Model Mayhem goes GIGO

Oh rubbish... are you trying to blame this on mechanics?
Yes you didn't read right.

Do you need other examples of flawed engineering.

Takoma Narrows Bridge comes to mind...

Of course anyone can make mistakes. Lessons learned, math learned, models fixed, knowledge accrues.
What's your point.
 
Wrong lessons learned...

Please refer to the thread title and OP to see my point.

A/B

I have read the title and OP and the subsequent comments. It is JSanderO that has learned the wrong lessons. Please read and understand the subsequent comments.
 
I have read the title and OP and the subsequent comments. It is JSanderO that has learned the wrong lessons. Please read and understand the subsequent comments.

O Basque... how clever...

This is not about the lessons I have learned... but about the lessons NIST was supposed to teach and every other model maker.

Archi(tect) Bunker Fellow of the AISMKKSSK
 
Nothing wrong with some humor... beats the insults slung here..

If you can't respond or comment on the graphic I posted... troll your own... give it your best shot..

I'll give it a shot...

Here's something for you guys to beat up on...

You gotta problem with it... go for it..

Your diagram misses the perimeter bowing (and explanation) at about (5), as DGM pointed out.

(10) and (11) don't match what was observed. The core would have pulled the perimeter, and the whole perimeter walls above the impact floors would have been seen bending inwards in pretty much the same way as WTC7 did (and the way enik postulates was the reason for inward bowing of the perimeter prior to collapse.)


A/B
There.
 
OK I reviewed it... and found little which say anything other than the core failed and was the cause (his reasoning) of the IB and this does not contradict the cartoon I produced.

I have to support Tom's statement that both sides seem to be kind of making things up and seeing what they want to see when they look at the 3 towers coming down.

:i:

Inward bowing happened minutes before the collapse. You seem detached from the visual evidence.
 
There is well supported research[citation required] that shows that half of Americans are below average intelligence..
Half of Americans are certainly below median intelligence. Below average intelligence there could well be more than half.
 
BTW, why exactly is this in the 9/11CT subforum?

JSanderO believes 19 terrorists did 9/11. He gives a high degree of plausibility to LIHOP. But this thread doesn't discuss any LIHOP or MIHOP nor anything related.
 
While I agree that the insides were gone by the time we see the descent of the curtain wall...the curtain wall did continue down to the ground and was above the con ed on the north side where the collapse was... why would the curtain wall drop for 100 feet at about FF...

Just explain that if you will...

You can use math if you like.

Resistance of remaining perimeter columns = 0.2g
Pull of gravity = -g
Levarage force of collapsing interior on perimeter wall = -0.2g

-g + 0.2g - 0.2g = -g
 
BTW, why exactly is this in the 9/11CT subforum?

JSanderO believes 19 terrorists did 9/11. He gives a high degree of plausibility to LIHOP. But this thread doesn't discuss any LIHOP or MIHOP nor anything related.
Would you really want it anywhere else? ;)
 
BTW, why exactly is this in the 9/11CT subforum?

JSanderO believes 19 terrorists did 9/11. He gives a high degree of plausibility to LIHOP. But this thread doesn't discuss any LIHOP or MIHOP nor anything related.

LIHOP has nothing do with how the tower collapsed in my humble opinion.

*I* meaning hijacking of planes
 
While I agree that the insides were gone by the time we see the descent of the curtain wall...the curtain wall did continue down to the ground and was above the con ed on the north side where the collapse was... why would the curtain wall drop for 100 feet at about FF...

Just explain that if you will...

You can use math if you like.

whatever you say...
If you don't know where you are going, any path will do.
 
Here is a fairly good treatise on Unknown Unknowns. I'd provide a copy of my training from back in the day however it's at the office.

Unknown Unknowns in Probabalistic Cost and Schedule Risk Models
Ooops - missed that post yesterday.

Thanks.

Half of Americans are certainly below median intelligence. Below average intelligence there could well be more than half.
Certainly but being technically correct tends to give the joke away. Most people who are going to "get" the joke would smell the rat if the correct word "median" was used....those who won't "get the joke" wont know the distinctions mean/median/mode anyway.

And they probably wouldn't recognise the other statistical lies by implication...or the comprehend the analogy to the same structural errors of logic when they are deployed in arguments here.
 
You are. Which makes it so ironic how you're complaining about other people being detached from the visual evidence.

I could be right too...

I doubt you can prove that I am wrong or that your conception is correct. It would seem to depend on some unknown variables.
 
Nothing wrong with some humor... beats the insults slung here..

If you can't respond or comment on the graphic I posted... troll your own... give it your best shot..

Here's something for you guys to beat up on...

You gotta problem with it... go for it..

A/B

Had the core detatched below the hat truss and collapsed inside the building as you have in figure 8 there would have been visible multi storey buckling in the upper section of the building as the floors pulled in and the perimeter became unsupported. The perimeter buckling that you show is symmetrical rather than on one side of the building and you assume that the "antenna drop" is an actual sinking of the support structure into the roof rather than a perspective effect seen from the north as the building tilts to the south.
 
The great and mighty no-model has spoken. No math, no physics, no engineering, the old J Fetzer Say So method of woo.

Do you see why you were fooled into joining Gage? I do. You sure do save on typing, and you will not be doing an analysis with math and physics, so the "Wrong" is the only effort you have left.

The anti-model stand is in line with the 911 truth fantasy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom