Model Mayhem goes GIGO

Only if your simplification is invalid. Care to demonstrate where, exactly, NIST went wrong in their models that caused them to "miss the clue"? You can go ahead and feel free to get technical, I have decent experience in computer simulation and modeling. I hope you'll fare better in this discussion than Chris "MSPaintFire" Sarns did.

You can't find the clues if you don't examine the whole place for them...

Can you show me where the investigators report the details of their examination of:

MG53
columns E3 and E4
column 36 floor 10
TT1's diagonals and the splices
8 - MG27s
TT2, TT3

Did they find and do analysis on the diesel plumbing to the gen sets?
What happened to the day tanks? Were the crushed or burned or intact?

You are not interested in these? Why not?
 
The cost of the study is irrelevant.

Not when it produces an arguably incorrect forensic report... with errors that one of those 6000 engineers shoulda caught...

I know you think it's the next best thing to sliced bread... and you're not alone... but I and a few others are not there with you.

Inquiring minds want to know...
 
OK Mr. T critique the attachment...

A. Is it possible?
B. if not, why not?

Be specific... be analytic... I welcome your criticism...
It is nonsense. See below.

Wrong, that would not do what we saw. You messed up. Where is the math?

How will you show NIST was wrong?

You agree no CD, no inside job, but you can't figure out 911?

Where is the list of models which match your GIGO theory?
 
Last edited:
Now some will say it hardly matters because the gross analysis is simple and even self evident... details don't matter... But of course that should be EASY to demonstrate with a model... Wouldn't be?

This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event. And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.

Right?

Oh the collapse itself already happened, so the mechanism of cause and effect is already known. Modeling will explain details by providing a realistic "scenario" or set thereof, which helps us ascertain whether it was:
A) Built to code
and B) How do we engineer the building better for greater occupant safety when something like this happens.

The priority of building codes is occupant safety, not stopping a full-on collapse once it's already begun. Build the building to stand long enough to allow for the escape of occupants. The towers mostly succeeded in that regard.

Since I know models rely on data input and what information is available I at least know that I'll never see a 100% exact model of everything. I don't need it to replicate verbadum what I saw on TV. It's not "realistic". But what it tells me about design flaws that contributed directly or indirectly to the collapse initiation, and whether occupants got out safely does.

Beyond that.... whether it satisfies controlled demolition theorists sufficiently isn't anyone's problem.

As to other errors, if it has an impact on code that you think is unwarranted I think that's perfectly fair. But I'm not expecting absolute 100% perfection in a model that tells me whether the building continues standing or not.
 
You are not interested in these? Why not?

Because for my area of expertise, they turned out to be irrelevant. A computer model of WTC7 was built. They used the computer to do some structural damage to it and to set it on fire multiple times, adjusting the parameters according to the best estimation of the observed damage and fires. They discovered that one of these simulations closely matched the actual collapse, and a working hypothesis of what actually happened was formed based on the steps that occurred during the simulation. At what point during this process do any of these variables factor in? Or do you not have a clue as to how computer modeling and simulation work? Are we going to see more MSPaintFire diagrams?
 
I don't need it to replicate verbadum what I saw on TV. It's not "realistic". But what it tells me about design flaws that contributed directly or indirectly to the collapse initiation, and whether occupants got out safely does.

And what WERE the design flaws that NIST told us and or that you understand them to be?
 
Right... we know the fire suppression and eggress was crappy... what about BUILDING CODE recommendations... structural design issues...

Are you sure you're an architect? The IBC 2006, you know, the BUILDING CODE, has 35 chapters, seven of which deals with structural design and analysis. Egress (how can you spell this word wrong and claim to be an architect?) and fire protection each have their own chapters. Thus, they're building code issues.

Yea, I'm thinking you're not actually an architect as you claim. You just pretend to be one on the internet.
 
Yea, I'm thinking you're not actually an architect as you claim. You just pretend to be one on the internet.

check in with NYS... my license if from 1982...

I asked:

What were the BUILDING CODE recommendations in the NIST report.. aside from the FIRE CODE and EGRESS issues.

Don't don't my clients that...

ps... loved the web site...

A/B
 
Last edited:
The question I have here is why hasn't anyone from the conspiracy believers come forward with a model of their own? They have a HUGE advantage in that they supposedly know it was thermite or explosives that caused the collapses. How hard is it to figure out where those charges would have been set and how much of each was used to create what we all see in videos and photos?

I mean thermite/explosives removes any assumed constraints such as temperature, how long the fires burned, where they burned, which columns were damaged/weakened, was fireproofing adequately applied, was fireproofing knocked off, stress and loads, etc.

Thermite/explosives bypass all that.

The conspiracy folks have the plans for WTC7. What's stopping all the architects and engineers on their side from coming up with a legitimate model explanation using explosives/thermite? 11 years and all the have is Gage making $80,000 and traveling the world, a few forums, and some others squawking about how they found thermite in some of the dust samples.

Every one of them is hellbent on proving certain things wrong with NIST's report, but won't touch an alternative analysis with calculations and models with a 10 foot pole.

The bottom line is, finding fault with NIST's report will NEVER prove thermite/space beams/explosives/missiles/etc.

If there is ONE analysis of how something other than fire and impact damage caused the collapses, please, by all means, show me a link. The ONLY folks I know who have come close to this are those that believe terrorists, planes, fire, and failed structural components brought those buildings down.

The explanation of the collapses of the Twin Towers can be separated into two distinct entities: (1) Failure of the remaining columns at the impact area, followed by the upper section of the building falling onto the lower section, causing (2) a "pancaking" destruction of the lower section.

There's no reason why truthers need to contradict both, though all of them do. Logically, one could assert that (1) was inevitable, but that The Conspiracy knew that (2) was impossible - the collapse could not proceed past the top floor of the lower section, or would have arrested at some lower point, and that the Conspiracy decided that complete destruction of the Towers was worth the risk of planting explosives/Thermite/explosive Thermite in the lower levels of the Towers. This is the only reason they would have to plant the putative "squibs" of the Truthers. (Truthers could also agree that total collapse was inevitable, once it had started, but (1) was impossible, so it had to be assisted by explosives/Thermite/explosive Thermite.)

If Truthers wish to be taken seriously in the scientific/engineering community, let them construct a model to show that (2) could not have happened, based on the design of the Twin Towers. No need to resort to conspiracism.

AFAIK, only Tony Szamboti has tried anything like this, but he argued more that the collapse below the impact area should have shown a "jolt" which he did not detect. He did not argue that the collapse was per se impossible.

Don't any of those top professionals at A&E 9/11 know anything about running engineering models? Why haven't they come up with a conspiracism-free model showing that the collapses, part 2, are impossible - and submitted it to an engineering journal?
 
Don't any of those top professionals at A&E 9/11 know anything about running engineering models? Why haven't they come up with a conspiracism-free model showing that the collapses, part 2, are impossible - and submitted it to an engineering journal?

Excellent point and the urging of which was among the things which got me tossed out of AE. How naive I was that this group was interesting in looking into the mechanism of collapse. They are completely uninterested in it to the point of denial that such things are even possible. A structure which stands for X number of years cannot collapse!

I don't think they are "top professionals"... but even that's not fair... not everyone can be at the top... but looks like they have a collection of low hanging fruit.

Funny..
 
check in with NYS... my license if from 1982...

I asked:

What were the BUILDING CODE recommendations in the NIST report.. aside from the FIRE CODE and EGRESS issues.
You're asking me to separate code recommendations from the very issues they all ultimately tie into. "The egress was crappy" to the point where the efficient tube-on-tube design of the towers - efficient as they were on space usage - made everywhere above the impact regions a death trap because the planes took out the exit access in the core. The open space plans made the spread of fire easier because there was no compartmentalization of the interior. Had the building been designed differently could the collapse have been prevented or postponed for longer, maybe? Those are considerations that tragedies like this make us aware of.

Like it or not whether it's egress or the building's structural design, these parts of the code are perfectly relevant, and will always be part of discussions like this, and I'm not understanding what your problem with that is :confused:

If you've read into the changes more than I have, and you have problems with some of the changes... or maybe if the structural design had it's own inherent weaknesses in this case... as I said earlier.... I think that's a fair argument, but as to whether or not those errors would have changed the ultimate conclusion of what lead to the towers collapsing.... not so much. CD theories don't cut it for me, but if you find something in the models NIST did which led to recommendations that were unneeded, sure, let's discuss, however I'm not concerned with nitpicking details which don't radically change my understanding of the collapse mechanisms...
 
Last edited:
You're asking me to separate code recommendations from the very issues they all ultimately tie into. "The egress was crappy" to the point where the efficient tube-on-tube design of the towers - efficient as they were on space usage - made everywhere above the impact regions a death trap because the planes took out the exit access in the core.

It seems to me... that there were all sorts of engineering decisions made in the two designs... 7 and the twins... which led to the total collapse and I distinguish those from the less than adequate fire safety, suppression, and emergency egress issues reveal. The list provided seems to completely ignore any recommendations about engineering design.. such as:

safety factor
alternate load paths
strength, design and type of steel frame connections
long span column free interiors supported on bar joints
use of load transfer structures
building over existing structures such as power stations
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom