Meteor over Moscow

They're not radioactive. And almost all of them strongly attract a magnet, but the meteorites themselves are not magnetized.

Thanks, so if the article and translation is correct, then what could cause these fragments to be radioactive? or even magnetised?
 
Could be, maybe there is a slight issue with the translation of the above article?

Just seems strange why they would say "unusually high traces of radiation"

again, maybe a translation issue.

Because they are blowhards.
 
The presence of radiation is being misrepresented. There may have been thermal radiation but there would have been no nuclear radiation at all; not a microrad. There would need to be nuclear materials present for any nuclear radiation to have been present.

The energy of the blast looks like it was around 500 kilotons, but unlike a nuke, the energy was released over several seconds (on the video, you could hear smaller later blasts after the big one) and spread out over a large volume of air, so the pressure wave would have been a lot less than for a 500 kiloton nuclear blast at the same altitude.

Actually, what has been recorded here could well answer a few questions about the Berwyn Mountain incident in 1974 (a.k.a. the "Welsh Roswell")

1. a bright trail across the sky seen from Ireland in the west to Cornwall in the south and to the Midlands in the east

2. a loud explosion that rattled windows and shook houses

3. an extended shaking described by people in the Welsh town of Llandrillo as bring "like an earthquake".
 
Rumor and myth, something that abounds after events like these.

Events like these, when was the last one?


Here's a couple more links
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2280416/Russian-Meteor-PICTURED-First-fragments-meteorite-tests-DID-come-space.html
Stones have magnetic field and emit unusually high traces of radiation


http://rt.com/news/meteorite-lake-chebarkul-urals-432/
Several vendors claim to be employees at the Chelyabinsk zinc factory, which was rumored to have been devastated by one of the large meteor fragments. One of the sellers who claims he got his 263-gram piece from the factory rubble even described it as smelling of sulphur and having magnetic behavior.
 
The presence of radiation is being misrepresented. There may have been thermal radiation but there would have been no nuclear radiation at all; not a microrad. There would need to be nuclear materials present for any nuclear radiation to have been present.

The energy of the blast looks like it was around 500 kilotons, but unlike a nuke, the energy was released over several seconds (on the video, you could hear smaller later blasts after the big one) and spread out over a large volume of air, so the pressure wave would have been a lot less than for a 500 kiloton nuclear blast at the same altitude.

Actually, what has been recorded here could well answer a few questions about the Berwyn Mountain incident in 1974 (a.k.a. the "Welsh Roswell")

1. a bright trail across the sky seen from Ireland in the west to Cornwall in the south and to the Midlands in the east

2. a loud explosion that rattled windows and shook houses

3. an extended shaking described by people in the Welsh town of Llandrillo as bring "like an earthquake".

Thanks. Thermal radiation? the pieces they've supposedly examined are at most 1cm long.
 
The latter could have been a translation error - if nickel-iron it would react to a magnet.
It would not itself be magnetic tho shock can slightly magnetize nickel iron

Explosive shock or meteorite impact are significant remagnetization processes. The mechanisms of remagnetization associated with the dynamic processes depend on the peak shock pressure, the nature of the shocked materials, and the behavior of the shock in the material. Magnetic measurements can be used to classify products formed during a shock process, and magnetic measurements can be used to investigate the process itself because of the special characteristics of the remanent magnetization vectors. The magnetic coercive force increases more rapidly in quenched and annealed iron-nickel alloys as nickel is added than it does in the alloys which have been shocked.
http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/search.js...94966753%7CNASA-Center%7CAmes+Research+Center
 
Yes, in #262 you told us that a hole in the ice was "polynya". In Ukrainian, according to Google Translate, wormwood is "полин", polyn. So it is easy to see how the translation error came about.

Thanks. Now it makes sense. I had no idea about the Ukrainian word.
 
NASA's update on the Russian meteor from the Space.Com link.

The reference to "infrasound stations" in Alaska was new to me. No word of seismic readings yet though. I read also that the burst at 15 to 20 miles altitude essentially lessened the impact of the explosion, as the atmosphere absorbed most of the energy. If I remember correctly, the ideal air burst altitude, for nuclear devices, is around 10,000 feet for most efficient devastation of ground structures. Also, there were several reports of intense warmth from the infrared component of the explosion, nothing near what Hiroshima victims experienced even though this burst was equivalent to 500 kilotons of TNT, much greater than the early atom bombs. It is likely that the nuclear events create much higher temperatures, I would think.

The effective blast height is directly related to the yield. In Hiroshima for example the ideal detonation height was ~2,000 feet. Below that and you would be expending energy digging a deep hole, higher than that and you would be releasing energy into the atmosphere instead of onto the surface. The blast radius is a square root of yield. So to double the most effective height you need to quadruple the yield. My back of the napkin estimate make the best height (best meaning causing the most damage) for a 500kt explosion is roughly 6,000 feet (or one mile to keep it simple). This eplosion was estimated to be as low as 30 miles (last number that I have seen). That's well above the effective height the Tsar Bomba range of weapons (the most powerful nuclear explosion ever attempted).

It is an interesting ad-hoc experiment that will probably be used for studying the effects of nuclear weapons related blast waves to civilian structures beyond the intended destruction zone and it probably will be used to refine expected damage estimates in those cases.

ETA: Whoops, 30 kilometers, not miles. Still more than a little bit above the ideal (100mt) Tsar Bomba blast height.
 
Last edited:
There is often confusion between an object that is a "magnet" (has magnetic poles and a magnetic field) and an object that is "magnetic" (can be attracted to a magnet).

A meteroite can be magnetic, but I know of no case where a meteorite has been a magnet, i.e., had a magnetic field of its own
 
If you read the link there is a direct reference to meteor shockwave producing mild magnetism in a nickel iron body. But it's really irrelevant other than as a guide to level of shock the body has undergone.

Explosive shock or meteorite impact are significant remagnetization processes.
I don't think he pulled that out of thin air.....so to speak ;)
 
If you read the link there is a direct reference to meteor shockwave producing mild magnetism in a nickel iron body. But it's really irrelevant other than as a guide to level of shock the body has undergone.


I don't think he pulled that out of thin air.....so to speak ;)
You forgot the link or didn't code it right.

But, because you used the term, "re-magnetized" I know what mistake you are making. The iron and other metals which attract a magnet in igneous rocks are aligned with the N-S poles depending on when the lava was first extruded. A large meteorite impact melts the rocks allowing the metals to be realigned with the current N-S poles.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geomagnetic_reversal

http://www.tulane.edu/~sanelson/geol204/impacts.htm
Some of the ejecta will be hot enough to vaporize, and the heat generated by the impact could be high enough to actually melt the rock at the site of the impact.
 
Last edited:
MAGNETIC FIELDS IN SMALL BODIES: METEORITES, COMETARY NUCLEI, ASTEROIDS, MOONS, PLANETS
Ferromagnetic substances may acquire or lose magnetization under some circumstances. Thus ferromagnetic material which cools from a high temperature to a lower one while held in a magnetic field is very efficiently magnetized (called thermo-remanent magnetization). Also, the growth of mineral grains in the presence of a magnetic field produces chemical-remanent magnetization. And the accretion of magnetic particles in the presence of a magnetic field produces depositional-remanent magnetization. The total magnetization of a natural object is often a superposition of magnetization components acquired through several processes over its lifetime. And these different components can be later disentangled, giving some details about the conditions prevailing under each acquired magnetization. Virtually all meteorites carry natural remanent magnetization...

...The evidence seems to show that chondrules (~ 1 mm in size) inside meteorites (~ 10 cm to 1 m in size) were probably magnetized by the interplanetary magnetic field. A predicted theoretical magnetic field in the early solar nebula (~ 30 µT = 0.3 Gauss), which was inherited from an earlier interstellar cloudlet, is about the correct value needed to magnetize the carbonaceous chondrites. In addition to chondrules, small interstellar grains (~ 1 µm in size) have been discovered in meteorites (notably silicon carbide SiC grains, graphite grains, and corundum Al2O3 grains), The distribution of their sizes follows a log-normal equation (e.g., Sandford 1996).
A chondrite meteorite is not going to have enough chondrules aligned in the same direction to attract metals to the meteorite.
 
Olivines are paramagneitc minerals, if submitted to a magnetic field strong enough, they may "build" a magnetic field which will disappear after the original field is removed.

Native iron is a ferromagnetic mineral; it will react to the presence of a magnetic field (a magnet will "stick") and it may retain an induced magnetic field after the original field imposed to the mineral is removed.

Magnetite and troilite are ferrimagnetic minerals, they have a permanent magnetic field. Yes, magnets will "stick" to them and these minerals may orient themselves according to Earth's magnetic field if they have a chance.

All minerals above are common in meteorites, so, magnetic meteors are not exactly unexpected. Sure, not in the levels shown at B-movies.
 
Google translates this as "wormwood" consistently, and the name Chernobyl (Чернобыльская) does not yield any translations. I am curious where you might have gotten this impression that it means "wormwood". Maybe Louigi Verona, the Russian who posted above, can figure this out.
The Chernobyl = Wormwood translation has been used by a number of woosters to link the accident site to that hallucinogenic herb.
In fact Chernobyl means "mugwort", a close relative of wormwood but not one in favour with French intellectuals. :)

The first one. Meteorites are never radioactive, and rarely magnetic.
Indeed, my alma mater found some interesting magnetic traces in the Canyon Diablo meteorite a decade ago.
Generally meteorites aren't radioactive, though they can contain radioactive material, just like pretty much any terrestrial rock.

There is often confusion between an object that is a "magnet" (has magnetic poles and a magnetic field) and an object that is "magnetic" (can be attracted to a magnet).

A meteroite can be magnetic, but I know of no case where a meteorite has been a magnet, i.e., had a magnetic field of its own
Ferro-magnetism does occur in meteorites though it's uncommon.
 
Olivines are paramagneitc minerals, if submitted to a magnetic field strong enough, they may "build" a magnetic field which will disappear after the original field is removed.

Native iron is a ferromagnetic mineral; it will react to the presence of a magnetic field (a magnet will "stick") and it may retain an induced magnetic field after the original field imposed to the mineral is removed.

Magnetite and troilite are ferrimagnetic minerals, they have a permanent magnetic field. Yes, magnets will "stick" to them and these minerals may orient themselves according to Earth's magnetic field if they have a chance.

All minerals above are common in meteorites, so, magnetic meteors are not exactly unexpected. Sure, not in the levels shown at B-movies.

Another reason to love Olivines!
Not only are they beautiful, but they come from outer space!
 
.....

Ferro-magnetism does occur in meteorites though it's uncommon.


ferromagnetism

Web definitions
phenomenon exhibited by materials like iron (nickel or cobalt) that become magnetized in a magnetic field and retain their magnetism...
I saw a video of a group successfully looking for meteorite pieces in the desert a while back, and they all had a magnet on a stick to check likely rocks as they hiked across the desert.

ETA: I remember wondering at the time what percentage of meteorite fragments they were missing because of not being magnetic material.
 
Last edited:
Have they decided how big it was yet? The wikipedia page reports some widely divergent estimates:
Estimates of the size of the object ranged from a diameter of 17 m (56 ft) to a few metres. In earlier reports, Russian scientists estimated the meteor weighed about 10 tons before it entered the Earth's atmosphere, and broke apart 30–50 km (20–30 miles) above ground. The United States space agency NASA estimated the diameter of the bolide at about 17 m and its mass at about 10,000 tons

10 to 10,000 tons seems a wide margin of error.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom