelling at 65% the speed of a bullet the dart the dart and the bullet will have the same momentum. The kinetic energy of the dart will still be 70% that of the bullet. If the bullet would still have 55% of its velocity after having passed through the wall ( a safe bet ) then the dart also would have enough KE to pass through the wall.

Now malcolm, please scale up the math and physics for a large Boeing and a brick and concrete wall.
-----
Here's the Boeing and the wall, kindly tell me why the Boeing didn't go through the wall,
[qimg]http://www.members.shaw.ca/freedomsix/pics/pentcrash.jpg[/qimg]


How about you answer my questions with a statement rather than a question irrelevent to the topic I asked about.

Furthermore, the example of the bullet and the dart were, by your starting that example, into a plaster wall. I addressed it and asked YOU to scale things up top a Boeing into the Pentagon. You instead require others to do it for you and then require others to explain why it does not occur as you, who will do no math, who will do no physics, believe it should have occured.

If fact the Boeing did indeed go into the building.

In point of fact early on in the topic of the Pentagon you made reference to the aircraft going through 12 walls. It was pointed out to you that it went through exactly ONE blast hardened exterior wall and that debris punched a hole in ONE non-hardened exterior wall.

Damage to the facade is visible along the entire length of where the plane hit.

I forget malcolm, what do you believe caused the amage at the Pentagon?
 
I blame nineteen terrorists, and others who abetted them. Were/are they Muslims? I do remember reading that somehwere, as a matter of fact. Does that matter? Would blame them less if they were Buddhists or Seventh Day Adventists? I blame them for what they did, not for what they were.

However, that's not the point you were trying to make, was it? You're warning me that I could be wrong. (Well, you're telling me I am wrong, but I don't have any reason to take your word for it in the face of the contrary evidence. So I'll take your statement, instead, as a polite warning that I could be wrong.) The important thing in any case is that if I am wrong, there are consequences.

This is called responsibility, and it's something people encounter and deal with as they gain experience with the real world. In the real world there are always consequences. People get hurt when you make bad decisions or mistakes. If I drive carelessly, I could kill people including my own passengers who are trusting me to keep them safe. If as a lab technician I make certain mistakes, I could injure or even kill a test subject (a healthy volunteer, no less), and even small injury resulting from such an error could ruin the research program and the careers of the senior researchers. That means those researchers must trust me with their own livelihoods. And that's nothing, compared with the level of responsibility assumed by the people here who have worked in such positions as air traffic controllers, military officers, engineers, and doctors.

Young people live in a sheltered world with few consequences, where no one is relying on them, or trusting them to make any important decisions, or really, paying much attention to them at all. Perhaps this accounts for why you have not yet learned the importance of keeping your word, as evidenced by your "change of mind" concerning the donation offer you chose not to honor. For most young people, no one has any reason to care if they keep their word or not, and short of going out and committing actual crimes, their decisions have few consequences more severe than a bad grade, or being grounded, or being seen as uncool by their peers.

So, yes, if I'm wrong about my conclusions about 9/11, I'm partly responsible for the real perpetators' benefit and for the real suffering of the ones I wrongly blame, here in the real world. And I actually care whether or not I make that mistake and cause that harm. That's why I evaluate the evidence in the most effecitve way available, using reason, scientific knowledge, and critical thinking. That's why I don't pay attention to what I want to be true, or whom I wish might be at fault, or which theory makes me feel better, or which theory is more fun to argue, or which theory the cool kids are promoting.

To most kids, no consequences appear more severe than being thought uncool by their peers. (The ones for whom that's not true are often called nerds, geeks, dweebs, etc.) So, it's right, in a way, that kids will favor the cool theory every time, without regard to critical thought or for any other reason than that it's cool.

But that's also why grown-ups shouldn't give them the car keys, let alone the machinery of legal retribution, until they show some capacity for responsibility.

That's also why debate techniques that undermine your own credibility, however clever they might seem to you, won't ever win you the retribution you claim to be seeking.

Respectfully,
Myriad

You say you blame 19 terrorists who just happen to be moslems.
You accept that if you are wrong, which you doubt but I claim, then you are partially responsible for the real perps benefits and the duffering of those wronged. Will your acceptance of responsibility stretch to the troops that have been and any casualties in Iran, should Iran be attacked?
You say you have evaluated the evidence in the most effective way available to you.
You won't mind if I attempt to present further evidence to you, to show that 9/11 was indeed an 'inside job', will you ?
After all, we both, despite your inferences that I am a 'cool' teenager, feel strongly about this matter, yet have arrived at different conclusions.
You wouldn't be posting on this threa if you didn't feel strongly about the matter, with that in mind, I hope you will allow me to present to you some of the many points which indeed show you to be incorrect about this.
I hope you enter into this dialogue with me with an open mind.
What better place to start than this current topic, the posts are right here. Do you believe that a Boeing 757 which is 125 ft wide and over 44ft tall, somehow managed to get through a hole say 12 ft by 20 ft ?
This is the hole,
car-whitep.JPG

Respectfully.
Would you also explain what could be construed as a veiled threat, I quote,
"If you're not really left handed, now's the time to reveal it".
 
Consequently, there is absolutely no possibility of any other source of these fires other than due to the demolition.

No source of fire other than demolition? The buildings were on fire. They carried on being on fire after they fell over. That really isn't difficult to understand.

I'll put this as simply as I possibly can:
1) Buildings are on fire.
2) Buildings fall over.
3) Fires carry on burning.
4) Metal may have melted due to fire.*

As opposed to your scenario which is apparently:
1) Buildings are on fire.
2) Explosives are set off.
3) Metal melts because of explosives.*
4) Buildings fall over, all fires go out.
5) Metal magically stays molten for at least two more weeks.*

Can you really not see how utterly insane that sounds? Fires can burn underground, or indeed under piles of rubble. Things under the piles of rubble are known to have been burning. Why would you think explosives need to be involved at any point?

I do notice that you have payed absolutely no attention to the fact that there isn't any evidence that metal was actually molten at any time after the collapse. Care to address that now? While it is amusing to demolish your bizzare arguments about how the metal melted, it's all rather pointless when you haven't shown that it actually did. It's rather like asking what kind of fairies the Invisible Pink Unicorn eats. There's no point asking it until you show that the IPU actually exists in the first place.

I also notice that you completely failed to address the main point of my post, which is that the "mini-nukes" you say you suspect were used do not actually exist. Care to provide any evidence here?
 
I am pretty new to the forums here, but I have not only read through every post in this thread, I have gone through every post in this thread: "Loose Change - Part III" and this thread: "Loose Change - Part IV" in the last week or so.

I have come to the conclusion that there is nothing you can do, short of taking people like Truthseeker1234, Killtown and Malcolm back in time to the locations of the events of 9-11-01 and letting them watch them in person, that will convince them that they are incorrect.

Malcolm has stated that there is nothing, no evidence that is available, no science, that will convince him that he is incorrect.

He does not seek the truth about the events of 9-11-01, he has stated so more than once.

I am not seeking the truth, I am seeking justice, vengeance and retribution.
I already know the truth.

I've said it once, and I'll say it again: I sincerely believe that malcolm and most others here who believe 911 was an inside job would NEVER accept any conclusion from ANY investigation that concluded anything other than an inside job.
You are totally, utterly, absolutely and completely CORRECT.

People coming to this forum for the first time need to be aware that the rebuttals to these people are posted more to show these people for what they are, as opposed to trying to convince the CTers that they are wrong, since they will never listen to reason and they refuse to apply logic.

Now, with that said, what is the title of this thread?
Answer: 175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Malcolm still has not proven that 175 did not hit the south tower.
Malcolm, please show us the proof.

Thank you.
 
Worried? Piffile. it doesn't even generate mild concern.

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

Pages 35 to 39 (23 to 25 as the PDF is numbered). For your sake, I chose pages with everything diagramed out in nice pictures, but you really should read it - interesting stuff, and can answer the vast majority of your questions.

The engine did not end up on the lawn - it was dragged into the building with the majority of the aircraft. you can see from the diagrams, the actual damage to the building was much wider than the distance between the two engines, which are much closer to the center-line of the aircraft.

Also, consider: http://www.911myths.com/html/pentagon_4.html

As the paragraph below states:
"This photo of engine remains was taken in either D or C-ring by VATF-1 workers."

You can't find pictures of the engine resting on the lawn because, in fact, the engine ended up inside the building.

Well, I've upheld my end of the agreement..your turn.
How did both engines get inside the building ?
 
Uh, did you link to the wrong pictures? Because I see a fence knocked down in those photos. Quite visibly so.
It is kind of you to point this out.
As you may have gathered, I am new to posting photos.
In the photo below, the two portions of the fence to the left of the picture are still intact. This is where the wing would have had to hit.
There is no mistake and no alternative explanation. The wall that you can see through the fence, is where the left wing and engine would have had to hit.
In fact, to get the nose of the plane into the hole, the engine would have been cutting a furrow in the ground and the famous white car would not be there.
There is no mistake. Take your time, have a cup of tea. Probably in your case coffee. You won't be able to escape the truth now, your conscience won't let you. As I say, take your time.

car911.JPG

pl11.jpg
 
The complete Pentagon Building Report is available at:

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/art017.html


Needless to say, Malcolm hasn't read a word of it. But, then, who needs scientists and structural engineers figuring out what really happened when you've got Killclown making up stuff.

Oh, Malcolm: You were caught lying about your imaginary "military bad boys." They don't exist, you know. When are you planning to apologize?
 
the part of the fence that is too far to the left for the wing to reach or the part that is actually knocked down?
A Boeing is 125 ft wingspan.
Half of that is 62 ft. The part of the fence that is upright isn't 62 ft away from the hole.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom