Meteor over Moscow

Wouldn't boron also cause a green flame?

(Green is not a good colour for me)
 
Ch 8 v 11 The place name "Chernobyl" means wormwood, and the apocalypticists made much of this, when the nuclear disaster occurred.

Полынья [Pronounced: Polynya] is the word used in the Russian article.

"Полынья, которая была обнаружена на озере Чебаркуль и первоначально принята за место падения обломков метеорита, образовалась по иной причине", - отметил замгубернатора.
Google translates this as "wormwood" consistently, and the name Chernobyl (Чернобыльская) does not yield any translations. I am curious where you might have gotten this impression that it means "wormwood". Maybe Louigi Verona, the Russian who posted above, can figure this out.

Well, it turns out that the Google translation of the article is clearly in error. Forget the "wormwood"! I know zero Russian, BTW. By googling [Полынья] I got the following translation:

Polynya
A polynya or polynia is an area of open water surrounded by sea ice. It is now used as geographical term for an area of unfrozen sea within the ice pack.
In other words, a "hole in the ice".:D Mystery solved.

ETA: So, the proper translation of the Russian text above should read something like:

The hole in the ice, which was discovered in Lake Chebarkul, and initially thought to be caused by space debris from a falling meteorite formed otherwise "- said the deputy governor.
 
Last edited:
rare not

"Bounced off the Moon"?:boggled:

It's not a piece of the small asteroid that came close.

Scientists monitor space objects very closely. Lots of these loose rocks have been recorded hitting Earth with trajectories mapped. Fireballs are very common. And even small impacts are common. This one happened to hit a densely populated area.

It's not that mysterious or as rare as you think.
Oh...I have seen fiery meteors before , some in the daylight. Huge ones! I would say one thing tho...don't believe you can read my mind.
 
I am running a skeptic society in Russia, similar to JREF, only much smaller, at least today.

Today we made a post, which basically looks into how known pseudo-scientists in Russia and various psychics and "esoteric philosophers" are interpreting this to their advantage. I think a meteor in the beginning of the year is a gift to many psychics. Now this can be interpreted as a "sign from god".
That's great. Good for you.
 
https://rt.com/news/meteorite-lake-chebarkul-urals-432/
The site of a meteorite hit in the Chelyabinsk Region. Small 0.5-1 cm pieces of black matter resembling rock were found around the ice hole caused by the meteorite. (Image courtesy of the press service of the Ural Federal University, photo by Alexandra Khlopotova)




https://rt.com/news/russia-meteor-meteorite-asteroid-chelyabinsk-291/
The search for the meteorite parts at Chebarkul Lake and at other two locations has officially been stopped. The huge ice hole found at the lake on Friday “has formed because of a different reason,” the Vice-Governor of Chelyabinsk region Igor Murog told Interfax-Ural.





So which is it?
 
Last edited:
SG - I'm not "confusing" anything and I dare say from your comet comment I know a fair bit more about this topic than you seem to.

and I've seen several.

argue with them

http://education.nationalgeographic.com.au/education/media/shooting-star-spec/?ar_a=1

SG - a comet is ice ( not just water ice but mostly ) and bears almost no relation to a meteor other than as a body entering the atmosphere
Apparently you are confusing something. There are several origins for meteors and meteorites, we both know that. So there needs to be some clarification here.

And I'm not in some contest with anyone about who knows more. Meteorites and meteor showers are my hobby, not my profession.

The Leonids, like all meteor showers, are of cometary origin. I'm well aware of what a comet is made of. I referred to the Leonids' fireballs because I watched them for many hours from the AZ desert back in 1998 during one year of the 'storm'. There were many many green trails that lingered in the sky after the fireballs.
Valentin Grigore of the Romanian Society for Meteors and Astronomy is an experienced meteor observer who monitored the Leonid shower from Targoviste, Romania on the night of 16/17 November. In a 6-hour observing period under dark skies he saw 796 meteors, of which 193 were fireballs. When the shower peaked in Romania, with 200+ meteors per hour, nearly 40% of the shooting stars were brighter than magnitude -3. Many were brighter than Jupiter, Venus, and the full moon.

I looked up the material that made up comets and found that link to the comet dust mission that collected dust from a comet. Some local astronomers from the U of WA were involved in that mission, but that's beside the point.

The point is, there should have been no copper in those Leonid's fireballs, but there definitely were green vapor trails, lots of them.


Iron nickel IS the most common meteor material. I suspect that it takes a big meteor to set up the conditions for nickel to vaporize and be seen as green where copper has a lower melting point so would vaporize first.

It's possible that the smaller nickel particles flare green just at the end as I've seen that in a tumble right at the end of an incoming

When we refined nickel at Inco via electrolytical process copper was a major byproduct or the ore along with cobalt and an amazing treasure trove of elements above platinum.
These meteors are ore bearing bodies which is what that asteroid mining company wants to exploit.
Terrestrial nickel ore is not the same origin as meteoritic nickel-iron. There is very little copper in chondrites and virtually none in nickel-irons. I posted links with this information.


From your link:
The colors of this shooting star may also indicate the minerals that make up the space rock. Different elements emit different-colored light when they burn. Iron, one of the most common elements found in meteors, glows yellow. Silicates, which contain a form of the element silicon, glow red. A green glow, clearly visible in the trail of this shooting star, indicates the presence of burning copper.
I'm not questioning that, I'm trying to reconcile it with the fact one sees green vapor trails more often than the amount of copper in meteorites.
 
Oh...I have seen fiery meteors before , some in the daylight. Huge ones! I would say one thing tho...don't believe you can read my mind.
I was only reading your post. If I read something differently than you intended, by all means correct it.
 
I think early on they hadn't found anything, now they have, but we'll really need to wait until the dust settles before we start seeing the scientific analyses of the meteorite. I'm certain with an object that size, in an area that populated, pieces will be recovered. I'd be out there scouring that lake surface if I were there and the police didn't stop me. :)

Strewn Field
smaller fragments tend to fall shorter
So the place to look is between the ice hole and the town where the airburst occurred.
 
Last edited:
I am curious where you might have gotten this impression that it means "wormwood". Maybe Louigi Verona, the Russian who posted above, can figure this out.
I didn't say it was a Russian word. According to wiki
The city name is the same as a local Ukrainian name for Artemisia vulgaris (mugwort or common wormwood), which is also чорнобиль "chornobyl".
In fact, Chernobyl is not in Russia, but is
... situated in northern Kiev Oblast, Ukraine, near the border with Belarus.
 
I didn't say it was a Russian word. According to wiki In fact, Chernobyl is not in Russia, but is
The word for wormwood is the same in Russian and Ukranian (spelled slightly differently). What is has to do with Chelyabinsk is beyond me.
 
The word for wormwood is the same in Russian and Ukranian (spelled slightly differently). What is has to do with Chelyabinsk is beyond me.
Then it is in a local dialect, or reflects local herbalist terminology, but it seems to mean wormwood locally one way or another. For what the apocalypticists made of this, see eg the "Endtime Ministries" site at http://www.endtime.com/archived-magazine-articles/chernobyl-shuts-down/
Most striking is the testimony of Hans Blix, Executive Director of the International Atomic Energy Agency, in a speech given before the UN General Assembly on October 23, 1990. To this great body he quoted Revelation 8:10-11 and said, “In Slavic languages, including the Ukrainian and Byelorussian languages, there is a word ‘chernobyl’, which means wormwood, bitter grass. This has a striking relevance to the Chernobyl tragedy. I am no fatalist. I do not believe in the blind inevitability of fate, but who can fail to be moved by these tragic and elegiac words from Revelation, which must leave their indelible imprint on the heart.”
I agree that the connection with Chelyabinsk is a mystery. The wormwood reference arose from a passage in Revelation referring to a star falling from the sky. This resembles a meteoroid impact, I suppose.
 
The word for wormwood is the same in Russian and Ukranian (spelled slightly differently). What is has to do with Chelyabinsk is beyond me.

It seems that this was a result of a mistake in the google translation of a web page. The correct translation should have been "hole in the ice", but for some reason was translated as "wormwood". I posted on this just recently.;) See post #262.
 
Last edited:
It seems that this was a result of a mistake in the google translation of a web page. The correct translation should have been "hole in the ice", but for some reason was translated as "wormwood". I posted on this just recently.;) See post #262.
Yes, in #262 you told us that a hole in the ice was "polynya". In Ukrainian, according to Google Translate, wormwood is "полин", polyn. So it is easy to see how the translation error came about.
 
Ah, I see!

Nice deduction for someone who know zero Russian! You are entirely correct.
 
http://www.ilsecoloxix.it/p/mondo/2013/02/18/AP8xhamE-caccia_nuova_meteoriti.shtml
In the frozen lake of Cerbakul, experts have found a hole in the ice presumably due to a fragment of the meteorite. And after three days of careful research have been able to recover fragments of stone which have a strong magnetic field and emit unusually high traces of radiation. Clear signs, according to scholars, that these fragments come just from space.


I didn't think that meteorites were usually radioactive or magnetic?
 
I think you just found the qualifications of these "scholars"


What do you mean?

That this statement is wrong
Clear signs, according to scholars, that these fragments come just from space.

or this statement is wrong
And after three days of careful research have been able to recover fragments of stone which have a strong magnetic field and emit unusually high traces of radiation.
 
http://www.ilsecoloxix.it/p/mondo/2013/02/18/AP8xhamE-caccia_nuova_meteoriti.shtml
In the frozen lake of Cerbakul, experts have found a hole in the ice presumably due to a fragment of the meteorite. And after three days of careful research have been able to recover fragments of stone which have a strong magnetic field and emit unusually high traces of radiation. Clear signs, according to scholars, that these fragments come just from space.


I didn't think that meteorites were usually radioactive or magnetic?

I think you just found the qualifications of these "scholars"

Hasn't the area been previously used for radioactive waste? If so I think there might be a more terrestrial reason for any radiation...
 
Hasn't the area been previously used for radioactive waste? If so I think there might be a more terrestrial reason for any radiation...

Could be, maybe there is a slight issue with the translation of the above article?

Just seems strange why they would say "unusually high traces of radiation"

again, maybe a translation issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom