[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
[qimg]http://pentagon911.0catch.com/_webimages/hole.JPG[/qimg]
You are correct on all points in your first paragraph.
These images do indeed show "the full extent of the impact area or at least where the fuselage hit".
We are asked to believe that the plane in the photos below went through the hole above.
Perhaps now, you will feel as outraged as I do.
The above photo is taken from this webpage,
http://pentagon911.0catch.com/
[qimg]http://www.members.shaw.ca/freedomsix/pics/pentcrash.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.members.shaw.ca/freedomsix/pics/purdue1_sim.jpg[/qimg]

Here is the hole, photo 8 on this webpage, sorry about the glitch.
http://911review.org/Wiki/snopespentagonrumor.html
 
In the cases of aircraft like the KC-10 (DC-10) and KC-135(707); absolutely. However, they may be strengthened simply because of the increased wing loading due to the max takeoff weight being increased by as much as 10% with no increase in wing surface area. They may also strengthen the wing because of the possibly of overstressing the mid and aft spars on landing. I imagine the landing gear main strut and trunnions would also larger and beefier. The added strength isn't armor, it's simply larger and heavier versions of existing parts. They aren't replaced with steel or titanium ....that's nonsense. I'm not even sure there is any structural beefening in the KC-10, as the empty weights of it and DC-10-40 are almost exactly the same @ 241,000 lbs.

Many military versions of civil aircraft are not strengthened because there is no increase in max takeoff weight or landing weight. For instance, the USAF and Navy C-40s(737-700), have a max takeoff weight of 171,000 lbs, the same weight as its civilian counterpart - the 737-700ER. The KC767 Tanker also has the same max takeoff weight as it's civilian counterpart, the 767-200ER - 395,000 lbs. The C-32/757? Yup same - 255,000 lbs. The VC-25(Air Force One)/E-4B and the 747-200B? Same at 833,000 lbs.

There are some who maintain that no plane could be strong enough to slide into one of the twins, like a knife into butter. So really I am doing no more than taking the middle ground, in maintaining that the plane that hit the south tower was strengthened.
 
There are some who maintain that no plane could be strong enough to slide into one of the twins, like a knife into butter. So really I am doing no more than taking the middle ground, in maintaining that the plane that hit the south tower was strengthened.
No, your claim is that they were armored bad boys. Strengthening and armoring are not the same thing.
 
There are some who maintain that no plane could be strong enough to slide into one of the twins, like a knife into butter. So really I am doing no more than taking the middle ground, in maintaining that the plane that hit the south tower was strengthened.


Malcolm - it's getting old stating facts and getting logical fallacies, like the one you repiled with above, in return. I simply ask for some evidence of armored transport planes, or evidence that the airplanes should've bounced off the towers. Do you have any? Yes or no? I dont want a response along the lines of "...military planes must be armored to protect them from enemy fire..." -or- "....planes dont just slide into buildings, thats impossible".

How about you search for something out of an engineering journal or university level engineering textbook, instead of conspiracy sites. I've also asked you, with no reply, why no physics professionals question the impacts as you do? Steven Jones was a physics proffessor, he is a member of the 9/11 Truth Movement. Why doesn't he think the impacts are anomolous? Please answer, I am most interested in your response to this...
 
The whole impeach Bush and Cheney movement know the truth etc.

"Know" seems to be a subjective term with truthers.

"argument from this" and "argument from that" are pointless and add nothing to the debate.

Of course they DO! They point out that some arguments are NON SEQUITURs. The conclusion does NOT follow from the premises. In short, those are NOT arguments. How does that NOT add to a debate ???

The brickwork behind is unscathed. You do remember all those claims, not so many pages ago about an aluminium wing travelling at 500 mph don't you ?
So where are the marks in the brickwork ?

Ground.

There are some who maintain that no plane could be strong enough to slide into one of the twins, like a knife into butter. So really I am doing no more than taking the middle ground, in maintaining that the plane that hit the south tower was strengthened.

You're not taking the middle ground, you are claiming that 175 did NOT hit the south tower. How is that "middle" ?
 
A large proportion of those in the truth movement still concerning themselves with spreading the truth outside politics, are confident of mini nukes being used and that number is increasing.

Unfortunately they have apparently failed to notice the rather major problem that such a thing doesn't exist.

In addition, your nonsense about the pools of molten metal has been debunked so many times it's not even funny any more. Suffice to say that no pools of molten metal were actually observed. In addition, you, and all the others, apparently seem to forget that explosions tend to be over rather quickly. A nuclear explosion takes somewhere on the order of milliseconds, while thermite, that other favourite of the molten metal brigade, burns for seconds, maybe minutes at most. So, whether nukes, thermite, conventional explosives or nothing at all were involved in the collapse, no demolition theory even pretends to explain molten metal weeks after the collapse.

Of course, reality doesn't have such a problem. Firstly, as already mentioned, while there is evidence that some metal was molten at some point, there is no evidence that it was molten at any time after the collapse, let alone weeks afterwards. Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, no explosives of any kind could keep the temperature that high weeks after the event. However, fires burning underneath the rubble could, and this kind of subterranean burning is a well known phenomenon, see here for example.

Given that the buildings were known to be on fire before the collapse, given that the existence or not of either subterranean fires or pools of molten metal does not support any kind of deliberate explosions and given that there is no evidence supporting their use, doesn't it seem a little silly to claim that they were used? Doesn't it seem even sillier to claim that not only were explosives used despite the lack of evidence, but that explosives that do not actually exist were used?
 
When you are satisfied as to my intentions viz a viz resolving this matter by legal means, kindly let me know and we'll get back to the points at issue.

Malcolm, in your attempt to sound educated and worldly, you expose yourself as ignorant. Remember "Ce la vie" [sic]? "Verb Transative"? Well, we can add "viz a viz" [sic] to the growing list of flashy phrases that our resident retired businessman doesn't seem to know anything about.
 
No, your claim is that they were armored bad boys. Strengthening and armoring are not the same thing.

Strengthened - armoured, argue over terminology all you like. They did get right into the twins and you can see the entry marks.
Whereas, the same cannot be said for the Pentagon.
 
Strengthened - armoured, argue over terminology all you like. They did get right into the twins and you can see the entry marks.
Whereas, the same cannot be said for the Pentagon.
Again, we're talking about a light steel columns that were only meant to provide support as opposed to a heavy reinforced concrete wall designed to lessen the damage from a bomb. Somehow you think that they are both of equal strength. I would love to read your proof of that.
 
I've already answered the questions concerning upward moving debris. See post 2732.

As for the "rooftop demolitions," the upward flow of ligher-colored substance at the roof level of the building pointed out in the video as "rooftop demolitions" appears indistinguishable from the lighter-colored flow at the roof level clearly visible in this CNN video from the start of the video approximately 25-30 seconds before the collapse, and continuously visible (except for a few seconds when the shot is zoomed too far out to see it clearly) until the collapse begins. Thus I conclude that it is most likely smoke from the fire. Only by freezing the frame does the editor of the video you linked to make it appear to resemble any sort of demolition-related phenomenon. Did you fall for his deception?

Respectfully,
Myriad
You have obviously studied 'my' video (I use the term 'my' for brevity only)
looking for the most ambiguous point, this you are entitled to do.
If you look at 'my' video more closely, you will see material being ejected above the surrounding smoke.
You make no mention of the two demolition squids, the row of demolitions or all the ejected materials. Also, some still burning steel being hurled outwards with far greater force than would be possible in a conventional collapse.
Here is more white demolition smoke, do you have an alternative explanation for this ?
Also, if you look closely into the shadow on the north side of tower 2, you will see steel on FIRE.
fema_wtc2exp.jpg

site1049.jpg
 
you think people like me are toothless.
I mentioned notions of 'superiority' in a recent post as being a root cause of
perpetual trouble.
People can think what they like, but when they put the wrong thoughts into action,
they put themselves outside the law.
It might only be a small thing, but such things can be costly.
I'll be making sure that happens.
...........

.........
My message is that 9/11 was an inside job and justice is going to be served in the matter, in spages.
...................

.............

Change will come and with ot justice. The guilty ones will be dealt with one at a time

Truly sounds like you want a revolution and after it occurs to punish those you believe caused the attacks of 9/11. No trials required, you already know who the guilty are.

I do not wish to emmulate tyrants. I'm not sure where you got that from. However, my answer is a definate no.
I do not advocate extra judicial punishments either.
My own personal belief is in the rule of law. I maintain that the law is there to resolve this current matter, not everyone else does. I do see the need for making law education much easier for young people. I advocate relaxing the need for two degrees for example. There is nothing difficult in learning the law, quite the opposite.
Within the 'truth' community, the argument isn't whether or not 9/11 was an inside job. That is resolved many times over. Neither is the argument on the finer points of that inside job.
The argument now is that the 9/11 truth is a political issue.
I keep many reference, but Congress does know for example, that OKC was blown up from the inside. I've actually posted the retired generals account on this thread. I'm confident that the same is true with regard to 9/11 and that the Congress is taking the 'firing of US attorneys' route rather than hanging out all the dirty washing in one go.

NOW , you say that there is a way to do all of this under the present system of law and goverance.
Which is it malcolm, a revolution and a purge afterwards or working within the present system?
 
I have never heard the word 'trolling' before coming on here and I still don't know what it means. I could guess near enough.
I have no need to engage in tactics or word play, I have the truth on my side.


Then you show that Rolfe was correct. You are very new to internet forums. "troll" is used extensively on internet forums. That you claim never to have encountered its use elsewhere suggests you have been to few other forums. Why not do a search for that word on any of your favorite CT friendly forums.
 
Malcolm - it's getting old stating facts and getting logical fallacies, like the one you repiled with above, in return. I simply ask for some evidence of armored transport planes, or evidence that the airplanes should've bounced off the towers. Do you have any? Yes or no? I dont want a response along the lines of "...military planes must be armored to protect them from enemy fire..." -or- "....planes dont just slide into buildings, thats impossible".

How about you search for something out of an engineering journal or university level engineering textbook, instead of conspiracy sites. I've also asked you, with no reply, why no physics professionals question the impacts as you do? Steven Jones was a physics proffessor, he is a member of the 9/11 Truth Movement. Why doesn't he think the impacts are anomolous? Please answer, I am most interested in your response to this...
A picture paints a thousand words, here's a few thousand words for you,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l38oEJwAb1Q&mode=related&search=
http://911blogger.com/node/9590
 
*sigh*. You know, maybe it's me, but I'm getting this image of jumping through hoops while chasing these goalposts...

Never the less, we persevere. From here: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/d/d6/Pentagon_precollapse.jpg

a pretty good shot made during the firefighting efforts. The fence is pretty well destroyed in that photo.

My personal opinion is in your shot, in all honesty, those marked windows are broken. There are different areas of reflection, particularly at about the 2 o'clock position on the window the lowest arrow points to.

I say "In all honesty" because I imagne that'll be thought of as being overly contrary, so I'll accept that they are not broken for the sake of argument. a few things just off the top of my head:

1. The windows are recessed, not flush with the outside of the building. If something hit flat against the rest of the building, it could have missed the window. Even if it broke apart, since the windows are re-enfoced, it could have withstood the impact accross it's surface area.

but that brings us to..

2. It missed the windows entirely. the windows marked are 2nd story windows, and it appears the damage went below that, to the first story. Note the floor is relativly intact. Some parts of the structure surrounding the windows fell into the breach, but that's about it.

If you want any more detail, you'll need to find me a map of the area around the pentagon, including how far from the Building the fence is, AND a location of where that shot was taken from and what it is showing. I'll have to ask that you not provide guessess about that - we need to know for certain that we are looking at the outer-most ring, and what part of the damaged area we are seeing. my guess is the left engine impact, but there is not enough information in that shot to go by.

Can I precis your post as follows,
In New York a commercial jetliner can bring down a skyscraper, in Washington the same plane can't break a window.
 
Malcolm, in your attempt to sound educated and worldly, you expose yourself as ignorant. Remember "Ce la vie" [sic]? "Verb Transative"? Well, we can add "viz a viz" [sic] to the growing list of flashy phrases that our resident retired businessman doesn't seem to know anything about.

Is this really the best post you can put together ?
 
Truly sounds like you want a revolution and after it occurs to punish those you believe caused the attacks of 9/11. No trials required, you already know who the guilty are.



NOW , you say that there is a way to do all of this under the present system of law and goverance.
Which is it malcolm, a revolution and a purge afterwards or working within the present system?

Where is your question ?
You answer in the penultimate sentence, then ask a clearly irrelevant question in your final sentence. I don't follow your reasoning.
I advocate that this matter be resolved using the tried and tested legal system, as you point out in your penultimate sentence.
 
Can I precis your post as follows,
In New York a commercial jetliner can bring down a skyscraper, in Washington the same plane can't break a window.
Can't break a window? Lots of windows were broken on the first floor. In both cases, it was the damage from the crash and the resulting fires that caused the collapses.

So, where is your proof that the armored bad boys existed?
 
Unfortunately they have apparently failed to notice the rather major problem that such a thing doesn't exist.

In addition, your nonsense about the pools of molten metal has been debunked so many times it's not even funny any more. Suffice to say that no pools of molten metal were actually observed. In addition, you, and all the others, apparently seem to forget that explosions tend to be over rather quickly. A nuclear explosion takes somewhere on the order of milliseconds, while thermite, that other favourite of the molten metal brigade, burns for seconds, maybe minutes at most. So, whether nukes, thermite, conventional explosives or nothing at all were involved in the collapse, no demolition theory even pretends to explain molten metal weeks after the collapse.

Of course, reality doesn't have such a problem. Firstly, as already mentioned, while there is evidence that some metal was molten at some point, there is no evidence that it was molten at any time after the collapse, let alone weeks afterwards. Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, no explosives of any kind could keep the temperature that high weeks after the event. However, fires burning underneath the rubble could, and this kind of subterranean burning is a well known phenomenon, see here for example.

Given that the buildings were known to be on fire before the collapse, given that the existence or not of either subterranean fires or pools of molten metal does not support any kind of deliberate explosions and given that there is no evidence supporting their use, doesn't it seem a little silly to claim that they were used? Doesn't it seem even sillier to claim that not only were explosives used despite the lack of evidence, but that explosives that do not actually exist were used?
Subterrainean burning? Undergound coal fires?
Manhattan Island is waterlogged. They had to excavate down to bed rock and then build a reinforced concrete 'bathtub'.
Consequently, there is absolutely no possibility of any other source of these fires other than due to the demolition.
Here is evidence of the fires,
http://www.infowars.net/articles/november2006/171106molten.htm
Here, evidence of the bathtub,
http://www.civil.columbia.edu/~ling/wtc/
 
Is this really the best post you can put together ?

Not at all.

As I stated earlier, I am personally done jumping through hoops with someone who continually lies, and refuses to acknowledge the mistakes they make, over and over and over again. I made a compilation of "Malcolm's Greatest Hits" (or more accurately, misses) earlier in this thread, with some of your more blatant half-truths, mistakes, and outright lies (such as the claim that 9/11 was a cloudy day), hoping that people will notice that you've been throwing (rule 8) against the wall for 50+ pages of this thread, and hoping something - anything - will stick. In the cases where you've been called on your nonsense, you ignore it and move on. Never once admitting or correcting your mistakes.

I ahve realized that it's worthless to pick one point and expect you to back it up. You simply run away - more like a child than anyone looking for serious debate. Sure, I could pick just one topic - say, you're earlier mentioned claim that 9/11 was a cloudy day - and ask you to back it up with proof. But why bother? You've proven that you have no interest backing anything up. Plenty of other posters here have shown you weather maps and photos form the day in question. You won't acknowedge that you are simply wrong. (Feel free to make my point for me and ignore this particular topic one more time.)

This last post was not "the best I could put together", but it was simply another piece of evidence that you are not who you have been claiming to be. Your continued attempts to introduce certain terms and phrases into your posts reeks of a child impersonating an adult - parroting what you heard, but just not clear exactly what it means (or how to spell it).

When confronted with your horrible grasp of common phrases and their meanings, you reply with this:

Is this really the best post you can put together ?

So, now it's my turn to ask you... is that really the best reply you can come up with when someone points out that someone claiming to be a retired businessman doesn't know how to spell "C'est la vie", or "vis a vis"?

Malcolm, you are a child. I don't mean that as an insult. I am saying that your actions and choice of language give you away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom