Meteor over Moscow

One would think it's a kinetic energy calculation, 65 tons at x speed

Well, that much energy is getting dumped into the atmosphere or ground no matter what, the only question is how much of it was in the explosion and how much before/after.
 
This may be useful to some thread readers wondering what makes the trail:

Ablation, Flux, and Atmospheric Implications of Meteors Inferred from Stratospheric Aerosol
Single-particle analyses of stratospheric aerosol show that about half of the particles contain 0.5 to 1.0 weight percent meteoritic iron by mass, requiring a total extraterrestrial influx of 8 to 38 gigagrams per year. The sodium/iron ratio in these stratospheric particles is higher and the magnesium/iron and calcium/iron ratios are lower than in chondritic meteorites, implying that the fraction of material that is ablated must lie at the low end of previous estimates and that the extraterrestrial component that resides in the mesosphere and stratosphere is not of chondritic composition.

They are talking about analyzing the stuff in the upper atmosphere, but they looked for meteor origin particulates.
 
Last edited:
More clarification of a trail of ionized gas following a meteor vs condensed water vapor (contrails) or combustion products, neither of which the meteor vapor trail is composed of:

Dispersion of meteor trails in the geomagnetic field
A meteor trail is modeled by a long column of weakly ionized plasma, whose dispersion is controlled by the geomagnetic field and the requirement to maintain effective space charge neutrality. First we consider scattering of a radar signal from an underdense trail and derive an expression for the amplitude of the backscattered signal as a function of time. Then, starting from the basic momentum balance equations for electrons and ions in a partially ionized plasma, we require divergences of ion and electron fluxes to be equal, plus assume equality of the flux components along the magnetic field direction. The analysis is really applicable to a whole range of plasma problems, although we focus upon meteor trails for now. It is found that charged particle densities satisfy a diffusion equation and we obtain an expression for the ambipolar diffusion tensor and expressions for the ambipolar electric field, valid for arbitrary relative orientations of the magnetic field and meteor trail axis. Results are somewhat different from previous analyses in the meteor literature.

Hope that helps. ;)
 
There could be many reasons for the lack of contrail - if it hits the type or atmospheric conditions where contrails do not form

Even there I cannot find a decent explanation for meteor contrails...the only mechanism I can think of is vortex based which would account for the raggedness off a oddly shaped object.

It's created during the burn phase. Once it's past that there's no longer a trail.

Steve S
 
There could be many reasons for the lack of contrail - if it hits the type or atmospheric conditions where contrails do not form

Even there I cannot find a decent explanation for meteor contrails...the only mechanism I can think of is vortex based which would account for the raggedness off a oddly shaped object.
"Contrail" is short for "Condensation Trail".
A meteor/ meteorite does not issue a contrail (Unless it is an ice object), but the more appropriate term would be "Ablation Trail", as the trail is parts of the meteorite/meteor that have ablated from the object itself
 
"Contrail" is short for "Condensation Trail".
A meteor/ meteorite does not issue a contrail (Unless it is an ice object), but the more appropriate term would be "Ablation Trail", as the trail is parts of the meteorite/meteor that have ablated from the object itself
And.... the largest component, as I've posted many citations for, is IONIZED GASSES.

The molecules are glowing as one can see when these things occur at night. Fireballs make pretty green trails that can sometimes linger for half an hour. :)

I don't know how much, if any, of the Russian meteor trail consists of any water vapor. I guess water vapor could condense inside a plasma cloud. Someone else will know more than me on that one.

Still, the main component of a meteor trail is a plasma of ionized gasses.
Neon lights could more accurately be called "plasma lights", as the light comes from the plasma inside of them. ...

...The colors are a result of relaxation of electrons in excited states to lower energy states after they have recombined with ions. These processes emit light in a spectrum characteristic of the gas being excited...

...Dust and small grains within a plasma will also pick up a net negative charge, so that they in turn may act like a very heavy negative ion component of the plasma (see dusty plasmas).

Space Shuttle plasma trail


This is getting beyond my pay grade but I'm guessing this explains a lot more about the appearance of the trail: Dusty plasma
A dusty plasma is a plasma containing nanometer or micrometer-sized particles suspended in it. Dust particles may be charged and the plasma and particles behave as a plasma,[1][2] following electromagnetic laws for particles up to about 10 nm (or 100 nm if large charges are present). Dust particles may form larger particles resulting in "grain plasmas"....

...Dusty plasmas are interesting because the presence of particles significantly alters the charged particle equilibrium leading to different phenomena. It is a field of current research. Electrostatic coupling between the grains can vary over a wide range so that the states of the dusty plasma can change from weakly coupled (gaseous) to crystalline.
 
This may be useful to some thread readers wondering what makes the trail:

Ablation, Flux, and Atmospheric Implications of Meteors Inferred from Stratospheric Aerosol
Quote:
Single-particle analyses of stratospheric aerosol show that about half of the particles contain 0.5 to 1.0 weight percent meteoritic iron by mass, requiring a total extraterrestrial influx of 8 to 38 gigagrams per year. The sodium/iron ratio in these stratospheric particles is higher and the magnesium/iron and calcium/iron ratios are lower than in chondritic meteorites, implying that the fraction of material that is ablated must lie at the low end of previous estimates and that the extraterrestrial component that resides in the mesosphere and stratosphere is not of chondritic composition.

They are talking about analyzing the stuff in the upper atmosphere, but they looked for meteor origin particulates.

No wonder I find getting up in the morning difficult, Gravity IS making the quilt heavier.

ETA: I am enjoying this thread I R Learnering stuff
 
Last edited:
Wait just a minute before you get too smug ;)...I'm a pilot and have a fairly good understanding of the dynamics and I've flown in the Concorde and seen pressure condensation off that and other planes....and it's very dependent on atmospheric conditions.

Contrails are from a variety of sources.
In a jet it's mostly water vapour from the engines - that's straight forward.

Condensation also occurs in a shock wave passing the sound barrier...
http://physics.aps.org/assets/932b05cfaedcee3d

there are also
wingtip vortices...

600px-F-15_wingtip_vortices.jpg

wiki image

As SG mentioned much on a meteor trail is ablative - I seen a daytime earthgrazer dripping green fire which is copper ablating. But ablation looks different - usually darker if not lit - and gray as well which some observers mentioned and also seemingly smelled.

If we assume nothing is ice based I'd have to think most of the white contrail is a combination of shock wave and random vortex formation - the erratic nature and apparently multiple streams after the breakup would give greater heft....as the trail is not persistent early on - it's a fireball with trailing gases...that's not a contrail

The white remainder IS a contrail.

http://9922fd5bfb2c14c00d30-dabbd35.../882/russia-meteor-contrails-sky_original.jpg

and I suspect it's from shock and vortex formation.
 
Sorry wingtip vortices (and shockwave condensation, wilson clouds whichever) still look awesome.

So we have a mixture of vacuum produced contrails from atmospheric compounds and ablated ionised compounds of unearthly origin.

Still I know this is merely people being picky over nomenclature but overall I am left with a feeling of big ET originating rock impacts atmosphere at high speed and leaves trail in sky.

No ******* **** Sherlock.

Some things are awethumb because they is, and Space rocks doing stuff is awethumb

ETA: Great Picture BTW
 
Last edited:
Meteorites contain very little copper.
Here's another source.
There's a trace amount of copper in chondrites, but that isn't what makes the vapor cloud green.

Wiki has an entry citing the color of meteorite trails that I believe is wrong:
The visible light produced by a meteor may take on various hues, depending on the chemical composition of the meteoroid, and the speed of its movement through the atmosphere. As layers of the meteoroid abrade and ionize, the color of the light emitted may change according to the layering of minerals. Possible colors (and elements producing them) include:

Orange/yellow (sodium)
Yellow (iron)
Blue/green (copper)
Purple (potassium)
Red (silicate)
There's no source for this entry and I'm 99% sure it's wrong. Yes, you get green light emitted when you ionize copper, but there just isn't that much copper in meteorites.


I believe the green you are seeing is very much like the excited ions one sees with the aurora borealis. I believe this is the green you are seeing:
Auroras are caused when high-energy electrons pour down from the Earth’s magnetosphere and collide with atoms. Green aurora occurs from about 100 km to 250 km altitude and is caused by the emission of 5577 Angstrom wavelength light from oxygen atoms.
But I will double check.

This one's over my head. It's all about the ions, yes, but not copper ions.
 
Contrail makes sense to me. As the pressure of the air superheats the meteor, the meteor in turn heats the air immediately around it by conduction, yes? And as the meteor passes, that very heated air rapidly cools, causing a trail of condensation to form along the path of the meteor, yes?

Or even better, heat isn't even a part of it - the meteor compresses the air in front of it; in the wake of the meteor the pressure very rapidly decreases, causing condensation.

It doesn't make sense to me that the meteor trail would be a dusty plasma. Perhaps it starts out that way in some fashion; but I don't imagine a cloud of plasma persisting in such a well-defined shape in the cold atmosphere for such an extended period of time.
 
Last edited:
I think there is dusty plasma and there was some from this rock.

I also think there was a standard compression wave/vortex contrail.

SG - copper is not always in meteorites but afaik I know it is always in those with green.
I'd say one in 50 (maybe less ) I've seen had a green aspect including the big earth grazer that was reported all over the eastern seaboard that day. That was really cool as it was not going fast - was crossing the horizon not "falling" and literally dripped green bits in the long trail.

just dumb luck I saw it - was doing the dishes and it crossed the horizon in front of my view over the Niagara Escarpment.

The most intense meteor shower I've seen we figured at about 70-80 per hour and not one of the maybe 15 fireballs with that shower had any green to it so yes copper is rare but not that rare.

Oh wait apparently nickel shows green as well and THAT makes sense with this fireball and is big time more common

Can fireballs appear in different colors?
Vivid colors are more often reported by fireball observers because the brightness is great enough to fall well within the range of human color vision. These must be treated with some caution, however, because of well-known effects associated with the persistence of vision. Reported colors range across the spectrum, from red to bright blue, and (rarely) violet. The dominant composition of a meteoroid can play an important part in the observed colors of a fireball, with certain elements displaying signature colors when vaporized. For example, sodium produces a bright yellow color, nickel shows as green, and magnesium as blue-white. The velocity of the meteor also plays an important role, since a higher level of kinetic energy will intensify certain colors compared to others. Among fainter objects, it seems to be reported that slow meteors are red or orange, while fast meteors frequently have a blue color, but for fireballs the situation seems more complex than that, but perhaps only because of the curiosities of color vision as mentioned above.

The difficulties of specifying meteor color arise because meteor light is dominated by an emission, rather than a continuous, spectrum. The majority of light from a fireball radiates from a compact cloud of material immediately surrounding the meteoroid or closely trailing it. 95% of this cloud consists of atoms from the surrounding atmosphere; the balance consists of atoms of vaporized elements from the meteoroid itself. These excited particles will emit light at wavelengths characteristic for each element. The most common emission lines observed in the visual portion of the spectrum from ablated material in the fireball head originate from iron (Fe), magnesium (Mg), and sodium (Na). Silicon (Si) may be under-represented due to incomplete dissociation of SiO2 molecules. Manganese (Mn), Chromium (Cr), Copper (Cu) have been observed in fireball spectra, along with rarer elements. The refractory elements Aluminum (Al), Calcium (Ca), and Titanium (Ti) tend to be incompletely vaporized and thus also under-represented in fireball spectra.

http://www.amsmeteors.org/fireballs/faqf/#5

55 tons moving at that speed through the atmosphere - going to be some odd emissions.:boggled:
 
Contrail makes sense to me. As the pressure of the air superheats the meteor, the meteor in turn heats the air immediately around it by conduction, yes?
No, the gas ahead of the meteor gets compressed and changes phase from gas to plasma. The sudden change of phase is part of what created an evolving pressure wave, which is what caused the damage.

There is nothing mysterious about it. It is basic material science.
 
I think there is dusty plasma and there was some from this rock.

I also think there was a standard compression wave/vortex contrail.

SG - copper is not always in meteorites but afaik I know it is always in those with green.
I'd say one in 50 (maybe less ) I've seen had a green aspect including the big earth grazer that was reported all over the eastern seaboard that day. That was really cool as it was not going fast - was crossing the horizon not "falling" and literally dripped green bits in the long trail.

just dumb luck I saw it - was doing the dishes and it crossed the horizon in front of my view over the Niagara Escarpment.

The most intense meteor shower I've seen we figured at about 70-80 per hour and not one of the maybe 15 fireballs with that shower had any green to it so yes copper is rare but not that rare.

Oh wait apparently nickel shows green as well and THAT makes sense with this fireball and is big time more common



http://www.amsmeteors.org/fireballs/faqf/#5

55 tons moving at that speed through the atmosphere - going to be some odd emissions.:boggled:
I think you are confusing
Copper (Cu) have been observed in fireball spectra
with, that's what causes the green color in the nighttime vapor trails.

Detecting an element in spectra doesn't mean there is a large quantity in the meteor. I posted three links that described the materials that make up the bulk of meteorites. You seem to have ignored them.

I've seen a whole night of fireballs with the 1998 Leonids storm and I've seen a couple other fireballs. Green is common, copper is not.

And copper is especially not common in meteors from comet dust which is what the Leonids is.
The impactor's payload, dubbed the "Cratering Mass", was 100% copper (impactor 49% copper by mass) to reduce debris interfering with scientific measurements of the impact. Since copper was not expected to be found on a comet, scientists could eliminate copper from the spectrometer reading.[9] Instead of using explosives, it was also cheaper to use copper as the payload.[5]
But then I can't find that nickel is common in comets either.

Regardless,
nickel shows as green
I believe is the answer we are looking for. Here I was looking all over and the answer was in a link I posted earlier. :o



So, bottom line, the vapor trail is still ionized atoms giving off photons. But, I don't see anything about water vapor on that page. Have you found anything that says there is water vapor in a meteor vapor trail?
 
I am running a skeptic society in Russia, similar to JREF, only much smaller, at least today.

Today we made a post, which basically looks into how known pseudo-scientists in Russia and various psychics and "esoteric philosophers" are interpreting this to their advantage. I think a meteor in the beginning of the year is a gift to many psychics. Now this can be interpreted as a "sign from god".
 
SG - I'm not "confusing" anything and I dare say from your comet comment I know a fair bit more about this topic than you seem to.

The colors of this shooting star may also indicate the minerals that make up the space rock. Different elements emit different-colored light when they burn. Iron, one of the most common elements found in meteors, glows yellow. Silicates, which contain a form of the element silicon, glow red. A green glow, clearly visible in the trail of this shooting star, indicates the presence of burning copper.

and I've seen several.

argue with them

http://education.nationalgeographic.com.au/education/media/shooting-star-spec/?ar_a=1

SG - a comet is ice ( not just water ice but mostly ) and bears almost no relation to a meteor other than as a body entering the atmosphere

Iron nickel IS the most common meteor material. I suspect that it takes a big meteor to set up the conditions for nickel to vaporize and be seen as green where copper has a lower melting point so would vaporize first.

metal, iron, & nickel in meteorites
meteorites.wustl.edu/id/metal.htmAbout 95% of all meteorites contain iron-nickel (FeNi) metal.

It's possible that the smaller nickel particles flare green just at the end as I've seen that in a tumble right at the end of an incoming

Often copper is associated with gold, lead, zinc and nickel deposits.

When we refined nickel at Inco via electrolytical process copper was a major byproduct or the ore along with cobalt and an amazing treasure trove of elements above platinum.
These meteors are ore bearing bodies which is what that asteroid mining company wants to exploit.
 
Last edited:
What the heck does "wormwood" have to do with anything? The Russian word is not even close to "hole in the ice".

I don't know about that particular article, but my first thought when hearing "wormwood" was a reference to the star falling from heaven after an angel blew a trumpet (New Testament, Revelation, no idea where therein).
 
I don't know about that particular article, but my first thought when hearing "wormwood" was a reference to the star falling from heaven after an angel blew a trumpet (New Testament, Revelation, no idea where therein).
Ch 8 v 11
the name of the star is Wormwood. A third of the waters turned bitter, and many people died from the waters that had become bitter.
The place name "Chernobyl" means wormwood, and the apocalypticists made much of this, when the nuclear disaster occurred.
 
Fantastic thread.
This image shows a good view of the ice thrown out in a pattern you'd see with an impact (or an explosion if you used dynamite to make a fishing hole).

One thing I learned from visiting the Carancas impact eventWP, the rumors and misinformation are rampant after one of these events, even info from some of the scientists is not always reliable, though certainly more trustworthy than the news and all the eye-witness accounts.

And the picture of a crater with a person in the background looks way bigger than the thing does in person due to how the camera deals with background and foreground perspective distortions.

So much to learn here!
But at the end of the day, I liked this post the most

Because I found it amusing...
[qimg]http://dailypicksandflicks.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/picdump-727-2.jpg[/qimg]
(oh, and for those who might not get the reference)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom