Model Mayhem goes GIGO

I could be right too...

I doubt you can prove that I am wrong or that your conception is correct. It would seem to depend on some unknown variables.
Inward bowing prior to collapse??

Take a look at NCSTAR 1-5A.
 
I think IB was the buckling...
Of course. It would take a very narrow technical use of the word "buckling" to suggest otherwise. Your useage is legitimate and your meaning obvious in context.
...I could be wrong...
you aren't.
...and therefore PART of the collapse...
Of course. Suggestions that failure of perimeter columns associated with inward bowing are not part of collapse mechanism are - to put it mildly - somewhat ill informed. The less mild version is a bit strong fro the MA. :)

I could be right too...
That is one of the possibilities. In this case the correct one.

...I doubt you can prove that I am wrong or that your conception is correct. It would seem to depend on some unknown variables.
Actually it doesn't depend on any unknowns but....
 
Aren't we lucky that you don't get to make decisions for anyone but yourself!

I understand the goals AND the limitations..

Reductio Ad Absurdum:

Big plane hit... made fires..building fell... Volia!

Inspector Closeau

I see nothing factually incorrect about the bolded statement.

You?

Well, he misspelled "Voila!", but nothing factually wrong.

The truther mindset seems to be that the simple, obvious explanation can't possibly be right. I believe that if a truther dropped a bowling ball on their toe, their reaction would be, "A little bowling ball that weighs 12 pounds couldn't possibly make my toe hurt that bad. OMG! I must have cancer".
 
Kindly address the issues raised in the OP... and you can answer the questions posed. How could I be a troll... I never studied it in architecture at university...

If you can't respond to the OP... play the toll card...

And please don't put my name in the same sentence as Chris Sarns... That's a low blow...

The only issues in the OP are your personal ignorance and incredulity. The only way to address them would be for you to learn something, which you show every sign of being unwilling and/or unable to do.
 
The only issues in the OP are your personal ignorance and incredulity. The only way to address them would be for you to learn something, which you show every sign of being unwilling and/or unable to do.
You must have a different OP to me. I'm in Australia - does this forum have different "Export Versions".
scratch.gif


These are the key bits of personal opinion from the OP that I can read:
[explanatory text - mostly undeniable truisms leading to this]

BUT
But if we have the engineering plans, the architectural plans, the interior design plans, the specifications and all the details we COULD conceivably make a computer model of the building and perhaps have the model include all the materials' properties and behavior.
Conceivably yes. Practically No.
I don't know that this level of modeling is possible. So we have the various FEA programs.
BUT
FEA is limited to and by the data inputs.
So true. Just look at the several threads showing this very problem. The most recent and most detailed is probably the WTC 7 Column 79 "walkoff' thread.
[A lot more explanatory scene setting stuff then]Which researchers and investigators have been shown to have made significant errors with their models or data?
Do we want the short list only? No problem with "made errors" There is ongoing discussion as to which errors are "significant". Some members notably Major_Tom claiming NIST made errors in "Key Areas" - problem is he wont say what he means by a "key area" or tell us which ones are in error or prove his claim...so that lot doesn't qualify.
...My conclusion is despite some excellent work... we really do have model mayhem and the models have not gone Gaga... but are more like GIGO
Not an unreasonable conclusion.
Now some will say it hardly matters because the gross analysis is simple and even self evident... details don't matter...
True. A lot of people say just that. Want a list of member names?
But of course that should be EASY to demonstrate with a model... Wouldn't be?
Err...."no!" - but I think you are being sarcastic. :)
This so called debate can and will never end with a model of the real event.
And as such some will never be satisfied that the event was explained.
Ample proof in this sub-forum - look to all the trolling threads and the efforts put into counter trolling AKA "feeding the trolls". :(
 
Unfortunately the mindset that came about thanks to all of the trolling from other 9/11 truthers also causes the less crazy threads to get equal treatment to the most crazy. I don't see anything remarkable about the OP... it's better by a long shot than other so-called "truther" threads. About the only thing I've taken issue with is that yes, simulations could be done with sufficient data but what's the specific goal of doing so? And are there enough details that he argues about that justify reworking the conclusion?

And does the conclusion come into general agreement with the collapse being a result of the attacks, but differ from the conclusions on say changes to the building code?

When I brought up code related questions it seems to me at least he believes they were either absent or negligible... That tells me it's unfamiliarity with the reports' conclusions or the follow-up statements NIST made. Quite a different league of ignorance (read minor by comparison) from the ones that talk about Newtonian laws somehow being violated.

My answer to both questions is no, but if someone has a personal interest just for giggles to go that far, then that's their prerogative. But I'm pretty convinced CD proposals are nothing short of quack jobs unless something rational comes out to favor it. I'm not holding my breath
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately the mindset that came about thanks to all of the trolling from other 9/11 truthers also causes the less crazy threads to get equal treatment to the most crazy. I don't see anything remarkable about the OP... it's better by a long shot than other so-called "truther" threads. About the only thing I've taken issue with is that yes, simulations could be done with sufficient data but what's the specific goal of doing so? And are there enough details that he argues about that justify reworking the conclusion?

And does the conclusion come into general agreement with the collapse being a result of the attacks, but differ from the conclusions on say changes to the building code?

When I brought up code related questions it seems to me at least he believes they were either absent or negligible... That tells me it's unfamiliarity with the reports' conclusions or the follow-up statements NIST made. Quite a different league of ignorance (read minor by comparison) from the ones that talk about Newtonian laws somehow being violated.

My answer to both questions is no, but if someone has a personal interest just for giggles to go that far, then that's their prerogative. But I'm pretty convinced CD proposals are nothing short of quack jobs unless something rational comes out to favor it. I'm not holding my breath

Since I am not an engineer, some of the more technical aspects of the discussion of collapse mechanisms goes over my head. However, given that the collapses of the towers was preceded by impacts of large planes at high speed which initiated large fires, the hypothesis that the collapses were caused by those events has to be strongly favored. In order for me to take any hypothesis involving explosives, thermite, an army of saboteurs armed with cutting torches, mini-nukes or directed energy weapons seriously, I need to see credible evidence that one of these alternative mechanisms happened.

Certainly analyzing how the collapses happened is useful for improving construction of future buildings to reduce the likelihood of such disasters, and has the additional benefit of countering truther propaganda, but finding errors in such analyses doesn't really, in my mind, raise a significant doubt that the impacts and fires caused the collapses.
 
Last edited:
FYI You don't have to know what happened beyond your view of the alleged natural collapse.

All you have to do is build a computer model of the tower according to the known specifications and program actions of force/damage, within the parameters of what was known to be available, against that building/model to get it to collapse as it actually did.

When you cannot do that you will realize some sort of explosive action was required.
 
FYI You don't have to know what happened beyond your view of the alleged natural collapse.

All you have to do is build a computer model of the tower according to the known specifications and program actions of force/damage, within the parameters of what was known to be available, against that building/model to get it to collapse as it actually did.

When you cannot do that you will realize some sort of explosive action was required.

Where is your model? Having problems with the math, or the computer part? 12 years are coming, and you can't show your work?
 
Did they make a computer model of a tower collapse? I didn't think so.

Yes, they did. For the WTC 1 & 2, NIST developed a static model for the collapse. For WTC 7, they developed a more detailed dynamic model, because the internal collapse mechanism wasn’t clear from the video.

CM…sometimes, please take the time to do a quick and simple internet search, before you post something.
 
Yes, they did. For the WTC 1 & 2, NIST developed a static model for the collapse. For WTC 7, they developed a more detailed dynamic model, because the internal collapse mechanism wasn’t clear from the video.

CM…sometimes, please take the time to do a quick and simple internet search, before you post something.

I was hoping you'd realize I was talking about a valid model like the one I mentioned.


Originally Posted by Clayton Moore View Post
FYI You don't have to know what happened beyond your view of the alleged natural collapse.

All you have to do is build a computer model of the tower according to the known specifications and program actions of force/damage, within the parameters of what was known to be available, against that building/model to get it to collapse as it actually did.

When you cannot do that you will realize some sort of explosive action was required.

You know like one of those video games where objects and people react realistically to varying levels of force.




For WTC 7, they developed a more detailed dynamic model, because the internal collapse mechanism wasn’t clear from the video.


They didn't program a dynamic model of the towers because the dastardly dots wouldn't cooperate and connect to make each town "collapse" at slightly less than free fall.
 
That's you're job. Handle it, handle it.
You see dumb people? I think you fail to see past your silly fantasy of CD on the WTC. You can't comprehend the WTC collapse was due to impacts and fires, I doubt you can see dumb people when you can't see reality.

Where is your model? You don't have a model, it takes math. You can't comprehend the models you ignore due to ignorance.

You can't produce anything to refute any of the models you make fun of due to ignorance of math and physics. You can't show your work.

You can't source your posts, you make up unconnected woo to make fun of models you don't source or explicitly show where they are in error.

The full up model of the WTC towers collapsed due to impacts and fire; 911 truth has no clue why the models were done, and failed to read the papers to understand the scope, purpose and goals. You can't reference anything to support your silly junk.


It appears the only thing you can see is what you call dumb people; and it appears all those "dumb people" have figured out 911 leaving you in the woo of 911 truth. You can't handle the full up model of reality, and in no way can you refute any models you complain about.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom