[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You were wrong in your assumption as to the reason for my question.
I asked the question to satisfy myself whether the visitor to the site went there with an open mind or to do a 'hit' piece.

Malcolm, seriously now, how do you make a statement like the one above?
And then use the reason below?

[/QUOTE]No geiger counter = no intention of following up the radiation findings of truthers. That's enough for me to see bias in the visit.[/QUOTE]

To go there with a gieger counter is an assumption ( or bias) of radiation.
To go there and do a chemical analysis of the rubble pile to get readings is a fact finding search, nothing is assumed in that. Can't you see the difference?
 
Do the 250 points by Killtown on that one webpage, taken as a whole, raise any doubts whatsoever in your mind ?


Killtown failed to make any valid points. He recycles debunked falsehoods and, like you, is impervious to real evidence. His nonsense raises no doubt whatever in the mind of any rationalist.

We get the idea that you won't be answering my question, Malcolm.
 
Mine and over 50 % of the voting public.

kirkman where do you get that "50%" number from? I live in one of the densest populated states in the USA and I have yet to encounter 1 yes thats ONE person who wants a re-investigation. You are not even a US citizen to be making such demands. I vote you don't. Your tiny fantasist conspiracy movement will be ignored. Thanks for playing and amusing us.

Yes we dispute the two pentagon policeman's testimony, Argument from authority noted but we have these
http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/PentWitnesses.xls

As far as the "brick of the pentagon unscathed" you should take note that the brick was behind the limestone veneer. It was also reinforced from within with geotextile fabric and structural steel floor to ceiling frames to anchor the windows. The brick was infill between the steel reinforced concrete columns in the wall.
http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/pentagon/pentagon-retrofit.htm
 

Attachments

  • wall-close-up.jpg
    wall-close-up.jpg
    72.9 KB · Views: 2
You seem to be being purposely obtuse. The photos I posted are closer to the collapse in both time and distance, than the long shot you referred to.
Bearing in mind all the previous posts that there were, extolling the ability of aluminium wings travelling at 500 mph being able to go through anything. How come. at the Pentagon, these same wings don't leave so much as a scratch on the brickwork.
http://www.911review.org/images/snopes/car-whitep.JPG
In this photo, a 6ft wire fence is still standing where the wing should have gone through,
http://www.911review.org/images/snopes/car911.JPG

Excuse me, you seem to be saying that the large image shows where the main fuselage smacked into the building (my inference here), so the relatively undamaged area to the left is where the wing didn't penetrate?

The smaller image shows the fence and sure enough it looks relatively intact, but I doubt that the building wall behind it was the impact area.

Looks to me like there's a hole (more or less) on the ground-level floor (behind the burned white car). This looks (to me) like the left end of the impact area. Naturally if the impact area ended about where that last ground floor window [frame] is, the fencing further away would still be standing unless debris hit it and apparently none did.

From the angle, you cannot see the full extent of the impact area unless you wish to claim that these images actually do show the full extent of the impact area or at least where the fuselage hit?
 
Malcolm, seriously now, how do you make a statement like the one above?
And then use the reason below?
No geiger counter = no intention of following up the radiation findings of truthers. That's enough for me to see bias in the visit.[/QUOTE]

To go there with a gieger counter is an assumption ( or bias) of radiation.
To go there and do a chemical analysis of the rubble pile to get readings is a fact finding search, nothing is assumed in that. Can't you see the difference?[/QUOTE]
A large proportion of those in the truth movement still concerning themselves with spreading the truth outside politics, are confident of mini nukes being used and that number is increasing. I wouldn't expect someone outside the movement to know that, but I would expect an unbiased amateur scientist, when planning to visit the sites, to be curious enough to want to satisfy himself with regard to mini nukes.
This mini nukes argument has been rolling along for a long time, you might describe it as a major matter. The believers seem to be coming out on top, mainly because of how long the 'hot spots' lasted.
It's to do with the length of time there were pools of molten metal, the vapourisation of over 1000 people, the vapourisation of all that concrete, floor pans, steel girders and columns and the damage to vehicles amongst other things.
As I say, I wouldn't expect someone not au fait with the 9/11 debates to think about taking a geiger counter. But it's really inconceivable that an unbiased 'scientist' wouldn't take a geiger counter with him. They're cheap enough etc, I daresay you could hire one.
Here are just a few sites to exemplify that,
I'm not asking you to read and inwardly digest these pages, just a quick skip through, to underline the importance to a 'scientist', who planned to visit the sites.
http://www.thepriceofliberty.org/06/09/25/ward.htm
http://clipmarks.com/clipmark/CC969F0B-9999-46D7-863C-79AB7D03ED70/
http://www.rense.com/general67/forensic.htm
http://wtcdemolition.blogspot.com/2007/05/wtc-nuke-thesis-from-anonymous.html
 
This is the quintessential example of trolling, Malcolm. You know very well what he meant. And it works both ways, and it's true whether or not your "theory" is correct.

I have never heard the word 'trolling' before coming on here and I still don't know what it means. I could guess near enough.
I have no need to engage in tactics or word play, I have the truth on my side.
 
Let me refer you to post 2734.
You can see quite clearly that the wall is untouched and a wire fence unbroken.
You can't have the half penny and the gingerbread. If an aluminium wing doing 500mph can go through most anything, as there are umpteen posts on this thread to that effect. Then why can't it go through a 6ft tall wire fence or leave not a mark on brickwork ?


*sigh*. You know, maybe it's me, but I'm getting this image of jumping through hoops while chasing these goalposts...

Never the less, we persevere. From here: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/d/d6/Pentagon_precollapse.jpg

a pretty good shot made during the firefighting efforts. The fence is pretty well destroyed in that photo.

My personal opinion is in your shot, in all honesty, those marked windows are broken. There are different areas of reflection, particularly at about the 2 o'clock position on the window the lowest arrow points to.

I say "In all honesty" because I imagne that'll be thought of as being overly contrary, so I'll accept that they are not broken for the sake of argument. a few things just off the top of my head:

1. The windows are recessed, not flush with the outside of the building. If something hit flat against the rest of the building, it could have missed the window. Even if it broke apart, since the windows are re-enfoced, it could have withstood the impact accross it's surface area.

but that brings us to..

2. It missed the windows entirely. the windows marked are 2nd story windows, and it appears the damage went below that, to the first story. Note the floor is relativly intact. Some parts of the structure surrounding the windows fell into the breach, but that's about it.

If you want any more detail, you'll need to find me a map of the area around the pentagon, including how far from the Building the fence is, AND a location of where that shot was taken from and what it is showing. I'll have to ask that you not provide guessess about that - we need to know for certain that we are looking at the outer-most ring, and what part of the damaged area we are seeing. my guess is the left engine impact, but there is not enough information in that shot to go by.
 
You can think what you want, but you thinking it won't change reality.





Ha ha. Please tell me you're not serious.






According to the Russians about 670 Ju-52s were shot down or destroyed trying to resupply the 6th Army.






Transports do, rarely, find themselves in harm's way. An RNZAF C-130H Hercules cracked its main wing spar avoiding an Iraqi SAM which was fired at it in the first Gulf War. The reality, nonetheless, is that transport aircraft are not armoured, and indeed, aircraft in general are seldom armoured in this day and age. The only armoured aircraft I know of are the A-10 and numerous variants of helicopter.

The way tactical airlift aircraft deal with hostile landing zones is to perform what's called a Tactical Landing:



and if that fails, there's always counter-measures:



-Gumboot
Would you agree that miltary versions of civilian planes are strengthened, so as to carry more weight ?
 
There's been a "proper" investigation. That it didn't fulfill your wish list is your problem.
The 'proper' investigation to which you refer, said that this plane
pentcrash.jpg

purdue1_sim.jpg


fitted into this hole.
car-whitep.JPG

Where are the,
1. wings
2. engines
3. tail
4. seats
5. luggage
6. marks on the wall where the wings hit
7. marks on the wall where the engines hit
8. marks on the wall where the tail hit
9. grooves in the lawn where the engines ploughed
10 where are there even broken windows in the pentagon facade.
 
My own personal belief is in the rule of law. I maintain that the law is there to resolve this current matter, not everyone else does.

[...]

Within the 'truth' community, the argument isn't whether or not 9/11 was an inside job. That is resolved many times over. Neither is the argument on the finer points of that inside job.

Malcolm, if that is the case, then you should present your proof to courts. But I hope you realise that your evidence and inference will be quite insufficient to convince juries and judges.

I'll let you decide whether that's because they are all paid shills, or because your theory is just plain wrong.
 
You can't have the half penny and the gingerbread. If an aluminium wing doing 500mph can go through most anything, as there are umpteen posts on this thread to that effect.

Not "anything". But you really, REALLY should read up on the effects of SPEED on kinetic energy.

Then why can't it go through a 6ft tall wire fence or leave not a mark on brickwork ?

One word: Ground.

Would you agree that miltary versions of civilian planes are strengthened, so as to carry more weight ?

Strengthened <> Armoured.

The 'proper' investigation to which you refer, said that this plane fitted into this hole.

That's a lie. Why do you lie, Malcolm ?

I have the truth on my side.

So says everyone in the world, Malcolm. That's why we have evidence to tell who REALLY has the truth.
 
Malcom, you really have this "the experts, first responders, and eye witnesses are all wrong, only I and a few like-minded laymen can REALLY see what happened by looking at a few videos and pictures" thing down, don't you?
 
Excuse me, you seem to be saying that the large image shows where the main fuselage smacked into the building (my inference here), so the relatively undamaged area to the left is where the wing didn't penetrate?

The smaller image shows the fence and sure enough it looks relatively intact, but I doubt that the building wall behind it was the impact area.

Looks to me like there's a hole (more or less) on the ground-level floor (behind the burned white car). This looks (to me) like the left end of the impact area. Naturally if the impact area ended about where that last ground floor window [frame] is, the fencing further away would still be standing unless debris hit it and apparently none did.

From the angle, you cannot see the full extent of the impact area unless you wish to claim that these images actually do show the full extent of the impact area or at least where the fuselage hit?
hole.JPG

You are correct on all points in your first paragraph.
These images do indeed show "the full extent of the impact area or at least where the fuselage hit".
We are asked to believe that the plane in the photos below went through the hole above.
Perhaps now, you will feel as outraged as I do.
The above photo is taken from this webpage,
http://pentagon911.0catch.com/
pentcrash.jpg

purdue1_sim.jpg
 
*sigh*. You know, maybe it's me, but I'm getting this image of jumping through hoops while chasing these goalposts...

Never the less, we persevere. From here: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/d/d6/Pentagon_precollapse.jpg

a pretty good shot made during the firefighting efforts. The fence is pretty well destroyed in that photo.

My personal opinion is in your shot, in all honesty, those marked windows are broken. There are different areas of reflection, particularly at about the 2 o'clock position on the window the lowest arrow points to.

I say "In all honesty" because I imagne that'll be thought of as being overly contrary, so I'll accept that they are not broken for the sake of argument. a few things just off the top of my head:

1. The windows are recessed, not flush with the outside of the building. If something hit flat against the rest of the building, it could have missed the window. Even if it broke apart, since the windows are re-enfoced, it could have withstood the impact accross it's surface area.

but that brings us to..

2. It missed the windows entirely. the windows marked are 2nd story windows, and it appears the damage went below that, to the first story. Note the floor is relativly intact. Some parts of the structure surrounding the windows fell into the breach, but that's about it.

If you want any more detail, you'll need to find me a map of the area around the pentagon, including how far from the Building the fence is, AND a location of where that shot was taken from and what it is showing. I'll have to ask that you not provide guessess about that - we need to know for certain that we are looking at the outer-most ring, and what part of the damaged area we are seeing. my guess is the left engine impact, but there is not enough information in that shot to go by.

Kindly consider my immediate prior post and this webpage,
http://pentagon911.0catch.com/
 
Would you agree that miltary versions of civilian planes are strengthened, so as to carry more weight ?


In the cases of aircraft like the KC-10 (DC-10) and KC-135(707); absolutely. However, they may be strengthened simply because of the increased wing loading due to the max takeoff weight being increased by as much as 10% with no increase in wing surface area. They may also strengthen the wing because of the possibly of overstressing the mid and aft spars on landing. I imagine the landing gear main strut and trunnions would also larger and beefier. The added strength isn't armor, it's simply larger and heavier versions of existing parts. They aren't replaced with steel or titanium ....that's nonsense. I'm not even sure there is any structural beefening in the KC-10, as the empty weights of it and DC-10-40 are almost exactly the same @ 241,000 lbs.

Many military versions of civil aircraft are not strengthened because there is no increase in max takeoff weight or landing weight. For instance, the USAF and Navy C-40s(737-700), have a max takeoff weight of 171,000 lbs, the same weight as its civilian counterpart - the 737-700ER. The KC767 Tanker also has the same max takeoff weight as it's civilian counterpart, the 767-200ER - 395,000 lbs. The C-32/757? Yup same - 255,000 lbs. The VC-25(Air Force One)/E-4B and the 747-200B? Same at 833,000 lbs.
 
2706 is not proof of anything. Provide any proof that such a "bad boy" exists. Sure, it makes sense to armor transports, but in reality, the military prefers load capacity over protection. Some may improvise and throw in a few hundred pounds of kevlar to protect against small arms fire, but the amount of steel to protect against against a missile or RPG would be way too much weight. Read up on the steel grating that they put around the IFVs in Iraq.
 
In this video the commentator offers an explanation for the 'rooftop demolitions'. Do you have an alternative explanation ? 40 to 45 secs.
Also, at 1.10 to 1.40, the commentator offers an explanation as to upward moving debris. Do you have an alternative explanation ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
I'm not asking you to comment on his explanation, I'm asking you for an alternative explanation.
Respectfully.


I've already answered the questions concerning upward moving debris. See post 2732.

As for the "rooftop demolitions," the upward flow of ligher-colored substance at the roof level of the building pointed out in the video as "rooftop demolitions" appears indistinguishable from the lighter-colored flow at the roof level clearly visible in this CNN video from the start of the video approximately 25-30 seconds before the collapse, and continuously visible (except for a few seconds when the shot is zoomed too far out to see it clearly) until the collapse begins. Thus I conclude that it is most likely smoke from the fire. Only by freezing the frame does the editor of the video you linked to make it appear to resemble any sort of demolition-related phenomenon. Did you fall for his deception?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Kindly consider my immediate prior post and this webpage,
http://pentagon911.0catch.com/

Sorry, but Considered and Rejected summarily based on the first two pictures on that site. Rest of the page isn't much better. Whoever created that webpage doesn't present anything other than "I don't understand, therefore scientists & investigators trained in this sort of thing are wrong".

I told you what was needed for more detail. That page doesn't answer any of my questions at all.
 
kirkman where do you get that "50%" number from? I live in one of the densest populated states in the USA and I have yet to encounter 1 yes thats ONE person who wants a re-investigation. You are not even a US citizen to be making such demands. I vote you don't. Your tiny fantasist conspiracy movement will be ignored. Thanks for playing and amusing us.

Yes we dispute the two pentagon policeman's testimony, Argument from authority noted but we have these
http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/PentWitnesses.xls

As far as the "brick of the pentagon unscathed" you should take note that the brick was behind the limestone veneer. It was also reinforced from within with geotextile fabric and structural steel floor to ceiling frames to anchor the windows. The brick was infill between the steel reinforced concrete columns in the wall.
http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/pentagon/pentagon-retrofit.htm
This is one example of 50%,
http://www.zogby.com/search/ReadNews.dbm?ID=855
Kindly understand that many people in the truth movement have moved over to politics. For example Cindy Sheehan is taking on Pelosi. The whole impeach Bush and Cheney movement know the truth etc.
No offence, but these terms,
"argument from this" and "argument from that" are pointless and add nothing to the debate.
To dispute one police officer is a mountain to climb, to dispute two is just plain silly. You seem determined NOT to accept proper evidence.
The thin limestone veneer was no more than weather protection, any explosion would have blown it off.
The brickwork behind is unscathed. You do remember all those claims, not so many pages ago about an aluminium wing travelling at 500 mph don't you ?
So where are the marks in the brickwork ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom