Model Mayhem goes GIGO

RUBBISH you can't infer my expectations. Let's see your degree in mind reading

I have a problem with reductionism... when you simplify or model reality you can miss the clue. Hisenberg was onto something.
See how the NIST FEA looks like the NBD and CNN vids? Gran daughter saw no resemblance. Did you?

Archi(tect) Bunker

Hisenberg. That was the guy whose balloon exploded over New Jersey in the '30s no?
"Oh the huge manatee!"

The uncertainty principle applies to quantum mechanics, not fire buckling open web trusses or lateral torsional buckling of the girders in WTC7.
 
Last edited:
Right... we know the fire suppression and eggress was crappy... what about BUILDING CODE recommendations... structural design issues...

Name the recs of NIST

A/B

check in with NYS... my license if from 1982...

I asked:

What were the BUILDING CODE recommendations in the NIST report.. aside from the FIRE CODE and EGRESS issues.

Don't don't my clients that...

ps... loved the web site...

A/B

It seems to me... that there were all sorts of engineering decisions made in the two designs... 7 and the twins... which led to the total collapse and I distinguish those from the less than adequate fire safety, suppression, and emergency egress issues reveal. The list provided seems to completely ignore any recommendations about engineering design.. such as:

safety factor
alternate load paths
strength, design and type of steel frame connections
long span column free interiors supported on bar joints
use of load transfer structures
building over existing structures such as power stations

IBC 2009 has structural design changes as the result of NIST's recommendations JSanderO doesn't know about.
New Section 1614 Structural Integrity.
Also Section 403.2.4 Sprayed fire-resistant materials (SFRM) Commentary – “Recommendation 6 of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) investigation of the World Trade Center (WTC) Report calls for the improvement of the in-place performance of the SFRM.” The code goes on about minimum bond strength of the SFRM.
 
Last edited:
Are you sure you're an architect? The IBC 2006, you know, the BUILDING CODE, has 35 chapters, seven of which deals with structural design and analysis. Egress (how can you spell this word wrong and claim to be an architect?) and fire protection each have their own chapters. Thus, they're building code issues.

Yea, I'm thinking you're not actually an architect as you claim. You just pretend to be one on the internet.

Half of all architects are below average.
 
Hisenberg. That was the guy whose balloon exploded over New Jersey in the '30s no?
"Oh the huge manatee!"

The uncertainty principle applies to quantum mechanics, not fire buckling open web trusses or lateral torsional buckling of the girders in WTC7.

such as:

"The notion of the observer becoming a part of the observed system is fundamentally new in physics. In quantum physics, the observer is no longer external and neutral, but through the act of measurement he becomes himself a part of observed reality. This marks the end of the neutrality of the experimenter. It also has huge implications on the epistemology of science: certain facts are no longer objectifiable in quantum theory. If in an exact science, such as physics, the outcome of an experiment depends on the view of the observer, then what does this imply for other fields of human knowledge? It would seem that in any faculty of science, there are different interpretations of the same phenomena. More often than occasionally, these interpretations are in conflict with each other. Does this mean that ultimate truth is unknowable?"
 
IBC 2009 has structural design changes as the result of NIST's recommendations JSanderO doesn't know about.
New Section 1614 Structural Integrity.
Also Section 403.2.4 Sprayed fire-resistant materials (SFRM) Commentary – “Recommendation 6 of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) investigation of the World Trade Center (WTC) Report calls for the improvement of the in-place performance of the SFRM.” The code goes on about minimum bond strength of the SFRM.

Now ANSWER the question I posed:

What SPECIFIC recommendations ASIDE FROM fire protection issues did NIST make regarding STRUCTURAL DESIGN.

Codes are being revised all the time.. If you can show ANY CODE revisions was directly related to NIST recommendations please do so.

Archi(tect) Bunker
 
Half of all architects are below average.

What a stupid comment! Below average in re what criteria?

hahahahaha

Have the posters at JREF are below average...

I'm in the 1 percentile... How about you?

Archi(tect) Bunker PC, BA, BArch, ADPSR, CEO, COO, CFO.
 
You gave the order in your cartoon wrong. Figure 6-7.

You asked for criticism. This puts the order you base your theory wrong. The core did not start to drop before the inward bowing.

What do you have to say to this?

I say I am aware of this... can you provide some sort of video which shows this?

Thanks!

And then I will address the timing issue.
 
See Major_Toms' site. I thought you said you read it?

I used to have the entire site committed to memory... but old age has set in and I can't recall see the time line... so since you remember... why don't you help me out... with a link of a quote???

OK I reviewed it... and found little which say anything other than the core failed and was the cause (his reasoning) of the IB and this does not contradict the cartoon I produced.

Back to you... give it another shot.

A/B
 
Last edited:
I used to have the entire site committed to memory... but old age has set in and I can't recall see the time line... so since you remember... why don't you help me out... with a link of a quote???

OK I reviewed it... and found little which say anything other than the core failed and was the cause (his reasoning) of the IB and this does not contradict the cartoon I produced.

Back to you... give it another shot.

A/B
Sorry, I don't play that game. Do your own research.
 
Isn't there a smaller WTC type building in Arizona? Why don't we just crash a plane into that and see what happens? I don't think the owners would mind as it's just for twoof and all.
 
Hisenberg. That was the guy whose balloon exploded over New Jersey in the '30s no?
"Oh the huge manatee!"

The uncertainty principle applies to quantum mechanics, not fire buckling open web trusses or lateral torsional buckling of the girders in WTC7.

such as:

"The notion of the observer becoming a part of the observed system is fundamentally new in physics. In quantum physics, the observer is no longer external and neutral, but through the act of measurement he becomes himself a part of observed reality. This marks the end of the neutrality of the experimenter. It also has huge implications on the epistemology of science: certain facts are no longer objectifiable in quantum theory. If in an exact science, such as physics, the outcome of an experiment depends on the view of the observer, then what does this imply for other fields of human knowledge? It would seem that in any faculty of science, there are different interpretations of the same phenomena. More often than occasionally, these interpretations are in conflict with each other. Does this mean that ultimate truth is unknowable?"
No, that's not what it means.

It does seem likely that ultimate truth is unknowable. In fact, it's easy to prove that complete formalizations of mathematical truth are not even possible.

I believe BasqueArch was lampooning those who flee from the subject at hand by retreating into profoundly arcane subjects they don't understand while quoting pretending to quote famous people whose names they can't spell.

That's just my guess. The truth is unknowable.


[size=-1](ETA: JSanderO was quoting a web page that appears to have been written by Thomas Knierim. JSanderO probably wanted us to think he was quoting Heisenberg, and I apologize for assisting that deception.)[/size]​
 
Last edited:
[size=-1](ETA: JSanderO was quoting a web page that appears to have been written by Thomas Knierim. JSanderO probably wanted us to think he was quoting Heisenberg, and I apologize for assisting that deception.)[/size]​

No JSandero was not trying to fool anyone ... You be paranoid...

He is demonstrating how you think you know stuff that not only can't you know it but you don't even know that you are blowing smoke..

Here's one for ya:

"There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know we don't know."

Guess Who.

extra points given for know when it was said.

Archi
 
No JSandero was not trying to fool anyone ... You be paranoid...

He is demonstrating how you think you know stuff that not only can't you know it but you don't even know that you are blowing smoke..

Here's one for ya:

"There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know we don't know."

Guess Who.

extra points given for know when it was said.

Archi
double extra points if you know the terms that ex-SecDef used were taught and were well known principles in Risk Management long before he said them
 
Last edited:
...
Guess Who.

extra points given for know when it was said.

Archi

double extra points if you know the terms that ex-SecDef used were taught and were well known principles in Risk Management long before he said them
Surely its even more basic than that?

Logic 101 - avoid false dichotomies. There is probably a fancy Latin name for the structure of this one. i.e. leaving out the category of "those we don't know about". Isn't it this simple:

Set A - things we know about - the "knowns" - comprising two sub-sets:
Subset A1 - "knowns" i.e. already have the status of "known";
Subset A2 - "unknowns" i.e. have status of "unknown" more specifically we know they exist but not what they are.

Set B - things we don't know about. Strictly the same two subsets exist but the word play goes a bit circular on the first one:
Subset B1 the "unknown knowns"....how can you not know that it is known...
scratch.gif


So forget that one - I'll settle for :
Subset B2 - "unknown" -the subset of factors which are unknown BUT we don't even know they exist.

But it is a "play on words" situation - using the word "[un]known" with two meanings. Is there a Latin name for those?


Plus, I suppose, we don't have to limit our comprehension to US specific examples.... :)


:runaway
 
Half of all architects are below average.
What a stupid comment! Below average in re what criteria?

Not really.

There is well supported research that shows that half of Americans are below average intelligence..


...and half of Australians are above average intelligence.

Plus all people who drink fluoridated tap water die after drinking it.

And white sheep eat more than black sheep.

Whilst four out of five dentists recommend Colgate Toothpaste. (Might be outdated)

Holden cars are involved in more accidents on Aussie roads than any other make (that one also is probably now outdated - but it is the same structure as the White v Black sheep)


(For a lot more see "How to Lie with Statistics" Darrell Huff - was a recommended text when I did the Engineering Degree. circa 1958>> A very simple tome - light hearted humour - probably why it was chosen for would be engineers)
 
Last edited:
Not really.

There is well supported research that shows that half of Americans are below average intelligence..


...and half of Australians are above average intelligence.

Plus all people who drink fluoridated tap water die after drinking it.

And white sheep eat more than black sheep.

Whilst four out of five dentists recommend Colgate Toothpaste. (Might be outdated)

Holden cars are involved in more accidents on Aussie roads than any other make (that one also is probably now outdated - but it is the same structure as the White v Black sheep)


(For a lot more see "How to Lie with Statistics" Darrell Huff - was a recommended text when I did the Engineering Degree. circa 1958>> A very simple tome - light hearted humour - probably why it was chosen for would be engineers)
He won't get it. ;)

Did you stay at a Holiday Inn? (maybe too US for you). :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom