[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Malcolm:

Please read this post by Unfit4Command. It's from another thread but it documents quite extensively the aircraft debris found in and around the Pentagon. Please offer, if you're able, a detailed and comprehensive rebuttal to each of the images and supported evidence presented in that thread.

A correction to my previous post to you.
The rivets don't go the wrong way, the lines of rivets are too close together for a 757. There is a better webpage somewhere that proves thus conclusively, but the n does get a mention here, it's the top part of the n in american, not the a,
http://www.freedomfiles.org/war/pentagon.htm
 
These fires didn't last for weeks, but months. This despite firemen pouring tons of water into the bathtub.
This into a cold concrete bathtub with no possibility of any other source for the fires.

Then what is the source of the fires, according to you ?

Belz... said:
And there you have it. You can now safely ignore the analysis of every expert on the planet by using that very same tactic.
There's no talking to some people and you're one of them.
For the second and last time, I won't be respondingto you anymore.

And there you have it. You can now safely ignore the analysis of every expert on the planet by using that very same tactic.
 
Unlike my main contention, which relies upon attributes other than the absolute proof that you neocons endlessly parrot.

So we're "neocons" now ?

Sheesh, I'm not even American. I'm still not sure what a neocon is, and I'm anything but conservative.

"Never in a million years, did a Boeing 757 that's 125 ft wide and 40 ft tall and doing 500mph, get through that hole".

Of course not. It didn't "get" through that hole, it CRASHED through it. It's NOT the coyote, Malcolm.

I'll do my very best to find that page, but don't hold your breath.

I know I shan't.

Move the goalposts anywhere you like across the front of the Pentagon. Then show me where the nose of a 757 went in.

All you've got is incredulity. You can ignore me all you want, but it won't change the fact. All you've got is incredulity.
 
I got these photos from a cousin in Chicago, they are very many and in a folder. I have no links other than my own computer.
I will post links whenever possible. I hope this one photo gets through,

is this not the doctored photo that has been proved to be firemen with a searchlight and not a fire in the hole?

i looked at that page you posted the link to, very crude and old 911 nonsense that has been debunked a thousand times, it even debunks itself

as i am new i cannot post the picture which purports to show that the debri letter is in fact an "n" but if i could you could see it was laughable and in no way looks anything like the real thing

someone else please post this complete travesty of a picture up please

there wasnt just one lightpole either was there, how did they get knocked over

this has made me even more sure you are just a wind up merchant on here for a laugh, pretty sick when you consider the folks who died that day though


for the record i am also not a neocon, not even american and very anti-bush
 
I don't dispute the large plane approaching the the Pentagon.
The light poles are a joke. There's a taxi with it's window broke by a falling light pole and not a scratch on the hood.
Softlee softlee catchee monkee = one thing at a time.
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread191416/pg1
Tell me in all honesty, how can a light pole crash down and through the windshield and not cave in the hood ?

So, you agree with all those witnesses, until they claim the large plane actually crashed into the Pentagon, right?

Light poles a joke, huh? Well, tell me, do you think that evidence as planted? Do you have any evidence of that?

As far of the taxi, stranger things have happened. There was a very long thread on this very forum where many scenarios were given about how that light post could have got there without caving in the hood. Do you think the taxi driver is lying? A plant? An idiot? Have you talked to him? ALL your statements have implications. You have a lot of evidence to hand wave away. Is this all you've got?

All you have is your own personal incredulity and NOTHING more. You are faced with eye witnesses testimony, DNA tests, physical evidence, expert opinion, and ALL YOU HAVE IS "I DON'T BELIEVE IT"?
 
"Never in a million years, did a Boeing 757 that's 125 ft wide and 40 ft tall and doing 500mph, get through that hole".

Thank you for showing the people reading these pages that you have ZERO understanding of the transfer of energy that occurs when a Boeing 757 traveling hunderds of miles an hour slams into a concrete building. Z E R O.
 

20ft? well, then what's the problem here?

"The impact on the Facade REMOVED (emphasis added) first-floor columns from column lines 10 to 14. First floor exterior columns from column lines 9, 15, 16, 17 were severely damaged, perhaps to the point of losing all capacity".

(from the pentagon performance report)

Just the missing columns, 10 to 14, at 20ft between columns is 4 times 20', or 80ft! tack on columns 9 to 17, we get 160 ft.

I kind of think the site you reference is too big on their estimate, believe it or not.

Half the distance, 10 ft between columns, would be a total for MAJOR damage to the columns,just the ones removed or severely damaged, (9 to 17, in other words) of 80 ft. Still wide enough for the majority of the body of the aircraft to get in.

It was estimated that the outer-most third of each wing tip did not reach the building.

roughing it out, 125ft wingspan, subtract 16 feet for the fusealage, leaves 109 ft among the two wings. Half of that (for each wing) is 54.5, (rounding to 54 since it's easier to get a third of.) one-third of 54 is 18. so 18 ft off of both wings is 36ft. 125 ft - 36ft is...89 feet...

Does that work?

If you think it doesn't work, you're forgetting there is another 10 ft of space to the left of column 9 before you get to column 8, and another 10 ft past 17 before you get to 18.

So, you have a (and this is done on the quick) 89 ft wide object going into a 100 ft. space.
 
is this not the doctored photo that has been proved to be firemen with a searchlight and not a fire in the hole?

i looked at that page you posted the link to, very crude and old 911 nonsense that has been debunked a thousand times, it even debunks itself

as i am new i cannot post the picture which purports to show that the debri letter is in fact an "n" but if i could you could see it was laughable and in no way looks anything like the real thing

someone else please post this complete travesty of a picture up please

there wasnt just one lightpole either was there, how did they get knocked over

this has made me even more sure you are just a wind up merchant on here for a laugh, pretty sick when you consider the folks who died that day though


for the record i am also not a neocon, not even american and very anti-bush
If you speak the truth, stay tuned and mind your manners and I'll educate you.
Insults will get you ignored.
Find the hole in the Pentagon, no moving goalposts, remember.
 
Malcom, refute the physical evidence, witnesses, and expert opinion. All you are doing is trying desperately to claim that it was impossible for a plane to have crashed into the Pentagon because you don't have to deal with all that messy evidence to the contrary if you do, at least in your own mind.

There are too many detailed descriptions of what path the plane took, what lightposts and other things it damaged on the way in, what it did when it entered the building, and what happened after the fireball for a rational person to believe somebody who thinks any conspiracy site can do no wrong and who believes sites like prisionplanet as if their words are from Jesus Himself.

If what you believe is true WHERE DID ALL THAT EVIDENCE COME FROM?
 
roughing it out, 125ft wingspan, subtract 16 feet for the fusealage, leaves 109 ft among the two wings. Half of that (for each wing) is 54.5, (rounding to 54 since it's easier to get a third of.) one-third of 54 is 18. so 18 ft off of both wings is 36ft. 125 ft - 36ft is...89 feet...

Does that work?

If you think it doesn't work, you're forgetting there is another 10 ft of space to the left of column 9 before you get to column 8, and another 10 ft past 17 before you get to 18.

So, you have a (and this is done on the quick) 89 ft wide object going into a 100 ft. space.

Quick adjustment, I can't tell from the diagram I found if the Fuselage is 25ft wide or if that's the distance between the rear landing wheels. in either case, it's not a lot of a change. redo-the math, it's a 91 ft wide object going into a 100 ft space.
 
My pleasure,
These fires didn't last for weeks, but months. This despite firemen pouring tons of water into the bathtub.
This into a cold concrete bathtub with no possibility of any other source for the fires.
Had you bothered to read just one of the webpages I put up, you would know all this and more. I'll put up one webpage and a couple of photos, I hope that's enough.
Don't forget, kindly read the webpage, there is a clear reference on it that mentions govt ability with mini nukes for decades.
http://www.thepriceofliberty.org/06/09/25/ward.htm

Edited by Darat: 
Lots of images, use links please

Just out of interest do you ever read either your own posts or the ones you reply to? Have you actually thought even a tiny little bit about what you are actually claiming? By saying that there was no souce for the fires, you are actually saying that there must have been incendiary devices secretly planted in the rubble after the buildings collapsed. Seriously, what have you been smoking?

As I have pointed out several times, the buildnigs were on fire. Just because they fell over doesn't mean the fires magically went out, so naturally there were fires in the rubble. No-one is arguing with this, so please stop pretending I am. However, your problem here is that the fact that there were fires in the buildings means that there is no other explanation needed for fires in the rubble, that is exactly what we expect.

Can you really not see how pointless your theories are? Either the buildings collapsed soley due to impact damage and fire and continued burning after they fell, or they were damaged and on fire and demolished using explosives and continued burning after they fell. At no point do the presence of fires or of molten metal prove anything about the use of explosives. This is because, as has been pointed out numerous times, firstly there were fires anyway and secondly explosions occur in a matter of milliseconds, not weeks. At it's most rational, your theory could be that explosives started the fires as the buildings collapsed, but since there is an awful lot of evidence that they wer already on fire that is a completely pointless and unsupported assumption.

Finally, I notice you still have failed to answer the important points. Once again:
I do notice that you have payed absolutely no attention to the fact that there isn't any evidence that metal was actually molten at any time after the collapse. Care to address that now? While it is amusing to demolish your bizzare arguments about how the metal melted, it's all rather pointless when you haven't shown that it actually did. It's rather like asking what kind of fairies the Invisible Pink Unicorn eats. There's no point asking it until you show that the IPU actually exists in the first place.

I also notice that you completely failed to address the main point of my post, which is that the "mini-nukes" you say you suspect were used do not actually exist. Care to provide any evidence here?
 
If you speak the truth, stay tuned and mind your manners and I'll educate you.
Insults will get you ignored.
Find the hole in the Pentagon, no moving goalposts, remember.

you could never educate me in anything to do with aircraft malcolm

do not try, you will only embarrass yourself further

i cannot do it so post up the image that shows you the "evidence" about the "n" on the fuselage, i suspect you will not because it is so ludicrous

my manners are considerably greater than someone who has welched on a bet for charity

as for insult, where did i insult you, i have said i think you are a wind up merchant, this should be a compliment as you have done a very good job

however it is still sick for anyone to speculate about innocent victims and how they met their deaths, especially when you accuse with no evidence, this is not an insult just an observation and opinion

there are plenty of pictures of entry holes available online and you will notice that what you have posted is the extreme left edge of the impact not the centre area from that perspective the tree and the car and the fence are decieving, look at some of the aerial shots that show you where the tree is, this may help you
 
is this not the doctored photo that has been proved to be firemen with a searchlight and not a fire in the hole?

i looked at that page you posted the link to, very crude and old 911 nonsense that has been debunked a thousand times, it even debunks itself

as i am new i cannot post the picture which purports to show that the debri letter is in fact an "n" but if i could you could see it was laughable and in no way looks anything like the real thing

someone else please post this complete travesty of a picture up please

there wasnt just one lightpole either was there, how did they get knocked over

this has made me even more sure you are just a wind up merchant on here for a laugh, pretty sick when you consider the folks who died that day though


for the record i am also not a neocon, not even american and very anti-bush

This photograph that is laughable and shows that the 'n' is nothing like the real thing. You don't have to post it, just type out the reference and I'll find it.
 
Just out of interest do you ever read either your own posts or the ones you reply to? Have you actually thought even a tiny little bit about what you are actually claiming? By saying that there was no souce for the fires, you are actually saying that there must have been incendiary devices secretly planted in the rubble after the buildings collapsed. Seriously, what have you been smoking?

The implications of what they are claiming can be completely lost on some conspiracy theorists.
 
Thank you for showing the people reading these pages that you have ZERO understanding of the transfer of energy that occurs when a Boeing 757 traveling hunderds of miles an hour slams into a concrete building. Z E R O.
Kindly educate me on this point. In other words, walk right in.
 
So, you agree with all those witnesses, until they claim the large plane actually crashed into the Pentagon, right?

Light poles a joke, huh? Well, tell me, do you think that evidence as planted? Do you have any evidence of that?

As far of the taxi, stranger things have happened. There was a very long thread on this very forum where many scenarios were given about how that light post could have got there without caving in the hood. Do you think the taxi driver is lying? A plant? An idiot? Have you talked to him? ALL your statements have implications. You have a lot of evidence to hand wave away. Is this all you've got?

All you have is your own personal incredulity and NOTHING more. You are faced with eye witnesses testimony, DNA tests, physical evidence, expert opinion, and ALL YOU HAVE IS "I DON'T BELIEVE IT"?
All I ever get is,
"This was debunked years ago" or in your case,
"There was a very long thread about this..."
You'll have no difficukty explaining how a light pole can crash down onto a car, smash the strengthened glass of the window and not touch the hood.
Do me a favour, prove it now.
 
This photograph that is laughable and shows that the 'n' is nothing like the real thing. You don't have to post it, just type out the reference and I'll find it.

it was on the page that you linked to, you post it it is your theory and your evidence, the freedom files pentagon link

it is a very poor paintshop mock up that tries to say the part shows an "n" and that the colour is wrong and that the lettering is too small

that is not an "n" not even close, so the rivets theory is wrong

this is why i think you are on the wind up

no-one could seriously base any conclusions on stuff that poor
 
I don't dispute the large plane approaching the the Pentagon.
The light poles are a joke. There's a taxi with it's window broke by a falling light pole and not a scratch on the hood.
Softlee softlee catchee monkee = one thing at a time.
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread191416/pg1
Tell me in all honesty, how can a light pole crash down and through the windshield and not cave in the hood ?
You can't be serious. The light hit the windshield, stopping all momentum and then the pole came to rest on the hood. Those poles are not that heavy. Why is it that you can lay on the hood of your car and not dent or scratch it? Their time line on whether the explosion happened before or after they moved the pole may be off. Of course, twoofers demand absolute perfection in eyewitness time lines. (Mineta, anyone?)
 
All I ever get is,
"This was debunked years ago" or in your case,
"There was a very long thread about this..."
You'll have no difficukty explaining how a light pole can crash down onto a car, smash the strengthened glass of the window and not touch the hood.
Do me a favour, prove it now.

No, you do ME a favor and actually do some investigation on your own. If you were REALLY after the truth, you would have intimate knowledge of both sides of the story.

Hell, I've seen pictures of drinking straws embedded firmly in tree trunks by a tornado. Freaky things happen in accidents. Any rational person would look at the entire body of evidence and understand that anomalies will exist, unexplainable things will exist, and still realize the preponderance of evidence supports the fact that a large airliner crashed into the Pentagon.

Only a biased or irrational person would look at a single event, a couple pictures, or a short video, not be able to explain exactly how it happened, and with great drama declare that the entire event MUST be a hoax, and all the evidence that is contrary to their theory is bogus.

Investigations don't work like that. Rational people don't think like that.

So, you tell me how does the official story explain the lightpost? How does the taxi driver explain the lightpost?

Like I said. "I just don't believe it" won't even get you far in a debate, MUCH less in a courtroom. You need to have this stuff sorted out before you folks begin the 'trial of the century'.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom