I quote,
"Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause."
Do you mean like blaming moslems for the inside job that was 9/11 ?
I blame nineteen terrorists, and others who abetted them. Were/are they Muslims? I do remember reading that somehwere, as a matter of fact. Does that matter? Would blame them less if they were Buddhists or Seventh Day Adventists? I blame them for what they did, not for what they were.
However, that's not the point you were trying to make, was it? You're warning me that I could be wrong. (Well, you're telling me I
am wrong, but I don't have any reason to take your word for it in the face of the contrary evidence. So I'll take your statement, instead, as a polite warning that I could be wrong.) The important thing in any case is that if I am wrong, there are consequences.
This is called responsibility, and it's something people encounter and deal with as they gain experience with the real world. In the real world there are always consequences. People get hurt when you make bad decisions or mistakes. If I drive carelessly, I could kill people including my own passengers who are trusting me to keep them safe. If as a lab technician I make certain mistakes, I could injure or even kill a test subject (a healthy volunteer, no less), and even small injury resulting from such an error could ruin the research program and the careers of the senior researchers. That means those researchers must trust me with their own livelihoods. And that's
nothing, compared with the level of responsibility assumed by the people here who have worked in such positions as air traffic controllers, military officers, engineers, and doctors.
Young people live in a sheltered world with few consequences, where no one is relying on them, or trusting them to make any important decisions, or really, paying much attention to them at all. Perhaps this accounts for why you have not yet learned the importance of keeping your word, as evidenced by your "change of mind" concerning the donation offer you chose not to honor. For most young people, no one has any reason to care if they keep their word or not, and short of going out and committing actual crimes, their decisions have few consequences more severe than a bad grade, or being grounded, or being seen as uncool by their peers.
So, yes, if I'm wrong about my conclusions about 9/11, I'm partly responsible for the real perpetators' benefit and for the real suffering of the ones I wrongly blame, here in the real world. And I actually care whether or not I make that mistake and cause that harm. That's why I evaluate the evidence in the most effecitve way available, using reason, scientific knowledge, and critical thinking. That's why I don't pay attention to what I want to be true, or whom I wish might be at fault, or which theory makes me feel better, or which theory is more fun to argue, or which theory the cool kids are promoting.
To most kids, no consequences appear more severe than being thought uncool by their peers. (The ones for whom that's not true are often called nerds, geeks, dweebs, etc.) So, it's right, in a way, that kids will favor the cool theory every time, without regard to critical thought or for any other reason than that it's cool.
But that's also why grown-ups shouldn't give them the car keys, let alone the machinery of legal retribution, until they show some capacity for responsibility.
That's also why debate techniques that undermine your own credibility, however clever they might seem to you, won't ever win you the retribution you claim to be seeking.
Respectfully,
Myriad