Meteor over Moscow

With extremely rare exception, all meteorites have a considerable amount of metal. But nickel-irons are almost all metal. The come from the core of a planetary body where the heaviest metals sank to the core (like our own planet) as the planet formed.
What planetary body, and what happened to it, please?
 
Because I found it amusing...
picdump-727-2.jpg

(oh, and for those who might not get the reference)
 
What planetary body, and what happened to it, please?
There were little baby planets in the early solar system that didn't make it. :(;)

The meteorites that contain iron-nickel crystals are fascinating in their possible origins and diversity. In the early solar system, asteroids and comets sometimes grew large enough to be considered planetary embryos (objects hundreds of kilometers in diameter, including the four largest remaining asteroids). These bodies were large enough to differentiate, even to melt due to the heat of formation and the decay of radioactive isotopes. This melting allowed the dense iron and nickel to sink to form a metallic core. At one point, there were at least tens of thousands of these planetary embryos, and they began to collide to form the planets. Some of the more violent collisions shattered the embryos, scattering fragments of their iron/nickel cores around the solar system (these fragments still comprise about 10% of all known asteroids). Different parent embryos would have resulted in meteorites of different compositions.
 
Something occurs to me as a possible reason why nobody saw the Russia meteor coming:

Since it was headed directly toward Earth, it would be hard to see it moving against the background. Also it was smaller than the other one, but usually these things are discovered because they move relative to the stars, but something coming straight at us would not move relative to the background.
It's not an issue coming straight at us because the Earth turns and people would see that angle from different views. The problem is size and coming at us from the Sun's side of the sky.
 
Does anyone have an explanation for what is going on in this video?

Claims - 'meteor was shot down'

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzKhPIArIKQ
:sdl: Silly idiots that make up all those CT theories. (Not you.)

If that video is real, and who knows, it would be a piece of the meteor that broke off and was traveling along the same trajectory.

There are images of this object from space, no doubt whatsoever it's a meteor, and there's no way given our current technology that Russia has the capability to get a missile off in time to hit that thing.

Now I suppose if they had some kind of automatic missile defense system there's some sci-fi scenario but it's just ludicrously unlikely.
 
Chebarkul Lake, Russia where the hole in the ice is. It's a big lake.

Scientists confirm Chebarkul Lake meteorite found in Russian Urals as meteorite with an iron content of about 10%
Scientists have discovered in Lake Chebarkul fragments of the meteorite, which fell on Friday morning near Chelyabinsk. Their extraterrestrial nature has been corroborated by chemical analysis, reported member of the Russian Academy of Sciences’ Committee on Meteorites Victor Grokhovsky of the Urals Federal University.
Previously there was information that an expedition comprising Urals University staff had set out to Chelyabinsk tasked with finding fragments of the meteorite.

"We literally only just finished the studies, and confirm that the particles found by us in the vicinity of Lake Chebarkul are of meteorite nature. This meteorite is classified as a chondrite; it’s a stone meteorite with an iron content of about 10%. Most likely, it will be given the name Chebarkul meteorite," said Grokhovsky.
I read this as they've found fragments near the hole.

OTOH,
No meteorite fragments found

Russian scientists and emergency workers have called off their search for fragments of the South Urals meteorite that hit Chelyabinsk and four other cities Friday crushing a factory wall and smashing window panes in some 3,000 houses.

Nothing has been found. A big ice hole discovered in Lake Chebarkul is now believed to have been caused by ‘other factors’.
:D


There are now abnormal radiation levels in the area.
Yeah, it's Russia. :p



The first story above was from today while the 'found nothing' was 2 days ago.
 
Last edited:
I was looking at a video and my laptop went haywire and crashed. It seems to be OK now apart from the fact that I've lost some cookies. Maybe it was nothing, but I thought I'd better mention it.

Anyway, it looks to me as if the meteor comes in, the brightness intensifies, and after the maximum brightness the meteor (or a part of it) carries on moving very fast, but there's no contrail.
 
:sdl: Silly idiots that make up all those CT theories. (Not you.)

If that video is real, and who knows, it would be a piece of the meteor that broke off and was traveling along the same trajectory.

There are images of this object from space, no doubt whatsoever it's a meteor, and there's no way given our current technology that Russia has the capability to get a missile off in time to hit that thing.

Now I suppose if they had some kind of automatic missile defense system there's some sci-fi scenario but it's just ludicrously unlikely.
I don't even think that is the case, and even if it did hit it would do nine tenths of sod all to a 10,000 tonne lump of rock traveling at 11-miles a second (40,000 mph)

My non-expert veiew: too high, too big and too fast for a successful intercept. Compare with the ABM trial results, or Patriot missiles against Scuds.

ETA: also I haven't seen any missile contrails in the videos I've seen - on a phone so can't easily watch them st the moment.
Sounds like nationalistic bluster.

The bit highlighted.
 
Last edited:
I don't even think that is the case, and even if it did hit it would do nine tenths of sod all to a 10,000 tonne lump of rock. ....
For the record, I was not saying the fragment, if it existed, hit the main object. I was saying it was merely nearby.

But I totally agree, this CT was predictable and hilarious. I haven't checked GodLikeProductions in a while, think I will for a laugh.
 
Originally Posted by macdoc
I meant the near miss asteroid. The yield was already in on the meteor. To get a proper comparison would need the velocity of the asteroid as well as the mass but thanks for that info.
And the incoming angle.

That's an interesting thought....how is the yield calculated?
Is it total energy including the passage through the atmosphere in which case angle is not important or is it impact or is it shock wave??

One would think it's a kinetic energy calculation, 65 tons at x speed

anyone care to enlighten?
 
It's not an issue coming straight at us because the Earth turns and people would see that angle from different views. The problem is size and coming at us from the Sun's side of the sky.

Yeah, you're right. I realized after I posted that that it was probably wrong because both the earth and the asteroid followed curved paths. With the size and with the sun behind it it would be much harder to see. Plus the whole needle-in-a-haystack thing.
 
Anyway, it looks to me as if the meteor comes in, the brightness intensifies, and after the maximum brightness the meteor (or a part of it) carries on moving very fast, but there's no contrail.

There could be many reasons for the lack of contrail - if it hits the type or atmospheric conditions where contrails do not form

Even there I cannot find a decent explanation for meteor contrails...the only mechanism I can think of is vortex based which would account for the raggedness off a oddly shaped object.
 
And now, none other than our old nationalist friend Zhirinovsky is espousing a 'USA did it' conspiracy

Glad someone else is thinking this. This had nothing to do with D14 at all

This happened 2 hours or more before the pass by was projected, no one saw this coming

This wasnt being tracked by NASA like they were doing for D14

1000+ hurt over what looks to be a semi flash, think about that.
 
There could be many reasons for the lack of contrail - if it hits the type or atmospheric conditions where contrails do not form

Even there I cannot find a decent explanation for meteor contrails...the only mechanism I can think of is vortex based which would account for the raggedness off a oddly shaped object.
In all the stuff I posted, you still don't understand the vapor trail? ;)

Here's another description

The typical meteor streak:
Atmospheric gases along the meteoroid's path are also heated and ionized. These hot, ionized particles produce the trail of glowing vapors that we call a “meteor.”

A contrailWP is condensed water vapor, not heated ionized gas.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom