[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Malcolm - it's getting old stating facts and getting logical fallacies, like the one you repiled with above, in return. I simply ask for some evidence of armored transport planes, or evidence that the airplanes should've bounced off the towers. Do you have any? Yes or no? I dont want a response along the lines of "...military planes must be armored to protect them from enemy fire..." -or- "....planes dont just slide into buildings, thats impossible".

How about you search for something out of an engineering journal or university level engineering textbook, instead of conspiracy sites. I've also asked you, with no reply, why no physics professionals question the impacts as you do? Steven Jones was a physics proffessor, he is a member of the 9/11 Truth Movement. Why doesn't he think the impacts are anomolous? Please answer, I am most interested in your response to this...
Do you mean journals such as Popular Mechanics ?
 
Can I precis your post as follows,
In New York a commercial jetliner can bring down a skyscraper, in Washington the same plane can't break a window.

I believe My first bullet-point was that those windows were NOT unbroken, so no, this would not be an accurate summation of my post.

But enough banter. Come over here. Going to let you in on a little secret. The rest of you, go away for a sec, this is for my main man Malcolm here...See, the thing is, I don't think you want anyone hearing me tell you this, cause I don't want you to get all embaressed. I mean, you should've been able to figure this one out. But there's a simple explanation as to why those windows are not broken (assuming they're not, for arguments sake)

The plane, and there was a plane, don't get any silly ideas, simply didn't hit those windows. That's right, nothing magic, no super-powers, the plane just missed them. Judging by the admittedly limited view provided from that picture, I'd say it went below them. Whatever they did to re-enforce the glass there helped, too. But mostly, the plane just missed.

We know the plane was not flying level when it hit, the right wing was tilted higher than the left, with the right hitting a generator and the left the ground. (referenced in a previous post of mine), and while a plane sitting on it's landing gear might be higher than 2 stories, one end of the wing isn't, so it would easily miss the 2nd floor if it were tilted.

So that's it. the big secret. Everyone can come back now, Malcolm has something he wants to tell you all, and it'll be...His next post! tune in soon!
 
You have obviously studied 'my' video (I use the term 'my' for brevity only)
looking for the most ambiguous point, this you are entitled to do.


No. I looked specifically for the parts you told me to look for, to answer the questions you specifically posed. To refresh your (and everyone's) memory:

In this video the commentator offers an explanation for the 'rooftop demolitions'. Do you have an alternative explanation ? 40 to 45 secs.
Also, at 1.10 to 1.40, the commentator offers an explanation as to upward moving debris. Do you have an alternative explanation ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation.


I would conjecture, from the fact that you asked them, that you regarded those questions as the strongest, least ambiguous points of the video. They've only become the "most ambiguous" points now that I've explained them.

If you look at 'my' video more closely, you will see material being ejected above the surrounding smoke.


Impossible to determine, because of the ways the video has been tampered with, as I said before.

However, I would not be surprised if plumes of dust expanded in all directions including upward at various moments in the collapse, because dust is carried by air currents and turbulent air currents (by definition of "turbulent" this implies motion in any and all directions) would occur in a collapse.

You make no mention of the two demolition squids, the row of demolitions or all the ejected materials. Also, some still burning steel being hurled outwards with far greater force than would be possible in a conventional collapse.
Here is more white demolition smoke, do you have an alternative explanation for this ?
Also, if you look closely into the shadow on the north side of tower 2, you will see steel on FIRE.
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/towers%20falling/fema_wtc2exp.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/towers%20falling/site1049.jpg[/qimg]


Since you claim to be unfamiliar with the term "troll," you might also be unfamiliar with the phrase "moving goalposts."

It's a fallacious and dishonest style of argumentation, in which you ask specific questions, then reject the answers as insufficient because they do not address different questions that you did not bother to ask.

This is exactly what you have done here. You asked me to comment specifically on "rooftop demolition" and upward movement of debris. Now you accuse me of deliberately "looking for the most ambiguous point" in so doing, and claim that I have not answered questions you never asked, about "squibs" (or was that "squids"?) and "white demolition smoke" and "steel on FIRE."

Otherwise-intelligent people who are unaccustomed to arguing with people more experienced than themselves often mistakenly see this as clever. What they overlook is that it destroys their credibility. (They think credibility is only damaged by being shown wrong, so they use moving goalposts and other dodges to avoid having to admit being shown wrong. Of course, what actually ruins credibility is not being shown wrong, it's being caught trying to weasel out of admitting it.)

Needless to say, if I were to answer your new questions, I (and everyone else reading this) now have every reason to believe that they too would in turn suddenly become "most ambiguous points."

Here are my questions for you, and rest assured that these goal posts will not move:

Did you fall for the video's deceptive claim of evidence for "roof demolition?"

Do you see now that there is no such evidence shown in the video, and the video was obviously pointing to a freeze frame of the ongoing flow of smoke from the fires and pretending it was something else?

How do you feel about the video producer attempting (whether or not he succeeded) to deceive you in this way?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Not at all.

As I stated earlier, I am personally done jumping through hoops with someone who continually lies, and refuses to acknowledge the mistakes they make, over and over and over again. I made a compilation of "Malcolm's Greatest Hits" (or more accurately, misses) earlier in this thread, with some of your more blatant half-truths, mistakes, and outright lies (such as the claim that 9/11 was a cloudy day), hoping that people will notice that you've been throwing (rule 8) against the wall for 50+ pages of this thread, and hoping something - anything - will stick. In the cases where you've been called on your nonsense, you ignore it and move on. Never once admitting or correcting your mistakes.

I ahve realized that it's worthless to pick one point and expect you to back it up. You simply run away - more like a child than anyone looking for serious debate. Sure, I could pick just one topic - say, you're earlier mentioned claim that 9/11 was a cloudy day - and ask you to back it up with proof. But why bother? You've proven that you have no interest backing anything up. Plenty of other posters here have shown you weather maps and photos form the day in question. You won't acknowedge that you are simply wrong. (Feel free to make my point for me and ignore this particular topic one more time.)

This last post was not "the best I could put together", but it was simply another piece of evidence that you are not who you have been claiming to be. Your continued attempts to introduce certain terms and phrases into your posts reeks of a child impersonating an adult - parroting what you heard, but just not clear exactly what it means (or how to spell it).

When confronted with your horrible grasp of common phrases and their meanings, you reply with this:



So, now it's my turn to ask you... is that really the best reply you can come up with when someone points out that someone claiming to be a retired businessman doesn't know how to spell "C'est la vie", or "vis a vis"?

Malcolm, you are a child. I don't mean that as an insult. I am saying that your actions and choice of language give you away.

You make the everlasting mistake, which to be fair to you, is common in the USA, of picking on what you think is the weakest point and ignoring the rest.
This 'selective targetting' of what to address, at the expense of the whole, will only work in a hit and run type situation. It cannot last the course.
Your 'weather' reference, is on relation to both yours and anyone elses ability to put together a reasonable scenario whereby 'hijackers' take over regular flights anh get their planes to their targets. No one got close, the best scenario was along the lines of 1) Go to the airport 2) hijack a plane 3} fly it to New York.
I didn't even have to dig partially deep. For example, ask questions like what were the hijackers carrying? Box cutter in one pocket, GPS in another, flight maps stuck down their shirts etc. Box cutters, by the way, were a banned item prior to 9/11 - see what I mean.
Or do you mean 'called out' on, for example, the one webpage of 250 smoking guns, Mr Homer, the 'scientific' probability theory, to say nothing of this current hole on the Pentagon ?
 
I believe My first bullet-point was that those windows were NOT unbroken, so no, this would not be an accurate summation of my post.

But enough banter. Come over here. Going to let you in on a little secret. The rest of you, go away for a sec, this is for my main man Malcolm here...See, the thing is, I don't think you want anyone hearing me tell you this, cause I don't want you to get all embaressed. I mean, you should've been able to figure this one out. But there's a simple explanation as to why those windows are not broken (assuming they're not, for arguments sake)

The plane, and there was a plane, don't get any silly ideas, simply didn't hit those windows. That's right, nothing magic, no super-powers, the plane just missed them. Judging by the admittedly limited view provided from that picture, I'd say it went below them. Whatever they did to re-enforce the glass there helped, too. But mostly, the plane just missed.

We know the plane was not flying level when it hit, the right wing was tilted higher than the left, with the right hitting a generator and the left the ground. (referenced in a previous post of mine), and while a plane sitting on it's landing gear might be higher than 2 stories, one end of the wing isn't, so it would easily miss the 2nd floor if it were tilted.

So that's it. the big secret. Everyone can come back now, Malcolm has something he wants to tell you all, and it'll be...His next post! tune in soon!

If the left wing hit the ground as you say, what happened to the underslung engine?
Can you show me whereabouts in the lawn it is,
pl1.jpg

Don't worry if you can't find it, neither can these,
http://www.asile.org/citoyens/numero13/pentagone/erreurs_en.htm
http://thewebfairy.com/killtown/pentalawn.html
I'll mention the wing itself and the fence, when you answer that.
 
No. I looked specifically for the parts you told me to look for, to answer the questions you specifically posed. To refresh your (and everyone's) memory:




I would conjecture, from the fact that you asked them, that you regarded those questions as the strongest, least ambiguous points of the video. They've only become the "most ambiguous" points now that I've explained them.




Impossible to determine, because of the ways the video has been tampered with, as I said before.

However, I would not be surprised if plumes of dust expanded in all directions including upward at various moments in the collapse, because dust is carried by air currents and turbulent air currents (by definition of "turbulent" this implies motion in any and all directions) would occur in a collapse.




Since you claim to be unfamiliar with the term "troll," you might also be unfamiliar with the phrase "moving goalposts."

It's a fallacious and dishonest style of argumentation, in which you ask specific questions, then reject the answers as insufficient because they do not address different questions that you did not bother to ask.

This is exactly what you have done here. You asked me to comment specifically on "rooftop demolition" and upward movement of debris. Now you accuse me of deliberately "looking for the most ambiguous point" in so doing, and claim that I have not answered questions you never asked, about "squibs" (or was that "squids"?) and "white demolition smoke" and "steel on FIRE."

Otherwise-intelligent people who are unaccustomed to arguing with people more experienced than themselves often mistakenly see this as clever. What they overlook is that it destroys their credibility. (They think credibility is only damaged by being shown wrong, so they use moving goalposts and other dodges to avoid having to admit being shown wrong. Of course, what actually ruins credibility is not being shown wrong, it's being caught trying to weasel out of admitting it.)

Needless to say, if I were to answer your new questions, I (and everyone else reading this) now have every reason to believe that they too would in turn suddenly become "most ambiguous points."

Here are my questions for you, and rest assured that these goal posts will not move:

Did you fall for the video's deceptive claim of evidence for "roof demolition?"

Do you see now that there is no such evidence shown in the video, and the video was obviously pointing to a freeze frame of the ongoing flow of smoke from the fires and pretending it was something else?

How do you feel about the video producer attempting (whether or not he succeeded) to deceive you in this way?

Respectfully,
Myriad
This is simply an attempt to concentrate attention on what you consider to be the weakest part of the video. In order to do this, you mis quote me.
Nobody is moving any goalposts, ket's keep it that way.
My words exactly, I quote,
"I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation".
Why, when I specifically asked you NOT to comment on his explanation, did not only go on to do exactly that. But also use that as a basis for a
concentrated attack upon my credibility.
Your words and I quote,
It's a fallacious and dishonest style of argumentation, in which you ask specific questions, then reject the answers as insufficient because they do not address different questions that you did not bother to ask.

This is exactly what you have done here. You asked me to comment specifically on "rooftop demolition" and upward movement of debris. Now you accuse me of deliberately "looking for the most ambiguous point" in so doing, and claim that I have not answered questions you never asked, about "squibs" (or was that "squids"?) and "white demolition smoke" and "steel on FIRE."

Otherwise-intelligent people who are unaccustomed to arguing with people more experienced than themselves often mistakenly see this as clever. What they overlook is that it destroys their credibility. (They think credibility is only damaged by being shown wrong, so they use moving goalposts and other dodges to avoid having to admit being shown wrong. Of course, what actually ruins credibility is not being shown wrong, it's being caught trying to weasel out of admitting it.)

Needless to say, if I were to answer your new questions, I (and everyone else reading this) now have every reason to believe that they too would in turn suddenly become "most ambiguous points."
Feel free to apologise,
Respectfully.
 
Where is your question ?
You answer in the penultimate sentence, then ask a clearly irrelevant question in your final sentence. I don't follow your reasoning.
I advocate that this matter be resolved using the tried and tested legal system, as you point out in your penultimate sentence.


Well it is good that you finnaly got around to stating your position on this. Only took a few posts for me to get a clear response.

In your previous posts you said things like "there is no question, we know who the perpetrators are" and that you would be making sure that those people were punished severely. You made no mention of any judicial process much less using the present sytem. Given that some in the "Truth" movement di indeed call for a revolution and some call for extra-judicial executions it was no large stretch to assume that was indeed your position as well.

If you did not know that some who would align themselves with you would call for such things it just again underlines that you must be new to all of this.

Now that you have cleared that up how about you supply the NOTAM I requested near the beginning of this thread, concerning flight restrictions at Offut. Please, no conjecture pieces by Killtown of any theorist, just the hard facts, just the NOTAM.

Next you can supply the evidence that "bad boy" versions of civilian jets such as you have described, actually exist. No conjecture, just the facts.
 
You make the everlasting mistake, which to be fair to you, is common in the USA, of picking on what you think is the weakest point and ignoring the rest.


You, by contrast, make the mistake common in crank circles, of ignoring all real evidence and repeating your thoroughly debunked falsehoods over and over.


This 'selective targetting' of what to address, at the expense of the whole, will only work in a hit and run type situation. It cannot last the course.


Yes, you're quite right, Malcolm. As your lies and errors have been exposed one-by-one, you find yourself left with nothing. Your fantasies lie in tatters.

There are no "military bad boys."
The forensic examiners who identified the crash victims in the Twin Towers and at the Pentagon are real people who do difficult, unpleasant work. They do not belong to your imaginary, mathematically-impossible conspiracy.


Your 'weather' reference, is on relation to both yours and anyone elses ability to put together a reasonable scenario whereby 'hijackers' take over regular flights anh get their planes to their targets. No one got close, the best scenario was along the lines of 1) Go to the airport 2) hijack a plane 3} fly it to New York.


Uh, yes, Malcolm, that's precisely what the hijackers did.



I didn't even have to dig partially deep.


In fact, you don't dig at all. You recycle nonsense that was proved false years ago. You attempt no critical thinking whatever. You merely swallow whatever preposterous rubbish is being peddled by uninformed, agenda-driven fantasists.


For example, ask questions like what were the hijackers carrying? Box cutter in one pocket, GPS in another, flight maps stuck down their shirts etc. Box cutters, by the way, were a banned item prior to 9/11 - see what I mean.


Well, we know the hijackers had knives, box cutters, and GPS systems. The pilots knew how to reach NYC using auto-pilot.

Show us how you determined that box cutters were banned items in 2001.


Or do you mean 'called out' on, for example, the one webpage of 250 smoking guns, Mr Homer, the 'scientific' probability theory, to say nothing of this current hole on the Pentagon ?
[/quote]


Killtown is a fraud who has discovered ZERO smoking guns. Not a single item on his list can stand scrutiny--pretty much like the stuff you post.
 
This is one example of 50%,
http://www.zogby.com/search/ReadNews.dbm?ID=855
Kindly understand that many people in the truth movement have moved over to politics. For example Cindy Sheehan is taking on Pelosi. The whole impeach Bush and Cheney movement know the truth etc.
No offence, but these terms,
"argument from this" and "argument from that" are pointless and add nothing to the debate.
To dispute one police officer is a mountain to climb, to dispute two is just plain silly. You seem determined NOT to accept proper evidence.
The thin limestone veneer was no more than weather protection, any explosion would have blown it off.
The brickwork behind is unscathed. You do remember all those claims, not so many pages ago about an aluminium wing travelling at 500 mph don't you ?
So where are the marks in the brickwork ?

To dispute a handful of witnesses who saw the plane impact the pentagon is a mountain to climb. to dispute ONE HUNDRED AND FIVE who saw the plane impact the pentagon is just plane silly. kirkman You seem determined NOT to accept proper evidence. zogby polls are commissioned by special interest groups and those who have agendas. Their sampling is flawed and questions leading. They are a blow off. no one takes them seriously. Onto the wings and 500 mph. You seem to ignore the fact that the pentagon walls were blast resistant. The tube frame and glass walls of the wtc were not. The wall thickness of the perimeter columns at impact level was only 1/4 inch. as far as Shehan, she is yesterdays news and can no longer generate front page news no matter where she decides to set up camp. It may interest you to know her late son was not drafted. He volunteered. Face it kirkman your movement Is over. They could barely get 1000 9/11 protesters to show up at ground zero on the fifth anniversary in a city of millions. The tiny group who tried to make a stand during earth day were squelched. laughed at, and had their only banner stolen. Watch any troofer video where they attempt to hand out literature. They are ignored.
 
If the left wing hit the ground as you say, what happened to the underslung engine?
Can you show me whereabouts in the lawn it is,
http://thewebfairy.com/killtown/images/pentalawn/pl1.jpg
Don't worry if you can't find it, neither can these,
http://www.asile.org/citoyens/numero13/pentagone/erreurs_en.htm
http://thewebfairy.com/killtown/pentalawn.html
I'll mention the wing itself and the fence, when you answer that.

then wing did not actually touch the ground but the left engine fairing did take out a chunk of curb near the wall.
 
I quote,
"Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause."
Do you mean like blaming moslems for the inside job that was 9/11 ?


I blame nineteen terrorists, and others who abetted them. Were/are they Muslims? I do remember reading that somehwere, as a matter of fact. Does that matter? Would blame them less if they were Buddhists or Seventh Day Adventists? I blame them for what they did, not for what they were.

However, that's not the point you were trying to make, was it? You're warning me that I could be wrong. (Well, you're telling me I am wrong, but I don't have any reason to take your word for it in the face of the contrary evidence. So I'll take your statement, instead, as a polite warning that I could be wrong.) The important thing in any case is that if I am wrong, there are consequences.

This is called responsibility, and it's something people encounter and deal with as they gain experience with the real world. In the real world there are always consequences. People get hurt when you make bad decisions or mistakes. If I drive carelessly, I could kill people including my own passengers who are trusting me to keep them safe. If as a lab technician I make certain mistakes, I could injure or even kill a test subject (a healthy volunteer, no less), and even small injury resulting from such an error could ruin the research program and the careers of the senior researchers. That means those researchers must trust me with their own livelihoods. And that's nothing, compared with the level of responsibility assumed by the people here who have worked in such positions as air traffic controllers, military officers, engineers, and doctors.

Young people live in a sheltered world with few consequences, where no one is relying on them, or trusting them to make any important decisions, or really, paying much attention to them at all. Perhaps this accounts for why you have not yet learned the importance of keeping your word, as evidenced by your "change of mind" concerning the donation offer you chose not to honor. For most young people, no one has any reason to care if they keep their word or not, and short of going out and committing actual crimes, their decisions have few consequences more severe than a bad grade, or being grounded, or being seen as uncool by their peers.

So, yes, if I'm wrong about my conclusions about 9/11, I'm partly responsible for the real perpetators' benefit and for the real suffering of the ones I wrongly blame, here in the real world. And I actually care whether or not I make that mistake and cause that harm. That's why I evaluate the evidence in the most effecitve way available, using reason, scientific knowledge, and critical thinking. That's why I don't pay attention to what I want to be true, or whom I wish might be at fault, or which theory makes me feel better, or which theory is more fun to argue, or which theory the cool kids are promoting.

To most kids, no consequences appear more severe than being thought uncool by their peers. (The ones for whom that's not true are often called nerds, geeks, dweebs, etc.) So, it's right, in a way, that kids will favor the cool theory every time, without regard to critical thought or for any other reason than that it's cool.

But that's also why grown-ups shouldn't give them the car keys, let alone the machinery of legal retribution, until they show some capacity for responsibility.

That's also why debate techniques that undermine your own credibility, however clever they might seem to you, won't ever win you the retribution you claim to be seeking.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
To dispute a handful of witnesses who saw the plane impact the pentagon is a mountain to climb. to dispute ONE HUNDRED AND FIVE who saw the plane impact the pentagon is just plane silly. kirkman You seem determined NOT to accept proper evidence. zogby polls are commissioned by special interest groups and those who have agendas. Their sampling is flawed and questions leading. They are a blow off. no one takes them seriously. Onto the wings and 500 mph. You seem to ignore the fact that the pentagon walls were blast resistant. The tube frame and glass walls of the wtc were not. The wall thickness of the perimeter columns at impact level was only 1/4 inch. as far as Shehan, she is yesterdays news and can no longer generate front page news no matter where she decides to set up camp. It may interest you to know her late son was not drafted. He volunteered. Face it kirkman your movement Is over. They could barely get 1000 9/11 protesters to show up at ground zero on the fifth anniversary in a city of millions. The tiny group who tried to make a stand during earth day were squelched. laughed at, and had their only banner stolen. Watch any troofer video where they attempt to hand out literature. They are ignored.
You'll have no difficulty silencing me then, will you?
 

I would say yes though I would also point out that the above image does not appear to show the impact area where the main fuselage hit. My guess is that it shows about where the left engine and a major part of the left wing would have hit.

I would think that your top image undermines your inadvertently misleading question with the bottom image. Surely, by inspection with the top image, you can see that the bottom image does not show the full impact area?


Where are the,
1. wings
2. engines
3. tail
4. seats
5. luggage
6. marks on the wall where the wings hit
7. marks on the wall where the engines hit
8. marks on the wall where the tail hit
9. grooves in the lawn where the engines ploughed
10 where are there even broken windows in the pentagon facade.

Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 were wholey or in part conveyed into the Pentagon interior due to momentum (and the airframe) and that the aircraft didn't go SPAT agains the concrete fascade of the Pentagon.

6. The edge of the damaged area (left wing) substantially encompasses the wing length and in consideration of the idea that the airframe would try to drag the wing into the interior even as the airframe was coming apart, it seems that the left wing is reasonably accounted for.

7. Since the engines hit and would destroy the exterior wall where they hit, what marks on the destroyed wall would you think would be visible?

8. Since the fuselage appears to have impacted farther to the right and out of the third/last image, it would be no surprise that there would be no marks on the part it didn't hit. It would also be a reasonable expectation that the tail might also bend and be dragged into the interior by the momentum of the airframe that was coming apart.

9. I believe that some witnesses thought the aircraft actually hit the ground but like some other eye witnesses their impressions may have been mistaken. Can't have marks on the ground if the people who thought the aircraft hit the ground were mistaken. There is nothing (to my mind) that requires that the engine(s) actually had to hit the grounds prior to impacting on the building, so their absence is hardly surprising.

10. I am not sure which was the unreinforced portion but the last image certainly shows some broken windows. If you recall, part of that wall had been reinforced and reconstructed with blast resistant windows. Given that the fireball probably didn't have the force of a BOMB, then barring impact by a substantial piece of debris or the part of the building wall being destroyed, the blast resistant windows would tend to be intact.

BTW, if it wasn't clear, this is all IMO. :)
 
Well it is good that you finnaly got around to stating your position on this. Only took a few posts for me to get a clear response.

In your previous posts you said things like "there is no question, we know who the perpetrators are" and that you would be making sure that those people were punished severely. You made no mention of any judicial process much less using the present sytem. Given that some in the "Truth" movement di indeed call for a revolution and some call for extra-judicial executions it was no large stretch to assume that was indeed your position as well.

If you did not know that some who would align themselves with you would call for such things it just again underlines that you must be new to all of this.

Now that you have cleared that up how about you supply the NOTAM I requested near the beginning of this thread, concerning flight restrictions at Offut. Please, no conjecture pieces by Killtown of any theorist, just the hard facts, just the NOTAM.

Next you can supply the evidence that "bad boy" versions of civilian jets such as you have described, actually exist. No conjecture, just the facts.

Do you remember these words, they are part of your post 2592
-----
Obviously you would agree that a bullet can penetrate a plaster wall. A bullet is made of soft lead, is not as sharply pointed as a dart and has less mass than a dart. A .22 caliber bullet has a muzzle velocity of just under 1100 fps, less than 60% greater than a dart travelling at 700 fps.

If a dart has 1.54 times the mass of a bullet and is travelling at 65% the speed of a bullet the dart the dart and the bullet will have the same momentum. The kinetic energy of the dart will still be 70% that of the bullet. If the bullet would still have 55% of its velocity after having passed through the wall ( a safe bet ) then the dart also would have enough KE to pass through the wall.

Now malcolm, please scale up the math and physics for a large Boeing and a brick and concrete wall.
-----
Here's the Boeing and the wall, kindly tell me why the Boeing didn't go through the wall,
pentcrash.jpg
 
This is simply an attempt to concentrate attention on what you consider to be the weakest part of the video. In order to do this, you mis quote me.
Nobody is moving any goalposts, ket's keep it that way.
My words exactly, I quote,
"I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation".
Why, when I specifically asked you NOT to comment on his explanation, did not only go on to do exactly that. But also use that as a basis for a
concentrated attack upon my credibility.


Oh dear, how sad.

Misdirection didn't work, veiled threats didn't work, righteous indignation didn't work, moving goalposts didn't work. So what's left in your bag of clever?

Apparently, transparently false claims of misquoting and misrepresentation.

Unless, perchance, you can cite where I misquoted you.

Or you can show how this:

In this video the commentator offers an explanation for the 'rooftop demolitions'. Do you have an alternative explanation ? 40 to 45 secs.
Also, at 1.10 to 1.40, the commentator offers an explanation as to upward moving debris. Do you have an alternative explanation ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation.
Respectfully.
(emphasis added)

I've already answered the questions concerning upward moving debris. See post 2732.

As for the "rooftop demolitions," the upward flow of ligher-colored substance at the roof level of the building pointed out in the video as "rooftop demolitions" appears indistinguishable from the lighter-colored flow at the roof level clearly visible in this CNN video from the start of the video approximately 25-30 seconds before the collapse, and continuously visible (except for a few seconds when the shot is zoomed too far out to see it clearly) until the collapse begins. Thus I conclude that it is most likely smoke from the fire. Only by freezing the frame does the editor of the video you linked to make it appear to resemble any sort of demolition-related phenomenon. Did you fall for his deception?


You have obviously studied 'my' video (I use the term 'my' for brevity only)
looking for the most ambiguous point, this you are entitled to do.
If you look at 'my' video more closely, you will see material being ejected above the surrounding smoke.
You make no mention of the two demolition squids, the row of demolitions or all the ejected materials. Also, some still burning steel being hurled outwards with far greater force than would be possible in a conventional collapse.
Here is more white demolition smoke, do you have an alternative explanation for this ?
Also, if you look closely into the shadow on the north side of tower 2, you will see steel on FIRE.
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/towers%20falling/fema_wtc2exp.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/towers%20falling/site1049.jpg[/qimg]


... is anything other than an unusually blatant textbook example of moving the goalposts. In fact, I won't be surprised if future discussions on this forum, about what "moving the goalposts" means, link to this post as an example.

What is obvious is exactly which points you asked me to focus my attention on, and that I responded exactly as you requested.

Feel free to apologise,
Respectfully.


Feel free to keep asking me to apologize, without justification.

Perhaps you're not as good at this as you thought.

Respectfully,
Myriad

PS If you're not really left-handed, now's the time to reveal it!
 
A large proportion of those in the truth movement still concerning themselves with spreading the truth outside politics, are confident of mini nukes being used and that number is increasing. I wouldn't expect someone outside the movement to know that, but I would expect an unbiased amateur scientist, when planning to visit the sites, to be curious enough to want to satisfy himself with regard to mini nukes.

Why would a scientist, let's just say for instance, have concerns about radiation in this situation? Unless he/she knew something already, he/she wouldn't even suspect radiation. All he/she knows at that time is planes have crashed into the towers, exploded, and subsequently, the buildings came down. Here was the catalyst, no reason to suspect nukes.

I'm not an expert, but by reading different forums and learning (I don't take one theory and run with it, I try to determine whether or not it can be ruled out) about what is being presented, I soon get an understanding about what I'm learning.
Greenings (Apollo20) findings have shown there to be a high amount of chlorinated species from the USGS reading, from the New York Board of Health 's data of the rubble pile, and the EPA's data. You can rule out thermite with these high amounts of chlorine. Thermite needs a certain aluminum to aluminum oxide ratio to remain energetic, but the one thing that will upset this ratio is chlorination. The nukes? These things have been banned for years, even the testing of them.
High levels of tritium? Exit signs have tritium in them, how many exit signs was there per floor in these towers? Melted cars? Chloroform is very corrosive, and as mentioned before, the high amounts chlorinated species found in the data would be a determining factor for that. There are chemical reactions of the metals involved and how they react to the heat, eventually becoming fuel itself. Chemistry reveals the true answer as to what happened with the collapse of the towers, not speculation and a Geiger counter.

I have already read those sites you linked to Me, last year. If you really believe that the govt. could plant nukes, or any other type of demolition device in a civilian building, for what purpose does it serve to go to such extreme lengths if they just LIHOP?
 
To Myriad,
My original post,
In this video the commentator offers an explanation for the 'rooftop demolitions'. Do you have an alternative explanation ? 40 to 45 secs.
Also, at 1.10 to 1.40, the commentator offers an explanation as to upward moving debris. Do you have an alternative explanation ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3X...elated&search=
I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation.

There is no deception on the part of the producer of the video because he shows film of regular smoke rising at the start of the video.
The video is stopped to explain and point out the squibs and to explain the upward ejected demolition smoke around the bottom of the mast, over and above the other smoke. It is clearly visible at 48 to 53secs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3X...elated&search=
At 40 to 45 sec the video is still. It starts again on 45 - 46 secs to be precise.
You are referring to all the smoke passing the roof top. I am referring to the extra demilition smoke that is clearly seen on 46 secs precisely.
In conclusion, there is no deceit on the part o the producer, because he show enough run of regular smoke at the start of the video for a discerning viewer to note the difference. The stopping and starting of the video is necessary to point things out.
 
To dispute a handful of witnesses who saw the plane impact the pentagon is a mountain to climb. to dispute ONE HUNDRED AND FIVE who saw the plane impact the pentagon is just plane silly. kirkman You seem determined NOT to accept proper evidence. zogby polls are commissioned by special interest groups and those who have agendas. Their sampling is flawed and questions leading. They are a blow off. no one takes them seriously. Onto the wings and 500 mph. You seem to ignore the fact that the pentagon walls were blast resistant. The tube frame and glass walls of the wtc were not. The wall thickness of the perimeter columns at impact level was only 1/4 inch. as far as Shehan, she is yesterdays news and can no longer generate front page news no matter where she decides to set up camp. It may interest you to know her late son was not drafted. He volunteered. Face it kirkman your movement Is over. They could barely get 1000 9/11 protesters to show up at ground zero on the fifth anniversary in a city of millions. The tiny group who tried to make a stand during earth day were squelched. laughed at, and had their only banner stolen. Watch any troofer video where they attempt to hand out literature. They are ignored.
Have you read those 'witness' accounts ?
I like the Tom Cruise one, where someone is blown bodily down a corridor, chased by a fireball, in places with the fireball overtaking him. Then, he is blown into a broom cupboard and the door miraculously slams shut, just in time to save him from getting turned into a mega junior whopper.
That's a real cracker, you must read that one.
I'll stick with the two cops, if you don't mind.
 
If the left wing hit the ground as you say, what happened to the underslung engine?
Can you show me whereabouts in the lawn it is,
Don't worry if you can't find it, neither can these,
http://www.asile.org/citoyens/numero13/pentagone/erreurs_en.htm
http://thewebfairy.com/killtown/pentalawn.html
I'll mention the wing itself and the fence, when you answer that.

Worried? Piffile. it doesn't even generate mild concern.

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

Pages 35 to 39 (23 to 25 as the PDF is numbered). For your sake, I chose pages with everything diagramed out in nice pictures, but you really should read it - interesting stuff, and can answer the vast majority of your questions.

The engine did not end up on the lawn - it was dragged into the building with the majority of the aircraft. you can see from the diagrams, the actual damage to the building was much wider than the distance between the two engines, which are much closer to the center-line of the aircraft.

Also, consider: http://www.911myths.com/html/pentagon_4.html

As the paragraph below states:
"This photo of engine remains was taken in either D or C-ring by VATF-1 workers."

You can't find pictures of the engine resting on the lawn because, in fact, the engine ended up inside the building.

Well, I've upheld my end of the agreement..your turn.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom