NoahFence
Banned
$16,000,000, 8 years and they could have done it in 5 lines and you don't feel ripped off? What kind of conservative are you?
The cost of the study is irrelevant.
$16,000,000, 8 years and they could have done it in 5 lines and you don't feel ripped off? What kind of conservative are you?
Only if your simplification is invalid. Care to demonstrate where, exactly, NIST went wrong in their models that caused them to "miss the clue"? You can go ahead and feel free to get technical, I have decent experience in computer simulation and modeling. I hope you'll fare better in this discussion than Chris "MSPaintFire" Sarns did.
The cost of the study is irrelevant.
Patience is a virtue... what are you waiting for? The second coming?![]()
...this.Not when it produces an arguably incorrect forensic report... with errors that one of those 6000 engineers shoulda caught...
For you to get around to some evidence of things like...
...this.
It is nonsense. See below.OK Mr. T critique the attachment...
A. Is it possible?
B. if not, why not?
Be specific... be analytic... I welcome your criticism...
Now some will say it hardly matters because the gross analysis is simple and even self evident... details don't matter... But of course that should be EASY to demonstrate with a model... Wouldn't be?
This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event. And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.
Right?
You are not interested in these? Why not?
I don't need it to replicate verbadum what I saw on TV. It's not "realistic". But what it tells me about design flaws that contributed directly or indirectly to the collapse initiation, and whether occupants got out safely does.
And what WERE the design flaws that NIST told us and or that you understand them to be?
Try here:
http://bit.ly/16yfgaC

Right... we know the fire suppression and eggress was crappy... what about BUILDING CODE recommendations... structural design issues...
Yea, I'm thinking you're not actually an architect as you claim. You just pretend to be one on the internet.
The question I have here is why hasn't anyone from the conspiracy believers come forward with a model of their own? They have a HUGE advantage in that they supposedly know it was thermite or explosives that caused the collapses. How hard is it to figure out where those charges would have been set and how much of each was used to create what we all see in videos and photos?
I mean thermite/explosives removes any assumed constraints such as temperature, how long the fires burned, where they burned, which columns were damaged/weakened, was fireproofing adequately applied, was fireproofing knocked off, stress and loads, etc.
Thermite/explosives bypass all that.
The conspiracy folks have the plans for WTC7. What's stopping all the architects and engineers on their side from coming up with a legitimate model explanation using explosives/thermite? 11 years and all the have is Gage making $80,000 and traveling the world, a few forums, and some others squawking about how they found thermite in some of the dust samples.
Every one of them is hellbent on proving certain things wrong with NIST's report, but won't touch an alternative analysis with calculations and models with a 10 foot pole.
The bottom line is, finding fault with NIST's report will NEVER prove thermite/space beams/explosives/missiles/etc.
If there is ONE analysis of how something other than fire and impact damage caused the collapses, please, by all means, show me a link. The ONLY folks I know who have come close to this are those that believe terrorists, planes, fire, and failed structural components brought those buildings down.
Don't any of those top professionals at A&E 9/11 know anything about running engineering models? Why haven't they come up with a conspiracism-free model showing that the collapses, part 2, are impossible - and submitted it to an engineering journal?
You're asking me to separate code recommendations from the very issues they all ultimately tie into. "The egress was crappy" to the point where the efficient tube-on-tube design of the towers - efficient as they were on space usage - made everywhere above the impact regions a death trap because the planes took out the exit access in the core. The open space plans made the spread of fire easier because there was no compartmentalization of the interior. Had the building been designed differently could the collapse have been prevented or postponed for longer, maybe? Those are considerations that tragedies like this make us aware of.check in with NYS... my license if from 1982...
I asked:
What were the BUILDING CODE recommendations in the NIST report.. aside from the FIRE CODE and EGRESS issues.
The inward bowing was seen before the "antenna drop".OK Mr. T critique the attachment...
A. Is it possible?
B. if not, why not?
Be specific... be analytic... I welcome your criticism...
The inward bowing was seen before the "antenna drop".
You're asking me to separate code recommendations from the very issues they all ultimately tie into. "The egress was crappy" to the point where the efficient tube-on-tube design of the towers - efficient as they were on space usage - made everywhere above the impact regions a death trap because the planes took out the exit access in the core.