Model Mayhem goes GIGO

JSanderO

Illuminator
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
3,232
Location
nyc
It occurred to me after witnessing and somewhat participating in 9/11 matters online for 6 years or so that what most interested so called *researchers* and I include NIST, FEMA, truth *scientists*, laypersons and so forth are doing is arguing or debating... what actually happened at the 9/11 *sites*.

It happened. It's not part of history. We can't relive it. But we can try to reconstruct it... kinda. We're talking with respect to the WTC, for example, of buildings standing one day and being turned into a pile of burning twisted rubble and dust the next. Much like the NTYSB does for an airline accident... the interested parties have taken upon themselves... or compelled to by Uncle Sam... to kinda do an NTSB type investigation and explain what happened. Fine. Concept is not hard to grasp.

And now the problem - methodology... or what I am calling Model Mayhem.

It is not possible to do as the auto industry does... full scale crash test to see how normal cars get messed up in collisions... with the towers and a few Boeings.

It's not possible to make a scale model and do that either.... with some model planes and leggos either (or the scientific equivalent).

It is possible to study SOME processes and or mechanisms that destroy "things" which either haven't been done yet (don't know)... or haven't been done with the bits of those buildings yet (don't know).

So what to do?

Most build and test mathematical models. Makes sense. Math is used to engineer everything... so why not use it to deconstruct anything?

And then there are these really cool things that computers can do... complex models... which can look like the real deal. See the attached model of a building that only exists in a computer and printed on a piece of paper. It looks like a photo of a real building But there are bolts or mortar or bricks... just pixels.

A lot of the work that has been done is based on pulling data from the visual record we have the events of 9/11. The model makers use this for the basis for the models. And so those with better video analysis and so forth can extract better data.

BUT

It's limited to what we can SEE. When we look at a person we can't see inside their skin... When we look at a building we can't see inside the exterior walls. But if we have the engineering plans, the architectural plans, the interior design plans, the specifications and all the details we COULD conceivably make a computer model of the building and perhaps have the model include all the materials' properties and behavior. I don't know that this level of modeling is possible. So we have the various FEA programs.

BUT

FEA is limited to and by the data inputs.

So in the end... what we have is a series of people building models based on the data they input into them... and this includes ALL the performance data of the materials, ALL the energy inputs... and of course all the laws of physics and engineering, chemistry and so forth at play when materials and energy mix it up.

Pick your inputs, select your modelling software.. press start and out comes your model.

So which researchers or investigators have the best models?

Which researchers of investigators have incomplete or incorrect inputs into their models?

Which researchers and investigators have been shown to have made significant errors with their models or data?

My conclusion is despite some excellent work... we really do have model mayhem and the models have not gone Gaga... but are more like GIGO

Now some will say it hardly matters because the gross analysis is simple and even self evident... details don't matter... But of course that should be EASY to demonstrate with a model... Wouldn't be?

This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event. And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.

Right?
 
So what to do?

Most build and test mathematical models. Makes sense. Math is used to engineer everything... so why not use it to deconstruct anything?

And then there are these really cool things that computers can do... complex models...


You do know these are the same thing? The computer just does the math. :confused:
 
911 truth is GIGO, Model Mayhem is residual 911 truth nonsense

...
This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event. And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.

Right?
Did you read the NIST report? No. You failed to comprehend the goal.

Some people can't grasp simple math, physics, fire science, and have an agenda based on political bias.

There was a full up model on 911, 4 real jets, 19 real terrorists/murderers, real buildings, real fire. If you can't figure out 911, you can't do science, physics, and math.

There is no model mayhem, we have real full scale WTC towers collapsing as they would due to impacts and fire. There was no need to model the towers except to verify they were built properly and what were probable causes of the collapse; they were built properly and they did collapse due to fire and impacts. 911 truth has no clue what the investigation were, and they were not needed to dumb down science so they can understand. They should have listened in first grade, cause and effect, but they squandered their education and picked to be in a fantasy world of thermite and the big inside job driven by dumbed down political biases. 11 years of failure.

Don't need cool computers to models of the WTC collapse, strictly engineers can use a napkin.


What caused the WTC towers to collapse? 8 terrorists and 2 planes with 66,000 pounds of jet fuel, the biggest office fires started in seconds in history - KE impacts equal to 1300 and 2000 pounds of TNT. Numbers that 911 truth ignore.

Model mayhem for the cult members of 911 truth, who can't comprehend goals and purpose, or realize the towers fell due to impacts and fires. They can't grasp Robertson realized the same. They have to invent experts and fall for lies, joining idiotic groups like Gage failed architects and nutty engineers. 911 truth is nonsense based on ignorance.

Model mayhem is residual 911 truth nonsense.
 
Last edited:
So a simple beam model of one perimeter column is GIGO?

It's a limited case and considering there were 100,000 members it's not a model of the building.

Is it useful? Yea... for understanding one beam or perhaps 1 column (which by the way was part of a composite if your are using the facade for an example) with one set of inputs.

One moment in time....
 
It occurred to me after witnessing and somewhat participating in 9/11 matters online for 6 years or so that what most interested so called *researchers* and I include NIST, FEMA, truth *scientists*, laypersons and so forth are doing is arguing or debating... what actually happened at the 9/11 *sites*.

It happened. It's not part of history. We can't relive it. But we can try to reconstruct it... kinda. We're talking with respect to the WTC, for example, of buildings standing one day and being turned into a pile of burning twisted rubble and dust the next. Much like the NTYSB does for an airline accident... the interested parties have taken upon themselves... or compelled to by Uncle Sam... to kinda do an NTSB type investigation and explain what happened. Fine. Concept is not hard to grasp.

And now the problem - methodology... or what I am calling Model Mayhem.

It is not possible to do as the auto industry does... full scale crash test to see how normal cars get messed up in collisions... with the towers and a few Boeings.

It's not possible to make a scale model and do that either.... with some model planes and leggos either (or the scientific equivalent).

It is possible to study SOME processes and or mechanisms that destroy "things" which either haven't been done yet (don't know)... or haven't been done with the bits of those buildings yet (don't know).

So what to do?

Most build and test mathematical models. Makes sense. Math is used to engineer everything... so why not use it to deconstruct anything?

And then there are these really cool things that computers can do... complex models... which can look like the real deal. See the attached model of a building that only exists in a computer and printed on a piece of paper. It looks like a photo of a real building But there are bolts or mortar or bricks... just pixels.

A lot of the work that has been done is based on pulling data from the visual record we have the events of 9/11. The model makers use this for the basis for the models. And so those with better video analysis and so forth can extract better data.

BUT

It's limited to what we can SEE. When we look at a person we can't see inside their skin... When we look at a building we can't see inside the exterior walls. But if we have the engineering plans, the architectural plans, the interior design plans, the specifications and all the details we COULD conceivably make a computer model of the building and perhaps have the model include all the materials' properties and behavior. I don't know that this level of modeling is possible. So we have the various FEA programs.

BUT

FEA is limited to and by the data inputs.

So in the end... what we have is a series of people building models based on the data they input into them... and this includes ALL the performance data of the materials, ALL the energy inputs... and of course all the laws of physics and engineering, chemistry and so forth at play when materials and energy mix it up.

Pick your inputs, select your modelling software.. press start and out comes your model.

So which researchers or investigators have the best models?

Which researchers of investigators have incomplete or incorrect inputs into their models?

Which researchers and investigators have been shown to have made significant errors with their models or data?

My conclusion is despite some excellent work... we really do have model mayhem and the models have not gone Gaga... but are more like GIGO

Now some will say it hardly matters because the gross analysis is simple and even self evident... details don't matter... But of course that should be EASY to demonstrate with a model... Wouldn't be?

This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event. And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.

Right?

The question I have here is why hasn't anyone from the conspiracy believers come forward with a model of their own?

They have a HUGE advantage in that they supposedly know it was thermite or explosives that caused the collapses. How hard is it to figure out where those charges would have been set and how much of each was used to create what we all see in videos and photos?

I mean thermite/explosives removes any assumed constraints such as temperature, how long the fires burned, where they burned, which columns were damaged/weakened, was fireproofing adequately applied, was fireproofing knocked off, stress and loads, etc.

Thermite/explosives bypass all that.

The conspiracy folks have the plans for WTC7. What's stopping all the architects and engineers on their side from coming up with a legitimate model explanation using explosives/thermite? 11 years and all the have is Gage making $80,000 and traveling the world, a few forums, and some others squawking about how they found thermite in some of the dust samples.

Every one of them is hellbent on proving certain things wrong with NIST's report, but won't touch an alternative analysis with calculations and models with a 10 foot pole.

The bottom line is, finding fault with NIST's report will NEVER prove thermite/space beams/explosives/missiles/etc.

If there is ONE analysis of how something other than fire and impact damage caused the collapses, please, by all means, show me a link. The ONLY folks I know who have come close to this are those that believe terrorists, planes, fire, and failed structural components brought those buildings down.
 
It's a limited case and considering there were 100,000 members it's not a model of the building.

Is it useful? Yea... for understanding one beam or perhaps 1 column (which by the way was part of a composite if your are using the facade for an example) with one set of inputs.

One moment in time....
A simple momentum model is not GIGO, the OP is BS.


There is no need to do a full up scale model, we know the KE at impact, we know the grades of steel used, etc, etc. Real data is in, and real data is out. No need to model what we saw. The model mayhem is in your mind. You don't understand the goal of models, and neither does 911 truth.
 
It's a limited case and considering there were 100,000 members it's not a model of the building.

Is it useful? Yea... for understanding one beam or perhaps 1 column (which by the way was part of a composite if your are using the facade for an example) with one set of inputs.

One moment in time....

You need to ask the individual people why such analysis is needed? Is it to figure out what happened to try and make sure it doesn't happen again or is it to prove a preconceived notion that the evil government was behind it?

IMO, people like Major Tom and femr2, like to claim neutrality between conspiracy and terrorist act, but in the recesses of their mind HOPE that it comes out the government was behind it so they can claim that they knew it years ago based on their work.
 
Aren't we lucky that you don't get to make decisions for anyone but yourself!

I understand the goals AND the limitations..

Reductio Ad Absurdum:

Big plane hit... made fires..building fell... Volia!

Inspector Closeau
 
You need to ask the individual people why such analysis is needed? Is it to figure out what happened to try and make sure it doesn't happen again or is it to prove a preconceived notion that the evil government was behind it?

IMO, people like Major Tom and femr2, like to claim neutrality between conspiracy and terrorist act, but in the recesses of their mind HOPE that it comes out the government was behind it so they can claim that they knew it years ago based on their work.

And how do you know what is in the recess of anyone's mind... Her Doktor Freud?

I could give a laundry list of design / engineering changes without doing a model... which would make those designs and ALL steel frames more resistant to catastrophic failure and I don't need no leggos.

Archi(tect) Bunker
 
If there is ONE analysis of how something other than fire and impact damage caused the collapses, please, by all means, show me a link. The ONLY folks I know who have come close to this are those that believe terrorists, planes, fire, and failed structural components brought those buildings down.

You have found the NIST FEA for 7 as a fair representation of what we saw? Or was it just a model of how 7 COULD collapse (true or not).

To my eye it hardly looks like the network movies... Even Pixar could do better.
 
You need to ask the individual people why such analysis is needed? Is it to figure out what happened to try and make sure it doesn't happen again or is it to prove a preconceived notion that the evil government was behind it?

I represent my own analysis firm and we compete with others like femr2 and UncleTom's Cabinetry... And we're a reputable firm and don't engage in corporate spying.

CEO and Chef.
 
And how do you know what is in the recess of anyone's mind... Her Doktor Freud?

I could give a laundry list of design / engineering changes without doing a model... which would make those designs and ALL steel frames more resistant to catastrophic failure and I don't need no leggos.

Archi(tect) Bunker
I could too. The problem would be no one could afford to actually build it. Do you think anyone would ever build a building like the Empire State today, or should?

You do know buildings are built so the owners can make money (with reasonable margins of safety)? That's what building codes are for. No building is guaranteed not to fail. WTC7 performed better than design.
 
Last edited:
Did you read the NIST report? No. You failed to comprehend the goal.

Model mayhem is residual 911 truth nonsense.

I did read most of them... I liked the pictures best... but they looked like cartoons to me... not the work of 6,000 PE's

Read my lips... no new investigations...
 
To my eye it hardly looks like the network movies... Even Pixar could do better.

There's your problem. You expect engineering models to look like something out of Hollywood. Nothing could be further from the truth.
 
You do know buildings are built so the owners can make money (with reasonable margins of safety)? That's what building codes are for.

Hate to break the news to you... but building and fire codes are there to protect the life and safety of the inhabitants.. the so called public...

But don't trust anything on wiki:

"A building code, or building control, is a set of rules that specify the minimum acceptable level of safety for constructed objects such as buildings and nonbuilding structures. The main purpose of building codes are to protect public health, safety and general welfare as they relate to the construction and occupancy of buildings and structures. The building code becomes law of a particular jurisdiction when formally enacted by the appropriate governmental or private authority."

end note: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Building_code

Archi(tect) Bunker
 
There's your problem. You expect engineering models to look like something out of Hollywood. Nothing could be further from the truth.

How do you know my expectation? I was only telling you whether the models I see convince me or resemble what I saw...

I don't think they could convince my grand daughter either and she can use a tablet!

eg: NIST FEA, Gage et al and their blocks,
 
Hate to break the news to you... but building and fire codes are there to protect the life and safety of the inhabitants.. the so called public...

And the NTSB only does the same. :rolleyes:

Do you agree that the WTC7 design performed better than code and protected it's inhabitants?
 
And the NTSB only does the same. :rolleyes:

Do you agree that the WTC7 design performed better than code and protected it's inhabitants?

No brownie points for Aviation safety regulations.

I've discussed your question with the product safety division here a Archi(tect) Bunker PC (that's professional corporation, not politically correct or personal computer though ABPC us both).... and the consensus was whose dumb idea was it to build that Rube Goldberg over a hot sub station as opposed to a slammin disco club when there was a waterfront property right across the street... River view fetch big bucks in the rental market.

One of our recommendations to property owners (our clients) is to evacuate your building if the one next to it is hit by a wide bodied jet...

Seems like Silverstein stole the idea from us. We are suing for IP infringement... as we speak.

AB
 
How do you know my expectation? I was only telling you whether the models I see convince me or resemble what I saw...

I know what your expectation is because you chose to compare them to Hollywood!

I don't think they could convince my grand daughter either and she can use a tablet!

eg: NIST FEA, Gage et al and their blocks,

Wait, what, you have problem with Finite Element Analysis? :confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom