[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would say yes though I would also point out that the above image does not appear to show the impact area where the main fuselage hit. My guess is that it shows about where the left engine and a major part of the left wing would have hit.

I would think that your top image undermines your inadvertently misleading question with the bottom image. Surely, by inspection with the top image, you can see that the bottom image does not show the full impact area?




Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 were wholey or in part conveyed into the Pentagon interior due to momentum (and the airframe) and that the aircraft didn't go SPAT agains the concrete fascade of the Pentagon.

6. The edge of the damaged area (left wing) substantially encompasses the wing length and in consideration of the idea that the airframe would try to drag the wing into the interior even as the airframe was coming apart, it seems that the left wing is reasonably accounted for.

7. Since the engines hit and would destroy the exterior wall where they hit, what marks on the destroyed wall would you think would be visible?

8. Since the fuselage appears to have impacted farther to the right and out of the third/last image, it would be no surprise that there would be no marks on the part it didn't hit. It would also be a reasonable expectation that the tail might also bend and be dragged into the interior by the momentum of the airframe that was coming apart.

9. I believe that some witnesses thought the aircraft actually hit the ground but like some other eye witnesses their impressions may have been mistaken. Can't have marks on the ground if the people who thought the aircraft hit the ground were mistaken. There is nothing (to my mind) that requires that the engine(s) actually had to hit the grounds prior to impacting on the building, so their absence is hardly surprising.

10. I am not sure which was the unreinforced portion but the last image certainly shows some broken windows. If you recall, part of that wall had been reinforced and reconstructed with blast resistant windows. Given that the fireball probably didn't have the force of a BOMB, then barring impact by a substantial piece of debris or the part of the building wall being destroyed, the blast resistant windows would tend to be intact.

BTW, if it wasn't clear, this is all IMO. :)

You are wrong about the hole. That is where the fusilage went in.
I have to type out in longhand as it were, the references to the photos, then I'm acting the goat, putting one up that doesn't work etc.
If you bear with me for a while, I'll prove to you conclusively that there is only one entrance hole for the 'fusilage' and it is the one in this photo.
car-whitep.JPG
 
... Your 'weather' reference, is on relation to both yours and anyone elses ability to put together a reasonable scenario whereby 'hijackers' take over regular flights anh get their planes to their targets. No one got close, the best scenario was along the lines of 1) Go to the airport 2) hijack a plane 3} fly it to New York.
I didn't even have to dig partially deep. For example, ask questions like what were the hijackers carrying? Box cutter in one pocket, GPS in another, flight maps stuck down their shirts etc. Box cutters, by the way, were a banned item prior to 9/11 - see what I mean.

I really thought this argument had been dropped as it had been thoroughly discussed earlier in the thread. Your continued belief that it would be impossible for trained terrorists to execute this attack is surprising.

Bringing small knives onto the aircraft would be a simple job as they were allowable at the time (you are correct that boxcutters were prohibited). If you take a look at the first paragraph on page 14 of this transcript, you can see that pocket knives are the suspected weapon of choice for the attack.
http:
//govinfo.library.unt.edu/911/archive/hearing7/9-11Commission_Hearing_2004-01-27.pdf

Here's an excerpt, "Our best working hypothesis is that a number of the
hijackers were carrying -- permissible under the regulations in place at the time -- permissible utility knives or pocket knives. One example of such a utility knife is displayed by Mr. Brinkley here, this so-called Leatherman item. We know that at least two knives like this were actually purchased by the hijackers and have not been found in the belongings the hijackers left behind."

Regarding navigation to NYC from the aircraft's current position, any person with pilot certification (I think the terrorists were commercial rated) should have no difficulty operating the cockpit navigation systems. They could use the pilots navigation charts right there in the cockpit or bring there own along. While obtaining my own pilot license, I would often bring sectional charts onto commercial aircraft to see if I could follow along.

There are many aspects of the 9/11 attacks that are not intuitively obvious to everyone (impact damage and subsequent structural failures) but the basic simplicity of the hijackings should be obvious.
V/R
G
 
I'm having very little difficulty ignoring you, I'll say that.

Rolfe.

Nearly funny, can you not persuade JimBenArm to make the odd appearance.
Then I could at least have a laugh whilst I'm cleaning your clocks.
 
Worried? Piffile. it doesn't even generate mild concern.

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

Pages 35 to 39 (23 to 25 as the PDF is numbered). For your sake, I chose pages with everything diagramed out in nice pictures, but you really should read it - interesting stuff, and can answer the vast majority of your questions.

The engine did not end up on the lawn - it was dragged into the building with the majority of the aircraft. you can see from the diagrams, the actual damage to the building was much wider than the distance between the two engines, which are much closer to the center-line of the aircraft.

Also, consider: http://www.911myths.com/html/pentagon_4.html

As the paragraph below states:
"This photo of engine remains was taken in either D or C-ring by VATF-1 workers."

You can't find pictures of the engine resting on the lawn because, in fact, the engine ended up inside the building.

Well, I've upheld my end of the agreement..your turn.
I'm not overkeen on the NIST report, I never did like fiction.
This engine that was dragged into the Pentagon, did the other engine and both wings also get dragged in ?
 
I really thought this argument had been dropped as it had been thoroughly discussed earlier in the thread. Your continued belief that it would be impossible for trained terrorists to execute this attack is surprising.

Bringing small knives onto the aircraft would be a simple job as they were allowable at the time (you are correct that boxcutters were prohibited). If you take a look at the first paragraph on page 14 of this transcript, you can see that pocket knives are the suspected weapon of choice for the attack.
http:
//govinfo.library.unt.edu/911/archive/hearing7/9-11Commission_Hearing_2004-01-27.pdf

Here's an excerpt, "Our best working hypothesis is that a number of the
hijackers were carrying -- permissible under the regulations in place at the time -- permissible utility knives or pocket knives. One example of such a utility knife is displayed by Mr. Brinkley here, this so-called Leatherman item. We know that at least two knives like this were actually purchased by the hijackers and have not been found in the belongings the hijackers left behind."

Regarding navigation to NYC from the aircraft's current position, any person with pilot certification (I think the terrorists were commercial rated) should have no difficulty operating the cockpit navigation systems. They could use the pilots navigation charts right there in the cockpit or bring there own along. While obtaining my own pilot license, I would often bring sectional charts onto commercial aircraft to see if I could follow along.

There are many aspects of the 9/11 attacks that are not intuitively obvious to everyone (impact damage and subsequent structural failures) but the basic simplicity of the hijackings should be obvious.
V/R
G

I'll have to take you at your word that you believe hijackers did it.
Rather than ask you to go over the many bits that add up to a definate no.
Why don't we go for broke on this hole in the Pentagon ?
If I can show to an unbiased observer that no 757 hit the Pentagon, then it must follow that the OCT is false. Do you agree ?
 
You say you blame 19 terrorists who just happen to be moslems.
You accept that if you are wrong, which you doubt but I claim, then you are partially responsible for the real perps benefits and the duffering of those wronged. Will your acceptance of responsibility stretch to the troops that have been and any casualties in Iran, should Iran be attacked?

Right back at you, Malcolm. What happens when you're shown wrong ?

You won't mind if I attempt to present further evidence to you, to show that 9/11 was indeed an 'inside job', will you ?

You've been withholding it ?

After all, we both, despite your inferences that I am a 'cool' teenager, feel strongly about this matter, yet have arrived at different conclusions.

It doesn't mean that you've arrived at it based on reasoning.

What better place to start than this current topic, the posts are right here. Do you believe that a Boeing 757 which is 125 ft wide and over 44ft tall, somehow managed to get through a hole say 12 ft by 20 ft ?

Easy: it didn't. The hole wasn't that small.

It also didn't "get through" the hole. This isn't the Coyote from the Loony Tunes.

Also, you might have noticed that the FUSELAGE of the plane is smaller than the plane itself.

Would you also explain what could be construed as a veiled threat, I quote,
"If you're not really left handed, now's the time to reveal it".

Why is everything a threat or a shill, to you ?

Consequently, there is absolutely no possibility of any other source of these fires other than due to the demolition.

How would explosives sustain these fires ????
 
I'm not overkeen on the NIST report, I never did like fiction.

[joke]
Really? Most of your posts indicate otherwise.
[/joke]

(Seriously, how am I not going to take a set-up line like that?)

Kidding aside, Don't be so quick to dismiss the NIST documents. A lot of the questions you have also occured to the people compiling the evidence and creating the NIST documents, and are answered there.

Besides, The Second link I sent wasn't to the NIST documents, although you're probably going to complain about that source as well. But it's two different sources corroborating the main issue: that the engine was brought inside the building.

This engine that was dragged into the Pentagon, did the other engine and both wings also get dragged in ?

Okay, first off, kudos, this is a reasonable question. And the answer is "Yes and No". Both engines were brought into the building. The connection between the wing and the fuselage are among the strongest in the aircraft, as is the engine connection to the wing. The whole thing just sort of plowed through the first floor, breaking support columns in the process. It's interesting to note also that most of the fuel was distributed between the engines as well. Since liquid does not compress very well, it assisted in breaking through the facade & columns.

The rest of the wings are a different matter. It's tough to say exactly what happened to all parts of the wings. They are still pretty strong in their own right, But impact with the generator at high speeds on the right and the ground on the left wing broke parts of them, and the parts went god knows where. Some parts did manage to hit the building, doing damage and starting fires. Some was pulled in with the main mass of the plane, and bits and pieces strewn all over the place. The right wing also encounted the 2nd-floor slab, which, since it hit in it's own plane, is going to prevent much of the wing from continuing it's current path. Since the wings are swept-back, and not perfectly perpendicular to the fuselauge, there is conjecture that part of the wing broke from the sudden stop, but some of it was forced by the 2nd-floor slab back towards the fuselauge, and pulled in as well.

BTW, can someone answer me this: What was the distance between the columns in the pentagon? for example, distance from center-to-center, from column 1 to column 2?
 
If I can show to an unbiased observer that no 757 hit the Pentagon, then it must follow that the OCT is false. Do you agree ?

That's the problem; you can't. In order to show anybody that no 757 hit the Pentagon you will have to show how the massive evidence that supports it is fake.

That includes the majority of eye witnesses, the physical evidence, the reports of first responders, etc.

In order for your theory to be correct ALL these bits of evidence must be fake, the responders lying, and the eye witnesses mistaken or lying.

You'd have to ask this observer:

  1. Why did many eyewitnesses report seeing a large twin-engine jetliner approaching the Pentagon and, in many cases, crashing into the building?
  2. What clipped the lamp posts on the highway overpass in a swath the width of a 757's wingspan?
  3. What gouged the construction yard generator in location in the path of a 757's flap canoe?
  4. What punctured a hole in the Pentagon's about 18 feet wide on the second floor and about 90 feet wide on the first floor?
  5. What was the source of the aircraft debris, some of which appears to match parts from a 757?
  6. What happened to Flight 77 and its passengers?
http://911research.wtc7.net/pentagon/evidence/witnesses/bart.html
http://www.geocities.com/someguyyoudontknow33/witnesses.htm
Why do so many of these eye witnesses report a large twin-engined airliner of approximate size of a 757 hitting the building? We all know eye witnesses aren't the wherewithal of evidence but still. Dude. How do you explain them?
 
No source of fire other than demolition? The buildings were on fire. They carried on being on fire after they fell over. That really isn't difficult to understand.

I'll put this as simply as I possibly can:
1) Buildings are on fire.
2) Buildings fall over.
3) Fires carry on burning.
4) Metal may have melted due to fire.*

As opposed to your scenario which is apparently:
1) Buildings are on fire.
2) Explosives are set off.
3) Metal melts because of explosives.*
4) Buildings fall over, all fires go out.
5) Metal magically stays molten for at least two more weeks.*

Can you really not see how utterly insane that sounds? Fires can burn underground, or indeed under piles of rubble. Things under the piles of rubble are known to have been burning. Why would you think explosives need to be involved at any point?

I do notice that you have payed absolutely no attention to the fact that there isn't any evidence that metal was actually molten at any time after the collapse. Care to address that now? While it is amusing to demolish your bizzare arguments about how the metal melted, it's all rather pointless when you haven't shown that it actually did. It's rather like asking what kind of fairies the Invisible Pink Unicorn eats. There's no point asking it until you show that the IPU actually exists in the first place.

I also notice that you completely failed to address the main point of my post, which is that the "mini-nukes" you say you suspect were used do not actually exist. Care to provide any evidence here?
My pleasure,
These fires didn't last for weeks, but months. This despite firemen pouring tons of water into the bathtub.
This into a cold concrete bathtub with no possibility of any other source for the fires.
Had you bothered to read just one of the webpages I put up, you would know all this and more. I'll put up one webpage and a couple of photos, I hope that's enough.
Don't forget, kindly read the webpage, there is a clear reference on it that mentions govt ability with mini nukes for decades.
http://www.thepriceofliberty.org/06/09/25/ward.htm

Edited by Darat: 
Lots of images, use links please
 
A Boeing is 125 ft wingspan.
Half of that is 62 ft. The part of the fence that is upright isn't 62 ft away from the hole.

i suggest you dont know where the centre of the hole is if you are implying this

i think you need to go look at other photographs and change your assumptions

even if it was, then they are maybe like your moving goalposts
 
Malcolm:

Please read this post by Unfit4Command. It's from another thread but it documents quite extensively the aircraft debris found in and around the Pentagon. Please offer, if you're able, a detailed and comprehensive rebuttal to each of the images and supported evidence presented in that thread.
 
Malcolm:

Please read this post by Unfit4Command. It's from another thread but it documents quite extensively the aircraft debris found in and around the Pentagon. Please offer, if you're able, a detailed and comprehensive rebuttal to each of the images and supported evidence presented in that thread.

Ya beat me to it!

How's things in Dog River?
 
That's the problem; you can't. In order to show anybody that no 757 hit the Pentagon you will have to show how the massive evidence that supports it is fake.

That includes the majority of eye witnesses, the physical evidence, the reports of first responders, etc.

In order for your theory to be correct ALL these bits of evidence must be fake, the responders lying, and the eye witnesses mistaken or lying.

You'd have to ask this observer:

  1. Why did many eyewitnesses report seeing a large twin-engine jetliner approaching the Pentagon and, in many cases, crashing into the building?
  2. What clipped the lamp posts on the highway overpass in a swath the width of a 757's wingspan?
  3. What gouged the construction yard generator in location in the path of a 757's flap canoe?
  4. What punctured a hole in the Pentagon's about 18 feet wide on the second floor and about 90 feet wide on the first floor?
  5. What was the source of the aircraft debris, some of which appears to match parts from a 757?
  6. What happened to Flight 77 and its passengers?
http://911research.wtc7.net/pentagon/evidence/witnesses/bart.html
http://www.geocities.com/someguyyoudontknow33/witnesses.htm
Why do so many of these eye witnesses report a large twin-engined airliner of approximate size of a 757 hitting the building? We all know eye witnesses aren't the wherewithal of evidence but still. Dude. How do you explain them?

I believe the evidence of my own eyes. Unlike my main contention, which relies upon attributes other than the absolute proof that you neocons endlessly parrot. I have decided to show that no plane hit the Pentagon. That's as far as I believe I can reasonably get on this forum. The only people I've had contact with prior to this forum all see the truth and argue only over the finer points. There's just no talking to some people, it's as simple as that.
You should be able to look at this hole and tell yourself,
"Never in a million years, did a Boeing 757 that's 125 ft wide and 40 ft tall and doing 500mph, get through that hole".
Here's the hole,
hole.JPG
 
Malcolm:

Please read this post by Unfit4Command. It's from another thread but it documents quite extensively the aircraft debris found in and around the Pentagon. Please offer, if you're able, a detailed and comprehensive rebuttal to each of the images and supported evidence presented in that thread.
The page you posted takes me back to a time when I was making my mind up.
One of many defining moments for me, was the piece on the lawn with the top part of a letter on it.
Then I came across a site that worked out, if memory serves me right, that the writing is the top part of an a in american and the rivets run the wrong way. It came from some other model that a 757.
I'll do my very best to find that page, but don't hold your breath.
Clearly something went through the wall. A lot has been done with regard to it being a Global Hawk etc, someone even tracked them all down and found one missing. It won't take you long to realise that the OCT is baloney. I then went down the road of all four 'hijacks' being a cover story etc etc.
 
i suggest you dont know where the centre of the hole is if you are implying this

i think you need to go look at other photographs and change your assumptions

even if it was, then they are maybe like your moving goalposts
Move the goalposts anywhere you like across the front of the Pentagon. Then show me where the nose of a 757 went in.
 
That's the problem; you can't. In order to show anybody that no 757 hit the Pentagon you will have to show how the massive evidence that supports it is fake.

That includes the majority of eye witnesses, the physical evidence, the reports of first responders, etc.

In order for your theory to be correct ALL these bits of evidence must be fake, the responders lying, and the eye witnesses mistaken or lying.

You'd have to ask this observer:

  1. Why did many eyewitnesses report seeing a large twin-engine jetliner approaching the Pentagon and, in many cases, crashing into the building?
  2. What clipped the lamp posts on the highway overpass in a swath the width of a 757's wingspan?
  3. What gouged the construction yard generator in location in the path of a 757's flap canoe?
  4. What punctured a hole in the Pentagon's about 18 feet wide on the second floor and about 90 feet wide on the first floor?
  5. What was the source of the aircraft debris, some of which appears to match parts from a 757?
  6. What happened to Flight 77 and its passengers?
http://911research.wtc7.net/pentagon/evidence/witnesses/bart.html
http://www.geocities.com/someguyyoudontknow33/witnesses.htm
Why do so many of these eye witnesses report a large twin-engined airliner of approximate size of a 757 hitting the building? We all know eye witnesses aren't the wherewithal of evidence but still. Dude. How do you explain them?
I don't dispute the large plane approaching the the Pentagon.
The light poles are a joke. There's a taxi with it's window broke by a falling light pole and not a scratch on the hood.
Softlee softlee catchee monkee = one thing at a time.
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread191416/pg1
Tell me in all honesty, how can a light pole crash down and through the windshield and not cave in the hood ?
 
My pleasure,
These fires didn't last for weeks, but months. This despite firemen pouring tons of water into the bathtub.
This into a cold concrete bathtub with no possibility of any other source for the fires.
Had you bothered to read just one of the webpages I put up, you would know all this and more. I'll put up one webpage and a couple of photos, I hope that's enough.
Don't forget, kindly read the webpage, there is a clear reference on it that mentions govt ability with mini nukes for decades.
http://www.thepriceofliberty.org/06/09/25/ward.htm

Edited by Darat: 
Lots of images, use links please
I got these photos from a cousin in Chicago, they are very many and in a folder. I have no links other than my own computer.
I will post links whenever possible. I hope this one photo gets through,
5575.jpg
 
[joke]
Really? Most of your posts indicate otherwise.
[/joke]

(Seriously, how am I not going to take a set-up line like that?)

Kidding aside, Don't be so quick to dismiss the NIST documents. A lot of the questions you have also occured to the people compiling the evidence and creating the NIST documents, and are answered there.

Besides, The Second link I sent wasn't to the NIST documents, although you're probably going to complain about that source as well. But it's two different sources corroborating the main issue: that the engine was brought inside the building.



Okay, first off, kudos, this is a reasonable question. And the answer is "Yes and No". Both engines were brought into the building. The connection between the wing and the fuselage are among the strongest in the aircraft, as is the engine connection to the wing. The whole thing just sort of plowed through the first floor, breaking support columns in the process. It's interesting to note also that most of the fuel was distributed between the engines as well. Since liquid does not compress very well, it assisted in breaking through the facade & columns.

The rest of the wings are a different matter. It's tough to say exactly what happened to all parts of the wings. They are still pretty strong in their own right, But impact with the generator at high speeds on the right and the ground on the left wing broke parts of them, and the parts went god knows where. Some parts did manage to hit the building, doing damage and starting fires. Some was pulled in with the main mass of the plane, and bits and pieces strewn all over the place. The right wing also encounted the 2nd-floor slab, which, since it hit in it's own plane, is going to prevent much of the wing from continuing it's current path. Since the wings are swept-back, and not perfectly perpendicular to the fuselauge, there is conjecture that part of the wing broke from the sudden stop, but some of it was forced by the 2nd-floor slab back towards the fuselauge, and pulled in as well.

BTW, can someone answer me this: What was the distance between the columns in the pentagon? for example, distance from center-to-center, from column 1 to column 2?
This webpage says 20ft.
http://pentagon911.0catch.com/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom