Model Mayhem goes GIGO

Excellent point and the urging of which was among the things which got me tossed out of AE. How naive I was that this group was interesting in looking into the mechanism of collapse. They are completely uninterested in it to the point of denial that such things are even possible. A structure which stands for X number of years cannot collapse!

I don't think they are "top professionals"... but even that's not fair... not everyone can be at the top... but looks like they have a collection of low hanging fruit.

Funny..
That is interesting, given that a short time ago I was also calling for ae911t to actually do an FEA of WTC7 either mechanical or fire. AE911T shouts for NISTinput data to their FEAs but won't indicate what they would do with it. If their goal is to simply rerun the NIST FEA then their approach is obvious, rather than dispute NIST's work they intend only to search for malfesance in the outcome as reported. That is to say that they expect to rerun the exact same computer modeling and see a completely different outcome.
Very telling in an organization that purports to seek truth yet goes about it with a prejudice of assumed lies.

In addition they use the bulk of the monies collected for public speaking tours rather than technical investigations. Again this indicates a presupposition that they already have the truth and technical imvestigations to refute NIST are uneeded, at least not by them.

Instead they support and tout simplistic and wholly inadequate 'papers' such as Mr.Sarns'.
 
Surely its even more basic than that?

Logic 101 - avoid false dichotomies. There is probably a fancy Latin name for the structure of this one. i.e. leaving out the category of "those we don't know about". Isn't it this simple:

Set A - things we know about - the "knowns" - comprising two sub-sets:
Subset A1 - "knowns" i.e. already have the status of "known";
Subset A2 - "unknowns" i.e. have status of "unknown" more specifically we know they exist but not what they are.

Set B - things we don't know about. Strictly the same two subsets exist but the word play goes a bit circular on the first one:
Subset B1 the "unknown knowns"....how can you not know that it is known...[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/scratch.gif[/qimg]

So forget that one - I'll settle for :
Subset B2 - "unknown" -the subset of factors which are unknown BUT we don't even know they exist.

But it is a "play on words" situation - using the word "[un]known" with two meanings. Is there a Latin name for those?


Plus, I suppose, we don't have to limit our comprehension to US specific examples.... :)


:runaway

Here is a fairly good treatise on Unknown Unknowns. I'd provide a copy of my training from back in the day however it's at the office.

Unknown Unknowns in Probabalistic Cost and Schedule Risk Models
 
The list provided seems to completely ignore any recommendations about engineering design.. such as:

safety factor
alternate load paths
strength, design and type of steel frame connections
long span column free interiors supported on bar joints
use of load transfer structures
building over existing structures such as power stations

Sunder made remarks concerning most of these whilst summarizing the major code changes the NIST report had recommended: http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/upload/Sunder_Progressive-Collapse_Remarks_050106.pdf

I'd say while the remarks hardly do the justice of explaining the actual changes or to explain the critique other professionals have made it's clear that many of the matters you say were not addressed were in fact brought up
 
Now ANSWER the question I posed:

What SPECIFIC recommendations ASIDE FROM fire protection issues did NIST make regarding STRUCTURAL DESIGN.

Codes are being revised all the time.. If you can show ANY CODE revisions was directly related to NIST recommendations please do so.

Archi(tect) Bunker

What makes you think something needs to change structurally?
 
Sunder made remarks concerning most of these whilst summarizing the major code changes the NIST report had recommended: http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/upload/Sunder_Progressive-Collapse_Remarks_050106.pdf

I'd say while the remarks hardly do the justice of explaining the actual changes or to explain the critique other professionals have made it's clear that many of the matters you say were not addressed were in fact brought up

Be serious... remarks in a Q&A are not what I am looking for. And you know it... It was a dodge or willful omission.

Why?
 
What makes you think something needs to change structurally?

Don't ask me questions... Respond to the points I made.

When a structure collapses... such as 7 from the bottom... drops at virtual FF acceleration for 2.25 secs you look at the bottom 100' very carefully.
 
In addition they use the bulk of the monies collected for public speaking tours rather than technical investigations...
.

AE911T is a PR operation which makes money so it can continue to make money. It sells a false narrative claiming that the official story is a false narrative.

Kettle calling the pot black... like the GWOT... AE911T will never end and never get anywhere.
 
Don't ask me questions... Respond to the points I made.

When a structure collapses... such as 7 from the bottom... drops at virtual FF acceleration for 2.25 secs you look at the bottom 100' very carefully.
The drops at virtual FF acceleration is the talk of failed 911 truth, and it means nothing. The interior of WTC 7 was gone, collapsed, there was nothing stopping the collapse of the facade. The total collapse took more than 15 seconds, very slow compared to g. But go ahead, spew the Gage FF acceleration crap, it is what 911 truth does.

WTC 7 burned for hours, with a lot of broken windows to feed the fire.
th_wtc7fire3-1-1.jpg

Fire does this to steel,
woodbeambentsteel-full.jpg

Destroys the strength of steel, it is called material science, like math but different. What did you say about math? Exactly.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/onemeridiansag.jpg
Fire destroys buildings, they knew WTC 7 was totaled well before it collapsed. If 300 fire-fighters had not died, WTC 7 would have stood. End of story; your inability to understand fire science, math, physics and structural engineering is a personal problem, and in pilot training, we never had personal problems, we flew, we won. Good luck.
 
Last edited:
The drops at virtual FF acceleration is the talk of failed 911 truth, and it means nothing. The interior of WTC 7 was gone, collapsed, there was nothing stopping the collapse of the facade.

While I agree that the insides were gone by the time we see the descent of the curtain wall...the curtain wall did continue down to the ground and was above the con ed on the north side where the collapse was... why would the curtain wall drop for 100 feet at about FF...

Just explain that if you will...

You can use math if you like.
 
Don't ask me questions... Respond to the points I made.

That's what I did. Asking question with regard to your "point" is the definition of responding to you. So again, what makes you think the building code needs changes to structural design?
 
While I agree that the insides were gone by the time we see the descent of the curtain wall...the curtain wall did continue down to the ground and was above the con ed on the north side where the collapse was... why would the curtain wall drop for 100 feet at about FF...

Just explain that if you will...

You can use math if you like.
Wow, I am an engineer, and the exterior, one single point on the exterior fell at free fall or faster due to frame of reference. But then you deny the need for math, and physics, so you are left with an anomaly due to ignorance. My parents and the USAF paid a lot to make me able to know you use BS instead of engineering.
Are you going to add physics another what you don't do like you did with math?; or what?


Guess what the system acceleration is? You have one point at free fall, but what about the system. Oops, that takes math and physics, and some engineering. My mom made sure I was an engineer, the USAF love it; made me a pilot and sent me to grad school... What was your goal?

You joined Gage, you were fooled. Now you can't figure out engineering models; but I can. Have a nice day.

Being an engineer is BS, it was more something I could fall back on while flying over the entire world, something to think about. It only takes a grade school education to figure out 911, and know Gage was fraud.

What does the model, E=mc2 look like? There was nothing stopping the facade from falling. The interior structure fell many seconds before. But that is the evidence, facts, reality; you are not using math; you need math to understand physics, and reality.
 
Last edited:
Right... we know the fire suppression and eggress was crappy... what about BUILDING CODE recommendations... structural design issues...
Name the recs of NIST
A/B

check in with NYS... my license if from 1982...
I asked:
What were the BUILDING CODE recommendations in the NIST report.. aside from the FIRE CODE and EGRESS issues.
Don't don't my clients that...
ps... loved the web site...
A/B

It seems to me... that there were all sorts of engineering decisions made in the two designs... 7 and the twins... which led to the total collapse and I distinguish those from the less than adequate fire safety, suppression, and emergency egress issues reveal. The list provided seems to completely ignore any recommendations about engineering design.. such as:

safety factor
alternate load paths
strength, design and type of steel frame connections
long span column free interiors supported on bar joints
use of load transfer structures
building over existing structures such as power stations

Now ANSWER the question I posed:
What SPECIFIC recommendations ASIDE FROM fire protection issues did NIST make regarding STRUCTURAL DESIGN.
Codes are being revised all the time.. If you can show ANY CODE revisions was directly related to NIST recommendations please do so.
Archi(tect) Bunker


Here they are:
NIST Proposed structural changes.

[FONT=&quot]“Status of NIST's Recommendations Following the Federal [/FONT]Building and Fire Investigation of the World Trade Center Disaster - August 8, 2011”

http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/upload/WTCRecommendationsStatusTable.pdf

Here are the structural changes adopted.

ASCE 7, AISC Specifications, ACI 318, IBC, structural code revisions directly related to the NIST recommendations:
The pdf file is corrupted so search “Section 1614 Structural Integrity” "1609.1.1,1609.1.2" these sections are presently in the IBC 2009 code book used by architects and engineers in all 50 states.

“Code Technology Committee
Area of Study – NIST World Trade Center Recommendations
2007/2008 Cycle
Code changes related to the CTC area of study noted above “

http://www.iccsafe.org/cs/CTC/Documents/WTC/CodeChanges/CTC_NIST_WTC_related_code_changes_1_of_2.pdf
 
Last edited:

Thanks for the link. I read the document produced as *NEW* in August 08 which I believe was after the final report on NCSTAR 1 which was published September 05 and the report on 7 came out in 2008.

The document you referred to does not discuss from my reading any of the factors which were in play in the WTC buildings....

Here is an example of the 2008 recommendations:

"1614.3.2.1 Columns.
Each column splice shall have the minimum des
ign strength in tension to transfer the design
dead and live load tributary to the column between the splice and the splice or base immediately below."

Not a bad recommendation...The reference document is less than 25 pages (discounting all the filler) and most of them more than half are about fire protection and of the sections which are about structure most of them are about masonry construction.

Good work NIST is learning from the collapse of the WTC... FAIL
 
Last edited:
Wow, I am an engineer....

My parents and the USAF paid a lot to make me able to know you use BS instead of engineering.

Money not well spend... from what I read here. Powers of observation are hindered by some sort of unknown psychological deficit....

Which is why this thread is named:

Model Mayhem goes GIGO

I have nothing against math or engineering. I work with engineers because I am a dumb architect. I respect them and physicists and most are quite capable of critical thinking and also capable of making mistakes.... and they do. Perhaps you remember the lens which was ground by Perkin Elmer for the Hubble Space Telescope. A perfect example of the best engineering money can buy screwing up.

The Blue Line of Silence

Archi(tect) Bunker
 
Thanks for the link. I read the document produced as *NEW* in August 08 which I believe was after the final report on NCSTAR 1 which was published September 05 and the report on 7 came out in 2008.

The document you referred to does not discuss from my reading any of the factors which were in play in the WTC buildings....

Here is an example of the 2008 recommendations:

"1614.3.2.1 Columns.
Each column splice shall have the minimum des
ign strength in tension to transfer the design
dead and live load tributary to the column between the splice and the splice or base immediately below."

Not a bad recommendation...The reference document is less than 25 pages (discounting all the filler) and most of them more than half are about fire protection and of the sections which are about structure most of them are about masonry construction.

Good work NIST is learning from the collapse of the WTC... FAIL

Only the structural sections I noted were adopted in the IBC 2009 code, not the rest of the structurals. 1614.3.2.1 noted above was (Section 1614). Many of the other recommendations such as redundant standpies, SFRM strength, etc, etc. were. I don't have the IBC 2012.
The rest are being studied before modification and possible adoption.

The claim at hand was that NO structural NIST recommendations had been adopted by building codes --- FAIL

Fortunately, experienced structural engineers don't listen to architects' mathless opinions.
 
Last edited:
That's what I did. Asking question with regard to your "point" is the definition of responding to you. So again, what makes you think the building code needs changes to structural design?

Not being an engineer.... my opinions don't count... but... I would think that there would be / should be more on the use of load transfer structures and what would be permitted uses in close proximity to them... the type of connections, the minimum FOS.

I would think that designs should include redundant load paths for multistory structures to mitigate against *global* collapse.

I would like to see light weight long span floors prohibited in high rise structures

etc. etc. and so forth

archi(tect) Bunker
 
Originally Posted by beachnut

Wow, I am an engineer....

My parents and the USAF paid a lot to make me able to know you use BS instead of engineering


Money not well spend... from what I read here. Powers of observation are hindered by some sort of unknown psychological deficit....

Which is why this thread is named:

Model Mayhem goes GIGO

I have nothing against math or engineering. I work with engineers because I am a dumb architect. I respect them and physicists and most are quite capable of critical thinking and also capable of making mistakes.... and they do. Perhaps you remember the lens which was ground by Perkin Elmer for the Hubble Space Telescope. A perfect example of the best engineering money can buy screwing up.

The Blue Line of Silence

Archi(tect) Bunker
JSanderO confuses the engineering and the manufacture. The engineering was right, the manufacture not. Engineers then fixed the problem and corrected Hubble to specs, in space.
Wiki
Origin of the Problem
A commission headed by Lew Allen, director of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, was established to determine how the error could have arisen. The Allen Commission found that the main null corrector, a testing device used to achieve a properly shaped non-spherical mirror, had been incorrectly assembled—one lens was out of position by 1.3 mm.[56] During the initial grinding and polishing of the mirror, Perkin-Elmer analyzed its surface with two conventional null correctors. However, for the final manufacturing step (figuring), they switched to a custom-built null corrector, designed explicitly to meet very strict tolerances. Ironically, this device was assembled incorrectly, resulting in an extremely precise (but wrong) shape for the mirror. There was one final opportunity to catch the error, since a few of the final tests needed to use conventional null correctors for various technical reasons. These tests correctly indicated spherical aberration. However, the company ignored these results, as it believed they were less accurate than the primary device which reported that the mirror was perfectly figured.[57]
 
Last edited:
JSanderO confuses the engineering and the manufacture. The engineering was right, the manufacture not. Engineers then fixed the problem and corrected Hubble to specs, in space.

Oh rubbish... are you trying to blame this on mechanics?

Do you need other examples of flawed engineering.

Tacoma Narrows Bridge comes to mind...

and I found this for ya:

http://listverse.com/2007/12/04/top-10-worst-engineering-disasters/

and those are DISASTERS not mistakes.

to err is human.. to forgive divine..

Archi(tect) Bunker
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom